Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School report is so vague it feels pointless

117 replies

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 00:22

My son has brought home his spring term report and for every subject he is working towards..school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year and a few exceptional children will be working at. Am I being unreasonable to wonder if nearly child is working towards what’s the point of sending home the report?
If my child is struggling I would genuinely like to help him but I feel there is such a vague approach to reports these days I can’t work out if he’s doing well or not. Is it normal to receive a school report and feel none the wiser?

OP posts:
Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 08:48

We have had the parents evening and it was very much no cause for concern/average child/could concentrate more.

With the report as he is just below, as expected for mid year, I’m wondering is he just below because of not understanding aspects of the curriculum or just below because of being mid-year. It could easily be either.

No criticism of the teachers; it’s clear to see they only have these options on the report. A lot of paperwork for such pointless feedback.

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 08:47

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 08:38

That's not how it works - my child got exceeding expectations on every report regardless of the time of year. They look at how they're doing at that point in time. A child working below expectations absolutely needs support.

Ok. Thats how your school did their reports and school will differ in how they report. There isnt a set format.

The two schools I work at do their reports as i described and as its a bit confusing they send out an explanation booklet as OP described.

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 08:38

Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 08:29

Yes but the year hasnt finished or, if year 1 the phase hasnt finished, so you wouldnt expect a child to have met the end of year expectations until the end of the year as they wont have covered the content to meet the end of year expectations. They dont need interventions if the end of year expectation is to use capital letters and full stops but they have only been taught full stops and capital letters is next terms teaching.
Theyd only need interventions if they had done the learning on full stops and still hadnt got it.

That's not how it works - my child got exceeding expectations on every report regardless of the time of year. They look at how they're doing at that point in time. A child working below expectations absolutely needs support.

Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 08:29

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 08:16

But working towards expectations does mean below, it's working towards/meeting/exceeding.

OP YANBU. I would want to know what targeted support if any the school are giving to help him meet expectations, and what you could do at home to help him. I'd ask for a meeting with his teacher to discuss it.

What year is he in? The mid year reports we got were always very short and then the summer one would have more detail (although still clearly a copy and paste job from a word bank)

Yes but the year hasnt finished or, if year 1 the phase hasnt finished, so you wouldnt expect a child to have met the end of year expectations until the end of the year as they wont have covered the content to meet the end of year expectations. They dont need interventions if the end of year expectation is to use capital letters and full stops but they have only been taught full stops and capital letters is next terms teaching.
Theyd only need interventions if they had done the learning on full stops and still hadnt got it.

BeretRaspberry · 31/03/2023 08:28

catinboooots · 31/03/2023 08:20

Last report I got said DS had excellent attendance. A week after they sent me a letter threatening me with a fine because he'd had too much time off sick.

I barely bother reading them.

Oh and don't get me started on homework. DS yr8 rarely gets any and it's never, ever marked.

Ours is the same. They get given an optional project every half term and that’s pretty much it.

HeadNorth · 31/03/2023 08:27

In Scotland with the 'curriculum for excellence' (snort) primary school reports descended into garbled, copy and paste, civil servant language - responsible citizen, effective contributor, it meant nothing. Parent's evening was your only hope of finding out whether your child was managing the work or not.

By secondary you at least had exam marks to give you a scooby how your child was faring.

catinboooots · 31/03/2023 08:20

Last report I got said DS had excellent attendance. A week after they sent me a letter threatening me with a fine because he'd had too much time off sick.

I barely bother reading them.

Oh and don't get me started on homework. DS yr8 rarely gets any and it's never, ever marked.

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 08:16

itsgettingweird · 31/03/2023 07:29

But they've given an explanation.

He's working towards - as expected.

If he want where he should be it would say below expectations.

So it gives the data they have - can't really blame the system because you don't like it!

But working towards expectations does mean below, it's working towards/meeting/exceeding.

OP YANBU. I would want to know what targeted support if any the school are giving to help him meet expectations, and what you could do at home to help him. I'd ask for a meeting with his teacher to discuss it.

What year is he in? The mid year reports we got were always very short and then the summer one would have more detail (although still clearly a copy and paste job from a word bank)

KittyAlfred · 31/03/2023 08:01

WellTidy · 31/03/2023 07:04

I see a huge difference between how Ds1 (independent secondary school) and Ds2 (state primary)‘s reports are written.

I’m not sure whether it is a primary/secondary difference, but in y7-9 DS1 would have a paragraph written per subject with lots of constructive feedback. Now in y10, for each subject, he is graded against his challenge grade, and constructive comments made as to how to achieve that challenge grade if he is below it in any subject. And a paragraph from the form teacher about him as a form member and person. Reports of some nature every half term.

DS2 is ranked at emerging/expected/exceeding and then a short paragraph about him as a person. Reports twice a year.

The difference is nothing to do with primary/secondary, and 100% due to paying vs not paying.

if you pay, you get more. Pretty basic really.

HubertTheGoat · 31/03/2023 07:55

Lougle · 31/03/2023 07:32

We get an effort grade, independent learning grade, and attainment grade. Then we get a table that shows the distribution of effort grades and independent learning grades by subject, so that we can see if their grade was typical of the year.

It seems fairly meaningless. For example, I know from talking to DD3's PE teacher because she has had a problem in his class, that DD3 is one of the 'more able' pupils and that she is in top set girls. Yet she is graded as 'meeting' requirements. This makes absolutely no logical sense, because she is clearly doing well as she is near the top of the top set. In another subject, Music, she is classed as 'mastering' despite playing no instruments at any level (although she is naturally fairly musical).

Being top of a cohort doesn't mean being above age related expectations though. Sometimes you get a very middling cohort. The expected range is also huge. The music curriculum doesn't require you to play an instrument beyond those you play in class, because that would be cometely unfair. She's being graded against the curriculum.

BeretRaspberry · 31/03/2023 07:42

carriedout · 31/03/2023 07:11

I don't understand why parents need so much direction from school tbh. You know your child well, you can see their work, you can see what they struggle with in homework already.

Yes the reports are quite generic, because of the drop down lists, but they provide an indication of whether the teacher thinks they are on track with their school work and you know a lot about how they are in general.

If you have any concerns, email a teacher.

Teachers have a huge workload and the Tory government has deliberately underfunded schools, they just do not have time to write an individual essay about each child.

This isn’t true with ours. We can’t see DS’s work. He’s in Yr 8 and recently gone down a set overall to 4 out of 7 (which they say is based on Maths and English attainment).

We have the opportunity to go to Parents’ Evening but you only actually get called if there’s a problem or concern, though we try and go anyway. In October, we got called for Maths. Got there and the teacher wasn’t as they were a supply teacher and apparently ‘didn’t do parents’ evenings’. Similarly, we got called to go to English this time and when we turned up, they didn’t know why we were asked to come and as they’d only been teaching him for 2 weeks, also couldn’t tell us anything.

You’d think it was a shit school but they got a recent outstanding from Ofsted. And conversely, last year and the year before, when DD was there and in top sets, they were the complete opposite.

We’ve tried speaking to them, including to the head of year who promised to do something and we’ve never heard from since, as well as the deputy head more recently who seems like he’s done bugger all too.

Our son is quiet and always has been and this seems to mean he gets overlooked. All we want to know is how he’s doing, why he’s gone down a set (if it’s possible to tell), and what we, as parents can do to help him at home. I didn’t think that was too much to ask.

quokka5 · 31/03/2023 07:40

I agree it is hard to interpret reports. While it's obvious if your child struggles to read, other subjects are harder to assess at home. DCs report is more detailed than the OPs DCs. There are three options- exceeds expectations, meets expectations and a third category, can't remember exact wording but indicates struggling. There are also comments, with underlying context i.e. 'full of energy' [can't sit still]. I think if there is nowhere to indicate your child is struggling then a report is a bit pointless, as it's the main thing you need to know.

HubertTheGoat · 31/03/2023 07:40

electricmoccasins · 31/03/2023 06:48

You know nothing about schools if you think classroom teachers have any autonomy over the format of school reports. They are told what to write. Usually given a word bank. The report box has a word maximum which you usually can't go over. Believe me, most classroom teachers want to say much more than bland statements, but are forbidden to do so by SLT.

Have never worked in a primary school that gives a word bank.

Abraxan · 31/03/2023 07:32

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:28

YANBU.

Ive had the same

“DD is a lovely girl who applies herself well. She enjoys science, maths and reading. She does need to work on putting her hand up and asking for help more. Otherwise a great start to the term”

Warning OP: you will get flamed. In MNLand teachers are allowed to be shit and incompetent and put in the bare minimum.

Teachers don't chose report formatting, type of content and frequency of reports.
They are simply given the instructions and asked to complete them.

Lougle · 31/03/2023 07:32

We get an effort grade, independent learning grade, and attainment grade. Then we get a table that shows the distribution of effort grades and independent learning grades by subject, so that we can see if their grade was typical of the year.

It seems fairly meaningless. For example, I know from talking to DD3's PE teacher because she has had a problem in his class, that DD3 is one of the 'more able' pupils and that she is in top set girls. Yet she is graded as 'meeting' requirements. This makes absolutely no logical sense, because she is clearly doing well as she is near the top of the top set. In another subject, Music, she is classed as 'mastering' despite playing no instruments at any level (although she is naturally fairly musical).

Highfivemum · 31/03/2023 07:29

Sorry shd say my DC.

Highfivemum · 31/03/2023 07:29

I agree. My DC Afrikaans first year in High school consists of a subject then a 3,4,5 after it. 3 being very good and 5 below. No comments about my DC. No parents evening either as it was cancelled as it was the strike days. So my DC is on a number and I have no idea how they are actually doing. A 4 could mean they are doing well or it could mean they should be on a 3 but don’t try hard enough. Awful reports.

itsgettingweird · 31/03/2023 07:29

But they've given an explanation.

He's working towards - as expected.

If he want where he should be it would say below expectations.

So it gives the data they have - can't really blame the system because you don't like it!

BrightArticles · 31/03/2023 07:27

I would aim for the parents evening to discuss any concerns and that opportunity to know exactly how the child is doing.

I am finding that school reports in secondary contain less information to how a pupil is progressing than primary reports, but because they have tests every term I think it's easier to know with the results how they may be struggling or not.

My dd primary reports had that bit of automatic writing but they did have personal detailed notes from the teacher which I apreciated.
In meetings I would discuss with the teacher what I was observing and listening from my dd on how she was doing in subjects, and the teachers would confirm it and give their input and advice.

I've been always very present in school material and study, working with dd, testing her knowledge, knowing the curriculum and going tro it with dd, asking questions after school, showing interest and excitement to hear her day, nothing strict, always in a fun way, like a routine thing, so after a while my dd would always keep me updated on how things were going at school, without me even asking. I also am attentive to her friendships and connections, it does really help to pinpoint how a child is doing and where is the struggle.

Theimpossiblegirl · 31/03/2023 07:27

We have to report to parents 3x a year, either a written report or parents evening.
We do an autumn and spring parents evening and a detailed summer report. It's much more personal.

Girasoli · 31/03/2023 07:24

Sorry that was a terrible sentence...I meant to say a side of A4 of writing at the front and all the levels at the back.

Girasoli · 31/03/2023 07:23

That is a shame - both DS1s school reports are and DS2s nursery reports "sound like them"...DS1 gets an end of year report which is all the levels at the back and a side of A4 (good and bad!) at the back. DS2 gets little term reports on his nursery app and they are short but definitely personalised eg "DS2 loves to talk about sharks and dinosaurs and spends most of the day in the nursery garden digging for worms"

But DS1 only gets one per year in the summer.

Fruitfriend · 31/03/2023 07:21

You still get words on the reports? We get a poorly formatted table with random numbers in it, and need to ferret through the 'curriculum' area of the school website (which doesn't work on mobile) to find a key to what the numbers mean.
Suggested that maybe the explainer should be at least distributed with the report and was told that teachers are very busy...
Then parents evening was 4.30 minutes per subject on a rubbish video chat platform. Only 2/3 of the teachers showed up and half of those had tech problems so no actual information was exchanged.

Iamnotthe1 · 31/03/2023 07:15

Underminer · 31/03/2023 00:52

The DfE makes it clear what should be in school reports, and you can bet most of us won’t have had the extra info requested in 2021/2022
arm yourself with this and contact the school if you don’t get a better report in the summer term
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/school-reports-on-pupil-performance-guide-for-headteachers#information-that-must-be-reported-in-annual-reports

I have no idea how to support my “working towards” child at all. If the report told me, even in bullet point form, we could do extra at home and this would help his progress.

What extra information? The White Paper was abandoned meaning the "Parent Pledge" no longer exists, not that it was passed into law anyway. Last year, all reports had to do differently was consider the impact of the pandemic so if a child was significantly behind, just recognise that may be pandemic-related and not specific to that child.

Schools need to send one report a year. If they are already sending more across the year then they are going beyond the required level in terms of frequency. It may be that each report serves a different purpose.

For example, in my school, we:

  • have a parents' evening in October to discuss settling in / initial attainment.
  • have a written report in December with attainment data, targets and a comment from the teacher, detailing attitude to learning, behaviour, social and emotional development, academic strengths/weaknesses.
  • a written report in March with updated attainment data and targets, no comment as it is followed by...
  • parents' evening in March to discuss progress.
  • written report in July with final attainment data, written comment on the year from the teacher, comment from the head and a self-reflection from the child.

That is so far above the reporting required (one written report before the end of the year and an opportunity to talk about it). However, if someone looked at the spring report in isolation (with data only), it would be easy to go "We don't know enough!" because you're not looking at it in the round.

carriedout · 31/03/2023 07:11

I don't understand why parents need so much direction from school tbh. You know your child well, you can see their work, you can see what they struggle with in homework already.

Yes the reports are quite generic, because of the drop down lists, but they provide an indication of whether the teacher thinks they are on track with their school work and you know a lot about how they are in general.

If you have any concerns, email a teacher.

Teachers have a huge workload and the Tory government has deliberately underfunded schools, they just do not have time to write an individual essay about each child.