Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that travel to various work locations count as work time?

64 replies

Beaniesmumsie · 30/03/2023 20:51

I just had a very good job interview with a big organisation and I’m feeling like they’ll offer me the job, they have many offices dotted around the country including Scotland, it’s a WFH position with HQ down south (I’m in the Midlands so about 3 hours drive). I was asked how comfortable I am with travelling and I said fine as long as it counts as work time. However they said they expect people to travel during their own time (not for big trips like to Scotland but they expect me to travel to HQ twice a month) and then do a full work day. Is this normal? In my previous jobs any travelling away from your place of work counts as work time.

I know if I get offered I’ll clarify with them to make sure I’m not misunderstanding them, but it’s gonna be a big sticking point for me.

YANBU - yes you should travel outside of core work hours
YABU - you had it lucky with previous jobs where travel to different offices count as work time

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beaniesmumsie · 31/03/2023 18:44

Just to clarify, it was advertised as a WFH position and I’m actually very close to some of their midlands office (where I know a lot of the projects are based out of). Unfortunately it’s not a massively senior position (about £43k) and it’s a different sector, that’s why I wanted to see how other work places approach this. None of the offices can be reached by train so I can’t work when I’m travelling (bar a few phone calls maybe). Oh well I’ll see if I get offered the position first before negotiating with them, but thank you all for sharing your experiences

OP posts:
LightGreenDot · 31/03/2023 18:33

It's good to know their policy but in reality it's normally a case of give and take. You would not be expected to get to an office 5 hours away for a 9am start without an overnight stay, but 3 hours and 10am start most people would consider reasonable once in a while.

Equally there will be days when you want to nip out in your normal working day to see your kids' sports day or whatever.

I've never known any workplace where anyone has counted hours to make sure they are 100% balanced, as long as everyone is treated well and the work gets done. Admittedly I've never worked in a place that has billable hours, timesheets etc when I guess it might be different. If you end up working somewhere where you have to nitpick about stuff like this, I would think it would not be a pleasant working environment for other reasons also.

Clymene · 31/03/2023 18:25

It depends how senior you are. At a certain level, there is no such thing as TOIL.

Bluntly, it's what you get paid £100k+ for.

StillWantingADog · 31/03/2023 18:23

I’d say a bit of both.

i used to have to travel to london - by train- fairly often. It’s 3 hours from here so normally I’d do 10-4.30ish in the office and travel either side. However I’d sometimes do some work on the train too.

timeforwotsits · 31/03/2023 18:20

No thanks

as a home worker any work outside of your working hours should count as working time

So either your working day includes travel and therefore you spend less time in the office as your travel is counted in your working day

but I wouldn’t be travelling in my own time especially for a big company

MajorCarolDanvers · 31/03/2023 18:18

I wfh in Scotland but travel around the UK.

Any travel I do outside core hours I get back as TOiL. Plus an audio half day TOIL for any overnights.

They are taking the piss if they expect your travel to be on your own time.

gogohmm · 31/03/2023 18:14

Driving to your office that you are based at (even if you work from home mostly) can't be claimed for tax reasons

EsmeSusanOgg · 31/03/2023 18:13

roses2 · 31/03/2023 17:48

If someone asked me at interview stage if commuting would be part of working hours because they live far away that would ring alarm bells about entitlement to me! Commuting to the contracted head office is always in your own time and at your own cost.

OP said they had multiple offices and they were being asked for regular (but not weekly) travel to offices that were not their home office. That is not covered by commuting.

EsmeSusanOgg · 31/03/2023 18:11

Cosyblankets · 30/03/2023 20:52

My husband has a job that requires travel. He travels in work time

This is the legal position. You take out usual commuting time. And the rest of the travel time to a non-work location is counted as work hour. If you do this outside core hours, you need to be paid for it / offered time in lieu.

If the company has all staff, including junior staff on/ around the NMW and they do not pay/ offer time back they are breaching national minimum wage rules. They may also be breaching the working time directive, dependent on the additional hours/ frequency.

difficultdifficultlemondifficult · 31/03/2023 18:08

I would expect an hours commute in my own time, everyone working out of the home has got to travel prior to their actual start time.

So say your work day begins at 9am I would expect to start travelling at 8am, then the arrival time should be set for however long it takes from then onwards

roses2 · 31/03/2023 17:48

If someone asked me at interview stage if commuting would be part of working hours because they live far away that would ring alarm bells about entitlement to me! Commuting to the contracted head office is always in your own time and at your own cost.

Theamofm · 31/03/2023 17:46

I WFH but if I have to go into the office during the middle of the day for a meeting my travel time has to be made back up because its during my working hours and I'm technically not working while I'm driving. Feel for you with the 3 hours though, mine not so bad.

Itsbytheby · 31/03/2023 17:42

Well if you have an 8 hour work day and want to spend 6 hrs of that driving that's pretty pointless.

I wfh, and when I need to go into the office (just over an hour) I tend to either get in for normal time and leave earlier or get in a bit later and leave at a normal time. But I tend to work on the train.

So I suppose I - unofficially - do a mix. But my work isn't really a clock in clock out type of role.

Champooforyou · 31/03/2023 17:37

Did you get offered? To be honest you might have come across as a bit of potential PITA staying you'd only ever travel in work time, especially for a senior position. But if that's a deal breaker for you better to get it out in the open.
I don't travel, but DH does and he'll often fly on a Sunday evening to be ready for a Mondya meeting, but may travel back in working hours at the end of the week, but will be working whilst travelling. Its just part and parcel of modern work I think.

Aprilx · 31/03/2023 17:23

Albiboba · 30/03/2023 20:58

It’s usually a bit of both. Once you get to a certain pay grade it’s expected based on your contract that you work until the job gets done, rather than being contracted until X time. So while lots of the travel would also be in work time it would be highly unusual for someone to be travelling from the south to Scotland for work but refuse to get on a train until their normal work time, or to demand to leave at 1pm so they arrive home by 5:30.

I agree that it is a bit of both. I have in the past done a lot of business related travel, when I lived in London I travelled to New York and Zurich a lot, when I lived in Australia I travelled between the main Australian cities a lot. Whilst I might turn up in the office I was visiting at say 10am and maybe I would leave at 4pm, this still meant a lot of the travel was on my time and some on the employers time.

I also would sometimes travel to say New York on a Sunday so I was ready to work on Monday. When I was visiting Zurich, I usually took a flight out at about 7pm so definitely “my time” but I would book a flight home say 4pm and so it was a bit of my time and a bit of their time.

Season0fTheWitch · 31/03/2023 17:22

Your commute to work is your problem to deal with. I chose to live 30 mins from my HQ so it's my personal time I travel in.

KrisAkabusi · 31/03/2023 16:57

TheFireflies · 30/03/2023 21:48

If it’s travel to my named office it’s classed as commuting and not part of work time.
If travelling to other offices not my named place of work, or to other locations, it’s in work time.
I guess yours might be a similar arrangement if you’re travelling to HQ.

Exactly the same for me. It's up to me to decide how far away I want to live from the main office, and it's my choice to do that commute.

Thatladdo · 31/03/2023 16:49

So a 3 hour communte either side of a shift once a fourtnite a problem?

Entitled much? 😆
Quite a few folk do that every day ya know...
Take it or leave it, stay over, whatever.

anniegun · 31/03/2023 16:27

Its a point of discussion before you take the job. Its not an unreasonable condition but you have to weigh it up as part of the overall package

JudgeRudy · 31/03/2023 16:24

I would say if you're expected to go into the office twice a month, and that has been stipulated before hand, then that's standard commute to work and like working anywhere else is up for you to facilitate. If you're occasionally being asked to eg attend meetings at the other end of the country, you'll likely get paid mileage and get TOIL however in my experience that's harder to agree. If you live in Birmingham and your meetings in Scotland then really you need to go up the day before. You'll likely be booked accomodation and a flight/train. The reality is though they'll let you leave at lunch on Tuesday to arrive at 8pm. Already you've worked 2 extra hours and you're stuck in a hotel. Up early, off to meeting, train/flight back, home for 10pm if you're lucky. Chances are you won't get anything 'back' for that.
Worth checking where your official base is. If it's HQ and that's 50 miles away, if you get sent somewhere else you'll only get paid for 'excess' mileage ie over 50. If you feel awkward it's perfectly reasonable to frame your questions around car insurance. If you're being paid mileage that's not a commute, that's work usage and you'll need business insurance.
Good Luck 👍

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 31/03/2023 16:02

Book a quiet carriage on a train and work there?

No way should you have to give up entirely your own time if the job is home-based.
An hour or so extra to get an early train/one later finish is fair enough, but not a 6hr round trip drive on top of a full working day.
They need to split it over 2 days and pay for your overnight in a hotel.

WindUpPenguin · 31/03/2023 15:54

In my job we have a 'home' office. You must travel to your home office 2 days a week. This counts as normal commuting and you are expected to travel on your 'own' time and do not have your expenses reimbursed. We have other sites, and if you need to be at one of those, you would be able to travel on work time (either in the work day, or taking flexi time) and you would book your travel through the travel system. You would also be entitled to claim back meals within the policy (which is something like £5 for lunch and £5 for breakfast if you have set off before a certain time).

HouseIsOnFire · 31/03/2023 15:19

I think it depends on the general hours too?

I have a fully remote contract and am 250 miles from hq. If I'm expected to go to hq, I'll leave at a reasonable time in the morning and drive back sometime after lunch the next day (hotels etc are expensed).

If the travel infringes my personal time, them I accept it because they are very flexible about me taking longer lunches, appointments, leaving early etc.

If they were rigid 9-5, then I would be rigid about travelling only during work hours.

mozzierella · 31/03/2023 15:09

Depends on pay and contract

HelpMeGetThrough · 31/03/2023 07:32

We have various offices around the country. One I go to is 400 mile drive up, so if I'm in the office the next day, I'll drive the afternoon before, probably leave about 2pm and get to the hotel about 7pm, do the next day in the office, leave at about 4pm and drive home.

One that's 200 miles from home, I'll drive up that day, be in for 9 finish at 5 and then drive home again.

Depends where the office is to be honest. The 200 mile one I can be there in 2.5 hours, so very doable up and back in a day.