Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend’s kid wants to go to private school

307 replies

Limegreencurtains · 30/03/2023 07:20

I’ve been with my boyfriend for over a year and things are going well. We have been discussing the eventuality of us moving in together although neither of us are quite ready yet. I have young children from a previous relationship as does he. Yesterday, he told me that his child wants to go to private school and he will be funding it all. I am shocked at the cost and the fact his ex would expect him to cover all expenses. I can’t help but imagine that this is now going to affect our future. Do I have the right to bring this up or is it none of my business? I could never afford to send my own nor would I want to. Last year, just before I met his kid, he asked if they were ok with Dad having a girlfriend to which they replied, they thought it was fine as long as he didn’t stop buying them stuff. The kid and ex are high maintenance and I personally feel my boyfriend is seen as the bank of Dad. We both come from humble backgrounds. He earns £50000 a year and I work part time. Am I being unreasonable in wanting to ask where this leaves our future financially or is it none of my business how he spends his money?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 30/03/2023 09:26

It's good to know the future committments of your boyfriend.

Antiquiteas · 30/03/2023 09:22

I suspect the big issue is actually that OP was hoping that she'd struck gold and her DP's income would be used to subsidise her part time salary, and she's sore that he wants to spend it on child instead!

What a shitty post @mrsm43s. You’ve completely neglected to mention his maintenance commitments. And £50k a year would hardly be ‘striking gold’. It’s a good salary, it’s not a huge salary.

middleager · 30/03/2023 09:22

' I could never afford to send my own nor would I want to'

The last part stands out for me. The huge costs aside, you have opposing views on private education and perhaps this is angering you just as much as the cost. If so, you need to respect his view.

PelvicFlora · 30/03/2023 09:21

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 07:27

It likely only makes a difference if he’s imagining that moving in with you will enable him to afford private school, his own living expenses and child maintenance. £50k doesn’t go that far if you’re paying private school fees, so I’d be worried that he is look for you to subsidise his choices.

If he’d be paying his fair share then it probably doesn’t make any difference. He can dorms his money as he sees fit.

The other red flag is the Disney dad behaviour and the focus around buying stuff. If that’s how he is raising his son (and he’s just as culpable as the child’s mother - possibly more so, as the dad’s house of plenty thing may be all him), that’s going to be almost impossible to live with. Especially when you have your own children.

I thought exactly the same. I imagine he thinks he'll be able to afford private school because you'll be subsidising him when you live together. Seeing this inequality play out in front of your own children, while you pick up half the tab is going to cause massive massive resentment.

You're right to pause and think hard about what this means for your future as a couple. If I were you, I'm afraid I'd cut my losses. It would be slightly different if he were a high earner and money was no object. But this will impact you and your children and I don't think you'll be able to get past that.

Bananalanacake · 30/03/2023 09:20

Just enjoy a relationship without living together

HereTodayHereTomorrow · 30/03/2023 09:20

My local private school is in the £40k-£50k bracket for fees, I am dying to know which schools he can afford on that salary!

Firsttimemum2023 · 30/03/2023 09:19

I’m a financial adviser and this is what I’d tell a client to do.

Make an excel spreadsheet with ALL your outgoings for both of you. Monthly direct debits, annual costs (car service/home insurance etc ) and less frequent items - if you spend 10k on replacing a car every 5 years, put down £167 a month towards car replacements.

Include food shop, what you spend on Christmas and Birthdays etc. include any savings you make each month.

However much these come to compared to your net incomes - put the surplus (hopefully there is one) in as your “lifestyle” costs. Realistically, if you’ve been accurate elsewhere and included savings if you make any, you’re currently spending this much on lifestyle stuff.

Now redo the spreadsheet including the cost of private school spread over the year. Account for other changes, are you moving together? Uniforms, school trips, travel etc.

consider if it’s acceptable that moving in together makes private school feasible (if it does) for his kid, but does it have any comparable benefit for yours?

If you end up having to reduce lifestyle costs can you actually do this? Do you want to?

maranella · 30/03/2023 09:18

swayingpalmtree · 30/03/2023 09:12

They really aren't. My DS is a day pupil at a top secondary school and his fees are £21k a year (without any extras). If you're talking Eton, Harrow, etc, then yes those schools are considerably more

21k a year on a 50k salary is not doable though is it? that leaves you with 17000 a year!!

No, absolutely not, which is why in my previous post I said there is no way he can afford to send his DC to private school on a salary of £50k. Obviously, that salary will go more or less far in different parts of the country, but as this guy is funding his own home and presumably at least part of his ex's home, plus 'buying stuff' for his child that sees him as 'the bank of dad', I'd say he's already spent that £50k salary without adding in any more expenses. As a PP said, if he's willing to go along with his ex's greedy plan then I'd worry that he can't do maths. He simply cannot afford to spend anything from £12-21k per year on school fees.

puretit · 30/03/2023 09:16

It's his child and it's his choice to send the child to private or not. However, it is your choice to stay in a relationship where a mans earnings is diminished by debt or private schools fees affecting you when he moves in.

FrostyFifi · 30/03/2023 09:15

He's obviously entitled to take on ridiculous, unsustainable costs associated with his child but you're equally entitled not to like the impact it will have on you in future as a combined household.
Unfortunately the only option that leaves you though is to walk away from the situation. The whole thing as you've described sounds like a nightmare waiting to happen, I don't see the blending of your two families having any chance of success.

Shelefttheweb · 30/03/2023 09:15

And then add in some extra on top of THAT for when private schools lose their charity status and have to start paying VAT, which they probably will when we get a Labour government.

Not just 20% extra VAT, they will also need to cover business rates. Though on the flip side they could stop offering bursaries and any community activities they do.

HappinesDependsOnYou · 30/03/2023 09:13

How much do you earn? You say you work part time but not what your income is. If he can pay private fees and match what you would be putting in then it's none of your business. If you will be expected to pay out more then him it is your business and you shouldn't move in with him

AbsoIutelyLovely · 30/03/2023 09:13

He can’t afford it. A terms fees, at best will wipe out a months salary. Every three months….

AlexaFeedMyKids · 30/03/2023 09:13

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 30/03/2023 08:33

Yes. That was my point. His situation is very different to OPs and so the attempts to compare the two financially are pointless.

So if OPs post said....

"Been with my bf for however long, just found out he's on £31k but I wanted to move in with him and share costs. I only work part time, but I would have hoped he was on more"

Would your reply still be the same?

RudsyFarmer · 30/03/2023 09:12

21k a year with potentially a 20% increase each year (as discussed on here last week). With extras on top such as uniform, clubs, trips. Private school is not affordable for most and certainly not on an average salary unless grandparents are helping out too.

mondaytosunday · 30/03/2023 09:12

So take away the school fees, how much do you all think you spend on your child a year? Food, clothing, birthdays, birthday parties, Christmas, trips etc? The Times puts this figure at around £11k/year. Some of this would be part of household expenses anyway, but school fees are not the only costs in raising children.
Fees are going up about 5% or more a year. And secondary is significantly more than primary. However I don't agree there's a huge surcharge on top - uniform can be expensive but after the initial cost not so much (you don't replace all of it every year and there's the second hand market) and most activities, other than residential trips, of which there aren't many (in fact my children only managed one which didn't cost much plus one ski trip in 12 years) are built in to the fees.
Anyone considering private education should plan out the full years, taking into account fee increases (as well as salary increases), other living expense increases and so on. Maybe he has savings or parents that will contribute.
Scholarships are usually only worth about 10%, and do come with strings. Bursaries would take in to account his, his ex, and your finances if he's living with you. And it's not just income, it's any holdings, and they look at it with forensic detail. Plus the child would have to be very clever to earn one. I know a few who got scholarships, I don't know any on a bursary.
His decision to consider a private education is between him and his ex, but as PP point out, if it affects how he can contribute to your living situation if you move in together, or if living together affects how much maintenance you get from your ex or the state, it warrants an open and honest discussion.
Too many people move in together without working out how the financial aspect will work, regardless of this particular issue of school fees.
You also refer to 'children' and 'they'. Does he have one child or more? As for him having a girlfriend yet still buy 'them' stuff, they should understand that private fees would impact on this far more than a girlfriend would!

ArcticSkewer · 30/03/2023 09:12

Do you both earn similar amounts? If so, maybe it is worth a chat at some point as things become more serious... it would impact how much he can bring to the household and mortgage loan for example.

If you earn less than him, then I'd expect he will have the same conversation with you at some point.

If you earn more - be careful - he may see you as the way he will maintain his lifestyle while he spends on his son!

swayingpalmtree · 30/03/2023 09:12

They really aren't. My DS is a day pupil at a top secondary school and his fees are £21k a year (without any extras). If you're talking Eton, Harrow, etc, then yes those schools are considerably more

21k a year on a 50k salary is not doable though is it? that leaves you with 17000 a year!!

Luckydip1 · 30/03/2023 09:11

He doesn't earn enough.

user1477391263 · 30/03/2023 09:11

He needs to look at the fees for ALL years, right up to 18 - not just the annual fees for the little kids. It rises as they get older.

And then add in extras. Yes, some are optional, but it's hard to say no sometimes.

And then allow for 5% increase each year as standard.

And then add on some extra for inflation, due to the times we live in.

And then add in some extra on top of THAT for when private schools lose their charity status and have to start paying VAT, which they probably will when we get a Labour government.

And then think about the stress of moving a child who is happy if you decide halfway through that this is too much.

And then choose!

maranella · 30/03/2023 09:09

Gensola · 30/03/2023 08:58

Private school fees are £40k a year for most decent secondary schools. He’s living in a dream land.

They really aren't. My DS is a day pupil at a top secondary school and his fees are £21k a year (without any extras). If you're talking Eton, Harrow, etc, then yes those schools are considerably more.

Thighlengthboots · 30/03/2023 09:08

But my point was she is not living with him, they are not charing finances, and they barely know each other after a year, so she doesn't get to dictate how he looks after his own child

Of course she has no right to tell him what to spend on his own child. BUT, if they are planning on moving in together and sharing finances which sounds like they are as they are talking about it, she does have a right to query the balance of contributions to ensure its fair. If he is so stretched financially from paying for private school which he absolutely WILL be on 50k, then that will affect what he can contribute towards their life together. If that means she will be contributing more than him and filling in the gaps that are caused by the cost of private school then thats absolutely pertinent to her and she has every right to discuss that with him. Its great that he wants the best for his child but if he hasnt properly worked out the budget which it sounds like he hasnt at all, as the sums simply dont work then thats concerning and he could end up in serious debt.

TeaForMeandThee · 30/03/2023 09:08

If he's funding this himself he can't afford it anyway so I don't think this issue will become a reality. This aside can you afford to pay half of all the bills if you only work pt or are you expecting him to subsidise you so you can carry on pt? When you have children from previous relationships the "one pot" approach doesn't work as you'll both have expenses relating to your children which the other person is not responsible for. I think you need to sit down together and work out the logistics of how your finances will work. Your post reads that you are thinking how him paying out for schooling is going to impact your lifestyle, he shouldn't be subsidising you and nor should you him. All this need to be worked out before you move in together.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 30/03/2023 09:08

He won't be able to afford it.

We earn 120k between us but private day school for our two remains completely beyond our means.

Justforlaffs · 30/03/2023 09:06

Gensola · 30/03/2023 08:58

Private school fees are £40k a year for most decent secondary schools. He’s living in a dream land.

Where are "most decent" schools £40k per year out of interest? Are we talking central London here?

Because my dc's go to one of the countries top schools in league tables and as voted by The Times year after year and it's £11,000 per year. I don't know any (bar boarding schools) that charge £40k per annum.