Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people like me should get some sort of financial help

156 replies

Shimmershine819 · 30/03/2023 13:39

I'm at my absolute wits end. Crohns disease for 25 years. I work part time in the NHS (25 hours per week). I cant afford to drop any more hours. I've done the calculations, we'd get no help as a family. We can't survive on DHs wage alone.

No more accommodations can be made for me. I'm so ill. I've just finished a 4 hour shift, 4 short hours and they felt like an eternity. I was in so much pain, nausea, sweating. Trying to put on a brave face.

The multiple treatments I'm on don't seem to be making a jot of difference.

I think of all of those out these like me, with chronic illness, quietly struggling through each day with no help. Not ill enough for PIP, too ill to try and live any kind of normal life. My life is now work and bed. Thank god DC are older now.

Just needed somewhere to offload.

OP posts:
teacakie · 01/04/2023 21:15

@Babyroobs

I can't get one automatically in Scotland because you need to have 12 points in 'planning a journey' or 8 in 'moving around'

The council have refused me a badge

I have a motability car!!!

I believe the automatic entitlement on planning a journey is 10 points in England but if you have 12 you don't automatically qualify. In Scotland 10 isn't enough and you need 12.

Its absolute madness

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 21:12

Whilst each council has their own criteria for issuing Blue badges, most will issue automatically for someone on enhanced rates of PIP mobility. Honestly, I help people apply for Blue badges all the time and even people who I think it may be borderline for getting one ( like a recent client of mine with a skin condition), got issues one. The odd one gets turned down, but the vast majority issues in a few weeks. Seems like you may just have been unlucky, I can't understand why on earth there would be any issues if you have enhanced PIP mobility.

This was my understanding, too. It is baffling. My doctors have written them letters and provided evidence as well as the PIP report. Nobody understands what their issue is and they refuse to explain. They keep saying they need more evidence and when the medical professionals have asked what evidence, there is no answer...

Meanwhile my child had to go to A&E and because I could not park in the disabled spaces I could not take her. Only because a friend came to help did she get taken there in time. It's dangerous. But still, no badge.

Maybe I am just cursed or something but these people all make my life hell.

Babyroobs · 01/04/2023 21:03

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 20:24

The blue badge people can also join the list of utterly useless idiots making disabled people's lives hell for no reason. Having received medical reports stating that most of the time I am pretty much housebound, a PIP report stating I get higher rate mobility, and evidence that I am having to pay nannies just to take my children to school and back because I can't, they are still arguing with medical professionals over a year after I applied for it claiming they "don't have enough evidence" to issue the badge to me.

Whilst each council has their own criteria for issuing Blue badges, most will issue automatically for someone on enhanced rates of PIP mobility. Honestly, I help people apply for Blue badges all the time and even people who I think it may be borderline for getting one ( like a recent client of mine with a skin condition), got issues one. The odd one gets turned down, but the vast majority issues in a few weeks. Seems like you may just have been unlucky, I can't understand why on earth there would be any issues if you have enhanced PIP mobility.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 20:30

Sorry @Shimmershine819 I didn't mean to take over your thread. It makes me so angry to read stories like yours, others on this thread and obviously in despair at the situation that I and my children have been put in as well. I don't understand hiw he public can be so callous that they don't demand change and that PIP/ DLA is significantly increased and granted without trying to humiliate disabled people, especially knowing that it could happen to anybody.

5128gap · 01/04/2023 20:29

You could get contributory ESA for 12m, or indefinitely if you're judged too ill to do any work. It's about £80 a week, more in the support group. Not a lot, but something. I'd second the advice to reapply for PIP.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 20:26

Even something like that which costs them next to nothing has to be turned into a battle. It's little wonder that suicide rates amongst disabled people are so much higher than in the general population.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 20:24

Snowythecatbitch · 01/04/2023 20:16

@SweetSakura , please go back to your local council re blue badge, I had a family member with myasthenia and they definitely had one and was much needed.
I happened to go with them to apply( pre COVID) and the guy didn't know what it was had to Google as is so rare. When having a flare up they needed a wheelchair. Perhaps get a persuasive letter from your neurologist?

The blue badge people can also join the list of utterly useless idiots making disabled people's lives hell for no reason. Having received medical reports stating that most of the time I am pretty much housebound, a PIP report stating I get higher rate mobility, and evidence that I am having to pay nannies just to take my children to school and back because I can't, they are still arguing with medical professionals over a year after I applied for it claiming they "don't have enough evidence" to issue the badge to me.

Snowythecatbitch · 01/04/2023 20:16

@SweetSakura , please go back to your local council re blue badge, I had a family member with myasthenia and they definitely had one and was much needed.
I happened to go with them to apply( pre COVID) and the guy didn't know what it was had to Google as is so rare. When having a flare up they needed a wheelchair. Perhaps get a persuasive letter from your neurologist?

BeccaS82 · 01/04/2023 19:18

I really feel for you and am in a similar situation. I have ME and have just negotiated down to 3 days issue is the job is still 5 days of work and end up working on days off. I too feel ill all the time and work or rest - no life or many friends at all. It’s lonely and scary. Also horrid to how many similar posts are on here. Sending hugs and 💐

OOmpityDoomipity · 01/04/2023 18:54

PIP is how the condition affects your life and ability to live a normal life, not how unwell you are as people can have good days and bad days.

I look in perfect health on the outside. I am definetly not.

I'd apply again, thered loads of support online for filling out the form

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 18:47

Shimmershine819 · 31/03/2023 14:20

And another thing is that I look the picture of health when I leave the house. I go from looking like something out of the living dead in the evening to a normal, healthy human by morning! I make a huge effort because I can't stand the sympthatic 'gosh you look pale/tired etc' so the hair is gone, make up on and I wear bright colours and a gradual tan. I dont want anyone in work to know how I really feel, I can't stand the pity or gossip. I can imagine walking into a pip assessment and them making a decision before I've even sat down.

Yes, you are likely a victim of pretending you are ok. The absolute opposite of the people who get lots of help. It is ridiculously unfair OP. I'm so sorry you are in this situation. I do agree with PPs though that you should be getting some level of PIP and should appeal. Absolute joke, I know, to have to go through all of that: the stress and intrusion and humiliation, on top of the existing struggle of having to cope day to day with work and illness. The system is broken.

Babyroobs · 01/04/2023 17:37

memesndmoreme · 01/04/2023 17:30

OP have you tried applying for ESA it's not means tested

I think op would have to drop hours to less than 16 to apply for ESA which is possibly a risk especially if it then wasn't awarded. And £77 assessment rate is maybe unlikely to make up for lost earnings by dropping hours ? It could be an option.

memesndmoreme · 01/04/2023 17:30

OP have you tried applying for ESA it's not means tested

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 17:27

Yes I do get PIP. I'm a lone parent. No savings: all spent on the children's health needs not met by services and now in debt in fact just to continue providing their childcare so I can work. Nobody gives a shit about disabled people.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 17:25

Thanks @Babyroobs . I just ran our details through a couple of benefit calculators but with the presumption that both of my children will receive middle rate DLA for care and lower rate mobility - which should be the case given their needs and the huge bundle of professional reports sent to DWP with the claim forms - and the calculators still say that we're entitled to nothing else but their DLA and my PIP. Basically we are completely stitched up by me having worked all the hours under the sun to increase my earnings and bought a house before I became chronically ill. It does make you wonder why you bothered, if after decades of paying all of that tax, when I become disabled and have disabled children and ex-H buggers off and leaves me with two babies to support alone so we actually need some help from the services we've funded for everyone else for years with no complaint, the answer is "no".

Eventually my health will collapse, they'll lose their home, I'll lose my job, and the state will have to pick up the tab for us all. All because they wouldn't provide us with a sensible amount of support to make it manageable and sustainable for us to continue as we are with me funding all of our living costs but needing help with just the extra costs that result from our disabilities. It's so demoralising, I really am on the verge of a nervous breakdown at this point from the financial pressure, the pain and exhaustion, and fighting constantly to get help that doesn't seem to exist. DWP, SS, schools, NHS, all utterly, utterly useless. But quite happy to take our money each month. It will never make any sense to me.

Eventually when my children are left with a parent who is either completely incapacitated or dead, my one comfort will be that it serves the state fucking right not to continue to profit from my pain anymore and treat us so inhumanely when I have done everything I possibly could. I've survived on 3-4 hours of sleep per night for years, because all of this admin has to be done and I have a demanding professional job. I am in constant pain. Nobody cares. It's just "give us the money and fuck off". Fill in some more forms, and we'll tell you to fuck off again. I am on the verge of giving up now, there is only so much one human can manage. And to know that if I'd never bothered, never worked, never bought a house we'd be much better off financially, my health would not be so ruined, and I'd have much more time with my children to support them properly, it is all such a kick in the teeth.

Thank you for trying to help. Sadly, I think that for us, there is no real help. 😔

Babyroobs · 01/04/2023 16:58

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 16:51

If your income is too high for UC, the it's probably best to get another benefit check done once your kids are in receipt of DLA as that would bump up your UC award considerably. You can also claim significant help towards ofsted registered childcare on UC.

Thanks for that. What's the income threshold for UC as a lone parent if the children are awarded DLA? I had no idea that affected it as we've never got any help like that, not even child benefit. The childcare costs for them needing 1:1 are the absolute killer. I couldn't believe it when I heard people getting UC, with non-disabled kids, were getting up to 85% of childcare cost paid while I am being hammered for tax and put into debt to fund childcare for disabled children as a disabled lone parent with just the measly 20% discount, while having my health crumble more every month. It is unbelievably unfair.

The threshold will be different for everyone depending on circumstances. It would depend what rates of DLA your children were awarded and you could also claim a carers element as long as one of your children was awarded middle rate DLA. If you have a partner then if both your kids were awarded ,middle rate DLA you could both claim a carers element each. If awarded highest rat care component of DLA then the disabled child higher element is a lot more than middle rate. All these elements added up together can make your total UC entitlement high. Then childcare elements added as well. The total award is then reduced by earnings. Families with multiple disabled children can end up having significant Uc entitlement even with decent earnings. Sorry I can't remember whether you said you are getting PIP yourself but if you are then if claiming UC you can also ask to be assessed for work capability if your illness limits the number of hours you can work. This could potentially ( depending on the outcome) increase your award further. then on top of this you would still get the actual DLA and PIP amounts paid separately.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 16:51

If your income is too high for UC, the it's probably best to get another benefit check done once your kids are in receipt of DLA as that would bump up your UC award considerably. You can also claim significant help towards ofsted registered childcare on UC.

Thanks for that. What's the income threshold for UC as a lone parent if the children are awarded DLA? I had no idea that affected it as we've never got any help like that, not even child benefit. The childcare costs for them needing 1:1 are the absolute killer. I couldn't believe it when I heard people getting UC, with non-disabled kids, were getting up to 85% of childcare cost paid while I am being hammered for tax and put into debt to fund childcare for disabled children as a disabled lone parent with just the measly 20% discount, while having my health crumble more every month. It is unbelievably unfair.

Babyroobs · 01/04/2023 16:42

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 15:09

DLA higher rates plus Uc higher disabled child element are not insignificant amounts ! I do understand that not all disabled children get higher rates though but a lot do.

My children should get middle rate if the DWP ever process their forms: it has been sitting with them for months. Yes, it is an insignificant amount when their childcare per month averages out at more than £2k, for me to be able to work, because they cannot cope with holiday clubs, after school clubs etc. And that is before any of their other needs are met. I mean, I could just not work, but then the state would lose way more than that in monthly tax payments.

Again, PIP is a pathetic amount, given the above plus a mortgage to pay. The mobility part is used for that, through motability, which is actually decent value. But the remainder, the "care" part, obviously doesn't even touch the sides of the costs of disability.

Like I said in my post above, a couple where one was unable to work and claiming PIP were getting around £1200 in UC and PIP even with the wife working and the husband disabled. It's not bad, in fact almost equivalent to a full time wage for some people. And he was only on standard rate of PIP.

Well yeah if people get UC as well it may be very different. I have read posts where able bodied people, even in two adult households, are receiving incredible amounts of UC that far exceed anything provided in disability benefits.

WCA is the work capability assessment for UC or ESA.

I see. It's the non-means tested disability benefits that I think are shocking because they come nowhere close to covering the costs of disability and therefore levelling the playing field at least financially for disabled people, which is their purpose. I've no idea about means tested top ups, we don't get anything like that. Surely if you have disabled people who are managing to work - often in significant pain - and contribute to taxes this should be supported, rather than leave them to struggle until their health collapses to a point where they can't work and have to have all of their living costs provided by the state. It's a stupid system that increases the isolation, physical and financial hardship of disabled people and also costs the taxpayer more money than it would to fund PIP and child DLA properly.

If your income is too high for UC, the it's probably best to get another benefit check done once your kids are in receipt of DLA as that would bump up your UC award considerably. You can also claim significant help towards ofsted registered childcare on UC.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 15:21

PetitPorpoise · 01/04/2023 15:15

I actually don't think that the answer is always more benefits, no. It does sound like you are in an unsuitable job for your condition. Are you public facing?

More understanding, and ways to help you retrain might mean that you can work in a role that is more flexible around your condition.

Even if people do this, there are still additional costs involved in being disabled. It is these costs that the non means tested disability benefits like PIP are supposed to meet. And they don't, because they are around half the amount that they should be.

Same issue for child DLA. And for those caring full time for severely disabled children, carer's allowance is an absolute joke.

The way disabled people and their families are treated in the UK is disgusting.

PetitPorpoise · 01/04/2023 15:15

I actually don't think that the answer is always more benefits, no. It does sound like you are in an unsuitable job for your condition. Are you public facing?

More understanding, and ways to help you retrain might mean that you can work in a role that is more flexible around your condition.

Jupitune · 01/04/2023 15:09

DLA higher rates plus Uc higher disabled child element are not insignificant amounts ! I do understand that not all disabled children get higher rates though but a lot do.

My children should get middle rate if the DWP ever process their forms: it has been sitting with them for months. Yes, it is an insignificant amount when their childcare per month averages out at more than £2k, for me to be able to work, because they cannot cope with holiday clubs, after school clubs etc. And that is before any of their other needs are met. I mean, I could just not work, but then the state would lose way more than that in monthly tax payments.

Again, PIP is a pathetic amount, given the above plus a mortgage to pay. The mobility part is used for that, through motability, which is actually decent value. But the remainder, the "care" part, obviously doesn't even touch the sides of the costs of disability.

Like I said in my post above, a couple where one was unable to work and claiming PIP were getting around £1200 in UC and PIP even with the wife working and the husband disabled. It's not bad, in fact almost equivalent to a full time wage for some people. And he was only on standard rate of PIP.

Well yeah if people get UC as well it may be very different. I have read posts where able bodied people, even in two adult households, are receiving incredible amounts of UC that far exceed anything provided in disability benefits.

WCA is the work capability assessment for UC or ESA.

I see. It's the non-means tested disability benefits that I think are shocking because they come nowhere close to covering the costs of disability and therefore levelling the playing field at least financially for disabled people, which is their purpose. I've no idea about means tested top ups, we don't get anything like that. Surely if you have disabled people who are managing to work - often in significant pain - and contribute to taxes this should be supported, rather than leave them to struggle until their health collapses to a point where they can't work and have to have all of their living costs provided by the state. It's a stupid system that increases the isolation, physical and financial hardship of disabled people and also costs the taxpayer more money than it would to fund PIP and child DLA properly.

WhoToldYou · 01/04/2023 15:07

Can you look for another job or transfer your job to home-working? You’ve typed in this thread more than I type in a day in my job. Most of it is by phone or Teams calls. We have several employees with disabilities because the job involves minimal physical activity. The most I have to do is walk to the other side of the room to the printer/scanner. If you took away the journey to and from work you’d have more energy for your job.

Instead of expecting the taxpayer (ie other working people who are also struggling) to provide you with more money, think about the changes you can make that will benefit you physically and financially.

SouthCountryGirl · 01/04/2023 15:05

Zippedydoo123 · 01/04/2023 14:58

Can you claim PIP?

The OP has been turned down

Zippedydoo123 · 01/04/2023 14:58

Can you claim PIP?

Jellyheadbang · 01/04/2023 14:56

I am single parent with multiple conditions, work pt, have mortgage, can't drive due to disability and can't not work due to mortgage etc.
I finally managed to get pip last year with help from citizens advice.
It's taken me out of food bank territory, please try again but with help.
Cab can complete the forms for you in your presence or over the phone

Swipe left for the next trending thread