Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School report is so vague it feels pointless

117 replies

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 00:22

My son has brought home his spring term report and for every subject he is working towards..school has sent a separate guide that every child at this stage of the year will be working towards as not completed school year and a few exceptional children will be working at. Am I being unreasonable to wonder if nearly child is working towards what’s the point of sending home the report?
If my child is struggling I would genuinely like to help him but I feel there is such a vague approach to reports these days I can’t work out if he’s doing well or not. Is it normal to receive a school report and feel none the wiser?

OP posts:
Newname221 · 31/03/2023 11:35

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 11:15

Knowing a position in class isn't getting information about other children, it's getting information about mine.

How would I feel if my child was at the bottom - well if I wasn't already aware that there were issues then it would be of concern, would lead me to find out exactly what interventions the school were putting in place and have a long think about what more I could do to support them at home. How can that possibly be a negative? I'd rather know than be blissfully unaware to save my own feelings.

If they were at the top, obviously I'd be happy. Everybody wants their child to do well. It would better help inform choices over secondary school for those in a selective area for example.

Of course it is. You are comparing your child to others. If they tell you that your child is last, you know every single other kid is working ahead of your child. If they tell you that your kid is first (but working behind national average) then you know every single other child is working below national average too.

Do you rank your own children in this way? Sophie is way smarter than Kevin. Simon is by far my most stupid child.

Comparing against kids in the class is pointless. Each class has a different dynamic. My daughters school has two classes for her year - the “top” and “bottom” class. Now obviously they aren’t marketed like this but anyone with a shard of common sense can work it out. My daughter is in the “top” class, working with children who are a year older than her (composite class) however she’s probably one of the bottom in her class - she’s nearly 2 years younger than some of the kids though. How would I feel if I got a report that my kid was bottom of the class? Probably crap. I’d probably try to get her to “catch up” too. But is that the right thing to do? Of course not! She’s actually working ahead of a whole OTHER class, and slightly ahead of the national standard!

You can’t rank them because it doesn’t work. My daughter is really gifted with numeracy but not so gifted with language. She’s great at science but crap at PE. Overall, she’s come out as average; but she’s definitely performing way ahead in maths. So individualised results are way more useful.

Also, being anything other than average is highly unlikely.

They may be top of the class but completely devoid of personality, or a nasty little piece of work.

Surely you have the intellect yourself to work out that if your child is working behind national averages then you should contact the school for more information on how to help?

People are also missing the fact that parents being involved in this type of discussion on mumsnet are a very specific demographic, and the majority of parents literally don’t give two hoots. I can assure you; the “average” parent is most definitely not this invested in their child’s schooling.

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 11:34

carriedout · 31/03/2023 10:29

Yeah that's a) weird b) nosey

How's in nosey? I don't want to know how your child is doing, just my own in relation to their cohort. They'll all find this out when they take their GCSEs. Luckily my child's private school does provide me with this roughly. The state schools mine attend don't though.

Isitthathardtobekind · 31/03/2023 11:24

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:31

I have worked in schools and can confirm school reports are mostly copy and paste jobs.

I have worked in schools and can confirm that this is not the case in all schools at all. In all the schools I have worked in, teachers put a lot of time and effort into writing these reports in their own time. Many are personal and detailed, others are not so great. It really depends on the expectations of the schools.

Since levels were removed, schools assess in their own way. It does seem strange that they would say all are WTS until the end of the year. How will you (or anyone) know until it is to late at the end of the year if they don’t then meet EXS. This sounds like it’s based on nothing more than curriculum coverage. It is possible to say whether children are EXS at this time of year by reflecting on whether they are on track to meet all the standards by the end of the year. I would ask to meet the teacher and ask this- is my child on track to meet expected by the end of the year? If they are likely to end the year still at WTS, ask for the reasons and what they need to work on to meet EXS.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 11:22

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 11:13

“It would help if you did XYZ at home to help with DD’s maths skills” is all that would suffice. It’s not rocket science, and there’s some piss poor excuses for crappy teaching on this site

If you can’t work that out for yourself, then I don’t know what to say …

They are coping well with maths. You continue to do whatever you are doing. No need to do extra. You need to work on their confidence. It says it all.

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 11:15

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:58

Because it’s not about the other children, you have no right to get information about anyone else’s child. You get information about where they are working in relation to expected standards (so against long-term averages)

How would you feel if your child was at the bottom? Or the top? How many parents would share this with their kids? How many kids would then share this with the class?

Absolutely love it when know it all parents tell us how to do our jobs 😂please, tell me your job and I’ll give you some tips!

Knowing a position in class isn't getting information about other children, it's getting information about mine.

How would I feel if my child was at the bottom - well if I wasn't already aware that there were issues then it would be of concern, would lead me to find out exactly what interventions the school were putting in place and have a long think about what more I could do to support them at home. How can that possibly be a negative? I'd rather know than be blissfully unaware to save my own feelings.

If they were at the top, obviously I'd be happy. Everybody wants their child to do well. It would better help inform choices over secondary school for those in a selective area for example.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 11:13

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:32

I honestly don’t understand how what the teacher said isn’t as clear as day.

Remember, many parents have a very poor grasp of literacy skills. Teachers need to write a report that is easily understood by someone with basic literacy skills.

“It would help if you did XYZ at home to help with DD’s maths skills” is all that would suffice. It’s not rocket science, and there’s some piss poor excuses for crappy teaching on this site

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/03/2023 11:11

I remember a few years ago on some forum or other (might have been here, can't remember) a parent saying "I'd like a weekly, written, detailed report on how he's done that week".

I still alternate between a guffaw and wanting to make the parent shadow a teacher for a week (including at home).

tigger1001 · 31/03/2023 11:07

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 00:31

I have worked in schools and can confirm school reports are mostly copy and paste jobs.

100% this! Have even had comments where it was a different child's name - so obvious it was just cut and pasted.

I agree op, report cards are not really useful these days. So generic.

TulipsLilacs · 31/03/2023 11:03

I've always found a score or grade to be the most useful. They get them for attainment in each subject and for things like behaviour, homework, classwork at secondary (state.) Then a comment by the form tutor.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:58

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 10:55

Because it would give a more realistic idea of how your child is getting on, rather than as this thread shows confusion over working towards/expected, or a report which has been copied and pasted and is the same as everybody else's?

What's wrong with transparency

Because it’s not about the other children, you have no right to get information about anyone else’s child. You get information about where they are working in relation to expected standards (so against long-term averages)

How would you feel if your child was at the bottom? Or the top? How many parents would share this with their kids? How many kids would then share this with the class?

Absolutely love it when know it all parents tell us how to do our jobs 😂please, tell me your job and I’ll give you some tips!

jaqueandjill · 31/03/2023 10:55

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:20

What the fuck? Why should that matter?

Because it would give a more realistic idea of how your child is getting on, rather than as this thread shows confusion over working towards/expected, or a report which has been copied and pasted and is the same as everybody else's?

What's wrong with transparency

BlackeyedSusan · 31/03/2023 10:47

Copy and paste is fine if it fits the child and actually gives you an impression of what's going on and can add the odd personalised comment. Teachers copied anyway when handwriting reports.

Some reports we've had have not been worth the effort the teachers' have put in as they tell you nothing much at all, waste of teacher time.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:47

Age also has a massive impact in lower school years. The youngest in the cohort are more likely to be behind the oldest. Does this mean they are stupid or not coping? No. It just means they aren’t as “ready” and will soon catch up.

My own daughter is much younger than many in the class and did struggle a lot in primary 1/2, but now she’s catching up fast.

Skiphopbump · 31/03/2023 10:43

My DS was often ‘emerging’. It was meaningless as between reports there was no indication of progress. The one subject he was at ‘expected’ at showed he was was progress as he would drop to emerging. Just seeing emerging in the report gave in indication of whether the gap was widening or narrowing.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:43

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:30

Of course it matters. They're not awarded GCSE grades and university entrance based on anything else!

It doesn’t matter though.

This is a primary school level report for starters. The fact is; the majority of the pupils in the class will be average. That’s how averages work. Roughly half of them will be on the better end of average, and roughly half of them will be on the poorer end of average.

Grades are not calculated at school level; they are calculated nationally. So knowing where they are in the class is again; pointless.

Here in Scotland it’s easy even for someone untrained to work out where their child is. I’ll use my own daughter as an example.

she’s working at first level for literacy. First level goes roughly from p2-4. She’s in p3.

They can either be meeting outcomes (which means working at p4 level) working towards them (which means achieving them on track but not completed all of them yet) working towards with support (a little behind their peers but getting there with differentiation) or not achieving (should really be at early level; will probably be moved)

For reading, my daughter is working towards level 1. She’s where she should be for her age.
For spelling, she’s working towards with support. She’s a little behind. The teacher has obviously discussed this with us. However the support is working and she’s going to get there just fine.
For numeracy, she’s meeting her outcomes, which means she’s working ahead of expectations.

It really doesn’t take a genius. Comparing her against her peers would be pointless; because she so happens to be in the “better” class of the two. So all the kids are on the “brighter” end of the spectrum. She’s probably one of the lower abilities for literacy in her class; but probably bang on average nationally.

Plus, progress isn’t linear. The best kids in lower primary might not be the best kids by GCSE level. I was pretty average at primary school; but achieved the top 10 exam results in my school cohort of 360.

carriedout · 31/03/2023 10:37

SpareHeirOverThere · 31/03/2023 10:29

This is not a ridiculous question - parents want to know how their child is performing in relation to their peers. We can't answer, for very good reasons - but now that grading has moved over to Above/Expected/Working Towards, you get a broad idea. Still, these are 3 very broad categories, and it's not odd to wonder more specifically what it meant by 'at expected' (barely at expected? nearly at above?).

My kids have always known themselves and I can tell by observing their homework ease/difficulty.

Teachers are not private tutors, parents do need to engage themselves.

carriedout · 31/03/2023 10:34

Whatdoyouthinkof · 31/03/2023 08:48

We have had the parents evening and it was very much no cause for concern/average child/could concentrate more.

With the report as he is just below, as expected for mid year, I’m wondering is he just below because of not understanding aspects of the curriculum or just below because of being mid-year. It could easily be either.

No criticism of the teachers; it’s clear to see they only have these options on the report. A lot of paperwork for such pointless feedback.

In these circs I would just put more effort in at home to support what they're doing in school - nothing complicated just encourage reading, find a documentary about whatever they're doing in history or geography or science, maybe visit an art gallery if it ties in.

School will be doing their bit already. They can't control the child though.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:32

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 10:24

You as a teacher may see if like that but clearly parents don’t - I get nothing at all from a report like that.

I honestly don’t understand how what the teacher said isn’t as clear as day.

Remember, many parents have a very poor grasp of literacy skills. Teachers need to write a report that is easily understood by someone with basic literacy skills.

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/03/2023 10:31

C1N1C · 31/03/2023 07:00

It's age dependent, but I think they should be brutal. To be told you're meeting expectations or could do better is not motivational and won't spur on the parents.

It's true for all stages of life... I remember someone in her third year if a PhD being told "maybe you're just not cut out for science"... and wow did she pull her finger out!

A teacher told me I was unlikely to get an O level in a subject, which I was picking as an option. No idea why but guess what I majored in my degree?!

I would have liked to see teachers given more honest end of year reports at dd’s state schools.

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:30

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:20

What the fuck? Why should that matter?

Of course it matters. They're not awarded GCSE grades and university entrance based on anything else!

SpareHeirOverThere · 31/03/2023 10:29

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:16

I would like to know is where exactly my child ranks in relation to their class/cohort.

This is not a ridiculous question - parents want to know how their child is performing in relation to their peers. We can't answer, for very good reasons - but now that grading has moved over to Above/Expected/Working Towards, you get a broad idea. Still, these are 3 very broad categories, and it's not odd to wonder more specifically what it meant by 'at expected' (barely at expected? nearly at above?).

carriedout · 31/03/2023 10:29

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:16

I would like to know is where exactly my child ranks in relation to their class/cohort.

Yeah that's a) weird b) nosey

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 31/03/2023 10:24

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 31/03/2023 09:45

But they've told you what she's like - lovely but shy/lacking in confidence - and what you can work on at home.

You as a teacher may see if like that but clearly parents don’t - I get nothing at all from a report like that.

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/03/2023 10:22

SpareHeirOverThere · 31/03/2023 08:57

I write honest reports in plain English. I get complaints. Lots of colleagues use vague, positive euphemisms from word banks. They get complaints. If we suggest ways to help children at home, some parents accuse us of dumping responsibility onto parents because we're lazy, can't be asked, not doing our jobs. If we don't suggest nightly reading and times table practice, some parents will complain that we're not offering constructive suggestions to help.

There's no winning. I think we should send home a grid with the attainment & effort (easy to read and understand) and 5 or 6 overall bullet points of praise and areas for improvement. The rest is wasted effort, better spent in a face to face meeting. To which some parents won't show up, then complain about.

Quite. There was a thread on here yesterday in which the parent was complaining that their Y12 child 's report had said the child didn't contribute enough in lessons.

I've just seen someone saying they want to know how their child ranks against the class/year - I can only imagine the furore if schools went back to doing that.

Newname221 · 31/03/2023 10:20

3WildOnes · 31/03/2023 10:16

I would like to know is where exactly my child ranks in relation to their class/cohort.

What the fuck? Why should that matter?