Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

16 year old living away from home

160 replies

mucky123 · 30/03/2023 10:18

Posting shamelessly for traffic rather than aibu as such.

My DD is currently year 10 (age 15). She would like to move out of home at 16 after she has done her GCSEs (so for yr 12). I think she wants to carry on studying at that stage rather than get a job. Her friend is moving out at that age and she would like to stay with her. I said that obviously at that age it is up to her where she lives but whilst she can live with us I would not be bankrolling her living with this friend (friend is sweet but going off the rails a bit and it would not be good for DD).
I do think it would be good for DD to live away from us by that age both for her and for us but with the option of coming home regularly (weekends, holidays or as often as she wants).
Money is no real object (I'm happy to pay for accommodation/schooling if it gives us all a happier couple of years before she is officially an adult) and she is bright but not motivated. I have looked at sixth form boarding school but I am not sure if that will be exactly what she wants as there will be an intense being with others whether she wants it or not/lots of rules which I think she will not be too keen on.

I have heard on here a few times about posters with teens that live away and come back at weekend/holidays (there was recently the 17 year old DSS who came home, got drunk and had sex with a random - it was suggested that he lived in a bedsit mid-week).

Do you know of any options that aren't boarding school as such. More like a college with a bedsit or even a job with a bedsit. I'd just like to consider all options with her and google search isn't coming up with much.

OP posts:
LookingOldTheseDays · 30/03/2023 15:00

Just because a 15 year old behaves like a normal teenager and says she wants more independence, that should not be a cue for their parents to look at ways to get them moved out of home ASAP.

misssunshine4040 · 30/03/2023 15:00

I moved out at 16 to work in a stable and live in accommodation was part of the job. I moved out permanently at 17. I was absolutely fine.

LookingOldTheseDays · 30/03/2023 14:59

Alwaystalkingaboutpoo · 30/03/2023 14:53

I just wanted to take moment to say what a lovely, intuitive and thoughtful parent you sound. Sometimes, just enforcing rules and not attempting to understand her world is the probably the most alienating thing you can do. It sounds like you are very in tune with her needs and still protective. She is lucky to have you. I’m sure, whether she sees it now or when she’s a bit older, your daughter will really value her Mum attempting to understand her needs and not dismissing them to ‘lay down the law’ as such. I really hope you find a solution to suit you both and allow you let daughter to find her way with a supportive family by her side. All the best! X

WTAF?

The parent who is looking for suggestions re: how to send a 16 year old to live in a bedsit is thoughtful and supportive?

Bear in mind that this girl is currently in year 10, so she's not even been 15 for that long at this point.

Alwaystalkingaboutpoo · 30/03/2023 14:53

I just wanted to take moment to say what a lovely, intuitive and thoughtful parent you sound. Sometimes, just enforcing rules and not attempting to understand her world is the probably the most alienating thing you can do. It sounds like you are very in tune with her needs and still protective. She is lucky to have you. I’m sure, whether she sees it now or when she’s a bit older, your daughter will really value her Mum attempting to understand her needs and not dismissing them to ‘lay down the law’ as such. I really hope you find a solution to suit you both and allow you let daughter to find her way with a supportive family by her side. All the best! X

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 14:51

25 years ago my cousins (one 16 and one 17) lived together in a house their parents bought for them.

The mum and dad moved 100 miles away for his work. The DC were obviously very much welcome to have gone with them but they didn't want to move - one of the DC was at a college they loved and the other in a very good apprenticeship.

They did absolutely fine but it very unusual even back then and I guess teens are effectively much younger these days.

mindutopia · 30/03/2023 14:50

I had a friend who lived on her own at 16. She got pregnant at 14 and was a bit of a wild child. I think her parents just hit the wall with dealing with her and then a baby on top of that. They had plenty of money and she was an only child. They privately rented her a 3 bed terraced house a few streets away. I remember coming home from school and going over to see her (she had left school at this point or maybe was mostly homeschooling herself with support from a special school). It felt so grown up at the time. She had a dining room with an actual dining table and her own tv and I just remember thinking this seemed so exciting (never mind the screaming toddler).

Looking back now though, she would have been so young. My dd is 10 and I can't imagine her moving out in 6 years (also can't imagine her having a baby in 4 years!). My friend came out largely okay, though has 4 children by 3 different dads and hasn't ever had a successful long-term relationship, but she did go to uni and also did an MSc and has a good job and bought her first house when she was late 20s. But I think that having a child to care for is probably what kept her out of too much trouble. It wasn't much of a party house with a baby/toddler around. But with total freedom, I think it would have been quite a bad situation for her.

lechatnoir · 30/03/2023 14:50

Well your updates would have been helpful in the op including the fact you were referring to boarding type school/college not kicking her out as you implied.

Isthisexpected · 30/03/2023 14:50

I think she needs more not less of you. I am really shocked at this situation.

cactiminds · 30/03/2023 14:43

Think you’re getting a bit of a hard time here, OP. It doesn’t make you a shit parent at all. I moved out at 16 (but went back home most weekends) and eventually moved back in with my parents a few years later. I struggled hugely with my mental health, and was fiercely independent. Being at home was putting a massive strain on my relationship with my parents and siblings, and having some time away from them every week was really helpful. It made me miss them and appreciate them and all that they did for me. They still supported me and let me know I could come home whenever I wanted/needed. Maybe you could look at options like this - she can stay with this friend for so many nights a week but has to come home for weekends?

celticprincess · 30/03/2023 14:41

She can’t just get a job which comes with accommodation at 16. She has to be in compulsory education or training - so an apprenticeship and I’m not sure many of those come with accommodation. Apprenticeships pay terrible as well. £6 per hour or something. So that’s not going to give her any real idea about living independently. If you are finding her accommodation and say money is no issue then you’re not setting her up for real life when she needs to get a job and pay rent properly - or do you plan to fund her for life.

I see you mentioned boarding school. I’d suspect that would the exact opposite of what she’s requesting!!

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 30/03/2023 14:41

Boarding school - preferably some distance away from flakey friend but more so to foster the sense on independence and “living away” if popping home isn’t an option

Weekly boarding somewhere nearby ish so she can pop home at the weekend from 1-2 hrs away

Good behaviour bond with cash into a savings scheme so she can go travelling in the summer holidays / other times as appropriate.

memorial · 30/03/2023 14:40

Absolutely bonkers. My DD1 was impossible and off the rails at that age. If she'd moved out I think she would have gone down a very dark path. With firmness pushing lots of tears she is now a wonderful 21yr old flourishing at uni.
I'm curious if she's your oldest? This is hard age. This is where you really need to parent them. Not give up on them. Awful idea.

Villssev · 30/03/2023 14:40

@Ripleysgameface that must be devastating for you

MsRead · 30/03/2023 14:34

Clymene · 30/03/2023 13:57

@MsRead - the home stays are literally staying in another family's home for a few weeks while attending language school. They're not foster care!

The OP asked for suggestions at no point did I suggest it would be foster care.

Villssev · 30/03/2023 14:33

myheartmyhead · 30/03/2023 14:22

My youngest wants to join the navy when he finishes his GCSEs
His choice that I will support if he doesn't change his mind... he's an October birthday so will be closer to 17 than 16
Depends on the maturity of the kid I think

Very different to what’s being proposed here

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 30/03/2023 14:32

You cannot underestimate how much your child needs stable parenting between 16/18. I would gently but firmly issue a flat no.
Boarding school? Maybe. Other than that, no.

StillMedusa · 30/03/2023 14:27

Absolutely bonkers.
Even setting aside the fact she can't rent, and will still have to be in education or training, how disengaged with your child do you have to be to be even entertaining such an idea?

Teens are headstrong and frequently obnoxious and ungrateful. 15 is pretty much peak age (I had four all at once!) One of mine WAS horrific, not just headstrong but did all sorts of illegal things and was just very very hard to tolerate.
He would have loved to have his own place so that he could do what he liked, for certain!

But we had responsibility for him, so we just kept our boundaries, and waited for him to mature.. which he did; by about 18 he was a lot more sensible, not so keen to move out Grin and actually lived at home til his mid twenties in the end.

Letting a headstrong child.. because she is a child, move in with a not sensible friend is just a major disaster. Boarding school if she really wants to try it.. yes. Might make her a bit more grateful and at least you can relinquish her without much guilt.

I really hope this is a wind up though because she needs parenting!

Houseyvibe · 30/03/2023 14:26

The more of your replies I read OP the more I think you've lost the plot and are scared of saying No to your DD. You clearly have money to support her and to all intents and purposes she's just a stropping teen pushing boundaries and you are feeding that. Give her the option of boarding school. If she doesn't like it she can crack on at home. year 10's do push boundaries, it is probably the hardest years along with year 9. I'm sure she's no different to millions of other year 10 girls and pandering to this won't do her any favours at all and probably will harm her .

IndysMamaRex · 30/03/2023 14:25

You tell your child she attends an appropriate 6th form boarding or she lives at home until she finishes education & has a job to support herself. To be honest she doesn’t sound very mature to me a she clearly hasn’t though about the practicalities of how she will support herself.

does she have a job? NO
can she pay rent, council tax & every other bill? NO
does she have a deposit or the funds to equipment a flat? NO
can she enter into any legal agreement such as a lease when under 18 without an adult? NO

I think you all need to sit down & have a serious conversation about what being an independent adult actually involves.

In the eyes of the law she is a child not an adult.

myheartmyhead · 30/03/2023 14:22

My youngest wants to join the navy when he finishes his GCSEs
His choice that I will support if he doesn't change his mind... he's an October birthday so will be closer to 17 than 16
Depends on the maturity of the kid I think

AlwaysLatte · 30/03/2023 14:21

16! Wow, that's young. Even at university age most students spend the first year in halls to adjust to their new-found independence.

Minfilia · 30/03/2023 14:19

Honestly OP, to me she sounds like a child with MH problems who thinks they will all be solved by moving out. It won’t solve her issues, it will likely just make things worse (but I also get the impression she won’t understand that).

I would look at boarding options too, so she still has one foot in the door (and frankly it will be a hard bump down to earth once she’s experienced that and she might realise home isn’t so bad after all).

I also have a fiercely independent DD, but she also knows that she needs me and she needs her home so our situation is different. But you’ve done the right thing saying you won’t bankroll her living with her friend, frankly that would be a disaster!

Villssev · 30/03/2023 14:16

Without going into detail, home is very, very hard. She is a confused but headstrong young person. She cannot accept any boundary or advice. She thinks she knows everything. She has always been fiercely independent

she is a teenager OP

i do sympathise and empathise but I suspect she is testing you. She wants you to say “No Way do I want you to move out!! Your my daughter, I love you, I want to be under the same roof as you, I want us to work through this difficult period - together!”

what she doesn’t want you to do I suspect is take her seriously and actively assist her moving out

Comefromaway · 30/03/2023 14:03

Home stays attached to full time colleges are set up so that the family you stay with have a lot of responsibilities which include providing breakfast and evening meal, laundry and they had to either provide a lift to college or be within easy reach of public transport. Dd had to follow the rules of the home.

Ripleysgameface · 30/03/2023 14:00

My 16 year old doesn't live with me anymore and it's a disaster in many ways.
He's with a relative who isn't really a parental figure so he does what he wants mostly and gets away with murder.

Its hard to parent them when they're not at home and they definitely still need parenting at that age. I don't see him at weekends either as he's 80 miles away in London so it's not easy.

I had to say yes to the move in my situation but if I were you I'd say no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread