Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School report is so vague it feels pointless

117 replies

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 00:22

My son has brought home his spring term report and for every subject he is working towards..school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year and a few exceptional children will be working at. Am I being unreasonable to wonder if nearly child is working towards what’s the point of sending home the report?
If my child is struggling I would genuinely like to help him but I feel there is such a vague approach to reports these days I can’t work out if he’s doing well or not. Is it normal to receive a school report and feel none the wiser?

OP posts:
3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:16

I would like to know is where exactly my child ranks in relation to their class/cohort.

StarmanBobby · 31/03/2023 10:07

We played school report top trumps in the park one end of term and discovering that all 6 of our kids pretty much had the same report, except the really naughty one who apparently lacked more focus than even the lacking in focus other boys!
Deffo cut and paste… though naughty kids parents had been called in endlessly, brainy kid had been told in person how brainy kid was repeatedly, and the rest were okay. Shaved and middling in subjects so we didn’t hear much from teachers…

marchdays · 31/03/2023 10:04

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:28

YANBU.

Ive had the same

“DD is a lovely girl who applies herself well. She enjoys science, maths and reading. She does need to work on putting her hand up and asking for help more. Otherwise a great start to the term”

Warning OP: you will get flamed. In MNLand teachers are allowed to be shit and incompetent and put in the bare minimum.

I don't see what's wrong with that report - as a parent I would be quite happy with that as a mid year catch up.

I want to know if my child is applying themselves and if there are any areas of concern.

It's also good to hear the teacher say something that shows they know the child and what they are interested in etc.

School is a long-term game and parents have to trust the teachers.

Astorminateacup · 31/03/2023 09:58

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 09:32

Well I know she likes science and is a lovely girl. It would be nice to get insight of what she is like in school and how/what I can support her with at home. I really am baffled as to why a few sentences on that is apparently so impossible

Because a teacher has to produce sometimes up to 90 of these within a week. So sadly while we would love to write something deeply personal about each student, it's virtually impossible. The report needs to highlight something about the student, so the teaher writes aomething about behaviour and enthusiasm, if you would like more, drop them an email or ask for a phonecall.

The report you copied seems like bein d done by her form tutor wh opropbably sees her for 10 minutes once a day, who has no clue how 30 of their form students are doing in each of their 10 subjects and how can they know what your daugher needs to do in Maths to improve?

Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 09:57

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 09:17

So hang on, regardless of ability or attainment, all pupils are deemed to be working towards expectations until the end of the year? There must be another system to communicate to parents how their child is doing, surely they're not left in the dark all year waiting to find out how they've done?

I think any parent who sees working towards/below/emerging should query it with the school, not assume that it's ok because they haven't covered the whole curriculum yet.

Im not entirely sure why schools share the mid year data to be honest. I think its because they have the data for internal purposes and its quick to share so it feels helpful, but i dont think its very meaningful without the teacher talking through it. Parents are entitled to know how thier child is doing and the end of year report is the one that is a requirement and normally has more info and comments. Most schools do one or two parents evenings to discuss progress as well and would contact parents if interventions were needed.
I agree id always ask questions if i wanted to understand more.

DixonD · 31/03/2023 09:55

Theimpossiblegirl · 31/03/2023 07:27

We have to report to parents 3x a year, either a written report or parents evening.
We do an autumn and spring parents evening and a detailed summer report. It's much more personal.

This is what ours does. Just had our second parent meeting this year and will have the report at the end of summer term.

Beowulfa · 31/03/2023 09:50

I had to write reports when I taught English abroad. Free text, no restrictions. Easy enough for outstandingly bright or struggling students, surprisingly hard for the average ones. Remember in a large group you are going to have a fair amount of students who are bluntly mediocre and quite unmemorable. This isn't necessarily a negative, society needs all sorts.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 31/03/2023 09:45

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 09:32

Well I know she likes science and is a lovely girl. It would be nice to get insight of what she is like in school and how/what I can support her with at home. I really am baffled as to why a few sentences on that is apparently so impossible

But they've told you what she's like - lovely but shy/lacking in confidence - and what you can work on at home.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 09:34

ConstanceOcean · 31/03/2023 09:30

What else do you want the teacher to say?

They’ve said what she’s doing well and what she can improve on.

Sounds like you’re just annoyed that the teacher wasn’t gushing over your child and saying how perfect they are.

Exactly.

We are specifically told we aren’t allowed to do that.

We also aren’t allowed to give an overly negative report.

It’s all about a shit sandwich in the world of reporting. And absolutely no kid has nothing to work on!

Glittertwins · 31/03/2023 09:33

Our reports were meaningless. Even had the wrong subject updated. DC doesn't even do the subject the comments related to

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 09:33

ConstanceOcean · 31/03/2023 09:28

school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year

YABU

You say yourself that the students are working towards because they haven’t finished the school year and so there’s nothing else to say if he’s coping fine.

The students who are working below will probably have a bit more information about how they can improve their score eg by increasing their attendance.

Most pupils who are working significantly below would have been spoken to regardless of the report anyway and the reports are just to keep parents in the loop about their progress.

The reports are vague and generic for most parents, a lot of paperwork for no real information..are you not just agreeing with that?

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 09:32

Astorminateacup · 31/03/2023 09:26

Out of curiosity, what would you like to have read, a detailed report of every second in the classroom?

I would LOVE to be able t owrite that for each student, but sadly I already work 60 hours a week and do reports after 9pm when kids ar ein bed, and the fact the reports are short are because I can barely keep my eyes open from exhaustion, not because I am incompetent.

Well I know she likes science and is a lovely girl. It would be nice to get insight of what she is like in school and how/what I can support her with at home. I really am baffled as to why a few sentences on that is apparently so impossible

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 09:32

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:28

YANBU.

Ive had the same

“DD is a lovely girl who applies herself well. She enjoys science, maths and reading. She does need to work on putting her hand up and asking for help more. Otherwise a great start to the term”

Warning OP: you will get flamed. In MNLand teachers are allowed to be shit and incompetent and put in the bare minimum.

It’s not about being shit or incompetent or doing the bare minimum. There are assessment standards; you can’t assess them til they have covered the content; and you can’t say they have achieved something til you have evidence they have achieved it.

Catspyjamas17 · 31/03/2023 09:31

YANBU.

DD1 was at primary school when there were national curriculum levels. It was so much easier to see where they are up to. I knew early on that grammar school would be an idea as she always was working a year or two ahead of the average attainment. DD2 was under the new system - working towards, meeting, strongly meeting etc. No idea, such woolly nonsense. Much prefer the secondary school system of giving grades for effort/application only then attainment only at the end of the school year.

A decent parents' evening via whatever means where the teacher can say to the parents "Your child needs to work on x right now" is much more valuable.

Yes it is. I'd rather have an informative report saying that than have to bother with parents' evening.

ConstanceOcean · 31/03/2023 09:30

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:28

YANBU.

Ive had the same

“DD is a lovely girl who applies herself well. She enjoys science, maths and reading. She does need to work on putting her hand up and asking for help more. Otherwise a great start to the term”

Warning OP: you will get flamed. In MNLand teachers are allowed to be shit and incompetent and put in the bare minimum.

What else do you want the teacher to say?

They’ve said what she’s doing well and what she can improve on.

Sounds like you’re just annoyed that the teacher wasn’t gushing over your child and saying how perfect they are.

ConstanceOcean · 31/03/2023 09:28

school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year

YABU

You say yourself that the students are working towards because they haven’t finished the school year and so there’s nothing else to say if he’s coping fine.

The students who are working below will probably have a bit more information about how they can improve their score eg by increasing their attendance.

Most pupils who are working significantly below would have been spoken to regardless of the report anyway and the reports are just to keep parents in the loop about their progress.

Astorminateacup · 31/03/2023 09:26

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:28

YANBU.

Ive had the same

“DD is a lovely girl who applies herself well. She enjoys science, maths and reading. She does need to work on putting her hand up and asking for help more. Otherwise a great start to the term”

Warning OP: you will get flamed. In MNLand teachers are allowed to be shit and incompetent and put in the bare minimum.

Out of curiosity, what would you like to have read, a detailed report of every second in the classroom?

I would LOVE to be able t owrite that for each student, but sadly I already work 60 hours a week and do reports after 9pm when kids ar ein bed, and the fact the reports are short are because I can barely keep my eyes open from exhaustion, not because I am incompetent.

LittleScottieDog · 31/03/2023 09:22

Many of the assessments used during the year test children on all aspects of the subject even if they haven't covered it that year. So if, for example, shape comes up in Maths in the summer term, the autumn and spring term assessments will still have questions on shape for that year group that they haven't been taught yet. That's why the majority of kids will still be working towards halfway through the year.

Honestly, a report at the time of the year is a bit pointless. A decent parents' evening via whatever means where the teacher can say to the parents "Your child needs to work on x right now" is much more valuable. Reports just take time and then don't normally tell the parents very much. One report at the end of the year to show achievements is much better in my opinion.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 09:22

electricmoccasins · 31/03/2023 06:48

You know nothing about schools if you think classroom teachers have any autonomy over the format of school reports. They are told what to write. Usually given a word bank. The report box has a word maximum which you usually can't go over. Believe me, most classroom teachers want to say much more than bland statements, but are forbidden to do so by SLT.

What do SLTs see as a benefit to generic full reports? Do they want to piss parents off and alienate them from helping their children?

CoffeeWithCheese · 31/03/2023 09:20

We just get parents evenings this point of the year - but the current class teacher clearly hates doing them, spends the entire time arse covering in case the SATs don't go as expected - despite knowing me well enough to know I care more about teacher assessment and don't give a shit about the SATs scores. To be sat there with a child who is easily top or near as damnit (she was doing the Y6 work back when in Y5 so this is Y6 mark 2) trying to couch and dodge that "she may get greater depth" is just a waste of my time and hers. Huge long script and then dodging any time for any queries but you have to go through the motions of showing up or you get snarked like the comments on this thread.

It's an issue with this teacher though because in SEN review meetings she tries to hide actual lack of progress by just throwing scores out with no explanation - but unfortunately I understand the scores so the scores mysteriously disappeared last review...

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 09:17

Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 08:47

Ok. Thats how your school did their reports and school will differ in how they report. There isnt a set format.

The two schools I work at do their reports as i described and as its a bit confusing they send out an explanation booklet as OP described.

So hang on, regardless of ability or attainment, all pupils are deemed to be working towards expectations until the end of the year? There must be another system to communicate to parents how their child is doing, surely they're not left in the dark all year waiting to find out how they've done?

I think any parent who sees working towards/below/emerging should query it with the school, not assume that it's ok because they haven't covered the whole curriculum yet.

RudsyFarmer · 31/03/2023 09:13

morekidsthanhands · 31/03/2023 00:47

No personal words in ours just a table with maths, reading, writing. Exceeding, expected or below. Then behaviour. Nicely coloured in red, Amber and green for all. Hate it. I've has 2/3 green for behaviour this time which is a win. Bit lovely red and Amber across the board for everything else. They all have learning difficulties so I expect it but it doesn't make it any less depressing!

Same. We get the end of year report which has written words on it but otherwise it’s a table that says below/expected etc and the opportunity to mention behaviour.

I rather like it. My kids have progressed from the report I received before Christmas and are on track to get a few Greater Depths and their behaviour is Exceptional in areas. What’s not to like?! 🤣

maddy68 · 31/03/2023 09:06

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 00:22

My son has brought home his spring term report and for every subject he is working towards..school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year and a few exceptional children will be working at. Am I being unreasonable to wonder if nearly child is working towards what’s the point of sending home the report?
If my child is struggling I would genuinely like to help him but I feel there is such a vague approach to reports these days I can’t work out if he’s doing well or not. Is it normal to receive a school report and feel none the wiser?

We always had to have children "working towards " at certain points of the year and miraculously they made progress over the year. Ofsted targets are met. Everyone is happy.

It's a farce. Once ofsted gets scrapped reports will become meaningful again

SpareHeirOverThere · 31/03/2023 08:57

I write honest reports in plain English. I get complaints. Lots of colleagues use vague, positive euphemisms from word banks. They get complaints. If we suggest ways to help children at home, some parents accuse us of dumping responsibility onto parents because we're lazy, can't be asked, not doing our jobs. If we don't suggest nightly reading and times table practice, some parents will complain that we're not offering constructive suggestions to help.

There's no winning. I think we should send home a grid with the attainment & effort (easy to read and understand) and 5 or 6 overall bullet points of praise and areas for improvement. The rest is wasted effort, better spent in a face to face meeting. To which some parents won't show up, then complain about.

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 08:54

There was a letter that only in exceptional circumstances would a child not be below as they are marked by year end of expectations not mid year.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread