Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?

166 replies

Fifi1010 · 31/03/2023 09:37

Our economic productivity has grown 0.8 percent per year on average since 2008 compared with 2 percent before. Why is that? High productivity increases the tax receipts , money for schools and healthcare. If we don't improve productivity living standards will further decline. Where have we gone wrong? I know Brexit is a problem but this started 8 years before.

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 31/03/2023 14:08

Echobelly · 31/03/2023 13:50

We are productive.

We are just using the wrong metrics to measure productivity.

This isn't talked about nearly enough but it's really important because governments make awful poliecies when they don't understand this.

We're still using metrics that are based on manufacturing things and we're not a manufacturing economy. These metrics don't take into account computing power increases and what that allows and the knowledge and service economies are a core of our economy now.

Unfortunately the government ignore this and is likely to suggest dumb solutions like 'Oh people should fewer rights at work and then they'll work harder'

Productivity isn’t a simple measure of worker output.

Believeitornot · 31/03/2023 14:08

Productivity is a measure of investment and what workers produce.

This government does not (and previous ones) invest. Therefore neither do businesses.

Things like infrastructure- railways, roads etc. education. Health service.

Government should spend money because that money goes into the private sector which then drives more investment. Eg if they want to build, it goes to building companies. If they want to invest in green technology, it goes to private companies.

There’s a bizarre idea that government spending = bad. Drives me fucking nuts.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 31/03/2023 14:01

I live in England, but I'm from Ireland originally. I used to be a primary teacher here and now my son and daughter are at school here (one primary, one secondary). From my experience the UK education system seems entirely odd and baffling. I genuinely don't understand it and I don't think it leads to good outcomes for young people. TBH I feel bad that I've put my children through it - the Irish system is so much more sensible and effective that I wish they were learning there instead.

It wouldn't take very much to fix it and I think it'd make a massive difference to the country as a whole.

StressedaboutUni · 31/03/2023 13:54

The Uk economy’s is dominated by the services industry compared to other advanced economies such as Germany which is based on manufacturing. It is increasing hard to increase productivity in the services sector compared to other sectors and coupled with a lack of investment in technologies and human capital.therefore the UK’s productivity has lagged.

moksorineouimoksori · 31/03/2023 13:51

Productivity is not the be all and end all

picklemewalnuts · 31/03/2023 13:50

Have we solved it yet? Some brilliant people here. Should be able to crack it!

CuteOrangeElephant · 31/03/2023 13:50

You don't get that it's getting to the exchange of contracts point that is painful?

That took 3 days in The Netherlands.

Echobelly · 31/03/2023 13:50

We are productive.

We are just using the wrong metrics to measure productivity.

This isn't talked about nearly enough but it's really important because governments make awful poliecies when they don't understand this.

We're still using metrics that are based on manufacturing things and we're not a manufacturing economy. These metrics don't take into account computing power increases and what that allows and the knowledge and service economies are a core of our economy now.

Unfortunately the government ignore this and is likely to suggest dumb solutions like 'Oh people should fewer rights at work and then they'll work harder'

GasPanic · 31/03/2023 13:44

CuteOrangeElephant · 31/03/2023 12:53

Well I don't have experience with the German house buying process. The Dutch one was completely hassle free, even if it did cost a bit more. When our offer was accepted we knew exactly when the move in date was, no way for the seller to back out.

That's the same in the UK though. You get your completion date at exchange of contracts and you know exactly when you are going to move in, and the seller cannot back out without huge penalties.

The problem isn't so much the UK system, it's peoples lack of understanding of it, and believing that they have bought a house rather than simply making an offer on it.

You have not bought a house until you have exchanged contracts. Everything else up to that point is negotiation, although I see a lot of people claim to have "bought a house" even if it is only sold subject to contract.

LlynTegid · 31/03/2023 13:22

I'd argue poor managers, also as a country we undervalue any manual skill.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 13:15

StamppotAndGravy · 31/03/2023 12:30

Poor education with a huge percentage of the population lacking basic numeracy; lack of technical skills in the workforce; poor healthcare so even working people work inefficiently and work when they're ill; low quality and unreliable childcare; and a crazy visa regime where it costs a fortune to bring smart people in so they go where the pay, weather, housing, healthcare and welcome are all better which had a knock on effect for business creation and investment.

As populations age, the UK is going to struggle to compete with the rest of the world for good people. It's a vicious circle.

Yep to all that, especially the poor literacy and numeracy standards.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 31/03/2023 12:57

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 12:22

Yep, so many "cliff edges" that discourage people working more hours, taking promotions, etc., due to tax hikes or benefit losses.

Like the £50k income threshold where you start to lose child benefit.

Or the £100k threshold where you lose free childcare and the tax free personal allowance.

Or the lower thresholds where you start to lose tax credits or UC, or council tax relief, etc.

ALL these cliff edge thresholds need reviewing so that people are guaranteed to keep most of the extra money they earn, i.e. have a maximum "Loss" of tax reliefs or benefits etc of 50%, so that for every extra pound you earn, at whatever income level, you're guaranteed to keep at least half, 50p of it after taking into account free childcare, child benefit, tax/nic rates, benefit clawbacks etc.

We really should never have allowed a situation where someone can lose 70p or 80p or even all of that extra pound they earn.

Yep!

CuteOrangeElephant · 31/03/2023 12:53

Well I don't have experience with the German house buying process. The Dutch one was completely hassle free, even if it did cost a bit more. When our offer was accepted we knew exactly when the move in date was, no way for the seller to back out.

TheWhalrus · 31/03/2023 12:42

I add that the German countryside currently has about 1.3 million vacant properties nationwide, most of which aren't expensive, but nobody wants the hassle of living in one of those places (plus a fair few of the locations are really tedious villages with no amenities, services or community spirit. Rural Germans are like this.

TheWhalrus · 31/03/2023 12:39

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:24

Going to have to pull you up on the house-buying part. We're in Germany and its much worse here. Usually additional fees (taxes, parasitic estate agents etc) make up 10-15% of the costs paid to own the property.

Is the process even slower? Or as slow? Estate agent fees are higher in Australia but they get the job done a lot quicker because the process is properly designed.

Much slower.....sometimes something like 10-12 months from offer accepted to move-in date. It's a joke and many people simply build their own place instead because its less hassle and not more expensive or more stressful.

Paloma66 · 31/03/2023 12:35

sst1234 · 31/03/2023 09:40

Because of part time tax credits culture. The last labour government damaged the economy hugely by introducing tax credits and subsidizing low wages. Employers have no incentive to invest in productivity and automation because they can get cheap labour subsidized by the taxpayer. This is arguably the worst policy introduced by any government in the last 25 years, because of the long term irreversible damage it has caused, making the whole country poorer.

I agree with this. It's been a disaster for this country in so many ways.

StamppotAndGravy · 31/03/2023 12:30

Poor education with a huge percentage of the population lacking basic numeracy; lack of technical skills in the workforce; poor healthcare so even working people work inefficiently and work when they're ill; low quality and unreliable childcare; and a crazy visa regime where it costs a fortune to bring smart people in so they go where the pay, weather, housing, healthcare and welcome are all better which had a knock on effect for business creation and investment.

As populations age, the UK is going to struggle to compete with the rest of the world for good people. It's a vicious circle.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 12:26

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:19

You can't just abolish tax credits overnight - it would lead to massive social problems.

Of course you can't, but you can certainly announce a "road map" of them being tapered away or reduced over a 5-10-15 year period to give people and organisations a chance to make the changes required.

In fact, that's similar with the introduction of Universal Credit, where new claimants go straight onto UC, but existing TC claimants stay on the old system, with an option to move to UC, and ultimately, after several years, everyone on TC will move over to UC.

