Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?

166 replies

Fifi1010 · 31/03/2023 09:37

Our economic productivity has grown 0.8 percent per year on average since 2008 compared with 2 percent before. Why is that? High productivity increases the tax receipts , money for schools and healthcare. If we don't improve productivity living standards will further decline. Where have we gone wrong? I know Brexit is a problem but this started 8 years before.

OP posts:
Lostinalibrary · 02/04/2023 11:16

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 11:09

Also, taxes are so high now that work is almost seen as something to be punished for doing and assets are taxed less than PAYE jobs.

Despite what the government wants you to believe, UK income tax is relatively low when compared with much of the rest of Europe. But you are correct, assets and non-earned income (rent, interest, capital gains etc.) is taxed at a lower rate than earned income, so there is a disincentive to doing PAYE jobs as opposed to investing or using a limited company through which to earn dividends rather than a wage.

It’s really not; there are some huge cliff edges where the effective rate of tax is 70% and over 100% if you have children and hit 100k. The chancellor himself commissioned a study which told him this is a huge problem by actual economists.

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 11:09

Also, taxes are so high now that work is almost seen as something to be punished for doing and assets are taxed less than PAYE jobs.

Despite what the government wants you to believe, UK income tax is relatively low when compared with much of the rest of Europe. But you are correct, assets and non-earned income (rent, interest, capital gains etc.) is taxed at a lower rate than earned income, so there is a disincentive to doing PAYE jobs as opposed to investing or using a limited company through which to earn dividends rather than a wage.

focuslocus · 02/04/2023 11:00

Because the Government is more interested in increasing benefits by 10% than giving workers an increase during a time of high inflation so more and more people are opting not to work or to work part time when it makes little different to the money they receive and they have a guaranteed income with inflation proof increase each year without having to worry about working.

Also, taxes are so high now that work is almost seen as something to be punished for doing and assets are taxed less than PAYE jobs. Lots of people have given up bothering.

justanotherdaduser · 02/04/2023 10:31

Moveforward · 01/04/2023 17:17

How do they work.out productivity?

I've just retired early and part of the reason was technology has taken over and often doesn't work so I ended up being unproductive whilst I mend it/probe to find out the issue/wait for IT to mend it/wait for updates/wait for third party tech to work again because its having tech issues.

I used to spend 85% of my time working and 15% max adminey/unproductive stuff. It became more like 66% productive 33% other stuff.

Productivity is a measure of output per unit of labur.

Most commonly used number is output in Pounds (or Dollar) per hour of work.

It answers the question :

What is the value of goods (or service) an average representative UK worker produces for an hour of work?

For UK, the answer in 2019 was abotu $54
For Germany, the answer was $69

So an average German worker produced over 25% more an hour than an average UK worker in 2019.

Or another way of looking at it is :

An average German worker produces in 4 days what an UK worker produces in 5 days. To achieve the same standard of living as UK, Germans need to work just 4 days a week (but obviously they work 5 days, hence higher standard of living!)

Ultimately, this number determines prosperity of nations, wages and standard of living, quality of public services and so on.

In your specific example, it would appear that your productivity at work fell due to poor decisions by your employer. If that happened to everyone else in the company, then the productivity of the business had fallen too.

Thankfully in the entire economy, something like that usually doesn't happen, and productivity normally rises over time - due to innovations, investment and improvement in skills. Obviously the experience of individual businesses will differ, some will fail, some will do well.

justanotherdaduser · 01/04/2023 21:17

MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 18:41

I wonder if they have similar split with higher proportion paid in benefits than paying taxes, only recently but still

They do. Benefit payment as percentage of GDP in UK is below EU average.

Among countries that spend more on benefit payment than UK are France, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Germany, Belgium, Finland and Austria -- all with more productive economy than UK.

We also should to be careful conflating Covid influenced statistics with the norm. The specific statistics you are mentioning is probably during 2021/2022 lockdown?

According to ONS, it was caused by government's response to the pandemic , though that didn't stop Daily Mail and similar papers from having a field day with the numbers.

