Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why does the UK have such low productivity compared other advanced economies?

166 replies

Fifi1010 · 31/03/2023 09:37

Our economic productivity has grown 0.8 percent per year on average since 2008 compared with 2 percent before. Why is that? High productivity increases the tax receipts , money for schools and healthcare. If we don't improve productivity living standards will further decline. Where have we gone wrong? I know Brexit is a problem but this started 8 years before.

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 04/04/2023 10:32

How are we defining cliff edges? Because if it's just about tax, that would be missing out a significant number of situations where people choose to work less because it isn't worth their while. And those happen all across the income spectrum.

It might be a person on UC working part time for NMW who isn't going to be any better off practically from doing the extra day once you factor in reduced top up benefits and free school meals. It might be someone who doesn't want to take the extra contract on because once they go over 50k, it's not worth their while when they lose child benefit as well as hit 40% tax. It might be someone who's going to lose 15 of the 30 free nursery hours when they go over 100k and be worse off for doing it. I haven't seen the report and nor do I claim to know exactly what the impact is, but I'd hope any government research has a wide scope.

I'm also not sure that only small numbers are affected, because even using the tightest definition of cliff edges there's a ripple effect. I'm pretty much certain never to earn 100k, but if I have to wait longer for medical treatment because the NHS doctor I need won't do the extra shift if it takes her over 100k, that's impacting me. These decisions don't only affect the people taking them.

justanotherdaduser · 04/04/2023 09:51

@Lostinalibrary , regarding this :
"Well yeah it is - the chancellor himself commissioned research into poor productivity and our tax cliff edges were a very clear problem."

Could you please share a link to the report or its name? (I couldn't find)

While they can certainly impact labour market participation decision at individual level, I would have imagined at worst the effect will be marginal, if at all detectable at national economy level.

But if these are identified as one of the major causes of U.K.'s stagnating productivity, I am curious to learn about the transmission channels through which tax cliff edge affect productivity and how that estimate was made.

Havanananana · 04/04/2023 08:55

"the chancellor himself commissioned research into poor productivity and our tax cliff edges were a very clear problem."

Which chancellor? The current multi-millionaire one? The one before him, who has no qualifications or experience in economics or industry (he's an academic) and who nearly crashed the economy? Or the one married to a gazillionaire, who doesn't know anyone who is working class and who is now PM?

The cliff edges are only a problem for those few affected - not for the millions of people for whom the challenge is finding a job that pays enough to keep a roof over their heads, and keep warm and fed.

MojoMoon · 03/04/2023 22:58

From a purely mathematical perspective, the increase in the labour market participation rate caused it (productivity is output divided by number of hours worked). The share of people in the labour market has risen (until psot-Covid) faster than output rose. Women working more and the post EU expansion arrival of lots of young working age eastern Europeans added to the potential workforce size.

So the question is then why doesn't more hours worked equal matching growth in output?

  1. the government effectively subsides low wages so the cost of adding more low-paid workers is not that high for companies. The employees will get topped up by benefit system and we tolerate low standards of loving.

Which leads on to

  1. companies don't invest in measures in improve productivity because they've found it cheaper to hire more workers instead.

The amount of investment made by businesses is low compared to other countries. That's not just about buying big machinery in factories but in the service sector as well - billing, admin, data, customer management, logistics etc.
Construction sector is very inefficient - dominated by small or even one man band companies and so doesn't scale up or incentivised much investment in improved equipment or processes

Businesses also aren't training their employees - again, the government doesn't make them do it (via mandatory apprenticeships or training budgets) and the economic benefits are not clear cut enough for them to do it.

Eleganz · 03/04/2023 22:43

Reugny · 03/04/2023 11:19

One of the problems with tendered contracts is that the company needs to be big enough to have individuals whose sole job is co-coordinating and writing up paper work for tendered contracts. (I work with firms who have to do this.)

