Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have your elderly mother live with you

34 replies

Valerie65 · 30/03/2023 01:24

My mum has become increasingly mentally dependant on my sister & I since our df died. She is still fairly fit physically, but has increasing depression, anxiety, bad nerves, loneliness etc. She can't stand being in the marital home any longer. There doesn't seem to be much around She could move into & doesn't want to go I'm a care home yet. She's going to see a Councillor in a couple of weeks & has started on antidepressants. In the meantime she only seems to be able to cope if she's at either of our houses. If we allowed it she would definately move in, although she doesn't want to be a burden & knows its not fair on our marriages. My dh gets on fine with her bit is becoming very frustrated with not feeling like his home is our sanctuary anymore. He couldn't have her living here full time. I have offered to stay at hers for a full week every other week, but he thinks that put a strain on our marriage. I just don't know what to do for the best. I'm torn between the two & we could have years of this

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChickenDhansak82 · 30/03/2023 12:19

As a teenager I remember my gran moving in with us for similar reasons and OMG I remember the tension it put my parents under! It was really stressful.

So on that basis, I would say YABU and it can absolutely break a marriage doing something like that!!

My parents survived but only because they managed to find somewhere very close for my gran to live (5 minute walk away).

Perhaps look at retirement villages rather than a nursing home. It means she can have independence living on her own with support if needed and lots of social stuff going on.

My gran moved into something similar eventually, first living on her own in a bungalow that had emergency pull cords if help was needed, then when she became more frail she moved into the residential bit. They had social stuff going on every day, so she always had something to look forward to!

KarmaStar · 30/03/2023 12:08

Assisted living where she's in her own bungalow in a small community of similar minded people?
An annex on one of your houses with strict adherence to privacy?
She's young yet,perhaps encouraging her to join clubs ,do volunteer work or redecorate her home might give her a focus to build on.
To answer your question,yes I would but my mum was very independent and was always out and about.

AlltheFs · 30/03/2023 11:50

We don’t have the room so there’s no option here, and it’s a very old thatched cottage with difficult stairs and uneven floors in a rural area so not elderly friendly. Nothing you can walk to etc.

My mum lives quite far away now and isn’t elderly yet but I think she might end up moving nearer to us (to a town) into a warden assisted flat when the time comes. Her own mother is still alive though in her very late 90’s and lives several hours away and my mum only sees her fairly infrequently so there’s no expectation IYSWIM that we will take care of her, as my mum doesn’t care for hers.

I hate having overnight guests so I can’t imagine anything worse than family moving in if I’m honest. Same for DH but we are both very introverted.

Number24Bus · 30/03/2023 11:44

I agree with the posters suggesting a retirement living flat. My PILs moved into one last year and one of the great things is that there is a ready made social life whenever you want it, by going downstairs to the communal areas. I think it would be a godsend for your mum.

gamerchick · 30/03/2023 11:40

My ex mil was very like this. Totally resisted going into a retirement place. Once she was in she loved it. Had her own self contained space and a communal space where she made friends and did activities.

What you're doing is not sustainable and it will put a strain on your marriage.

KnittedCardi · 30/03/2023 11:33

No. I would have ended up in prison for murder. My brothers (4 of us) all felt the same. She was a difficult lady. We eventually found her live in carers. Cost a fortune, and they didn't stay long, because she was so mean. She was on a range of drugs for anxiety, depression, sleep etc etc. She was still mean 😂

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 30/03/2023 10:13

No. My mum rents a flat in an independent (sheltered) housing complex. The proceeds from selling her house plus pension comfortably pay the rent. As she did not move until she was 80 I didn't think it made sense to buy one.
She is happier there than she has been for years, has friends her own age and they muddle along together.
We agreed years ago that as I was the only one out of 3 that did anything practical, all of her money would be put aside to pay for the best care possible, even if it means it all gets spent. I am not sacrificing my one and only life to make sure my siblings get an inheritance!

CC4712 · 30/03/2023 10:05

Sorry for the loss of your dad. How old is your mum? Does she drive/get around independently?

I'd say absolutely NO to her living with you, and certainly not staying with her for weeks at a time. A night here and there at most- and then cut back to a meal/shopping etc once her MH improves. Did the Dr say when things should start to improve?

Surely she could downsize and find something nearby? Does she have any hobbies or friends? Once her mental health improves, would she volunteer somewhere, join rotary, WI etc?

You said she isn't having counselling for a few weeks! Could she afford to pay privately for a few sessions? What about acupuncture or an alternative therapy to help relax her?

Are you on nextdoor.com? Find out what is available in your area for older people. My MIL volunteers at a luncheon club. People get a 2 course meal for £5 , sometimes there is entertainment and most people make new friends there. My own mother is a widow. She joined a group that do outings in a mini bus. It might be to a seaside town then lunch, a museum, famous place etc. Give your mum a list of local things that are on. Age UK or mental health charities might have ideas on your area too.

It sounds like your mum has some glimmer of awareness by not wanting to burden you and your sister, so its time to start easing back the dependance- not enforcing it even more. Best of luck op.

Freddiefan · 30/03/2023 10:05

We moved so that we were close to my mother but she developed dementia. One day I was on my third visit of the day to her and her neighbour, who was gardening and had seen me, said 'your mother has been out looking for you because she hasn't seen you for ages'!
One evening, when I was sitting next to my husband with tears dropping off my chin, he said 'it's me or your mother'. That forced me into looking at care homes. One of mum's neighbours had previously told me to speak to her if my mother had to go into a home so I went to see her. It turned out she is a hairdresser in care homes and she told me the best one.

finalwhistle · 30/03/2023 10:04

It would be a firm no from me.

My DF is similar (not as bad as your dm) but has mental health issues along with some physical ones and there's no way I could have him living here, it would ruin my own mental health completely.

Finesterre · 30/03/2023 10:02

A month is not really long enough for anti-depressants to start working properly - give it it another few weeks and see how she is.

2022again · 30/03/2023 10:01

depending on how old she is this could be your future for the next 30 years! this only works if you have a spouse and children that are fully in agreement. Bereavement is a terrible place to be in and at 2 years she may only be just beginning to work through her grief, so look at whatever support she needs to come to terms with the loss of her life partner, its not a quick fix ( so your idea of sometimes staying at hers may well help)but people can start to live a more fulfilled life.....often there are groups locally, does she have any particular interests?...but long term she may prefer to be in a retirement complex.

Theelephantinthecastle · 30/03/2023 09:57

How old is she?

What happens if you're unavailable? E.g. if you said you were away over Easter?

I think in consultation with your sister you should gradually be less available. Move to she is on her own 3-4 nights from 2-3 and then gradually keep upping it from there. She isn't going to make any changes while you make it so easy for her.

Sorryyoufeelthatway · 30/03/2023 09:56

A move to sheltered accommodation with activities and a warden would be good. Do not underestimate the stress on your health and marriage. Good luck!

funnelfan · 30/03/2023 09:54

You don’t say how old she is, but if she moves in with you then you’re signing up for the rest of her life. Realistically, she won’t always be fit and independent, how will you manage when she starts to get frail? Will you become her carer? It’s a massive ask, it’s not just like having a lodger.

She needs help to regain confidence in a degree of independent living, as PP have said

JussathoB · 30/03/2023 09:46

Hi OP, it’s clear you and your sister are doing a lot to support your mum. However I would absolutely not have your DM move in with either of you. I think it’s a mistake for her to become so dependent on you. Everyone needs their own space and their own life.
Continue trying to support but I don’t think having to stay over at hers for a full week every other week would be reasonable at all.
Investigate other accommodation for her- possibly she could move to a flat or small house nearer to you or your sister? Would she feel safer and less lonely in an independent living place? Try to get her involved in some sort of activity or hobby which might provide company even if it’s just one morning a week. Use technology eg face time to reduce the need to stay over with her. Help her find ways to soothe herself- music, lighting at home.
Good luck. I think the real issue is sorting out some new accommodation for her, but not in your house!!

Chickenly · 30/03/2023 09:42

Yes I would, for two reasons:

  1. My siblings live abroad, I’m the only child who can shoulder any caring burden.
  2. I have a separate area of my home with its own living space/bedroom/kitchen etc. I wouldn’t do it if it meant I was losing my “sanctuary” or causing DH to lose his.

I would do it because I’m in the lucky position to do so without sacrificing as much as others would and because I’m unfortunate enough to be the only person who can.

toomuchlaundry · 30/03/2023 09:42

Much as I love my mum and much as my DH loves her, it would a no. After DF died she moved into a retirement flat near us and is still pretty independent as reaches her 90s.

I always wonder what happens in families that move in one parent, what happens if there is another parent who might need help a few years later? MIL and FIL are divorced and okay to live independently at the moment but both are beginning to suffer ill health (slightly younger than my DM). If we had moved DM in after DF died, what happens to MIL and FIL when they need more care?

Coastalvenues · 30/03/2023 09:34

No I wouldn't have an elderly parent live with me in a million years I'm afraid

L1ttledrummergirl · 30/03/2023 09:29

Mil moved into an over 60s complex when fil died. The community there supported each other and she became much less dependent on her dc.

It was also good because when she had a fall, she had a link to call or help, she had aids to support her and a network of people who worked within the community.
An amazing lady started as her cleaner but did courses in massage to further her skills, mil loved these. When mil needed end of life care, the network was in place to help us to support her.

It was the best thing she could have done.

Hbh17 · 30/03/2023 09:18

No. Never. No Way.
You are not responsible for your mother, so she has to work this out for herself and not depend on you and your sister.
Your husband has to be the priority here.

Creditonian · 30/03/2023 09:15

Valerie65 · 30/03/2023 01:24

My mum has become increasingly mentally dependant on my sister & I since our df died. She is still fairly fit physically, but has increasing depression, anxiety, bad nerves, loneliness etc. She can't stand being in the marital home any longer. There doesn't seem to be much around She could move into & doesn't want to go I'm a care home yet. She's going to see a Councillor in a couple of weeks & has started on antidepressants. In the meantime she only seems to be able to cope if she's at either of our houses. If we allowed it she would definately move in, although she doesn't want to be a burden & knows its not fair on our marriages. My dh gets on fine with her bit is becoming very frustrated with not feeling like his home is our sanctuary anymore. He couldn't have her living here full time. I have offered to stay at hers for a full week every other week, but he thinks that put a strain on our marriage. I just don't know what to do for the best. I'm torn between the two & we could have years of this

Jeez - offering to stay at her house is generous in the extreme - for a week!! I definitely sympathise btw

thegreenlight · 30/03/2023 08:29

We are building a bungalow at the bottom of the garden for my mum. She’s getting to choose everything and it’s giving her a fresh start. We had an architect design it while my dad was still alive just in case and sadly it proved to be a timely decision (she was not involved in the building plan as that was dictated by our odd shaped garden and the likelihood of achieving planning. She absolutely wouldn’t move in with us but this is a happy medium. She has her own space but is as close as if she lived across the road!

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 30/03/2023 07:57

If I had moved my mother in, it would have ended my marriage. I also doubt very much that I would still be alive. Read into that what you will.

MissSueFlay · 30/03/2023 07:54

My DM has bought a flat which is a half-way house between living on her own and going into a care home. It's one of these 'active retirement communities' - look up Churchill's or McCarthy Stone. It's a block of flats but there's a restaurant, communal lounge, activities, large maintained garden, cleaner, etc. Now she has company she's less dependent on my sister and I. We did consider pooling resources and buying a bigger house together, but it would have changed our lives too much, mostly because of the kind of person she is. You might not have that aspect to consider.

Swipe left for the next trending thread