Reductions in indirect taxes and increased benefits-in-kind, largely in response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, drove the proportion of individuals receiving more in benefits than they paid in taxes increased from 47.5% to 54.2% in FYE 2021, the largest annual increase since records began in 1977.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?
MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 18:41

I wonder if they have similar split with higher proportion paid in benefits than paying taxes, only recently but still

justanotherdaduser · 01/04/2023 17:46

MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 15:39

I’d also look at benefits system and compare with others and see if it disincentives in any major way

Unemployment benefit in UK is one of the lowest among the advanced economies.

This link has good cross-country comparison (click on the 'table' tab) : https://data.oecd.org/benwage/benefits-in-unemployment-share-of-previous-income.htm

UK unemployment beneift, measured as a percentage of previous income, is 5th from the bottom. There are a large number of significantly more productive economies with much better benefits.

Benefits and wages - Benefits in unemployment, share of previous income - OECD Data

Find, compare and share OECD data by indicator.

https://data.oecd.org/benwage/benefits-in-unemployment-share-of-previous-income.htm

Moveforward · 01/04/2023 17:17

How do they work.out productivity?

I've just retired early and part of the reason was technology has taken over and often doesn't work so I ended up being unproductive whilst I mend it/probe to find out the issue/wait for IT to mend it/wait for updates/wait for third party tech to work again because its having tech issues.

I used to spend 85% of my time working and 15% max adminey/unproductive stuff. It became more like 66% productive 33% other stuff.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/04/2023 17:06

Moreorlessmentallystable · 01/04/2023 16:06

But how is that the taxpayer's problem? If you decide to have a kid you should have the means to either: live on one wage, have family to help with childcare, organise different shifts with your partner, or had improved your earning potential before having said child, so they can attend paid childcare. Our life choices are not anyone else's responsibility.

Most countries support you having children.

If we don’t have them unless we can tick all your boxes how will the population reproduce. It is absolutely the tax payers job to support children. We need a young population.

Reugny · 01/04/2023 16:25

JenniferBooth · 01/04/2023 16:22

Wish you Tories would make up your minds and stick to it
NEW: Father-of-six Jacob Rees-Mogg has said that the UK pension age will HAVE to rise as Brits aren't having enough kids - something which he and Boris Johnson led "by example" with

If people in their 20s and 30s could afford housing maybe the birth rate would increase.

Reugny · 01/04/2023 16:23

@Moreorlessmentallystable sorry didn't make it clear doing that from 9 months is ridiculous. Most European countries expect you to do that at 2.

JenniferBooth · 01/04/2023 16:22

Wish you Tories would make up your minds and stick to it
NEW: Father-of-six Jacob Rees-Mogg has said that the UK pension age will HAVE to rise as Brits aren't having enough kids - something which he and Boris Johnson led "by example" with

Reugny · 01/04/2023 16:16

Moreorlessmentallystable · 01/04/2023 16:06

But how is that the taxpayer's problem? If you decide to have a kid you should have the means to either: live on one wage, have family to help with childcare, organise different shifts with your partner, or had improved your earning potential before having said child, so they can attend paid childcare. Our life choices are not anyone else's responsibility.

Other European countries actually subsidize parents of very young children but once the children are eligible for child care, which is much cheaper than in the UK due higher levels of state funding, then parents are expected to work.

In fact until you are 18 lots of European countries give you a lot but then once you are a working adult you pay more direct taxes to fund it.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 01/04/2023 16:06

L1ttledrummergirl · 31/03/2023 09:56

Because the government use employment productivity as the measurement of success. Anyone who is out of employment is considered unproductive including those unable to work due to disability, unpaid carers (who save the country millions), sahp, volunteers etc.

It's insane that someone on minimum wage will be expected to place their 9 month old in childcare, paid for with childcare vouchers (tax payers), which costs more than they earn, so that they can work for minimum wage and count as productive.

But how is that the taxpayer's problem? If you decide to have a kid you should have the means to either: live on one wage, have family to help with childcare, organise different shifts with your partner, or had improved your earning potential before having said child, so they can attend paid childcare. Our life choices are not anyone else's responsibility.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 01/04/2023 16:01

sst1234 · 31/03/2023 09:40

Because of part time tax credits culture. The last labour government damaged the economy hugely by introducing tax credits and subsidizing low wages. Employers have no incentive to invest in productivity and automation because they can get cheap labour subsidized by the taxpayer. This is arguably the worst policy introduced by any government in the last 25 years, because of the long term irreversible damage it has caused, making the whole country poorer.

💯 %, nowadays people just expect to be subsidized as if it was their birthright ...so sad.

MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 15:39

I’d also look at benefits system and compare with others and see if it disincentives in any major way

postwarbulge · 01/04/2023 15:30

While at Uni, I got a summer job in a factory drilling holes in bits of metal used to make bus conductors' ticket machines. The machines I was using had been made before WW1!

MarshaBradyo · 01/04/2023 14:44

Kazzyhoward · 31/03/2023 11:42

We don't want our little darlings to get their hands dirty with manual work, trades, manufacturing, etc.! We'd far rather they went to Uni for 3 years to get a Mickey Mouse degree and then work in call centres, retail or hospitality on minimum wage!

Not sure this is the issue. If those retail jobs exist it doesn’t matter whose little darlings work them the productivity level is the same.

So are people arguing for reducing hospitality, retail and call centres as sectors?

And increasing manufacturing etc?

I’m not sure why the latter is looked up to, I recall a piece on China saying what they want to do is less of being world’s factory and more of world’s ideas and services.

In some ways what the U.K. offers.

Maybe it’s easier to think of which sectors people want to grow and which they want to shrink.

Some have higher productivity than others - I think finance, creative sectors and engineering do quite well?

JenniferBooth · 01/04/2023 14:33

The low paid jobs were there BEFORE the tax credits. The abolition of the wages councils led to that as predicted. So if tax credits were abolished do you really think employers would step up and pay more. Because they didnt after the wages councils were abolished in 1993

15th December 1992.

" ONE in four workers who approached the Scottish Low Pay Unit in the

past year was being paid below the legal minimum rate set by the wages

council.

This fact was highlighted in a ''Food for Thought'' survey carried out

for the pay unit by Roy Wood, senior lecturer at the Scottish Hotel

School in Strathclyde University.

The report comes at a time when the Government is intent on pushing

through Parliament legislation which will abolish the 26 wages councils

still in existence.

Wages councils were established in 1909 with the support of Sir

Winston Churchill who told the Commons it was required to protect

low-paid workers from unscrupulous employers.

But the present Government denies the lower paid require this

protection. Michael Forsyth, Minister of State at the Department of

Employment, who is responsible for the Trade Union Reform and Employment

Rights Bill which covers the abolition of the councils, wrote in a

letter date December 10: ''There is no good reason to believe that the

abolition of wages councils will lead to widespread reductions in pay .

. . It is of little help to workers to saddle employers with

bureaucratic requirements which do nothing to encourage enterprise and

initiative.

The letter went on: ''Most of the workers covered by wages councils

are not poor; many work part-time and live in households with two or

more earners.'' Mr David Stark, the recipient of the letter, and an

official of the Transport and General Workers Union, however does not

agree with the Minister.

He said: ''Unfortunately there are a number of unscrupulous employers

who will take advantage of the absence of wages councils to cut wages.''

The author of the survey, Mr Roy Hood, said: ''I believe wages will

decline. Some employers will cut the hourly rate and there will also be

a general decline in the real value of wages over a period of years.''

The Scottish Low Pay Unit believes that existing evidence does not
back up Michael Forsyth's assertion. It points to numerous workers who

are not covered by wages council rates and who earn even lower than the

average of just over #3 an hour set by the councils.

It has examples of security guards who earn #1.70 an hour and have to

work 100 hours a week to earn a wage. It points to young receptionists

who are paid as little as #1.50 an hour, and the worst example of low

wages which the unit has on its file is that of a third-year apprentice

car mechanic who is paid #1 an hour.

Morag Gillespie, of the Scottish Low Pay Unit, said: ''There is

considerable evidence which suggests that once wages councils are

abolished wages will indeed be cut. The latest checks show that one in

10 workers covered by wages councils are underpaid. Take away the

protection of the councils and the wage levels could plummet even more.''

More than 200,000 Scottish workers are covered by wages councils

including those in hairdressing, retail trades, hotels, and restaurants.

Wage rates set by councils vary between #100.81 for a 39-hour-week in

the button manufacturing industry to #120.90 in tailoring.

David Stark, who is a member of the aerated waters wages council,

explained how the councils operate. He said: ''The councils are made up

of equal numbers of employers' and workers' representatives plus three

independent members who are appointed by the Secretary of State for Employment. Both sides put their case for a new wage rate to the

independent members then retire to separate rooms. ''Independent council

members can call either side back in and ask for further information.

The independent chair then puts their proposals to the full council and

it is voted on by both sides. This means that the new rate is set by the

independent members.''

At the recent aerated wages council of which David Stark is a member,

the council agreed an 11p hourly increase giving new hourly wage rates

of #3.08 -- #123.20 for a 40-hour week. He said: ''We are fortunate that

in this industry most of the large companies have trade union agreements

and the council rate is only a benchmark. But in many other industries

where there are no union agreements employers will exploit the absence

of the council.'

Michael Forsyth does not agree. In his letter he writes: ''Without the

councils, wage rates will adjust to suit local economic circumstances .

. . businesses themselves are best able to judge what they can afford

and what levels of pay are necessary to recruit and retail suitable

employees.'' The Government expects to guide the legislation through

Parliament within the next nine months and be in a position to abolish

the councils a few weeks later.

The Low Pay Network, which is campaigning to save the wages councils,

believes it is a contradiction for Mrs Gillian Shepherd, Employment Minister, to have overall responsibility for this legislation when she

also has responsibility within the Cabinet for women's issues.

It points out that the industries covered by the councils ''tends to

employ significant proportions of women especially on a part-time

basis.''

Winston Churchill, in his capacity as President of the Board of Trade,

was responsible for introducing wages councils and had this to say on

the subject. ''. . . where you have what we call sweated trades, you

have no organisation, no parity of bargaining, the good employer is

undercut by the bad, and the bad undercut by the worst . . . where these

conditions prevail, you have not a condition of progress, but a

condition of progressive degeneration.

But then Sir Winston always was a renegade!"

justanotherdaduser · 01/04/2023 13:49

EffortlessDesmond · 01/04/2023 13:36

Thank you @justanotherdaduser for the link to the Nicholas Henderson memo. I haven't ever seen that, because (I assume) that when it was being circulated, I was living overseas. It really brings home the limited intellectual quality among our politicians (of all parties) and the enduring obduracy of the Treasury and the unions. I have only skimmed it, but will read it properly.

It's a fascinating read, if only for the history. Hope you enjoy it

Henderson was retiring and this was meant to be his valedictory despatch, probably why it was so unusually forthright. Economist leaked it the same year causing some embarassment for the Callaghan government at the time.

Margaret Thatcher invited him back from retirement to serve as ambassadtor to Washington where he played a key role during the Falkland war.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/04/2023 13:36

Thank you @justanotherdaduser for the link to the Nicholas Henderson memo. I haven't ever seen that, because (I assume) that when it was being circulated, I was living overseas. It really brings home the limited intellectual quality among our politicians (of all parties) and the enduring obduracy of the Treasury and the unions. I have only skimmed it, but will read it properly.

determinedtomakethiswork · 01/04/2023 10:27

I am really enjoying this conversation. It's very depressing of course but it's so heartening to hear so many women with such intelligent points of view.

justanotherdaduser · 01/04/2023 00:29

There are two aspects to this -

Productivity expressed in output per hour worked ($ / hour of work) in UK is relatively low compared to many of its advanced economy peers, say, the likes of US, Germany, Netherlands, France, Belgium, Denmark and so on.

