Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend’s kid wants to go to private school

307 replies

Limegreencurtains · 30/03/2023 07:20

I’ve been with my boyfriend for over a year and things are going well. We have been discussing the eventuality of us moving in together although neither of us are quite ready yet. I have young children from a previous relationship as does he. Yesterday, he told me that his child wants to go to private school and he will be funding it all. I am shocked at the cost and the fact his ex would expect him to cover all expenses. I can’t help but imagine that this is now going to affect our future. Do I have the right to bring this up or is it none of my business? I could never afford to send my own nor would I want to. Last year, just before I met his kid, he asked if they were ok with Dad having a girlfriend to which they replied, they thought it was fine as long as he didn’t stop buying them stuff. The kid and ex are high maintenance and I personally feel my boyfriend is seen as the bank of Dad. We both come from humble backgrounds. He earns £50000 a year and I work part time. Am I being unreasonable in wanting to ask where this leaves our future financially or is it none of my business how he spends his money?

OP posts:
Mummysalwaysright · 30/03/2023 10:56

How old is your partner's child? i.e. will this be for the next 14 years or, 7 or 5 etc.?

£50k a year salary doesn't buy much private schooling if you need to live off it as well! They are horribly expensive just for the fees, but there will be all sorts of add-on costs like uniform, school trips etc. which really mount up.

whumpthereitis · 30/03/2023 10:54

More doable if what he is left with is £50k after tax. OP didn’t specify. he could also arrange with his ex to pay the school fees in lieu of child support.

It’s also entirely possible that he earns more than he’s led OP to believe. It’s not exactly unheard of for people with higher than average salaries to hide that fact when it comes to dating.

Goldbar · 30/03/2023 10:53

VWHoliday · 30/03/2023 10:47

I suspect the big issue is actually that OP was hoping that she'd struck gold and her DP's income would be used to subsidise her part time salary, and she's sore that he wants to spend it on child instead!

Struck Gold?

It's a decent salary but it's not private school, high life kind of money.

Indeed. I don't know why some people are harping on about this guy being some sort of meal ticket. That's not a huge salary and living together might result in the OP losing all sorts of benefits/UC entitlements. So she might be much worse off - it's hard to know either way!

VWHoliday · 30/03/2023 10:47

I suspect the big issue is actually that OP was hoping that she'd struck gold and her DP's income would be used to subsidise her part time salary, and she's sore that he wants to spend it on child instead!

Struck Gold?

It's a decent salary but it's not private school, high life kind of money.

Gablonz · 30/03/2023 10:44

Am I being unreasonable in wanting to ask where this leaves our future financially or is it none of my business how he spends his money?

YANBU to ask the tough financial questions and you should. This sort of thing should be discussed anyway, whether or not a man is contributing to private school fees for his child or not. Too many people move in together without having proper financial discussions and it causes major problems later.
It isn't really your business what his maintenance payments are and whether he is paying for private school fees but it is your business as to whether he is financially stable and will contribute on an equal basis if you are living together.
It needs to be really clear before you even start living together who is contributing what and how all bills are to be divided and whether you are going to purchase a house or rent and how those costs will be split - and so on and so forth.
This is to ensure the financial stability of you and your own children. I don't agree with others who are making out you were eyeing up his 50K salary or that it shouldn't be a problem what he spends his money on as you should be financially independent, so the whole discussion is irrelevant. The point is, that you need to avoid a scenario where he moves in and you end up subsidizing his living costs, at the expense of your own children's needs, because his outgoings towards the private school fees mean that he ends up unable to contribute fairly to his new household.

You'd be better off continuing to live separately. Get yourself in a better financial position - ie. going full-time as soon as childcare and so on allows. See how he gets on living on his own and paying private school fees. If you still love each other and, after discussion, think the financial situation is appropriate, then you could consider moving in together. It's far too soon at the moment anyway.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 30/03/2023 10:41
  1. Private school fees are likely to go up by 20% in a couple of years' time.
  2. A child doesn't "choose" to go private; his parents do.
  3. If your kids are bright enough, even you could afford to send them there as most schools do 100% bursaries. But you don't want to, so I think you might be incompatible.
Mummyoflittledragon · 30/03/2023 10:40

My dd goes to private school. She chose her school and there were a couple a little cheaper, a couple a little more expensive. The fees 2 years ago were just over 13k. Next year they’re 15k. Plus the bus costs 3 times the cost of the bus to her former secondary. Then there’s uniform. Not too bad for a girl but still cost almost 1k. Dd will wear the same PE kit (all branded right down to football socks), 2 blazers and skirts for the 3 years of private school. Presuming she stays at 6th form, this will be her own clothes plus the PE kit. Boys grow exponentially and blazers are about £90 a pop.

This doesn’t even involve all the trips. His ds is going to want to go with his mates, isn’t he? There are some cheaper trips but a lot of more expensive ones. He is living in cloud cuckoo land if he thinks his salary is enough. However, you would be unreasonable to bring his finances up in relation to you. Better to discuss fees.

Viviennemary · 30/03/2023 10:36

He is just your boyfriend at the moment, But you are obviously seeing a future where he subsidises you financially. I don't think you can take that for granted.

Goldbar · 30/03/2023 10:35

You haven't been together very long and this is all getting quite complicated (demanding ex, private school fees etc.). I'd be very careful about making this relationship anything more than casual and I'd ditch it if it became heavy weather (e.g. because he's stressed about money/ wants to move in/ can't afford to do stuff).

At the moment, not your monkeys, not your circus. Do you really want to change this?

VWHoliday · 30/03/2023 10:34

TomeTome · 30/03/2023 09:05

He can’t afford private school, so I’d just be worried that he can’t add up or make financial plans.

I agree with this.

I wouldn't even think about setting up home with him.

backinthestoneage · 30/03/2023 10:33

Is his job secure? Could he get another one paying a similar amount easily? Does he have savings to fall back upon - just in case?

Houseyvibe · 30/03/2023 10:33

cyclamenqueen · 30/03/2023 09:26

That’s presumably for boarding . Most around here are around £15k to £17k . Further north you might find lower.

I wish! our day school fees are about £25k. None of them are less than about £21k for secondary

Ktime · 30/03/2023 10:30

As pp asked, how is going to afford private school on 50k pa?

Will you be giving up benefits when you move in together?

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 30/03/2023 10:28

BumpyaDaisyevna · 30/03/2023 09:08

He won't be able to afford it.

We earn 120k between us but private day school for our two remains completely beyond our means.

With ALL these calculations, surely it depends MASSIVELY on outgoings... I know people who fund private schools on relatively low(comparatively) incomes ... But their mortgages are minimal /paid off...

A family member earned close to 250k - ir used to irritate them that everyone assumed they would privately educate... They couldn't afford private ed for their kids as their mortgage was eye watering... (London Borough)

Christy135 · 30/03/2023 10:27

I dont think 50k is enough to fund a private school. I would definitely have a conversation about the costs if you were to live together.

AlexaFeedMyKids · 30/03/2023 10:25

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 10:09

Lots of people have said that the OP is just annoyed because she thought she’d bagged a £50k earner (the implication being that she’s looking for him to pay for her).

“Did his £50k appeal to you as a way of subsidising your own part time salary OP?”

“Is his £50k minus private school fees still more than your part time wage?”

“Seems he has a nice income to me for her considering she only works part time”

And so on.

Being concerned that a man you might live with is making financial decisions beyond his means does not mean that you are upset he won’t be able to pay for your life. It’s totally reasonable to consider whether his choices will curtail your current lifestyle (which you pay for!)

Ok, that's 3 people and none of them were me so irrelevant to our debate.

I didnt say she wanted her life paying for, I said if he was on £31k and OP came on saying she wished he was on more what would people say.

I'm over it now anyway, considering OP hasn't been back at all to clarify anything people are just pissing in the wind with assumptions and going round in circles with debates.

HappyAsASandboy · 30/03/2023 10:22

Surely the only thing to do is sit together and work out how finances will be if you live together? Number on paper or in a spreadsheet should show up the assumptions that you're both making at the moment, and then you can discuss those assumptions.

From a neutral position, assuming your children are school age and not pre-school, you're both making big financial decisions by presuming part time working and by presuming private school. Writing down your joint costs and joint incomes will show whether those assumptions are both possible and then you can talk about what could change to make the sums add up.

Martin Lewis has has a good budget spreadsheet to get started with. It lists the most common income and expenditure types and you can add your own. Go through bank statements to make sure you catch every little thing, and be honest about how much you spend on annual things like Christmas and birthday presents. On £50k plus a part time wage, I'd be very surprised if the two of you can afford a house for a family of 4/5 and child maintenance and part time working and private school fees for one or more children.

I say all that as a parent with children in the state and private school systems. I have no problem at all, in theory, with one child going to private and one to state, but the private school fees absolutely can't be allowed to impact the standard of living and out-of-school opportunities that the state school children get.

SamPoodle123 · 30/03/2023 10:18

Umm, how the heck would he be able to afford private on that salary?! I am sorry, but he would not be able to afford private on that salary.....after tax, most of his salary would be covering the cost of private school. How would he pay rent and bills? No way.

horizonsblue · 30/03/2023 10:14

It doesn't matter how much he is earning or not earning. He could get a second job if he wanted to.

From the ex's perpective: she wants to give her child the best, and if that is private schooling then it's private schooling. IF your partner wants to fund it, then he can fund it. It has absolutely nothing to do with you. Whether they are "high maintenance " or not, has nothing to do with you, and you are not in a position of strength to comment. The ex wants the best education for her child which costs money. That it may affect your future plans with your partner is irrelevant to her because you are not her priority. You are not in the picture.

You claim that they see your partnerhas bank of Dad...well he is. He has to provide for his child. But your own chlldren also have their own bank of Dad.

If the parents want to send the child to private school, it is for them to figure out how to do it. May be mother has come into some inheritance, you never know. Your argument is that there is not enough money for private school, but that would leave more money for you and him. You have no right or position to have input in the child's future education.

From your perspective: You see all this money go down the drain for private education, money that can help you build a more comfortable life with your partner

. But it's NOT your money. It is his money.
You will always come second.

NoTouch · 30/03/2023 10:14

You need to have a sit down and work out how it would all look/work and how you see your futures and if you are on the same pages. His priority will be, and should be, his kid and your priority will be yours. You obviously have a lot of life experience and should be able to sit down and have open and frank conversations, these are important things to get out in the open.

If it is important to him to send his dc to private school the consequences of that are his choice, but it probably makes you financially incompatible for living together for the next 12+ years.

Also think about things such as child benefit or any other benefit. With a £50k salary if he moves in you might lose this soon.

Do you want kids with your next partner? (sound like you have enough between you already so make sure contraception is rock solid) If you do you are not compatible.

Doesn't mean you can't continue the relationship if you are happy living separately long term.

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 10:09

AlexaFeedMyKids · 30/03/2023 09:48

And at what point has anyone on this thread said that? You've just made that up yourself.

My scenario was if this man was on £31k and OP said she wasn't happy with his salary, what would the responses be. Because that's basically what's being said here.

Lots of people have said that the OP is just annoyed because she thought she’d bagged a £50k earner (the implication being that she’s looking for him to pay for her).

“Did his £50k appeal to you as a way of subsidising your own part time salary OP?”

“Is his £50k minus private school fees still more than your part time wage?”

“Seems he has a nice income to me for her considering she only works part time”

And so on.

Being concerned that a man you might live with is making financial decisions beyond his means does not mean that you are upset he won’t be able to pay for your life. It’s totally reasonable to consider whether his choices will curtail your current lifestyle (which you pay for!)

RosaBonheur · 30/03/2023 10:05

Changechangechanging · 30/03/2023 10:00

If it means that he's spending over half his income on school fees, you'll have to decide whether you want to have a long term relationship with someone who can't afford to do nice things unless you pay for them

OP works part time with a couple of children to bring up. How is she going to afford to do nice things unless he pays for them?

Obviously, we don't know the full story here - OP may be a higher earner, even on part time wages. She may own outright or have a tiny mortgage. Even a lottery win or inheritance.

The devil is in the detail with this one, I think.

They don't live together so I assume he is not currently funding the OP's lifestyle.

Changechangechanging · 30/03/2023 10:00

If it means that he's spending over half his income on school fees, you'll have to decide whether you want to have a long term relationship with someone who can't afford to do nice things unless you pay for them

OP works part time with a couple of children to bring up. How is she going to afford to do nice things unless he pays for them?

Obviously, we don't know the full story here - OP may be a higher earner, even on part time wages. She may own outright or have a tiny mortgage. Even a lottery win or inheritance.

The devil is in the detail with this one, I think.

RosaBonheur · 30/03/2023 09:57

It's a tricky one, OP.

If he is willing to pay to send his kid to private school then that's his decision and not technically anything to do with you. In reality, if he would be stretching himself financially by doing it, that does have an impact on the standard of living you would enjoy together.

I don't think there's anything wrong with asking him how much private school will cost and how he's planning to pay for it. If it means that he's spending over half his income on school fees, you'll have to decide whether you want to have a long term relationship with someone who can't afford to do nice things unless you pay for them.

happysingleversary · 30/03/2023 09:57

So you both have children from previous and don't want any together?

So you're not setting up a family home and your finances can just be separate?

that's not the same as a relationship where you're starting out and starting a family. That would be difficult and you probably wouldn't want to do it with someone who was already committed to their own family, which he is even though he's not romantically involved with the mother - neither are many husbands.

He already has a family.

If he's just your boyfriend then cool. I can't imagine sharing my finances with someone, it's too tricky and you'd have to be on exactly the same page and without a family already for that work. Otherwise it would just be a whole hassle you could do without.