Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Discipline for just under 2 year old

36 replies

Unrulywifey81 · 30/03/2023 08:49

Youngest is 2 in July and Dh and I are at loggerheads over how to discipline him

He is a very active little boy, not many words yet (car, dog, mama, dada) that's about it so gets frustrated easily when trying to tell us what he wants

If he wants someone to play with him or go somewhere will come over and get try and get us to stand up and show us etc. Can be a bit grabby with his brother and his toys (oldest is 7) and if he is ever too rough we always remind to use gentle hands.

Dh wants to use the step as punishment when he has a tantrum or gets too upset. I think he is too young yet to really comprehend. Dh had put youngest on the step a few times and after a few minutes of crying he does calm down but then goes and does the same thing again.

We're now not talking as I was playing with youngest the other day and he wad frustrated over one of his toys. Dh was on nights and said he could hear him screaming from the bedroom so asked why I didn't put him on the step, I explained I was trying to work through what was frustrating him and this had caused an almighty row and being called a rubbish parent and that I'm raising a split brat etc.

I can't remember what we did with the eldest however although I don't think we used the step until a lot later and they've turned into a lovely, well mannered, thoughtful child.

Any suggestions?

OP posts:
Oopswediditagain2023 · 30/03/2023 09:08

We didn't use the step until much later (probably 2 and a half?) and we don't use it as a punishment but as a place where they can go and calm themselves down. We also use it if they're doing something dangerous and need to be taken away from the situation. Sometimes we sit with them on it to help them chill out a bit!

It's very difficult to know the best thing to do with them when their communication still isn't great. I don't think your DH is necessarily in the wrong to suggest the step as in that situation you've described, it would have been taking him away from a frustrating place for him and letting him calm down (I'd have sat with him in that instance). Again at that age, I would shout "NO" quite firmly if they were about to do something dangerous/violent!

HealthyFats · 30/03/2023 09:07

Your husband is completely clueless.

Dirtydiesel · 30/03/2023 09:06

He doesn't have the communication skills and understanding for the naughty step. My son is much older but because of his disability will be in many ways developmentally to your son and I have never used naughty step type punishment. If he being rough you may need to move him away from his brother but not as a punishment but to put a stop to it and enable him to calm down.
When you are saying gentle hands etc you may want to think about the tone of voice you are using because it needs to be calm and quiet but also firm like you mean it.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 30/03/2023 09:06

Completely agree with you and all other comments here, the step is a good tool however only when they comprehend what is happening and why. He is way too young yet, get some supernanny on for OH

Goingtothebeach · 30/03/2023 09:05

You can't discipline a baby. It's ridiculous. Anyone who believes you can is wrong and a bit thick.

You just have to have bags of patience and go with the flow. Distraction, ignoring tantrums until they pass, making sure they're safe.

SomebodysMum · 30/03/2023 09:04

Your husband is a moron. If he can’t understand how the naughty step is supposed to work and what age it’s appropriate for, how the fuck is a 2 year old supposed to understand the concept?

DiastasisRectiSucks · 30/03/2023 09:01

“The step” is supposed to work by giving the child time to think about what they did and why they shouldn’t do it again, by understanding that they are currently being punished with withdrawal of affection and freedom as a result of their actions.

Children aren’t developmentally ready for that level of logic and inference till at least 9.
They don’t have impulse control or empathy until much later than 2.

So how the actual fuck is your barely speaking 2yr old BABY supposed to benefit from punishment and isolation for doing entirely developmentally expected things???

Sceptre86 · 30/03/2023 09:01

My baby is 18 months. She's learning to communicate too and does have quite a few words but still gets frustrated and has tantrums. I can appreciate it's tough doing shifts with young kids but a few tantrums isn't going to turn them into a spoilt brat. I'd be telling him to get over himself and I wouldn't use the naughty step for such a young child. Your son really isn't doing anything out of the ordinary.

PurBal · 30/03/2023 08:58

DS also 2 in July and we’re struggling with knowing what to do for discipline so will watch with interest. I was leaving things like the step until he was a bit bigger and could understand. I do think the step should be used for intentionally bad behaviour rather than an expression of emotions though. For frustration I get down to his level, get him to look at me and say “I know you’re frustrated we can’t do X, let’s do Y instead”.

JackHackettsMac · 30/03/2023 08:54

Your DH is a stupid twat!

At that age your son is still learning to communicate with you and punishing him with the naughty step is not the solution to any behaviour that you don't like. Fair enough to try it when he's at least 3yrs old.

Patience, love and understanding are all he needs at the moment.