See here for a chart comapriing UK with some other OECD member countries https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/labor-productivity-per-hour-pennworldtable?tab=chart&country=GBR~USA~FRA~DEU~NLD~SWE~DNK~AUT~BEL~GRC~PRT~POL~FIN~HUN~CZE~RUS&region=World

This fact translates to comparatively lower standard of living in UK, lower wages, lower government revenue and so on.

But as the chart shows, this had been so for many decades. By 1970s several of our European neighbours had pulled ahead of UK, triggering the famous despatch from Sir Nicholas Henderson, UK's ambassador to France, in 1979 about British decline and its causes. Leaked almost immediately, but declassified only in 2006, this is still an interesting read -
https://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/110961

The second aspect is that productivity growth since the global financial crisis in 2008 had been much lower than previous trend. (this is also true for most other advanced economies, but UK situation is more acute)

This is a much bigger problem because it contributes to stagnant wages, rising pressure on government budget etc. In the absence of productivity growth, the pressure on NHS, school budgets, elderly care etc will continue to worsen, especially now when percentage of retired people in UK population is going to rise for next few decades.

The near stagnant productivity growth since 2010 is a puzzle. Number of studies have investigated various causes behind it and none have been able to fully explain the gap between trend UK productivity growth before the 2008 crisis and the actual now.

There is one constant though whenever UK low productivity is disussed - low investment (both private and public sector). Among OECD economies, UK's investment as a share of GDP is much lower than OECD average or most of its peers.

Here is quick comparison of UK investment as a percentage of GDP compared to few other countries and other high income economies - https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NE.GDI.FTOT.ZS?locations=GB-FR-DE-XD

The chart shows that lower investment in UK had been theme for at least 30 years. So that alone cannot fully explain stalled productivity in the last 12 years. But higher investment, either from government or private sector will certainly help.

Few other explanation I have come across are -

Very low interest rate environment since 2008 allowed many firms that would have otherwise gone bust to survive, locking in labour and capital in relatively less productive activities.

Simiarly too, labour market churn since 2008 had been much lower than before.

But as said before, none of these fully explain the gap between current productivity growth and previous trend.

Productivity: output per hour worked

Productivity is measured as gross domestic product (GDP) per hour of work. This data is adjusted for inflation and for differences in the cost of living between countries.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/labor-productivity-per-hour-pennworldtable?country=GBR%7EUSA%7EFRA%7EDEU%7ENLD%7ESWE%7EDNK%7EAUT%7EBEL%7EGRC%7EPRT%7EPOL%7EFIN%7EHUN%7ECZE%7ERUS&region=World&tab=chart

Havanananana · 31/03/2023 22:27

EffortlessDesmond · 31/03/2023 21:11

Yes, I accept your reservations on the legal framework, but the Canadian company still has to persuade its Uk workforce to work for below market wages, and why would they?

No it doesn't. CPCPP is designed to allow the Canadian/Australian/Mexican etc. business to set wages in the UK. In this case the Canadian company can sue the UK government for imposing a minimum wage that makes the business less profitable (and if it wins, the UK taxpayer ends up paying) - and if the corporation wins, it can say to the employees that the job now pays £x an hour, and if you don't accept this, we'll close the factory. Either way, both the employees affected and the UK taxpayer lose out - and the taxpayer and Treasury also lose out as the sacked employees will cease to be taxpayers themselves and will instead be receiving support and benefits from the Treasury.

Meanwhile the Canadian company transfers production to Vietnam, pays the employees there £50 a week and now has tariff-free access to the UK market.

DewinDwl · 31/03/2023 22:18

Lack of investment in equipment, staff training, technology, innovation, etc. What should be spent on investment goes to shareholders, bonus etc. I think the "prioritise the shareholders over everything including the company's viability" trend has been going on for decades worldwide but it seems worse in the UK.

Apart from that the UK did worse than most comparable economies since the 2008 recession. And then, Brexit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread