Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just checking if iabu before I kick off...

435 replies

TheSnootiestFox · 29/03/2023 22:59

Is 4 and a half hours in an urgent treatment centre without being seen even for triage unreasonable for a 12 year old with a suspected broken foot? No pain relief, nothing and he's been crying and begging me for help for hours.....my blood is boiling but I just need a reality check before I decide whether to say something or not. Opinions please!

OP posts:
mcmooberry · 31/03/2023 18:31

I know it's all resolved now but I would have (internally) blown a gasket at that utter lack of compassion for my son and spent the time composing my letter of complaint (and I have a VERY high bar before I will complain as I know the negative effects of an unfounded complaint). They must have compassion fatigue or some such thing. The phrase "if you're that bothered" about getting him some paracetamol just sums it up. Even if they had apologised profusely about not having any and reassured you that you wouldn't lose your place in the queue if you nipped out to get some, that would have been easier to swallow. My husband one waited in hours at A&E with a broken arm, we didn't actually think to take paracetamol before heading off, I assumed he'd have a slug of morphine on arrival! (it was a few years ago)

Belleoverandover · 31/03/2023 18:28

I know no consolation but with a suspected heart attack (after being advised by NHS24) I was left for 8 hours before being triaged.
I hope it's all resolved now for the sake of your child. Not nice for a child experiencing pain like that.

T1Dmama · 31/03/2023 18:18

As awful as it is, a broken foot isn’t life threatening. It’s frustrating but more urgent cases will jump the queue in front of you.

ancientgran · 31/03/2023 13:59

ArcticSkewer · 31/03/2023 12:00

I was interested so googled it. Wow! Their webpage is amazing!
https://www.cornwallft.nhs.uk/miu-waiting-times/

Short answer is dial 111.

Most of the services are then appointment based.
You can see the number of people waiting (and the open and closed times!) as 'live' information.

It's a+e if life or limb threatening.

You have really good services there. We don't have any of that, not even a miu within 20 minute drive any more.

I don't live in Cornwall, it was reported on the news for the south west so we heard it in Devon as well. Where I am you can't book appointments for A&E or MIU by phoning 111 although one small hospital that isn't too far away has out of hours doctors based there and you can get an appointment to see them, well you could the last time I used the service which was pre pandemic.

We can also look at waiting times and people waiting for our local A&E and MIU but we can't make appointments, you turn up, get triaged and wait. It can be misleding, at the moment it says 64 in A&E but only 9 waiting to be seen which means 55 have been triaged not that they are all getting , treatment, waiting time of 1hr 17 mins is to be seen by a nurse or doctor which can be triage.

I had a similar situation with our A&E a few weeks ago, I looked at our local Devon page, MIU close to closing time and 5 people waiting to be seen at A&E, so got there and A&E for walk ins was being run by one nurse practitioner and the waiting room was full. HCA was trying to do crowd control with the drunks and she was pretty amazing with the patience of a saint. We waited about 5 hrs which isn't that bad by current standards but it could be a shock to someone going to A&E thinking there is a queue of 5 and they could be seen very quickly.

The fact remains that the health authority are saying they are expecting a very difficult Easter and appealing for people to seek help elsewhere whenever possible. The population will swell tonight and tomorrow as holidaymakers arrive.

Of course plenty of people in Cornwall will be further then 20 minutes away from a hospital or one of those on the list with limited opening times and no xray facilities.

Where I am in South Devon we have integrated care, south Devon is a leader in integrated care.

ArcticSkewer · 31/03/2023 12:00

ancientgran · 31/03/2023 09:01

To all the "go to A&E" comments, I live in the south west, just been on local tv that the health authority in Cornwall is appealing for people to only go to A&E if it is life threatening. I don't think a suspected broken foot qualifies so maybe stop with the "you should go to A&E" because it isn't necessarily what the NHS is saying.

I was interested so googled it. Wow! Their webpage is amazing!
https://www.cornwallft.nhs.uk/miu-waiting-times/

Short answer is dial 111.

Most of the services are then appointment based.
You can see the number of people waiting (and the open and closed times!) as 'live' information.

It's a+e if life or limb threatening.

You have really good services there. We don't have any of that, not even a miu within 20 minute drive any more.

Emergency and urgent care waiting times

On this page, you can check the waiting times for our emergency and urgent care services in Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly. Contact NHS 111 before turning up.

https://www.cornwallft.nhs.uk/miu-waiting-times

steppemum · 31/03/2023 11:21

which is why she thinks we are terrible for suggesting going to a+e,

you keep misquoting me or putting words in my mouth.

I did not say people were terrible for suggesting it, I was just pointing out that it is not the wonderful solution people think it is, because you get sent home/to UCT.In other words, don't have ago at the OP she is at the mercy of the system.

But I should say that I have been to this hospital 3 times with suspected fractureswith me/my kids

The second and third were recent and we were sent to UTC. One wasn't fractured, I couldn't walk though and was in tears with pain, and was told to walk over to UTC, then the nurse took pity on me and I was put in a wheelchair and taken over. (was during Covid, and dh wasn't allowed in though so no-one to push wheelchair!) One was a toe fracture which they strapped up. They were both in last 4 years ish.

before that, about 12 years ago I had a very bad ankle fracture (snapped both bones) and I was taken in through A&E and admitted, straightened ankle with gas and air and strapped it and then in a bed for 24 hours before they operated.

That was 12 years ago though.
But it mught be indicative of minor fractures v. serious fractures. I don't know.
(and they have rebuild and re-organised it all since, hence the UTC)

ancientgran · 31/03/2023 09:01

To all the "go to A&E" comments, I live in the south west, just been on local tv that the health authority in Cornwall is appealing for people to only go to A&E if it is life threatening. I don't think a suspected broken foot qualifies so maybe stop with the "you should go to A&E" because it isn't necessarily what the NHS is saying.

anyolddinosaur · 31/03/2023 08:44

stressedoutstudent · 30/03/2023 14:32

Our in hosp shop is not allowed to sell paracetamol as staff need to be able to document the time taken once admitted. Theres absolutely no choice of a receptionist - who is already busy in an area like A&E, being able to sell medication. Such a ridiculous suggestion.

No more ridiculous that telling the parent of a child with a broken bone to go out and get some. You could reasonably assume it will be taken 5 minutes after it is sold - if you felt you had to document it. There is no precise documentation of taking any the patient has brought with them. This is just a nonsense excuse.

Pottedpalm · 31/03/2023 08:23

Helpmeimtired · 29/03/2023 23:07

He’ll be fine.

Bloody hell! Why bother to type such a dismissive comment?
How do you know he will be fine? Would you want your child crying in pain for hours? Take a look at yourself!

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 08:18

ArcticSkewer · 31/03/2023 08:13

Yes - at yours! Where you went somewhere miles from a+e, not in the room next door so obviously basically part of the whole a+e system as per steppemum (which is why she thinks we are terrible for suggesting going to a+e, at hers you get sent next door. I still don't think that's a big deal. Would you have found that a big deal?)

You went somewhere with daytime only opening hours and chose to sit under a poster for four hours telling you that 111 calls were prioritised (and didn't at that point call 111 to get said appointment or to check if you were in the right place) and then chose to go home instead of to 24 hour a+e.

Steppemum's situation is actually far worse. Apparently there broken bones are not dealt with at all by a+e so it's a daytime only service and you get turned away from a+e when it is closed. I say apparently as I would be very shocked but it could be true, things seem terrible these days.

Your wait for triage was appalling but why the rest of it? That part is on you. At least a 4 hour wait somewhere that is open 24 hours makes some kind of sense. That's assuming your urgent care can deal with fractures that turn up rather than referred via a+e/gp. Mine can't but if yours can, great. You'd hope they would tell you as you book in, as per steppemum in reverse. But possibly only after triage, which would be poor!

Steppemum's situation is actually far far worse. I worry for us all if fractures are considered a daytime only non 'accident or emergency'.

Anyway I am glad you got things sorted. The wait is disgraceful. I've learned to always phone 111 for advice from this thread. I did actually remember doing that a few years ago for something and being sent miles away to what was probably an urgent care centre I didn't even know existed til I phoned! That was an appointment system as well. Left to myself I would have gone to a+e but it worked out probably quicker. So 111 seems a good call.

I didn't move him as I was awaiting instructions from the so called medical professionals.

Also, in the back of my mind was the time when he was a toddler and his older brother collided with him on a bouncy castle. We took him to the big a and e in the next city with a query broken arm and sat for hours. When my husband and I said we'd take him home, make him comfortable, arrange childcare for his brother and bring him back later when it was hopefully quieter, we were told that if we left we'd be classed as refusing treatment for an injured child and social services would be informed, so we stayed put. Why would I risk even more hassle by leaving knowing that is their policy?

OP posts:
ArcticSkewer · 31/03/2023 08:13

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 07:22

That's exactly what happened though, @ArcticSkewer ! x

Yes - at yours! Where you went somewhere miles from a+e, not in the room next door so obviously basically part of the whole a+e system as per steppemum (which is why she thinks we are terrible for suggesting going to a+e, at hers you get sent next door. I still don't think that's a big deal. Would you have found that a big deal?)

You went somewhere with daytime only opening hours and chose to sit under a poster for four hours telling you that 111 calls were prioritised (and didn't at that point call 111 to get said appointment or to check if you were in the right place) and then chose to go home instead of to 24 hour a+e.

Steppemum's situation is actually far worse. Apparently there broken bones are not dealt with at all by a+e so it's a daytime only service and you get turned away from a+e when it is closed. I say apparently as I would be very shocked but it could be true, things seem terrible these days.

Your wait for triage was appalling but why the rest of it? That part is on you. At least a 4 hour wait somewhere that is open 24 hours makes some kind of sense. That's assuming your urgent care can deal with fractures that turn up rather than referred via a+e/gp. Mine can't but if yours can, great. You'd hope they would tell you as you book in, as per steppemum in reverse. But possibly only after triage, which would be poor!

Steppemum's situation is actually far far worse. I worry for us all if fractures are considered a daytime only non 'accident or emergency'.

Anyway I am glad you got things sorted. The wait is disgraceful. I've learned to always phone 111 for advice from this thread. I did actually remember doing that a few years ago for something and being sent miles away to what was probably an urgent care centre I didn't even know existed til I phoned! That was an appointment system as well. Left to myself I would have gone to a+e but it worked out probably quicker. So 111 seems a good call.

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 08:10

FannyPhart · 31/03/2023 08:09

I think this centre needs naming if it is this incompetent.

I have made a formal complaint btw, but its in East Yorkshire. I have no sentimentality about naming it!

OP posts:
FannyPhart · 31/03/2023 08:09

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 07:23

It's not the waiting for treatment that offended me though, that's a given. It was the lack of triage. 4 and a half hours without triage is unacceptable 😤

I think this centre needs naming if it is this incompetent.

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 07:23

JackiePlace · 30/03/2023 23:54

This type of wait doesn't seem unusual to me . I was at the SDEC in a hospital in Bristol last week and they had a sign up at the entrance saying the wait will be approximately 8 hours! Thankfully mine was just over 1hr as an appointment had been made for me beforehand.

It's not the waiting for treatment that offended me though, that's a given. It was the lack of triage. 4 and a half hours without triage is unacceptable 😤

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 07:22

ArcticSkewer · 30/03/2023 22:44

Really? So your urgent care closes at 5pm and all the broken bodied people just limp home for the night, to try again tomorrow.

That's terrible @steppemum

That's exactly what happened though, @ArcticSkewer ! x

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 31/03/2023 02:58

TheSnootiestFox · 30/03/2023 13:07

Exactly! Zero empathy and zero candour.

I recently was in a&e waiting with DH when an elderly woman sat next to us. She was in a lot of pain in her neck and back and could barely move. She told me that the nurse on the door had refused to let her son come in with her. I kept her topped up with water but, as she didn't have any money on her, she wouldn't let me buy her a cup of tea a snack (probably too proud). It took 7 hours for her to be triaged and then she was whisked off immediately. If we hadn't been there she would have spent hours alone without even a drink. Not much compassion on show there.

Similar situation a few years ago when a quadriplegic and diabetic family member was left in a hospital corridor for several hours without their carer and not given/offered liquids, food or communicated with. Just left feeling helples, impotent and vulnerable in a potentially dangerous situation.

I agree with above that the problems with the NHS isn't just down to money it's where it's allocated and it needs a massive management overhaul. About 7% of our taxes in the UK goes to the NHS that's a massive amount and more than 3 times what is spent on defence. I have several family members working in the NHS who are tearing their hair out over the system

JackiePlace · 31/03/2023 00:00

Incidentally when OH had a compound fracture of the humerus he was kept overnight in hospital without any pain relief as a matter of protocol. I think it was something to do with concussion as he had been in a car accident.

JackiePlace · 30/03/2023 23:54

This type of wait doesn't seem unusual to me . I was at the SDEC in a hospital in Bristol last week and they had a sign up at the entrance saying the wait will be approximately 8 hours! Thankfully mine was just over 1hr as an appointment had been made for me beforehand.

ancientgran · 30/03/2023 23:08

steppemum · 30/03/2023 22:58

I don't know what they do if you turn up wiht a broken foot after hours. I suspect you would be seen by OOH doctor and sent home to return in the morning.

It si really common to strap people up and say X-ray opens at 9am. That has been going on for years

Yes. Forty five years ago I took a 2 year old son to hospital with suspected broken leg, my nextdoor neighbour was a sister at children's hospital and she was sure it was broken. They looked at it and said nothing they could do till the next morning to come back at 9 am. So in my experience you are right it has been going on for years. At least you can easily carry a 2 year old home.

steppemum · 30/03/2023 22:58

I don't know what they do if you turn up wiht a broken foot after hours. I suspect you would be seen by OOH doctor and sent home to return in the morning.

It si really common to strap people up and say X-ray opens at 9am. That has been going on for years

ArcticSkewer · 30/03/2023 22:44

Really? So your urgent care closes at 5pm and all the broken bodied people just limp home for the night, to try again tomorrow.

That's terrible @steppemum

steppemum · 30/03/2023 22:38

ArcticSkewer · 30/03/2023 15:37

And how would this be terrible? You are asked to walk, what, 200 metres? Essentially it's like moving from one part of the hospital to another. They've just triaged so broken bits turn left, other cases turn right, in a way. So going to A+E is still the right decision, just then follow the signs for the specific part that deals with broken bits (if you are there within its opening hours of course, otherwise stay in a+e)

Ops urgent care seems to be miles from the a+e, so when it closes at the end of the day, it closes. It prioritises calls from 111 and tells you that in reception (so you can phone from there). There isn't a handy x ray machine and doctors on 24hour call a two minute walk away.

You completely missed the point.

After the OP had sat in UTC and was sent home, people were saying to her don't go home go to A&E.
They were also saying you shouldn't have gone to UTC
In our hospital, A&E would just send you right back to UTC.
In other words, A&E won't see you if you try and go there after UTC

ancientgran · 30/03/2023 20:14

1AngelicFruitCake · 30/03/2023 20:05

Shocking but not surprised. My daughter had to walk to x ray, walk back again. Im Trying to carry her but really struggled to. They said I’d be lucky to find a wheelchair!

Crazy isn't it. I hope your daughter is OK now.

1AngelicFruitCake · 30/03/2023 20:05

ancientgran · 30/03/2023 16:07

I was sent to walk to xray when I broke my ankle, no help offered, no wheelchair available. As I struggled back, leaning on the wall and in pain a nurse came running with a wheelchair, they'd seen the xray and it finally clicked that I wasn't saying I was in too much pain to walk for the fun of it.

Fast forward, go to MIU with broken foot, immediately offered an wheelchair, short wait for xray and then the senior nurse insisted on wheeling me out to the drop off/collection point where my husband had the car waiting. Two miles apart, same trust, different world.

Shocking but not surprised. My daughter had to walk to x ray, walk back again. Im Trying to carry her but really struggled to. They said I’d be lucky to find a wheelchair!

1AngelicFruitCake · 30/03/2023 20:03

LakieLady · 30/03/2023 15:25

When I was in A&E a few months ago, they had people coming round distributing packed lunches in little carrier bags for patients waiting to be seen. Each one had a sandwich, a drink and a chocolate biscuit.

Given that people who need to be admitted sometimes have to wait 24 hours before they get a bed, it's probably just as well.

That’s lovely! We were lucky and at 8pm
they brought toast and juice for the children.