Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

16 year old living away from home

160 replies

mucky123 · 30/03/2023 10:18

Posting shamelessly for traffic rather than aibu as such.

My DD is currently year 10 (age 15). She would like to move out of home at 16 after she has done her GCSEs (so for yr 12). I think she wants to carry on studying at that stage rather than get a job. Her friend is moving out at that age and she would like to stay with her. I said that obviously at that age it is up to her where she lives but whilst she can live with us I would not be bankrolling her living with this friend (friend is sweet but going off the rails a bit and it would not be good for DD).
I do think it would be good for DD to live away from us by that age both for her and for us but with the option of coming home regularly (weekends, holidays or as often as she wants).
Money is no real object (I'm happy to pay for accommodation/schooling if it gives us all a happier couple of years before she is officially an adult) and she is bright but not motivated. I have looked at sixth form boarding school but I am not sure if that will be exactly what she wants as there will be an intense being with others whether she wants it or not/lots of rules which I think she will not be too keen on.

I have heard on here a few times about posters with teens that live away and come back at weekend/holidays (there was recently the 17 year old DSS who came home, got drunk and had sex with a random - it was suggested that he lived in a bedsit mid-week).

Do you know of any options that aren't boarding school as such. More like a college with a bedsit or even a job with a bedsit. I'd just like to consider all options with her and google search isn't coming up with much.

OP posts:
Clymene · 30/03/2023 13:57

@MsRead - the home stays are literally staying in another family's home for a few weeks while attending language school. They're not foster care!

Invisimamma · 30/03/2023 13:56

Georgeandzippyzoo · 30/03/2023 13:54

But 16 isn't uni that is only starting alevels in the September.
There's a hell of a lot of difference in maturity and ability to look after yourself before starting a levels v starting uni.

No I started uni at 16, quite common in Scotland. I had my Highers and an unconditional uni offer at 16 (turned 17 in the Dec after starting uni).

LookingOldTheseDays · 30/03/2023 13:56

Georgeandzippyzoo · 30/03/2023 13:54

But 16 isn't uni that is only starting alevels in the September.
There's a hell of a lot of difference in maturity and ability to look after yourself before starting a levels v starting uni.

A summer born child in Scotland could move out at 16 and start uni a few mths later at 17.

MsRead · 30/03/2023 13:54

There are companies that find suitable families who host foreign students/ home stay arrangements for teens aged 14-18. I know there were companies in Kent but this was before BREXIT.

Would it be possible to maybe turn her bedroom into more of a bed sitter with a social space? Or is there a relative who may want ‘help’ around the home and is willing to sacrifice some space in their home?

I would also be very cautious because it’s not necessarily the maturity level of your child but the possibly nefarious intentions of others who would identify a teen in a potentially independent living situation.

How are things for her at home? Does she have underlying issues at school or socially that may also be driving this idea. Whilst most teens want independence and will say they want to leave home, usually it’s just about testing boundaries.

I’ve worked with teens for twenty years and strongly feel that they need almost as much supervision as toddler, just it involves a lot more pizza, petrol and patience. If she lives away and not in a boarding school situation I’d say that geography alone will seriously impede your ability to parent, she will always have somewhere to run away to if things are said that she doesn’t like but needs to hear. If pushed, I would say boarding or a structured home stay and if it’s a home stay she has to pay some of the cost from a part time job. Tricky one, good luck!

Georgeandzippyzoo · 30/03/2023 13:54

Invisimamma · 30/03/2023 10:58

I moved out at 16. I shared a flat share in the city for 3 months over the summer and worked until I moved into university accommodation in the September.

It depends on her maturity level. I was very diligent and ambitious, with a network of similarly minded friends . I was earning and able to manage my money and then got student loans. I was only 45mins from home. I loved it and wouldn't change it although looking back it was pretty young.

But 16 isn't uni that is only starting alevels in the September.
There's a hell of a lot of difference in maturity and ability to look after yourself before starting a levels v starting uni.

Comefromaway · 30/03/2023 13:51

I agree with Looking, what you are describing is normal teen behaviour.

LookingOldTheseDays · 30/03/2023 13:48

What you're describing is normal teen behaviour (thinking they know best, being headstrong etc). She hasn't gone off the rails and the relationship hasn't broken down.

It is beyond belief that you think her moving out would be for the best. I don't know whether this is real, but I hope it isn't.

BlueyDragon · 30/03/2023 13:48

I thought I knew it all at 16 too - couldn’t wait for independence. In hindsight I’m glad I wasn’t allowed all the freedom I wanted, and I had plenty as I was boarding full time and my parents were living abroad so I was carting myself around the UK and Europe aged 16. There’s plenty of freedom in a boarding school set up whilst not having to do boring adult stuff like pay bills; what you aren’t allowed to do is whatever the hell you like. If your DD is resisting those strictures she is not ready to leave home. The “independently funded friend” also rings alarm bells particularly as you don’t know where the money is coming from or how long it (or the friendship) will last.

As PP’s said, at 16 she cannot sign contracts in her own name so she will not be independent at all, she’s reliant on over 18s until she is one herself.

Whilst I really sympathise - we have had a couple of really bad years with DD although for different reasons - I also think for her own good you need to offer her the sixth form boarding option or home.

Clymene · 30/03/2023 13:45

Sorry I cross posted with you. She doesn't sound like a child who is off the rails at all though. It just sounds like you want to teach her a bit of a lesson

Sugarplumfairy65 · 30/03/2023 13:45

I was living in a bedsit one week after my 16th birthday. It was hell!
There is no way I would have allowed one of my children to do the same.

Clymene · 30/03/2023 13:43

Just fyi you are legally responsible for your daughter's wellbeing until she's 18.

The fact that you think this:
More like a college with a bedsit or even a job with a bedsit could be a solution is worrying.

If she doesn't get into the expensive 6th form boarding school, then you need a plan B. You also said you didn't think she will want to board.

I don't understand why you're being so passive. You can say no. She cannot move out. She can't rent property legally, she can't stay in a hotel. She needs to stay in some form of education.

Poor kid is only 15 and her parents want to get rid of her Sad

SchoolTripDrama · 30/03/2023 13:39

I moved out at 16 (I didn't really have a choice the house was too full) and it's the biggest mistake I ever made. I should've stuck it out. I ended up living in a homeless hostel and whilst everyone else my age was having fun, I was worrying about bills

Villssev · 30/03/2023 13:39

Sorry if I missed

but she is diagnosed ND, yes?

mucky123 · 30/03/2023 13:37

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/03/2023 12:58

The back story might be relevant in terms of options, OP. I looked into accommodation options for one of dd's friends at that age because her relationship with her parents had completely broken down. There was supported accommodation available through the local council, but eligibility was based on an assessment by Social Services, with priority obviously being given to those with the greatest need.

Of course, it's totally fair enough if you don't want to share the back story. It is indeed none of our business. However, the detail might inform some of the options that are available to you.

Thank you for your post, that was kind and thoughtful. I understand what you mean. No the relationship has not broken down and she has a safe, happy, large and comfortable home here (no blended family). We would not put her in SS accommodation (and even though she might try to get it if she thought that was a way of living on her own I doubt they would give it to her as they will see she is safe here).
She is going through a very difficult phase (has been for about 2 years). She is fine at school and does loads of extra-curricular where she is polite, helpful, friendly. She doesn't seem to be misbehaving (bit of vaping tried, not much drinking (certainly never drunk), lots of boyfriends but I'm pretty sure no sex, no staying out beyond curfews). You wouldn't think from the outside there wasn't anything wrong.
Without going into detail, home is very, very hard. She is a confused but headstrong young person. She cannot accept any boundary or advice. She thinks she knows everything. She has always been fiercely independent. She has counselling and is under camhs. I think this is just a phase but I also think she would be happier doing her own thing for at least part of the week - might make her appreciate what she has here. She is always nicer when she has been away on a scouting weekend or with school and comes back. She is travelling in the Summer on the world scout jamboree to Korea and she can't wait, the thought of the independence, being with other young people. She is attractive, vivacious and other young people seem to love her (boys and girls) although she only lets them get so close. We are by nature more homey, less interesting and she is quite scornful of us.

What I want is to show her possibilities of different types of future that is not staying here and going to the same school. There is independence at 18 but that seems like a lifetime away when you are 15 but if one of these schools/colleges take her fancy maybe she can imagine herself there and maybe she can aspire to that.

OP posts:
KnittingNeedles · 30/03/2023 13:36

Because it's none of your business. I wasn't interested in advice on that, I am interested in what other people on mumsnet might have done/heard of for offering a form of independence at 16

But 99% of posters will have zero experience of this. Most of us with children of this age have them living at home, doing Highers/A-levels, debating whether or not to leave home to go to uni in a couple of years. Not doing Nat 5s/GCSEs and moving out into a flat!

It's deeply weird. Going to boarding school or some sort of specialist dance or music school with boarding houses (staffed by adults) is totally different from being desperate to get rid of your 16 year old into independent living with a friend.

Rebel2 · 30/03/2023 13:30

I moved out at 16, to agriculture college Smile and lived in halls

quietnightmare · 30/03/2023 13:29

Does she want to move out so she thinks she will be able to go out evert night have parties, girlfriends:boyfriends over, get drunk all the time, stay in bed all weekend, smoke/vape whenever she wants because if that's the case she's going to need a job and doing all the above and paying rent on a 16 year olds wage isn't going to happen.

If her friend is moving out anyway why don't you say to her she stays with you in the week and she can get an evening job/weekend job and she can use that money to pay her friend on the weekend to stay there with her and go out and do whatever she wants. All sounds ridiculous to me but everyone is different.

Side note friends that live together young can easily fall out over mess/bills/spending too much time together it's a lot for a 16 year old to navigate

PinkiOcelot · 30/03/2023 13:22

I would have been devastated if my DDs had expressed wanting to leave home then. In fact I was last year when dd1 moved out at 21.

can’t believe you’re so blasé about it. Have you not got a good relationship with her or something?

JazbayGrapes · 30/03/2023 13:15

16 seems to be the "magic age" for all sorts of things ,leaving home, having sex and until a while ago smoking cigarettes!

I maybe old-fashioned, but 16 is way too young for sex. Yes, its legal, but only because many teens are sexually active anyway and it would be counterproductive to criminalize all the young lovers.

dottiedodah · 30/03/2023 13:07

16 seems to be the "magic age" for all sorts of things ,leaving home, having sex and until a while ago smoking cigarettes! However the reality is most kids of this age, are not equipped for life ,and run the risk of all sorts of problems with no adults to supervise them.I would be unhappy about this .Its only a couple of years to 18 and then it still seems young unless at Uni or something.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/03/2023 12:58

The back story might be relevant in terms of options, OP. I looked into accommodation options for one of dd's friends at that age because her relationship with her parents had completely broken down. There was supported accommodation available through the local council, but eligibility was based on an assessment by Social Services, with priority obviously being given to those with the greatest need.

Of course, it's totally fair enough if you don't want to share the back story. It is indeed none of our business. However, the detail might inform some of the options that are available to you.

VanCleefArpels · 30/03/2023 12:57

mucky123 · 30/03/2023 12:22

Hurtwood House looks amazing. Obviously getting in might be difficult (although she is pretty bright (currently in Grammar school) and articulate and creative). It's also close enough I could get her on a Friday night easily. I will talk to her about doing a visit/open day. It's something that could be inspiration to stick in at the GCSE's, the hope of something different. Course fees are eye-watering but it would be worth it I think.

Hurtwood is not academically selective - they look for students who will “fit” and a lot of students are round peg in square hole type kids who are looking for something different to what they have had before. It’s way more relaxed than a traditional boarding school, teachers called by their first names etc

mucky123 · 30/03/2023 12:49

Bbq1 · 30/03/2023 12:43

Op, why aren't you answering the pp's asking what the backstory is? There clearly is one.

Because it's none of your business. I wasn't interested in advice on that, I am interested in what other people on mumsnet might have done/heard of for offering a form of independence at 16. Some of the advice has been quite helpful and I have a number of different options/websites.

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 30/03/2023 12:43

Op, why aren't you answering the pp's asking what the backstory is? There clearly is one.

threeplusmum · 30/03/2023 12:36

16 is a very vulnerable age, I personally wouldn't allow my child especially daughter to live independently but that's just me.