Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To seriously consider increasing nursery time for 2yo before baby's born

34 replies

Endofmytetherfinally · 31/03/2023 08:06

She does 2 days at present but has become so difficult at home on the other days I'm genuinely worried about my ability to cope with her and a newborn.

I've tried techniques from 'how to talk so little kids will listen', I've tried ignoring (non dangerous behaviour) and love bombing anything good. Genuinely don't know what else to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Endofmytetherfinally · 01/04/2023 20:55

Thanks @Coffeeandchocs will try stamping feet. I've done 'can you draw how angry you are' but she's too small. Or doing grrr and trying to laugh her out of it but I don't think she gets it.

To be fair to her dad, I'm not really the main caregiver, he's very silly and playful with her and so hands on. We both do 4 days so they have plenty of time alone, I just think she's got some attachment issues with me now I'm pregnant.

OP posts:
maryberryslayers · 01/04/2023 16:39

Increase the nursery days and don't feel guilty. With her being at nursery, both her and the baby will get the attention they need. A newborn and a toddler need very different things. Toddler will be happy and entertained and baby can feed/nap in peace and you'll be able to take it to baby classes/swimming too.

When I had my second I kept 3 days for my 2yo increasing to 4 once he started pre-school at almost 4. It worked well and I felt able to cope on my 'both kids at home' days.

Coffeeandchocs · 01/04/2023 13:10

If she can tell you she’s sad but not why then she’s struggling to process and show her emotions (normal for this age) so maybe teaching some techniques to express her feelings other than shouting and screaming might be useful too. Me and my little boy do stampy feet, if he starts screaming and throwing himself around I say “you’re angry, let’s do angry stamping feet!”, it redirects him to express his anger in a different way (that won’t scare the neighbours!). I stamp my feet and he does the same and it usually ends in giggles instead of crying. It doesn’t work all the time and usually I have to have suggested it before he is in full meltdown but it does work most of the time.
With the wanting you to pick her up instead of dad, this is something dad needs to work on with her. Make dad pick ups fun, put her on his shoulders, count to five steps then tickle, sing a song while holding her. It’s likely dad will have to take over more when the new baby is here so he needs to focus on improving that. It’s no one’s fault, kids tend to gravitate towards the main caregiver naturally, who can blame them? But if that’s becoming a problem now I’d suggest working on that before the new baby arrives.

Endofmytetherfinally · 01/04/2023 12:04

Also I'm pretty sure she can walk, it's a short distance but she might be scared (lawnmower or other people approaching). When it is too far my issue is she doesn't want her dad picking her up, just mummy which really isn't possible.

OP posts:
Endofmytetherfinally · 01/04/2023 12:02

Thank you so much @Coffeeandchocs, really appreciate it. I actually do say it's scaring the neighbours because it's true, little boy next door says to his dad 'is she okay?' whereas mummy feels sad feels manipulative somehow although it's also true! And you're right she might care more about me then her.

I try and talk to her about it when she's calmed down but she doesn't know why or at least she can't seem to tell me. She just says her name sad which really upsets me too. Thanks for saying it's not necessarily something we're doing. I'm finding it very difficult and sure the pregnancy hormones aren't helping.

To be honest I'm very lenient and try not to say no much but my husband is incredibly risk averse as is his dad so she hears it more than I'd like. My parents were the same as you. Only for stuff that's dangerous. But to be fair I can't argue that climbing on the table or stepping into a road (suburban and very rarely cars around but still) when she's told no and why isn't dangerous..

OP posts:
Coffeeandchocs · 01/04/2023 09:02

I don’t mean to bombard you but I’ve just remembered another thing that’s really helped us. Limiting how much we say no, so that it’s reserved for the times we really need to put a stop to something. I made a note in my phone one morning how many times I said “no!” to my son, and it was 32 times! Can you imagine being told no to things you wanted to do, that many times!? Maybe you could try that, see how many times you’re actually stopping her from doing something. Then think about what you’re saying no to. One of our big ones was climbing on the dining room chairs, I must have said no ten times to that alone. When you think about what you’re saying no to, do you really need to stop what they’re doing? My son was exploring and learning to climb, why did I actually need to stop that? I just needed to be there to make sure he was safe and allow him to do it. You’d think that would create a feral child haha, but it’s actually quite the opposite. He’s had enough of standing on the chairs now he’s figured it out and had a bit of fun with it and moved onto the next thing. We reserve the “no”s for things he absolutely cannot do, touching the fire, annoying the dog, turning the oven knobs etc. And because we are now saying it less, it has more of an effect and he listens more. It’s picking your battles really, when you ask them to do something think about why you’re asking. Is it because they’re doing something that’s annoying you, or are they doing something unsafe?