My local area use to have small firms do the local council gardening. The council decided to combine with another council to "save" money and find one firm to do it all. This meant any company who completed the bid now had to complete more paper work with examples of when they handed contracts that big. So unsurprisingly the small firm didn't bother tendering. The winner was a big firm and the first month they took over it was interesting watching their "gardeners" mow. Some of them clearly had never used any lawn mower before. The council then got loads of complaints from the public about the state of the grass, verges, hedges, etc.

I think you've just described most public sector procurement there.

Larger firms that write good tenders and then pull in cheap untrained labour to do skilled jobs badly and charge public sector bodies extra when they complain about the quality and want it sorting out. Bane of my life.

Lostinalibrary · 03/04/2023 22:34

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 12:36

... there are some huge cliff edges where the effective rate of tax is 70% and over 100% if you have children and hit 100k. The chancellor himself commissioned a study which told him this is a huge problem by actual economists.

Nobody would dispute that rates are high for certain high earners, but only 4% of the working population earns over £100,000. For 96% of workers, and particularly the 40% earning less than £30,000, this is not an issue. For the UK as a whole, it is certainly not a "huge problem".

Well yeah it is - the chancellor himself commissioned research into poor productivity and our tax cliff edges were a very clear problem.

HungryMum101 · 03/04/2023 22:23

Youngishone · 03/04/2023 00:19

Short contracts mean always looking for a new job rather than concentrating on the current one. Private equity takes money out of business rather than investing. Complex life admin hours on the phone to several people to get anything done. Tendering means contracts go to the cheapest rather than the most competent

Yes, this

Kazzyhoward · 03/04/2023 13:44

Reugny · 03/04/2023 11:19

One of the problems with tendered contracts is that the company needs to be big enough to have individuals whose sole job is co-coordinating and writing up paper work for tendered contracts. (I work with firms who have to do this.)

My local area use to have small firms do the local council gardening. The council decided to combine with another council to "save" money and find one firm to do it all. This meant any company who completed the bid now had to complete more paper work with examples of when they handed contracts that big. So unsurprisingly the small firm didn't bother tendering. The winner was a big firm and the first month they took over it was interesting watching their "gardeners" mow. Some of them clearly had never used any lawn mower before. The council then got loads of complaints from the public about the state of the grass, verges, hedges, etc.

All so very true. Smaller firms simply don't have the experience/resources/time to prepare "professional" bids for public sector and other big contracts. It's all about dotting the i's, crossing the t's, ensuring the right "words" are in the right places, the right policies in place, etc.

I had the job of doing grant claims for the firm I worked for in the 90s. They were an absolute nightmare, and it was all about matching exactly your application against the published criteria and ensuring your bid matched exactly what the awarding body was expecting to see. That only comes with experience. Once I got a grant claim knocked back by a quango because our application had included the purchase of a particular piece of equipment, let's say the Acme 101x - in reality, the bid took so long for them to approve, the 101x had been superseded by the 101y and we couldn't buy a 101x, so bought the 101y instead which was basically identical, similar price, did the same job, but just a few "tweaks" from the manufacturer. Grant was denied because we didn't "meet the conditions" which was to buy exactly what we had applied for! No amount of persuading, letters from supplier, marketing literature from manufacturer would persuade the awarding body!

Same today with a local theatre trust I work with. The trust spent best part of 20 years trying to get grants to renovate it. Always knocked back. They had a change of management and one of the new trustees was experienced in grant applications, they got awarded the first grant they applied for, for millions! But then, they had trouble finding "acceptable" contractors to do the work, as the bids had to be approved by the awarding body, and all the bids from local contractors, which the trust members knew and trusted, and which were acceptable by them, were rejected by the governing body, for reasons such as not having an adequate anti-bullying policy in one case, another contractor rejected for not declaring the number of disabled employees and gender analysis.

It's nothing to do with whether they can do the work at a suitable price - it's all political and woke these days, and small firms simply don't know how to do all the nit-picking, box-ticking, etc - they are too busy doing the work than to spend all their time doing all the nonsense. The end result is that the "professional" firms get the work and usually do a crap job of it, and probably 2 or 3 times the price, because they've got to employ a small army of people just to write "professional" contract bids containing all the nonsense required.

Reugny · 03/04/2023 11:19

Youngishone · 03/04/2023 00:19

Short contracts mean always looking for a new job rather than concentrating on the current one. Private equity takes money out of business rather than investing. Complex life admin hours on the phone to several people to get anything done. Tendering means contracts go to the cheapest rather than the most competent

One of the problems with tendered contracts is that the company needs to be big enough to have individuals whose sole job is co-coordinating and writing up paper work for tendered contracts. (I work with firms who have to do this.)

My local area use to have small firms do the local council gardening. The council decided to combine with another council to "save" money and find one firm to do it all. This meant any company who completed the bid now had to complete more paper work with examples of when they handed contracts that big. So unsurprisingly the small firm didn't bother tendering. The winner was a big firm and the first month they took over it was interesting watching their "gardeners" mow. Some of them clearly had never used any lawn mower before. The council then got loads of complaints from the public about the state of the grass, verges, hedges, etc.

Reugny · 03/04/2023 11:11

AfraidToRun · 02/04/2023 23:21

because the technology thats replaced humans is shit. Constantly breaks, doesn't work as intended and needs a million workarounds.

That's because UK managers go for the cheapest option or the option that has the best sales people.

Kazzyhoward · 03/04/2023 11:00

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 12:36

... there are some huge cliff edges where the effective rate of tax is 70% and over 100% if you have children and hit 100k. The chancellor himself commissioned a study which told him this is a huge problem by actual economists.

Nobody would dispute that rates are high for certain high earners, but only 4% of the working population earns over £100,000. For 96% of workers, and particularly the 40% earning less than £30,000, this is not an issue. For the UK as a whole, it is certainly not a "huge problem".

The £100k is only one cliff edge. There's also the one at £50k which affects a lot more. There's also the benefits cliff edges at much lower income levels which affects huge numbers. Add up all the people at each cliff edge and you'll come up with a pretty significant number of workers/potential workers.

Youngishone · 03/04/2023 00:19

Short contracts mean always looking for a new job rather than concentrating on the current one. Private equity takes money out of business rather than investing. Complex life admin hours on the phone to several people to get anything done. Tendering means contracts go to the cheapest rather than the most competent

Ingrowncrotchhair · 03/04/2023 00:07

Neededanewuserhandle · 31/03/2023 10:30

No long term investment - it's always about hedge fund bonuses and dividends for Sir Bufton Fucking Tufton and we have to accept it because we have too many forelock tugging race to the bottom twats.

Just what I was going to say

L1ttledrummergirl · 02/04/2023 23:54

Dh works in a factory. They had someone try to sell the company a piece of equipment to do dh job, except, it could only do half the job and was much slower. They kept dh.

AfraidToRun · 02/04/2023 23:21

because the technology thats replaced humans is shit. Constantly breaks, doesn't work as intended and needs a million workarounds.

JimmyDurham · 02/04/2023 23:08

In a nuitshell, lack of automation. Employing cheap labour instead of machines means it takes more UK workers to produce a given item/complete a given task that workers in more automated counties. Hence our productivity per head is dire.

duoplik · 02/04/2023 23:05

@Havanananana is that 4% of PAYE earners?

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 12:36

... there are some huge cliff edges where the effective rate of tax is 70% and over 100% if you have children and hit 100k. The chancellor himself commissioned a study which told him this is a huge problem by actual economists.

Nobody would dispute that rates are high for certain high earners, but only 4% of the working population earns over £100,000. For 96% of workers, and particularly the 40% earning less than £30,000, this is not an issue. For the UK as a whole, it is certainly not a "huge problem".

Hawkins003 · 02/04/2023 11:54

@Fifi1010
At a guess various levels of technology development, different areas of manufacturing being built overseas, not sure really

justanotherdaduser · 02/04/2023 11:50

Lostinalibrary · 02/04/2023 11:16

It’s really not; there are some huge cliff edges where the effective rate of tax is 70% and over 100% if you have children and hit 100k. The chancellor himself commissioned a study which told him this is a huge problem by actual economists.

The cliff edges are a problem and a disincentive to work for some; they should be fixed.

But those distortions don't change OP's original point that overall tax in UK is not unusually high despite what the government wants you to believe.

This chart shows OECD economies overall tax as a percentage of GDP.
https://www.oecd.org/coronavirus/en/data-insights/tax-to-gdp-ratios

UK's tax-to-GDP at 33% is exactly at OECD average

Since discussing productivity here, a number of more productive economies, including, Denmark, France, Germany, Austria, Netherlands, Sweden, Belgium etc have higher tax revenue than UK.

Also, some more productive nations like US and Switzerland have lower overall tax revenue (as pct of GDP) than UK.

Whatever is ailing UK productivity, it's not tax rate. Lowering it will make some people happy but at macro level will not make any difference to UK's productivity problem.

https://www.oecd.org/coronavirus/en/data-insights/tax-to-gdp-ratios

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/04/2023 11:43

Tax needs to be viewed as a whole though: income tax isn't the whole story. A like for like comparison would need to include national insurance and VAT, plus take into account benefits and goods and services that are provided subsidised or free in the countries being compared. You've only to look around you in the UK and other European countries (France and Switzerland are the two I've been to most recently) to see how crap our infrastructure has become and how much worse poverty has got.

Yes, very true.

MarshaBradyo · 02/04/2023 11:43

I’d break it down into sectors and look at which are most productive and least

Not sure it necessarily means the least productive should be decreased but changes are hard

Increased productivity can mean fewer people. Aiming for fewer people doesn’t always go down well as we’ve seen recently.

I find the earn more at the supermarket line interesting as a sector it is investing in other ways to pay etc therefore reducing number of staff. That’s not always seen positively but in times of labour shortage it probably is.

Phineyj · 02/04/2023 11:39

Tax needs to be viewed as a whole though: income tax isn't the whole story. A like for like comparison would need to include national insurance and VAT, plus take into account benefits and goods and services that are provided subsidised or free in the countries being compared. You've only to look around you in the UK and other European countries (France and Switzerland are the two I've been to most recently) to see how crap our infrastructure has become and how much worse poverty has got.

The NHS waiting lists alone explain why productivity's gone into reverse.

It really isn't that much of a "puzzle": well educated, well treated, well housed, healthy people working with good tools, equipment and systems are motivated and productive! Especially if they think their children will be better off than them. How many of us truly believe that?

Havanananana · 02/04/2023 11:24

An average German worker produces in 4 days what an UK worker produces in 5 days. To achieve the same standard of living as UK, Germans need to work just 4 days a week (but obviously they work 5 days, hence higher standard of living!)

Actually, the average German worker only works 34.6 hours a week, around 2 hours a week less than the average UK worker. Many workplaces close at 1 pm on a Friday. And they still have a higher standard of living and more leisure time than the UK worker because of investment in automation and decent rates of pay - as well as far better healthcare provision, childcare, public transport etc. and a culture that does not condone overtime and work-martyrs who work all hours. Nor do Germans generally accept long commutes.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/04/2023 11:22

A better way to put it, I think, is that bottlenecks, marginal tax rates and cliff edges function as a real disincentive to work more at various income points in the UK system.

Sometimes that calculation is made by a person who relies on top up benefits to pay the bills, other times by a person who doesn't want to take on the extra job because it's not worth the effort once they hit 50k once you factor child benefit in, other times by someone who doesn't want to go over 100k because they lose their personal allowance and the 30 hours. For whatever reason, we haven't addressed this, and fiscal drag means it's probably going to become more common.

Swipe left for the next trending thread