Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told DD6 the truth about Santa?

219 replies

Santaslittlehelper83 · 30/03/2023 10:13

A bit of an unseasonable thread, but it started as her questioning the existence of the Easter bunny, as a few things didn't add up to her about the school's easter egg hunt. We've never made a thing of the easter bunny, but have had egg hunts at home so I eventaully said 'yes it's the parents that hide the eggs'. I wish I hadn't as her train of thought went to the tooth fairy, then Santa. I wanted her to believe for a couple more years, as she still seems so little. I tried being vague saying along the lines of 'well we have to believe to keep the magic alive etc.....'. She wasn't to be fobbed off though and outright asked me if Santa was real and got the presents. In the end I felt I couldn't outright lie, so told her I didn't know whether Santa was real, but it is the parents that buy the gifts, and explained the tradition around that.

Well.....last night and this morning it is like the bottom has dropped out of her world. She is really upset and says she wishes she didn't know, that she feels there is no more magic in the world. I just don't know what to say to her, how to comfort her. She was so dejected going into school today, but she knows she can't say anything to her friends (I did have a quick word with the teacher). Has anyone else been through this, when a young child has been so upset? Was I unreasonable, should I just have lied?? Although I do believe she is upset, she is a bit of a dramatic child, and I think may be playing up to this abit. I feel awful and she is probably picking up on this. Arrrgh....any advice??? TIA.

OP posts:
Hillarious · 30/03/2023 14:09

I really don't understand why people make out to children that Santa provides all the presents. They just get themselves into a pickle.

Santa the courier is just fine, arriving after they've gone to bed. Just gets difficult once they're going out to the pub and are back later than when the parent have gone to bed. Then we realise Santa the courier arrives just before everyone gets up.

NotAHouse · 30/03/2023 14:09

Babymamaroon · 30/03/2023 14:05

@NotAHouse

Yes I'm super thank you Smile

I'm in the 'let kids be kids' camp. Magic and all.

I don't think they need to understand all things grown up. Not just yet.

That includes being prepared for them encountering snuff movies, does it? Bonkers.

Snugglemonkey · 30/03/2023 14:06

My 6 year old asked about Santa pre Xmas. He said he heard at school that some people don't believe. I totally lied. He is 6. We are so not giving up the magic of Christmas yet!

Babymamaroon · 30/03/2023 14:05

@NotAHouse

Yes I'm super thank you Smile

I'm in the 'let kids be kids' camp. Magic and all.

I don't think they need to understand all things grown up. Not just yet.

NotAHouse · 30/03/2023 13:59

Babymamaroon · 30/03/2023 13:50

I'm a grown woman and still believe!

It's strange that you couldn't find a suitable response to a 6 yr old but if this isn't important to you then it does stand to reason you wouldn't care whether she believes or not.

Would you answer honestly to any question? What if she overheard the words 'snuff movie" - would you explain that?

Lesson here is be prepared!

Christ, lady, are you OK?

BlackBarbies · 30/03/2023 13:58

I personally think you did the right thing🤷‍♀️

Sammmmmy1512 · 30/03/2023 13:57

Explain to her that you are the real santa and you are the real easter bunny, just because 'santa' doesnt exist doesnt mean the magic cant really be kept alive. Google it, there are ways to explain is that the parents are the real santa and easter bunny

MidnightEagle · 30/03/2023 13:54

Aww this is so sad for her. Even I wish I still believed in Santa. It was so magical!!

GaspingGekko · 30/03/2023 13:51

OP I would probably have done the same thing. Our situation is different, DH is not Christian and we live in a country where Christians are minority. So DC knew that santa doesn't go to everyone, that some people don't celebrate Christmas etc.
And they figured out pretty early on that santa isn't real, but we still put out the mince pie and carrot and talk about him.

I find it odd that people think the only magic of Christmas is from santa. My DC still love the magic, from the traditions we've created, the excitement of gifts, the family being together, the food. It's a magic time of year and telling your DD the truth isn't going to stop that.

ananass · 30/03/2023 13:51

Wedoronron · 30/03/2023 13:39

Surely religion is just the same just people forgot to point out it was made up.

Not sure there is a religion that tells you to lie to your kids for c.10 years and then hope they forget you lied when they learn the truth.

Babymamaroon · 30/03/2023 13:50

I'm a grown woman and still believe!

It's strange that you couldn't find a suitable response to a 6 yr old but if this isn't important to you then it does stand to reason you wouldn't care whether she believes or not.

Would you answer honestly to any question? What if she overheard the words 'snuff movie" - would you explain that?

Lesson here is be prepared!

glitterisntgendered · 30/03/2023 13:43

It's fine, it's done. She'll be fine. DS hasn't believed in the Easter bunny or tooth fair since he was about 4 and he still loves it all. She will be upset for a while (as she would have been any age when she found out) but Xmas is a long way away, she will be fine by then

Ps kids believe what they want to. DS has discussed with an 8 yr that tooth fairy isn't real (I did say not to tell other kids, he hasn't told the little kids) but she believes so she just thinks he's wrong and that's fine, everyone can believe something different.

Wedoronron · 30/03/2023 13:39

ananass · 30/03/2023 10:33

None of these things are real.

Adults lying to their children is ridiculous, especially as they mock actual religious people.

She asked you for the truth, you tried to tell her the truth. Always tell her the truth.

Surely religion is just the same just people forgot to point out it was made up.

BaileysBreakfast · 30/03/2023 13:37

Fwiw, I do lie about Santa but badly, so my Dc don’t really believe they just pretend they do so that they get presents!!

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 30/03/2023 13:35

It’s done now, but it’s a shame you couldn’t have come up with something in the moment. Yes different beliefs etc but ultimately believing that magic might be real is one of the joys of childhood and she’s young to have lost that for the sake of a white lie. They figure it out when they are ready anyway.

BaileysBreakfast · 30/03/2023 13:34

I regret lying to my two about Santa. I kind of bowed to pressure from my dh about it. I only know one parent who has never lied to her dc. Children who have never been lied to have a truly impressive instinct for calling out bullshit (judging by the family I know anyway!). She will know she can trust you to tell her the truth. The truth isn’t always what you want it to be and she will learn that too.

Snorlaxing · 30/03/2023 13:31

I think that some parents keep the Santa thing going for their own gratification rather than for their kids.
If Christmas stops being magical because your child Knows then you are doing Christmas wrong. You can still go through the rituals, talk about him as if he's real and enjoy being with family and friends.
Kids enjoy playing make believe even when they know it's not real. They appreciate it when others join in and can still talk and enjoy Santa like previous years.

Stickmansmum · 30/03/2023 13:30

And yes, I adore Christmas and the santa thing is a total PITA in my opinion. Never liked it and its certainly not the highlight in our house although I try so hard to make it as magical as possible for them.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2023 13:29

Magic is carols and Christmas trees and celebrating as people across the world have done for thousands of years. It's lighting a candle against the dark. If you're Christian (even if you're not) it's the Christ Child in his mother's arms, precious and vulnerable like every other newborn.

Magic can also be an embodiment of the love and generosity of the world, which is what Santa represents in our house. Each to their own.

Stickmansmum · 30/03/2023 13:28

I think its okay! I try hard to never get in the position of them asking me outright and when they do and I am backed in a corner, I tell them 'of course there is a santa! wink wink' and bring them in on the conspiracy a bit without actually saying out loud there is not. They can then choose to make of that what they wish but its a bit of a softer landing.

You drew a hard line in the sand about it so the best next thing to do is treat her with respect and have a proper conversation about why adults love to keep this magic alive for kids and what a wonderful thing it is for as long as it lasts. Then make sure you speak about all the things in the world that are absolutely magical for real. Newborn babies and puppies and kittens, the seasons and the weather, anything in nature really, how people love and form bonds etc.

whyhere · 30/03/2023 13:23

SusiePevensie · 30/03/2023 13:03

Meh. I love Christmas. Really really don't like the telling kids santa is real. It's not magic. Magic is carols and Christmas trees and celebrating as people across the world have done for thousands of years. It's lighting a candle against the dark. If you're Christian (even if you're not) it's the Christ Child in his mother's arms, precious and vulnerable like every other newborn. It's thinking of nice presents and getting them too. It's feasting with friends and family. It's telling Christmas stories and going for a Boxing Day walk.

Telling them Santa is real is just lying.

(Deep breath. I have to keep schtum about this in real life).

Me too, SusieP, me too!

toastofthetown · 30/03/2023 13:23

Nanny0gg · 30/03/2023 10:54

But it's up to the parents and a 6 year old will tell, guaranteed

It’s not up to parents when children find out that lies (in the bluntest possible term) they’ve been told are lies. Different children believe in different things and it should be ok to discuss that in the classroom. Many families don’t celebrate Christmas at all and as such their children don’t get presents or believe in Father Christmas. Should the Jehovah’s Witness child in class at school have lied throughout December to maintain a myth for the rest of the class?

SusiePevensie · 30/03/2023 13:20

Plus - if Santa is real and gives good children presents, then the kids that don't get nice presents must be bad. Which is just lovely for poor kids.

whyhere · 30/03/2023 13:15

ananass · 30/03/2023 10:33

None of these things are real.

Adults lying to their children is ridiculous, especially as they mock actual religious people.

She asked you for the truth, you tried to tell her the truth. Always tell her the truth.

Exactly! If the two major Christian festivals hadn't been taken over by commercialism (starting with Coca Cola, years ago) none of us would be in this fix with children! Actually, the true story of St Nicolas (December 6th) is absolutely lovely - it makes far more sense to tell children about that than to invent 'Father Christmas'.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/03/2023 13:04

For fuck's sake in the 70s few children believed in Father Christmas (because we never used 'Santa') past about 4 because older siblings told us the truth and with no care about scarring us for life.