Coffeeandchocs · 01/04/2023 08:53

Endofmytetherfinally · 01/04/2023 08:30

I agree @Coffeeandchocs and I'm not trying to use discipline that's beyond her understanding but I'm desperate to find a way to stop her shouting and screaming when we say no. We try the positive asking what we do want instead of what we don't like talk in a quiet voice and explain why, you're scaring the neighbours etc. But nothing seems to work and it absolutely shreds my nerves.

I think some shouting and screaming does just fall within the “terrible twos” stage. They’re frustrated an awful lot of the time. I’m sure you know this, though I just wanted to emphasise the point that you may well not be doing anything wrong and it might, like a lot of things with little ones, be a phase.
I try to offer choices as much as I can with my two year old, I think it satisfies the craving they have to have some control. Whether my child has a satsuma or banana for snack makes no odds to me but gives him a sense of his opinion being important when I give him that choice. Anything that you can bring her choices into I think will really help. “Do you want to go to the park or for a walk?”
I also keep consequences of his actions to things he can see. I understand why you’d tell your daughter she is scaring the neighbours as it attaches some feeling to it which is good, but does she care about the neighbours? I’d say, “I know you’re angry, but shouting makes mummy feel sad”.
With regards to her wanting to be picked up instead of walking. Are you sure where you’re expecting her to walk isn’t too long of a distance? They do tire really easily. I also find walks late afternoon always end in my little one wanting to be picked up, he’s more tired then but in the morning he will walk for a lot longer. Have you tried a scooter or balance bike?

Endofmytetherfinally · 01/04/2023 08:30

I agree @Coffeeandchocs and I'm not trying to use discipline that's beyond her understanding but I'm desperate to find a way to stop her shouting and screaming when we say no. We try the positive asking what we do want instead of what we don't like talk in a quiet voice and explain why, you're scaring the neighbours etc. But nothing seems to work and it absolutely shreds my nerves.

OP posts:
Coffeeandchocs · 31/03/2023 09:26

Squamata · 31/03/2023 08:28

I'd have no qualms about sending her in more. Don't feel guilty. When the baby comes, nursery is a valuable baby-free space!

However, I don't think that's a solution to all behaviour issues - you do need to find a way to feel on top of things rather than defeated by it. Nursery can't sort it all out for you and if her behaviour is poor at nursery that causes problems too.

How pregnant are you? Have you tried talking to her about the process, reading books with her etc? She might be unsettled by you being less mobile, more tired etc but if you show pictures or make a little book of what will happen, how you won't be this way forever and she'll always be special and part of your family, it might help.

With tantrums you need to do all you can to minimize (routines for snacks, sleep, activity etc) to help prevent her being overwhelmed and give vocal warnings 'we will do this in two minutes, one more minute of playing' etc.

Praise good behaviours a lot and tell her she's a good girl etc. Screaming, refusing to get in pram you can wait it out so long as it's not dangerous. Things like pulling car fur and drawing on walls would be absolute scorched earth unacceptable to me, very firm voice and she goes on the step or toy taken away etc - immediate consequence. They sound kind of like attention seeking things though.

When you say you've tried techniques - how long for? It can take a while for something to take effect.

I had dc2 when dc1 was 2.5. it was hard but survivable! Having a place to put the baby in our main rooms (high chair, bouncer, sleepyhead type thing) helped as I could pop baby down and sort dc1 out if she was acting up, and give her more attention while dc2 watched us.

I don’t think the techniques you suggest are appropriate for a two year old. Taking a toy away for drawing on walls would just upset and confuse them, they’d not see or understand the link between their drawing and them losing a toy! The naughty step is also a very outdated discipline technique. Putting a two year old on a naughty step for pulling a cat’s fur makes no sense, you’ve not taught the child the acceptable way to touch the cat, just removed her from the situation.
The giving timing warnings “we will do this in two minutes, you have one more minute of playing” is also ridiculous to say to a two year old. They don’t know what a minute is! You can tell them what’s coming next, for example “we’re playing with the dolls now, then we’re going to go for a bath” would be useful but giving them timings means absolutely nothing and will just cause confusion.

Choppies · 31/03/2023 09:26

I’m keeping my 18 month olds nursery routine of 4 days - just started Mat leave for number 2 a week ago - I figure in 6 months I’ll have to go back to work (maybe 3 days) so best to keep the place and keep her routine then I can give her all my love and attention when she’s at home (and DH is mostly around to help divide and conquer) - I find the newborn stage really hard and she loves nursery anyway! Tbh I figure she will have more fun there than watching me breastfeed - I get a nap - baby gets one-on-one time - house isn’t a total mess = everyone is happy (even if it will mean I’m skint hahaha!)

if you don’t have lots of family around then paid childcare is a must IMO

Goldenbear · 31/03/2023 09:19

You shouldn't put the 2 year old on the naughty step, completely inappropriate. All the behaviour is typical for that age, they are literally a baby still, a person who has existed on this planet for 2 years, lower your expectations. It is wearing but you need to encourage kindness, demonstrate stroking the cat in a gentle way, smiling and that the cat likes that, demonstrate the cat is sad when it's fur is pulled. It is about making good behaviour a habit.

peaches19 · 31/03/2023 09:18

It might also get better once the baby is here. We had some behaviour struggles just before my youngest was born which then went away once the baby arrived - I think it was fear of the unknown.

Coffeeandchocs · 31/03/2023 09:10

Hi OP, I see no issue with you increasing your toddlers days at nursery if you think it will be beneficial for you both.

The only thing I would say, having a son the same age and currently receiving advice from a speech and language therapist, everyone assumes at this age that children understand the words “no” and “don’t” but it actually isn’t always the case. You can teach “no” by using games where things are wrong, for example put an apple on a plate, “is the apple on the plate”.. “yes”… take the apple off the plate and ask again, “is the apple on the plate” ..”no”. When telling her not to do something, like “don’t pull the cats fur”, we shouldn’t assume the “don’t” is understood. Instead of saying “don’t xxx” redirect to what you want her to do. “Stroke the cat gently” works better than “don’t pull the cats fur”. It takes some time to get used to but implementing some different ways of speaking really does help communication with a child this age.

Endofmytetherfinally · 31/03/2023 09:09

That was for @Tarantallegra by the way. For the other questions, I've got 6 weeks left to go with my pregnancy and nope nursery don't accommodate half days.

OP posts:
Endofmytetherfinally · 31/03/2023 09:08

This did really help, thank you.

OP posts:
Endofmytetherfinally · 31/03/2023 09:08

Thanks for the replies. At 2 I don't think the naughty step is going to work for her. She gets the firm voice and toy removed but it doesn't seem to make any difference. We've talked a lot about the new baby and given her as much reassurance as we can.

She has an incredibly consistent routine too. I've been trying the techniques since she could start talking (she's very verbal) so it is a long term strategy not 'oh I did it once and it hasn't worked'. I agree it's attention seeking but I'm not sure how much attention she can have. It's completely 1-1 from myself or her dad or her grandparents on the days she's not at nursery.

OP posts:
RecklessBlackberries · 31/03/2023 08:58

This is our plan when/if we have a second. DS currently goes to nursery 2 days a week, we plan to up it to full time in April with the idea of having DC2 around October.

We're sending him earlier than we need to both in case I have a hard pregnancy but also so he doesn't directly blame the baby. He loves his nursery so I think he'll be fine with it.

Catsonskis · 31/03/2023 08:51

Hi op, I was in exactly same position when dd 2 came along 6m ago. DD1 was 2 and I upped her from 2-3 days when I was about 30 weeks (I had horrendous pgp but I also didn’t want to increase just as baby arrived).

ifs been the best thing for all 3 of us, she adores nursery and I reall focus on her in the morning and after I collect her rather than splitting my day between them all day. We’re all happier for it. I’m going to reduce back to 2 days soon but mainly because she’s a summer born so I only have 1 year before she starts school, plus easier to have them both by myself all day now baby is sitting/eating/feeding at better times, and dd1 is older.

id 100% recommend. If it doesn’t work you can always cancel the extra day!

Aozora13 · 31/03/2023 08:51

I have 3 DC with 5 years between the eldest and youngest. It worked well for us to keep older DC in nursery 3 days a week through younger siblings arriving and mat leave. It gave them stability and continuity and they were/are happy at nursery. It also meant I could have time to just focus on the baby (and sleep more) and was able to be better for the older kid(s) when they were home. We have no family support nearby so paid childcare is a big feature in our life!

Monstermoomoo · 31/03/2023 08:32

I increased my son's days at nursery before his brother was born, despite being a SAHM. We don't have any help with the kids from family so nursery is all we have for a bit of relief every now and again. I have no regrets! I guarantee you my older child was happier having fun with his friends at nursery than he would've been stuck at home with his newborn brother

Squamata · 31/03/2023 08:28

I'd have no qualms about sending her in more. Don't feel guilty. When the baby comes, nursery is a valuable baby-free space!

However, I don't think that's a solution to all behaviour issues - you do need to find a way to feel on top of things rather than defeated by it. Nursery can't sort it all out for you and if her behaviour is poor at nursery that causes problems too.

How pregnant are you? Have you tried talking to her about the process, reading books with her etc? She might be unsettled by you being less mobile, more tired etc but if you show pictures or make a little book of what will happen, how you won't be this way forever and she'll always be special and part of your family, it might help.

With tantrums you need to do all you can to minimize (routines for snacks, sleep, activity etc) to help prevent her being overwhelmed and give vocal warnings 'we will do this in two minutes, one more minute of playing' etc.

Praise good behaviours a lot and tell her she's a good girl etc. Screaming, refusing to get in pram you can wait it out so long as it's not dangerous. Things like pulling car fur and drawing on walls would be absolute scorched earth unacceptable to me, very firm voice and she goes on the step or toy taken away etc - immediate consequence. They sound kind of like attention seeking things though.

When you say you've tried techniques - how long for? It can take a while for something to take effect.

I had dc2 when dc1 was 2.5. it was hard but survivable! Having a place to put the baby in our main rooms (high chair, bouncer, sleepyhead type thing) helped as I could pop baby down and sort dc1 out if she was acting up, and give her more attention while dc2 watched us.

Noicant · 31/03/2023 08:20

Can you do 5 half days?

Tarantallegra · 31/03/2023 08:20

Obviously not what you asked but I've got an almost 2 year old and a 9 week old and I had the same fears as you. My 2 year old is big for his age and very strong and I had zero luck teaching him to be gentle before the baby came with tantrums, snatching and hitting, it was a nightmare and I thought more than once that I'd made a mistake.

It has definitely been difficult since his sister came along but it really didn't take long for him to learn to be gentle and they now have the sweetest relationship. Pregnancy with a toddler was so rough I feel much more energetic on the other side and a lot more able to run around after a toddler so he's happier and calmer when I do have to sit and feed the baby. There are of course complete nightmare days when nobody naps and it's all overwhelming but on the whole things are much better than I expected.

Agree with others about upping the nursery days before the baby is here but just wanted to share my view from the other side in case it helps x

Namechanger355 · 31/03/2023 08:19

Yes but many women send their kids post Mat leave to nursery is my point - so they are younger.

and you aren’t being unreasonable because quite frankly having the two together isn’t just like combining the difficulty of a newborn and a 2 use old - it will be worse because you won’t be able to leave them in the same room together alone for at least a while. So 3 days (or even more) seems like a perfectly sensible thing to do

Endofmytetherfinally · 31/03/2023 08:15

Shes just 2. My aibu really is that I feel guilty her being at nursery when technically she could be at home with me. At the moment when she's there I'm at work. Feels different if I'm home.

In terms of the behaviours. Screaming at the top of her voice when she's told no. Deliberately doing the things i ask her not to (drawing on walls, pulling the cats fur). Refusing to walk or go in the pram so I have to carry her when I'm heavily pregnant.

She bought my Mil to tears the other day with a tantrum so I know it's not just me. She's apparently fine at nursery though. We do so much outdoors to tire her out that I just don't know what else I can do.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread