Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend’s kid wants to go to private school

307 replies

Limegreencurtains · 30/03/2023 07:20

I’ve been with my boyfriend for over a year and things are going well. We have been discussing the eventuality of us moving in together although neither of us are quite ready yet. I have young children from a previous relationship as does he. Yesterday, he told me that his child wants to go to private school and he will be funding it all. I am shocked at the cost and the fact his ex would expect him to cover all expenses. I can’t help but imagine that this is now going to affect our future. Do I have the right to bring this up or is it none of my business? I could never afford to send my own nor would I want to. Last year, just before I met his kid, he asked if they were ok with Dad having a girlfriend to which they replied, they thought it was fine as long as he didn’t stop buying them stuff. The kid and ex are high maintenance and I personally feel my boyfriend is seen as the bank of Dad. We both come from humble backgrounds. He earns £50000 a year and I work part time. Am I being unreasonable in wanting to ask where this leaves our future financially or is it none of my business how he spends his money?

OP posts:
CheersForThatEh · 30/03/2023 13:16

What is your actual issue?

He cant afford it?
It might affect how you split the bills?
His child and your child will be treated differently?
That he doesnt see your child as his own?

BrieAndChilli · 30/03/2023 13:12

There are lots of things you need to consider:

if you move in together then (and I am assuming as you say you work part time) then your benefits will most likely stop as his income will be taken into account. This will mean that your 'income' will drop. Will you still be able to affords your half of the bills and standard of living?

Will you be pooling all of your income and splitting everything equally? or will you both keep your income and then split the bills 50/50? if so be mindful of the above point regarding your benefits.

Where will you live? do either/both of you own your house? if so will you be selling and buying jointly? if moving into 1 then will you be contirbuting towards the mortgage or have a stake in the house? will either of you be giving up a secure council tenancy? if you split then it is unlikely you will get another one.

Will there be enough bedrooms for all the kids?

What is the price of private school? you are looking at 15k plus all the extras - trips, meals, uniform etc, none of which come cheap!!

How about other inqualities between his and your kids - will he be spending thousands at xmas and birthday compared to you spending £100s?

Do either of you have debt?

a year when you both have kids is not a long time, i would adivse caution and leave it a few more years before moving intogether. if the worst happens and you split you may ahdv put yourself and your children into a vunerable position.

Itsbytheby · 30/03/2023 13:12

how much do you earn? It's a bit rich to question how he is going to contribute to your financial future if you don't plan to do the same.

That said, if you are planning a future with him this is obviously a long term and significant financial commitment. So I can see why it would worry you.

rogueone · 30/03/2023 13:11

School fees are expensive. I would be careful moving in together as he may be looking to contribute less in your shared home so he can fund his childs education. By moving in he will pay less rent etc.

I have two kids in private and the only ones he would get money if are the ones who have received a scholarship or a bursary. Bursary is for low earners and 50K is not

Chickpea17 · 30/03/2023 13:10

He can't afford it on £50k

MaybeSmaller · 30/03/2023 13:08

Do people not realise that people's financial situations - income, outgoings and savings - might be significantly different from their own?

Judging by this thread, a lot of people seem to have very, very fixed ideas about the salary you require to be able to send a child to private school, to the extent that anyone earning below that level (regardless of their overall financial situation or the cost of the school fees, which vary massively) must be taking the piss or be completely deluded to think they can have a child educated privately.

Far too many people are focused on this specific thing, when the real problem is the intention to blend families with wildly different expectations about money. At least two PPs have shown that yes, you can send a child to private school on £50K provided that everything else is in good order.

UndercoverCop · 30/03/2023 13:06

@Antiquiteas
https://www.brentwoodschool.co.uk/admissions/fees
Definitely not Eton, not even particularly prestigious

StackPath

https://www.brentwoodschool.co.uk/admissions/fees

Notegoat · 30/03/2023 13:03

Poor troll. They didn’t check their figures before they started the thread.

MaybeSmaller · 30/03/2023 13:02

whumpthereitis · 30/03/2023 10:54

More doable if what he is left with is £50k after tax. OP didn’t specify. he could also arrange with his ex to pay the school fees in lieu of child support.

It’s also entirely possible that he earns more than he’s led OP to believe. It’s not exactly unheard of for people with higher than average salaries to hide that fact when it comes to dating.

£50K IS a higher than average salary, though. The average (median) is £33K.

It's usual to specify the figure before tax when comparing salaries.

Scotty12 · 30/03/2023 12:58

Unless he is expecting you to pay for all living costs over and above school fees, he cannot afford it on his salary.

JudgeJ · 30/03/2023 12:55

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 30/03/2023 07:54

He will be funding it because you and your kids will be supporting him to do so. It’s a no from me 🚩

Interesting and typical of MN that hos ex's role in supporting their child is being ignored, she should be contributing to their education or would she be happy to forgo support payment to allow him to fund theur fantasy of a private education on a relatively modest income. She, the ex, seems to be expecting his new partner to fund her lifestyle.

quokka5 · 30/03/2023 12:54

Raising the issue will make you seem like you are only interested in his money. I expect the private school idea will collapse when he actually prices things up.

JudgeJ · 30/03/2023 12:49

user56912 · 30/03/2023 07:25

If he’s funding it alone he can’t afford it. Simple as that. Fees will be at last £15k out of taxed income. He would have very little left to live on

Surely if their parents want these children to go to private school then their mother, his ex, should contribute 50% instead of expecting her ex to fund it 100%.

Lavenderflower · 30/03/2023 12:35

I think realistically he is unlikely to be able to afford. I think his first priority is to his. I think that for him and the child's mother to decide. However, I think you need to consider realistic whether this relationship has any long term prospect. If I was in your position, I wouldn't move in.

Deedee87 · 30/03/2023 12:34

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:31

Exactly my thought - but then they could look at local clubs etc outside of school?
My school focussed on hockey for both girls and boys, so my cousin (who went after me) had to do rugby in his own time…

Maybe he was looking at what he felt the best teams were?

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:33

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:23

I went to private school (not TOO long ago) The fees are ridiculous, as are the extras - paying for trips, uniform etc. I had a scholarship and a bursary (fee reduction for low income) and even as a day pupil it was a huge expense.

There’s also the added element of keeping up with the other kids - they notice if you’re not wearing designer gear/second hand uniform and it’s not very pleasant to be the odd one out.

I don’t understand the idea of a child asking for private education - is there something in particular the child is desperate to do e.g. be a footballer? Maybe he thinks going to a school with extra support for those with sporting aspirations would help? That might be doable in a different way… If they’re high achieving then there may be other schools/activities they could look at, too. Plenty of my peers at school came out with v average grades and don’t have a special, shiny job because they went to insert private school name here.

I’d be shocked if this hadn’t come from ex partner - no way I was asking for private school, it wasn’t on my radar until I landed there aged 12.

The other thing I just remembered is the HOURS at some of these schools.
I was a day pupil, yet I was expected to be there 8:30-21:00 4 days a week, 8:30-18:00 1 day a week AND we had Saturday school 08:30-14:00…
Not much of a work/life balance for kids, not to mention the poor parent picking up at 21:00 🫠

LakieLady · 30/03/2023 12:32

Alarae · 30/03/2023 07:36

Assuming he is not contributing to a pension and has no student loan/taxable benefits, the most his net salary would be on 50k would be £3,168. That is just above 38k a year.

Unless you have very cheap private schools and housing where you are, I have no idea how he is going to afford that on his salary without things being very tight.

SIL had her two youngest in a school that was £8k a term - each! I thought she meant £8k for the pair of them when she first told me the amount. It's not one of the old, posh independents, either.

And the uniform and all the other kit they had to have cost well into 4 figures, as well.

That wouldn't be doable on salary of £50k.

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:31

Exactly my thought - but then they could look at local clubs etc outside of school?
My school focussed on hockey for both girls and boys, so my cousin (who went after me) had to do rugby in his own time…

Deedee87 · 30/03/2023 12:29

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:23

I went to private school (not TOO long ago) The fees are ridiculous, as are the extras - paying for trips, uniform etc. I had a scholarship and a bursary (fee reduction for low income) and even as a day pupil it was a huge expense.

There’s also the added element of keeping up with the other kids - they notice if you’re not wearing designer gear/second hand uniform and it’s not very pleasant to be the odd one out.

I don’t understand the idea of a child asking for private education - is there something in particular the child is desperate to do e.g. be a footballer? Maybe he thinks going to a school with extra support for those with sporting aspirations would help? That might be doable in a different way… If they’re high achieving then there may be other schools/activities they could look at, too. Plenty of my peers at school came out with v average grades and don’t have a special, shiny job because they went to insert private school name here.

I’d be shocked if this hadn’t come from ex partner - no way I was asking for private school, it wasn’t on my radar until I landed there aged 12.

i once babysat a kids who was turning 12 and his parents left it to him to choose school.

he was stuck because he was very talented at both football and rugby. The free schools had football teams whereas the private school focused on rugby…

Mari9999 · 30/03/2023 12:27

OP, you have a right to ask if he can meet his half of the expenses at the point and time that you are planning to move in together. He too should ask the same of you at that time.

Until such time that a move is imminent, it really isn't your business to inquire about his expenses particularly as relates to his child. He too might have reservations as to your having children but only working part time.

Deedee87 · 30/03/2023 12:26

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/03/2023 11:43

@Mummyoflittledragon

why on earth do kids need branded sports socks??!

surely all that is setting kids expectations very high? Unless they themselves get really really good jobs they are not going to be able to maintain that level of expense on themselves are they

I looked after kids who went to private school and they were only allowed to buy socks from the school shop. Also hair accessories and winter jackets etc. P.E. Kits all had logos too, also book bags etc.

everything had to be specific length so often had to be tailored a couple times a year as they grew. . Unless you’re good at sewing yourself etc

KnackeredAF · 30/03/2023 12:23

I went to private school (not TOO long ago) The fees are ridiculous, as are the extras - paying for trips, uniform etc. I had a scholarship and a bursary (fee reduction for low income) and even as a day pupil it was a huge expense.

There’s also the added element of keeping up with the other kids - they notice if you’re not wearing designer gear/second hand uniform and it’s not very pleasant to be the odd one out.

I don’t understand the idea of a child asking for private education - is there something in particular the child is desperate to do e.g. be a footballer? Maybe he thinks going to a school with extra support for those with sporting aspirations would help? That might be doable in a different way… If they’re high achieving then there may be other schools/activities they could look at, too. Plenty of my peers at school came out with v average grades and don’t have a special, shiny job because they went to insert private school name here.

I’d be shocked if this hadn’t come from ex partner - no way I was asking for private school, it wasn’t on my radar until I landed there aged 12.

PhillySub · 30/03/2023 12:21

He can send his child to a private school if he wants. You become involved in knowing what will be left as shared income and how it affects the lifestyle of all of you. You don't want to end up supporting him.

WombatChocolate · 30/03/2023 12:18

Firstly, it’s never going to happen because he can’t afford school fees.People need considerably higher salaries to pay school fees.

Perhaps he doesn’t have a good grasp of finances and what his income can and can’t provide. If he provides lots of stuff to ex wife and kids, has he run up debt?

I would say that before you consider moving in with him, an honest discussion about finances is needed. You can both keep your finances separate if you want and probably should, but knowing each other’s situation is vital information. Knowing if someone can manage money or has run up big debts is really important, and for many would be a deal breaker.

SquidwardBound · 30/03/2023 12:13

Shelefttheweb · 30/03/2023 11:27

That is why I said “imagine if the OP had said…”. My point is even IF her motivation had been gold digging then it STILL would not be unreasonable to discuss this.

Ah right. Yes. I agree.

It’s totally reasonable that, if you’re considering moving in with someone at some point in the next few years, everyone considers whether that would be in their financial interests.

A man choosing to spend a very significant proportion of his income on school fees is going to affect lifestyle choices for a partner.

Indeed, even for a girlfriend it’s something to consider. It may well mean that he can no longer afford to go for the odd weekend away or that he’ll be cutting back on meals out or something. It’s not unreasonable for her to think through how his decisions will
affect her life and whether that’s something she’s fine with.

It’s not even like it’s unforeseen circumstances that he’s having to adapt to. It’s an active choice. It’s totally fine for someone to think ‘nope. Actually I don’t fancy aligning my lifestyle with his choice to spend his money differently’.

as you say, that’s true whether the issue is him no longer being able to contribute equally to costs or whether she’s expecting him to pay for her.

Even if she’s a ‘gold digger’, this choice would definitely be an indication that she’s digging in the wrong place. 🤣