Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP's attitude to small amounts of money - boils my piss. AIBU?

287 replies

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 11:21

Me and DP are on the same page about 'big' finances.

But our attitudes to small amounts of money don't tally, and it boils my piss.

Let me give you some examples:

  • DP never ever scans his Clubcard at Tesco to get things at the lower price. We don't shop at Tesco for the big shop, so it's only really when he gets a meal deal for lunch at work. But why wouldn't you just scan your card?
  • If there's a multi-buy offer on at the supermarket, DP won't get the additional items if we don't need the additional item that week. But this is stuff that we will probably need the following week or the week after. And we have room for it. So why not just get it while its on offer?
  • DP has to do tax self-assessments. He missed the January deadline. He'll get fined £100 if its not done by end of April. But DP's away a lot over the next month so I don't see him getting around to it. So he'll just end up paying £100 to the government needlessly.

It's relatively small amounts of money. We can afford it. And its his money so his choice. So I know I'm kind of BU.

But I find it infuriating and wasteful.
I'm not advocating for him massively going out of his way to save a few pennies. I'm suggesting that things like bunging an extra bottle of squash in the basket when it's a 2-for-1 offer, or scanning your Clubcard at the self-service checkout aren't huge undertakings or impositions so why the hell wouldn't you do it?!
Please tell me you can see my perspective and I'm not being wholly U?!

OP posts:
MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:26

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 16:20

But, despite that, you think your husband should make sure he does it you way.

Thinking this stuff doesn’t matter so he can do it however he likes is a ‘shitty attitude’ apparently. 🙄

Even the fact you’ve aligned bogofs and not doing a tax return and presented it as the same, equally weighted problem is silly.

Nope, as I've said repeatedly, I don't expect DP to do things my way.

I'm baffled and frustrated by his approach but I've never expected or asked him to change it.

OP posts:
MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:25

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 16:17

I think expecting your partner to care bout your attitudes to minutiae is controlling. Even more if you’re checking up on it via bank statements and questioning his lunch spending.

There are lots of things you care about to varying degrees. It’s fine to expect him to care about the big stuff or the high priority stuff. But expecting him to adopt your perspective on supermarket promotions (when money is in no way an issue) is a weird attitude to take in a couple.

People have limited resources - cognitive and otherwise. I didn’t say he shouldn’t care about you or what you cared about. This is petty shit and you sound like a nightmare.

I think expecting your partner to care bout your attitudes to minutiae is controlling
I respectfully disagree. I think its indicative that you know your partner well, you know what they care about you act in a way, albeit mundane, which shows them love and respect. For me, caring about a partner's attitude towards minutiae is partly what indicates a depth of feeling and care beyond friendship.

I absolutely don't expect DP to adopt my attitude towards supermarket promotions. That's why, as I've said repeatedly if you took the time to read the thread, I've only mentioned the Clubcard once and I've never berated him for him not taking advantage of BOGOFs etc. His money, he can do what he likes It absolutely baffles me and frustrates me but he's his own person so up to him.

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 30/03/2023 16:24

Given that I'm more like your husband, OP, I wonder if the following is true for you too?

I don't scour around for small deals. Likewise, when I'm doing a job, it's usually with a "bosh - first link on Google - follow instructions - done" attitude.

As a result, I do a lot more than my husband with the same amount of time, and 95% time it's good enough. 5% of the time, some kind of research would have saved from being bitten on the arse.

He puts a lot of thought into jobs. Researchs, plans, gets every last tool. Does a very thorough job, with minimal errors. Sloooooowly.

We work with that. I deal with volume, he deals with precision. We decide what approach is needed as divvy up work accordingly.

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 16:22

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:19

I mean, I care enough to always get a bargain and I physically can't understand people who pass up bargains. But its not something I lose sleep over or would sit my DP down for a 'big talk' about or anything.

My response was specifically about a PP's comment about DP spending 'cognitive resource' on things I care about. My comment was that spending his 'cognitive resource' on this particular is neither here nor there really. But that DP should care about other things I care about.

i was talking about expending cognitive resource on this petty shit - as you well know.

Not saying that your husband should never consider you in any way.

Not buying a BOGOF a bottle of squash is completely different to not caring about stuff that matters.

Darkoutsideclosethecurtains · 30/03/2023 16:22

"take care of the pennies and the pounds will take care of themselves"

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 16:20

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:17

That was my quote 😆

What I meant by 'no big deal' was that BOGOFs, Clubcard, promotions etc. aren't things I care about deeply and passionately.

But, despite that, you think your husband should make sure he does it you way.

Thinking this stuff doesn’t matter so he can do it however he likes is a ‘shitty attitude’ apparently. 🙄

Even the fact you’ve aligned bogofs and not doing a tax return and presented it as the same, equally weighted problem is silly.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:19

I mean, I care enough to always get a bargain and I physically can't understand people who pass up bargains. But its not something I lose sleep over or would sit my DP down for a 'big talk' about or anything.

My response was specifically about a PP's comment about DP spending 'cognitive resource' on things I care about. My comment was that spending his 'cognitive resource' on this particular is neither here nor there really. But that DP should care about other things I care about.

OP posts:
SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 16:17

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 14:43

Please see my previous post. The 'shit attitude' I referred to isn't DP's.

The 'shit attitude' I referred to is a PP who suggested that DP shouldn't spend 'cognitive resource' thinking about things I care about. I said this was, in general, a shit attitude to have towards couple-dom.

DP is, of course, free to leave at any point. It's not a hostage situation 😅

I think expecting your partner to care bout your attitudes to minutiae is controlling. Even more if you’re checking up on it via bank statements and questioning his lunch spending.

There are lots of things you care about to varying degrees. It’s fine to expect him to care about the big stuff or the high priority stuff. But expecting him to adopt your perspective on supermarket promotions (when money is in no way an issue) is a weird attitude to take in a couple.

People have limited resources - cognitive and otherwise. I didn’t say he shouldn’t care about you or what you cared about. This is petty shit and you sound like a nightmare.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 16:17

coldmarchmorn · 30/03/2023 16:08

We're just talking shopping and Clubcards and BOGOFs and saving here so no big deal

It's a big deal to OP, It's a big deal to me. It's a big deal to lots and lots of people. It is literally throwing away money on a regular basis. It's lazy and it's disrespectful and its wasteful.

It's not just a different way of doing things that makes no difference. It's like setting fire to tenners on a regular basis.

That was my quote 😆

What I meant by 'no big deal' was that BOGOFs, Clubcard, promotions etc. aren't things I care about deeply and passionately.

OP posts:
coldmarchmorn · 30/03/2023 16:08

We're just talking shopping and Clubcards and BOGOFs and saving here so no big deal

It's a big deal to OP, It's a big deal to me. It's a big deal to lots and lots of people. It is literally throwing away money on a regular basis. It's lazy and it's disrespectful and its wasteful.

It's not just a different way of doing things that makes no difference. It's like setting fire to tenners on a regular basis.

burnoutbabe · 30/03/2023 15:53

If the dp hada moral objection to Tesco tracking his data then that works be one thing. But he has a club card on his key fob and just can't be bothered to use it!

Also the kid not being able to use a club are and paying double seems incorrect - it's £3.90 for meal deal and £3.50 with clubcard. So they probably didn't get meal deal items.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:45

coffeemoon · 30/03/2023 15:38

@MissMoneyBallBags I don't think it's comparable with the privacy thing. If you were to post all over social media about his life then that would be objectively a pretty shit thing to do if he's asked you not to.

The money thing is different because you can each make your own decisions about your own money without it having much impact on the other's life. The couple hundred pounds a year you might be worse off by will not affect your actual life at all.

I don't mean to be flippant but, truly, these issues are not comparable.

I respectfully disagree.

I'm not talking about posting our private life all over social media. I'm talking about mentioning relatively minor things in passing to friends.

If I made my own decision to tell a friend that DP's mum was unwell, for example, that wouldn't affect his life one bit. But he wouldn't like it. So I wouldn't share it.

DP's never asked me not to share personal things. I just know him well and know what he likes and doesn't like, what he'd want me to share and wouldn't, and I keep conscious of that regardless of my own leanings.

OP posts:
MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:41

coffeemoon · 30/03/2023 15:34

But this is an arbitrary thing, different people look at it differently and both ways of doing it are actually (objectively) fine.

What if he started moaning at you because you are penny-pinching too much, started telling you to relax and stop being so uptight? That would be awful, but it's the same thing in reverse.

You're expecting him to change his behaviour to match your preference.

Can't you see a problem there? You're not giving him agency.

Yes, I absolutely can see what you mean. As I said in the OP, I know I'm being U because it's his money. I don't curtail his agency or expect him to change - he can do what he likes, I've mentioned the Clubcard thing once and I don't berate him for not getting offers when we're shopping. I've never suggested he change his behaviour, I'm just venting on MN.

I should say, I'm not penny-pinching in the sense of being miserly. I hate people who are like this, it makes for a miserable life.
I'm happy to spend huge amounts of money on things I want or need. I don't scrimp on things, I don't buy cheap.
BUT if there's a bargain to be had on the things I need or want, I'll get it. That might be £50 off a £2,000 handbag, or it might be 40p off a Tesco meal deal. If there's money to be saved, I'll do it.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 30/03/2023 15:40

I see the two as being connected but I don't think he does at all.

To be fair, I don’t either. And that’s as someone who was scrabbling down the back of the sofa in the hope of finding coins at one stage. I’m so happy not to have to worry about 40p any more.

burnoutbabe · 30/03/2023 15:40

Blinkingstars · 30/03/2023 13:10

It’s his general overall attitude to money which would make me ditch him if he did this. Tesco Clubcard at till reductions are an offer to pay less money for what you are buying. To not choose to pay less on-the-spot money for your shopping is frivalent money wasting. I don’t care how much it is you are saving.

Agreed. I couldn't date someone who had such a different attitude to money -all this talk of "hassle" when it's a key fob he just needs to scan.

If he did it every time that's money saved plus points earned towards a day out /railcard each year. Would baffle me why he won't do it when it's straight money off at the till.

coffeemoon · 30/03/2023 15:38

@MissMoneyBallBags I don't think it's comparable with the privacy thing. If you were to post all over social media about his life then that would be objectively a pretty shit thing to do if he's asked you not to.

The money thing is different because you can each make your own decisions about your own money without it having much impact on the other's life. The couple hundred pounds a year you might be worse off by will not affect your actual life at all.

I don't mean to be flippant but, truly, these issues are not comparable.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:36

AspectArea · 30/03/2023 15:30

p.s. to add to this with a vague memory.. i once watched a foreign language film about a guy who dies and walks around his house/garden looking at all the stuff he owned and tallies them up to time. that bed cost me 2hours of work. that car, 20 months of work - that sort of thing. Money IS time if you live on earned income. i can't remember the name of the film, sorry, but it struck a really big chord with me as a teen.

if your DP didn't have such a wasteful attitude towards money, could oneof you drop a day a week of work?

that's how i think.

We could drop time at work even with his approach.

As I said, he's very proactive on 'big' finances and big amounts of money. But smaller amounts he has a total blindspot for. I see the two as being connected but I don't think he does at all.

OP posts:
bingoitsadingo · 30/03/2023 15:36

lucylantern · 30/03/2023 12:36

I’m with you OP.

Really interesting to see the arguments from posters that £100 extra spent on lunch is seen as not a problem but £100 fine for a tax return is not ok. Makes no sense to me but ok 🤷‍♀️

Well you have to do the tax return at some point, so you might as well do it sooner and not pay the fine.

