Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?

166 replies

Fifi1010 · 31/03/2023 09:37

Our economic productivity has grown 0.8 percent per year on average since 2008 compared with 2 percent before. Why is that? High productivity increases the tax receipts , money for schools and healthcare. If we don't improve productivity living standards will further decline. Where have we gone wrong? I know Brexit is a problem but this started 8 years before.

OP posts:
Yellowdays · 31/03/2023 22:13

Brexit has definitely made us far less productive.

Ragged · 31/03/2023 21:55

This thread confuses me. I barely understand what "productivity" means and I have half a degree in economics, I definitely couldn't answer the question. Yet so many people here are confident.

20th in 2017?
or maybe 7th in 2017.
13th in world in 2020?
FT article that says "mediocre" not terrible.

better question, what do others have that UK lacks?
I don't think comparison to tiny states like Singapore or Luxembourg helps, they have too unique situations.

Ireland has high productivity because of low corporation tax (apparently).
Norway has high skill, well educated workforce, but also very supported/good workers rights.
Switzerland adds high value & is highly integrated into global economy (banking).

Switzerland & Ireland are services economies, aren't they? I don't think UK being a service economy is the problem. USA, France & Italy have plenty of lazy people, USA is especially young. Japan is old. Don't think it's a generational problem.

The Most Productive Countries: How to Replicate them at Work

What you could be doing differently? In our ultimate guide to workplace productivity we delve into the different ways to increase output, and measure it.

https://www.expertmarket.com/uk/crm-systems/the-ultimate-guide-to-work-place-productivity

SecretVictoria · 31/03/2023 21:29

There are IMO so many jobs that could be part time but are full time. I used to have one, I could have quite easily done it in three days….but most people need five days wages. I reckon this is true for loads of jobs…but it’s known that most need an f/t income to survive. I wasn’t productive on the other two days as the job didn’t lend itself to that.

So we have people in jobs that are unnecessarily f/t because you can’t live on a p/t wage.

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 21:21

The UK is a world leader in computer games. Among the world leaders in designing, developing and marketing them too. If we are clever enough to do that then we should be shit hot at making sure we profit from them as well? Or am I delusional?

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 21:11

Yes, I accept your reservations on the legal framework, but the Canadian company still has to persuade its Uk workforce to work for below market wages, and why would they?

Havanananana · 31/03/2023 20:56

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 20:26

Your opinion, but many of these economies are growing faster than ours. The EU wants to control the industry standards, work T&C and legal frameworks in a manner that hamstrings outsiders. And the value of the EU economy, as a proportion of global trade, is waning slightly relative to other groups, as world trade ebbs and rises. I am not cheerleading but I do see advantages in having free trade deals across the world.

But these economies are growing from a far lower baseline, so if the wage of someone in Mexico increases from £50 a week to £55, while it is true that his wage and spending power have increased by 10%, it is still far below that of workers in the 27 EU countries.

The EU wants to control the industry standards, work T&C and legal frameworks in a manner that hamstrings outsiders.

But that is exactly what the CPTPP does as well - with far lower standards than those currently acceptable in the UK and the EU - with the added problem that trade disputes will not be handled in public, but will be settled in secret trade courts to which even Parliament will not have access.

If a company from Canada believes that UK minimum-wage legislation is stopping it from making a profit in the UK, it can sue the UK government for millions, effectively taking control away from Parliament and giving it to unelected secret courts and the corporations. At least within the EU, the UK had a voice and had judges on the various European Courts, the decisions of which were open to public and Parliamentary scrutiny. Giving this power away will be an economic and political disaster for the UK.

Havanananana · 31/03/2023 20:47

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 20:30

And @Havanananana , the UK is not going to be selling mass-manufactured widgets into these markets. We shall be marketing computer games and intellectual property.

But Vietnam and Mexico will be selling mass-manufactured widgets, food products and confectionary into the UK market, bankrupting the UK companies in these industries and putting thousands out of work.

The Japanese are experts at computer games - and local language versions will still be produced in the Far East, not in the UK. As for IP - how many people in the UK are employed in developing new products and processes? A few thousand at most, leaving manufacturing and agriculture to go the same way as UK shipbuilding, steel-making, aerospace, motor manufacturing etc. If only high-skilled jobs remain, how will those in the UK with lower skills earn a living and how will they afford to buy all the wonderful cheap imported products if they have no money?

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 20:30

And @Havanananana , the UK is not going to be selling mass-manufactured widgets into these markets. We shall be marketing computer games and intellectual property.

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 20:26

Your opinion, but many of these economies are growing faster than ours. The EU wants to control the industry standards, work T&C and legal frameworks in a manner that hamstrings outsiders. And the value of the EU economy, as a proportion of global trade, is waning slightly relative to other groups, as world trade ebbs and rises. I am not cheerleading but I do see advantages in having free trade deals across the world.

jcyclops · 31/03/2023 20:20

I remember, many years ago, reading a comparison between two manufacturing companies - one in Germany and one in the UK. They produced the same products to equal quality standards, and sold at roughly the same price as the market was international. They both used the same production machines and shop-floor productivity was almost identical. The main difference between the companies was that the UK company had over twice as many non shop-floor employees, with more sales, HR, accounts, managers and directors. The German company's overall productivity was thus much higher and they could pay higher wages and still make greater profits.

Havanananana · 31/03/2023 20:10

However, the glimmer of light on the horizon is that the UK has just joined an even larger free trade bloc than the EU: the CPTPP which represents over 16% of global GDP.

The GDP of the EU is around $17 trillion. The GDP of CPTPP is $13.5 trillion. It is not "an even larger free trade bloc than the EU".

The GDP of Japan, Canada and Australia makes up most of the GDP of CPTPP, and the UK already has FTAs with Japan and Australia. The GDP per head of the other countries is far lower and average wages are far lower than in the UK, so UK factories will be competing with factories paying in Mexico, Vietnam and elsewhere paying workers £50 a week. Joining this trade bloc will bankrupt UK businesses and put thousands of UK workers out of work, and just how many bottles of Scottish whisky or "British" cars does Badenoch think these people will be able to afford on £50 a week?

And to compound the idiocy, trade disputes will be settled in secret Trade Courts, in which corporations will be able to sue the UK government if legislation is brought in that affects profits. Leaving the EU was a bad move, but to join the CPTPP and place UK trade policy in the hands of another, secretive group of "unelected bureaucrats" will be even worse.

Lostinalibrary · 31/03/2023 19:46

Tax. No point working more to be worse off. The UK has lots of cliff edges where this actually happens. The chancellor was told this is a significant reason for poor productivity by research he commissioned.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 31/03/2023 19:37

Nobody's getting paid enough compared to the cost of living. Whats the point in working hard for fuck all?

GasPanic · 31/03/2023 18:39

I think what Thatcher did at the time was probably the correct move. It was the way she did it that was bad. Ultimately, if you are going to take peoples jobs away, you need to offer them alternatives, which she didn't.

At that point in time the UK needed to transition from an economy where people bang stuff with hammers to a more advanced service based one, software, fintech etc. That is the only way to add value, because labour costs for manufacturing in foreign countries undercut ours considerably. We did pretty well at this transition.

Then with Blair and the EU we went the opposite. Lack of investment in robots, manufacturing infrastructure and just imported cheap labour to compensate. This subsidises manufacturing costs, but ultimately the labour has a lot of hidden costs associated with it, houses, schools, medical care etc. And those hidden costs are in no way compensated for by taxes generated by those people that are imported as they are mostly on minimum wage.

So we are now at a stage where we lack robots, technology and investment in manufacturing infrastructure which is why our productivity is so low.

People talk about stuff like the UK can't grow its own food, its too expensive here and now we have left the EU we cannot get fruit pickers. But the Dutch seem to manage it without the cheap labour force. So how ? Well probably because their farming in very high tech, with glass houses and controlled environments and they invest in the technology. Whereas we just get a lot of low paid workers in to pick fruit by hand and our farmers buy Range Rovers instead of investing in technology, then complain when they aren't subsidised enough to compete with the rest of the world.

We are or have been a very unbalanced country in many respects. These things go in cycles, and the rebalancing is just beginning. We'll probably have another 5 years or so of adjustments, and then start to move forward again in a much more balanced way than before. Hopefully with lower living costs (housing in particular) and greater investment in technology.

Elvis1956 · 31/03/2023 16:35

MisschiefMaker · 31/03/2023 10:11

Why would productivity grow? We'd need to be investing in technology to increase per-hour output. However this is more expensive upfront and in this short-termist culture we prefer to rely on endlessly importing cheap labour to keep wages low - and therefore costs low. This makes the country outwardly look successful but obviously many people experience lower standards of living as a result as wages remain compressed and our infrastructure can't keep up with the growing population. The "productivity" measure gives the game away though.

This. My opinion as to why Thatcher moved us from being a manufacturing economy to a service one is 2 fold. One to crush the unions who had crippled the UK under both Labour and Tory government.
Secondly the lack of investment in equipment and technology. Read Tony Benn 's diary from when he was a minister in the 1960s inspecting equipment made in the 1860s. The US financed both Japan and German rebuilding in part to remove us from our ddominant position.
Thatcher couldn't come clean on this because it would be seen as an attack on her own support

Eleganz · 31/03/2023 16:22

There have been a lot of poor decisions over the last few decades that have contributed. They all come down to successive governments creating an environment where there is poor investment in technology and skills and a low wage economy that means productivity has fallen off a cliff across both the public and private sectors. In the UK private wealth seems to largely be generated by either cost cutting (i.e. keeping workers on low wages and not investing in businesses) or through public to private wealth transfer (which occurs with increasing frequency instead of genuine investment in public services. It is essentially the result of the UK's application of trickle down economics.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 31/03/2023 16:10

Wikipedia has the UK as 20th out of 69 countries and a lot of the countries above us are tiny rich nations such as Switzerland (8million) Netherlands (15 million) Singapore (5million). I am surprised that Italy and Spain have better productivity than the UK though.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_labour_productivity

List of countries by labour productivity - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_labour_productivity

Endlesssummer2022 · 31/03/2023 15:36

There are also lots of people who want to do the bare minimum and have constant tea and fag breaks. I’ve been in offices with people like these and they try to discourage others from going the extra mile in case it makes them look bad.

I’ve also been in back office roles in finance in London and it’s absolutely fucking relentless from the start of the day to the end, whenever that is. People churning work out like machines in some teams.

Reugny · 31/03/2023 15:32

Endlesssummer2022 · 31/03/2023 15:29

Poor investment in technology and technology related careers.

Your can't expect people to work in technology if they don't have basic literacy and numeracy skills.

Reugny · 31/03/2023 15:31

LlynTegid · 31/03/2023 13:22

I'd argue poor managers, also as a country we undervalue any manual skill.

I agree.

It's interesting how car plants run with Japanese management were more productive than those with British management.

I nearly had a chance to work for car plant run by a Japanese firm but in the office. I was told that I needed to work certain hours that were exactly the same as those working in the plant.

Endlesssummer2022 · 31/03/2023 15:29

Poor investment in technology and technology related careers.

duoplik · 31/03/2023 15:21

As populations age, the UK is going to struggle to compete with the rest of the world for good people. It's a vicious circle

I do think this is a big issue, and more of our younger people will go abroad for a better QOL.

sst1234 · 31/03/2023 15:04

moksorineouimoksori · 31/03/2023 13:51

Productivity is not the be all and end all

No, it’s imaginary fairy money that pays for things.

StressedaboutUni · 31/03/2023 15:04

@Echobelly But productivity is literally output per worker in a given fixed period of time (e.g. per hour). This takes into account extra output through improved technology, knowledge etc. the problem is that in the services industry, which the UK is primarily based on, it is hard to make further gains in productivity unless we dramatically increase human capital which takes a long time. It is much easier in the manufacturing sector. We can’t change the metric of productivity as ultimately output per worker, whatever it is called, determines the UK’s international competitiveness and economic performance.

Echobelly · 31/03/2023 14:42

Exactly @Believeitornot , but the government acts as though it is because that's what most people assume. Or what they assume most people assume.

Swipe left for the next trending thread