The sooner we start with these big things the better. Unfortunately, governments for the last 30 years have preferred to kick things into the long grass if changes can't be made within 3-5 years. Short term thinking will be the ruin of the UK due to this short-term-ism.

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:24

Going to have to pull you up on the house-buying part. We're in Germany and its much worse here. Usually additional fees (taxes, parasitic estate agents etc) make up 10-15% of the costs paid to own the property.

Is the process even slower? Or as slow? Estate agent fees are higher in Australia but they get the job done a lot quicker because the process is properly designed.

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 12:22

Bucketheadbucketbum · 31/03/2023 12:12

In the UK It doesn't pay to work more, loose benefits, hit higher tax bands etc

Yep, so many "cliff edges" that discourage people working more hours, taking promotions, etc., due to tax hikes or benefit losses.

Like the £50k income threshold where you start to lose child benefit.

Or the £100k threshold where you lose free childcare and the tax free personal allowance.

Or the lower thresholds where you start to lose tax credits or UC, or council tax relief, etc.

ALL these cliff edge thresholds need reviewing so that people are guaranteed to keep most of the extra money they earn, i.e. have a maximum "Loss" of tax reliefs or benefits etc of 50%, so that for every extra pound you earn, at whatever income level, you're guaranteed to keep at least half, 50p of it after taking into account free childcare, child benefit, tax/nic rates, benefit clawbacks etc.

We really should never have allowed a situation where someone can lose 70p or 80p or even all of that extra pound they earn.

TheWhalrus · 31/03/2023 12:20

CuteOrangeElephant · 31/03/2023 11:34

It's the lack of investment and vision.

Take for instance the house buying process. I don't think there is another western country where the process is so unsure and convoluted. A lot of time, money and energy goes into the conveyancing process, it just gets sucked in and produces nothing of value.

Healthcare. This is purely anecdotal. I have had the same cardiac investigations done in the UK and in the Netherlands.

In the UK: I had to take pretty much 3 days off work, just sat around the hospital awaiting different investigations, scheduled on different days, at inconvenient times.

In the Netherlands: got a phone call, scheduled an appointment convenient to me, went to the specialist. Had all my investigations done in one morning (ultrasound, ECG, blood test, basic measuring/weighing, appointment with the consultant), was outside back on my way to work within 2 hours. Got the results via the phone.

Now I bet the UK option is more efficient for the NHS, but in the overall picture the Netherlands wins.

Going to have to pull you up on the house-buying part. We're in Germany and its much worse here. Usually additional fees (taxes, parasitic estate agents etc) make up 10-15% of the costs paid to own the property.

This does have certain benefits though: tenants, and especially long-term tenants have much stronger rights to not be evicted, and people tend to only buy one property and then live in it, typically at some point in their 30s or 40s rather than constantly trading up as per the UK.

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:19

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 12:17

Tax credits, as @sst1234 said in the first response. Get rid of them and companies will invest in automation rather than demanding we import more cheap labour which just adds to the pressure on infrastructure.

However, the glimmer of light on the horizon is that the UK has just joined an even larger free trade bloc than the EU: the CPTPP which represents over 16% of global GDP.

You can't just abolish tax credits overnight - it would lead to massive social problems.

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 12:17

Bucketheadbucketbum · 31/03/2023 12:12

In the UK It doesn't pay to work more, loose benefits, hit higher tax bands etc

True, but low productivity is present for those of us working long hours for poor wages - it's a bigger problem than in work benefits.

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 12:17

Tax credits, as @sst1234 said in the first response. Get rid of them and companies will invest in automation rather than demanding we import more cheap labour which just adds to the pressure on infrastructure.

However, the glimmer of light on the horizon is that the UK has just joined an even larger free trade bloc than the EU: the CPTPP which represents over 16% of global GDP.

BloaterW1 · 31/03/2023 12:14

Real lack of investment in technology and reliance on tax credits to top up wages .