Scanning a clubcard isn't something you have to do, and you have to do it all the time to get the rewards. So it's not zero-cost if you value not having to think about it.

coffeemoon · 30/03/2023 15:34

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:27

On this issue no. But he's not bothered about this issue, hence why he's not doing the saving things in the first place.

But, more generally, absolutely. I'm very conscious of the things DP cares about and will make efforts even if its stuff I don't care about. For example, DP's a really private person. I am absolutely not. But I don't share personal things because I know DP cares about privacy. I use my 'cognitive resources' to remember the things DP cares about this and act accordingly.

But this is an arbitrary thing, different people look at it differently and both ways of doing it are actually (objectively) fine.

What if he started moaning at you because you are penny-pinching too much, started telling you to relax and stop being so uptight? That would be awful, but it's the same thing in reverse.

You're expecting him to change his behaviour to match your preference.

Can't you see a problem there? You're not giving him agency.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:30

CountZacular · 30/03/2023 15:25

Sorry, I’ve only skimmed but I wonder if this has anything to do with your money situation growing up.

We didn’t have much money so getting the best value is important. Financially we could afford an extra 40p per day (for example) on lunch but if it’s unnecessary it would really bother me as it’s still a waste.

I think it really does, yes.

At times growing up we had absolutely nothing. We lived in an area of high poverty where most didn't have a pot to piss in. We had a food bank before they became a 'thing' because lots of people in the area couldn't afford to eat or prioritised other things over feeding their children.

DP's family had more. They weren't well-off but DP never went without and never watched his parents go without. He grew up in an area where everyone had enough to eat and nice houses etc.

So, yes, I really do think those experiences have had an impact.

OP posts:
AspectArea · 30/03/2023 15:30

p.s. to add to this with a vague memory.. i once watched a foreign language film about a guy who dies and walks around his house/garden looking at all the stuff he owned and tallies them up to time. that bed cost me 2hours of work. that car, 20 months of work - that sort of thing. Money IS time if you live on earned income. i can't remember the name of the film, sorry, but it struck a really big chord with me as a teen.

if your DP didn't have such a wasteful attitude towards money, could oneof you drop a day a week of work?

that's how i think.

GrinAndVomit · 30/03/2023 15:29

Blossomtoes · 30/03/2023 15:24

Oh dear.

It’s a discriminatory policy.

Hopefully that doesn’t hurt your head too much 😊

AspectArea · 30/03/2023 15:28

I'm with you OP. Generally being wasteful isn't an attractive trait, and the little effort it takes to scan a clubcard fob on your keyring.. it's disrespectful to the effort going into earning the income to BUY that stuff. I find it very distasteful actually - this money is not worth my time/energy when it's really no energy at all. And the tax penalties are just laziness.

Unless you're both millionaires/billionaires, I wouldn't like this, and financial values are really important to me in a relationship. I honestly couldn't be with someone who pissed money away on laziness. That's what's happening here.

Other people feel differently (you can see that on this thread). that's fine.

but i wouldn't want to enter into a relationship with people who do this - it's a fundamental incompatability.

MissMoneyBallBags · 30/03/2023 15:27

coffeemoon · 30/03/2023 15:21

If you reverse it though, are you showing much care for him and his approach to life here? I feel like you are being pretty intolerant of the fact that he just has a different outlook than you on penny-pinching.

On this issue no. But he's not bothered about this issue, hence why he's not doing the saving things in the first place.

But, more generally, absolutely. I'm very conscious of the things DP cares about and will make efforts even if its stuff I don't care about. For example, DP's a really private person. I am absolutely not. But I don't share personal things because I know DP cares about privacy. I use my 'cognitive resources' to remember the things DP cares about this and act accordingly.

OP posts:
CountZacular · 30/03/2023 15:25

Sorry, I’ve only skimmed but I wonder if this has anything to do with your money situation growing up.

We didn’t have much money so getting the best value is important. Financially we could afford an extra 40p per day (for example) on lunch but if it’s unnecessary it would really bother me as it’s still a waste.