Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just checking if iabu before I kick off...

435 replies

TheSnootiestFox · 29/03/2023 22:59

Is 4 and a half hours in an urgent treatment centre without being seen even for triage unreasonable for a 12 year old with a suspected broken foot? No pain relief, nothing and he's been crying and begging me for help for hours.....my blood is boiling but I just need a reality check before I decide whether to say something or not. Opinions please!

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 01/04/2023 19:08

LovelyIssues · 01/04/2023 12:31

That sounds horrific OP! How is he today?

Thank you x he's up and about today. Fortunately no harm done but it was rather grim at the time!

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 01/04/2023 19:07

EstherGreenwood19 · 01/04/2023 12:47

Totally understand your frustration but kicking off will serve nobody, least of all your son.
kick off in the ballot box and vote the Tories out.

Why? Genuine question.

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 01/04/2023 19:06

Rosula · 31/03/2023 23:06

How can it not be the Tories' fault, given that they are in charge of the NHS and in charge of funding it, and they have been in power for 13 years? It really cannot be blamed on any other party.

My personal view, fwiw, is a lot of the problems are caused by crap managers and unsuitable staff. Many Tories are business people and probably have little tolerance for the poor management in the NHS, if anyone bothered to ask them. Just throwing money at people unable to spend it wisely is not going to help. But hey, it's easier just to blame the Tories!

OP posts:
Crazymum156 · 01/04/2023 15:03

I stood in a queue at reception of A&E, after being called because my dad was there.(end of life) I was behind splinters , sunburn etc. Told I had to wait my turn because nobody could deal with me. .... meanwhile my dad passed away unaware I was there. I don't blame the staff it's not their fault but the hospitals are overwhelmed by people who don't really have an emergency. And people like op son have to sit and wait in pain.

EstherGreenwood19 · 01/04/2023 12:47

Totally understand your frustration but kicking off will serve nobody, least of all your son.
kick off in the ballot box and vote the Tories out.

pollymere · 01/04/2023 12:34

Most UTCs run an appointment system and often are running two hours late on a bad day. If you don't have an appointment you'll be a lower priority to be seen unless there's an urgent risk to life. Always ring 111 to book an appointment first.

LovelyIssues · 01/04/2023 12:31

That sounds horrific OP! How is he today?

LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 01/04/2023 10:59

GettingStuffed · 31/03/2023 18:45

At Christmas I was sent to A&E with breathing difficulties, I was triaged in about 10 minutes after arrival.

Yet I was sent to A&E with breathing difficulties by the GP surgery 2 days before Christmas and it was over 3 hours before I was triaged - everywhere is different. Our region has already been discussed in this thread for telling people not to go to A&E unless life threatening but there isn’t always the alternatives to choose and, for illness rather than injury there aren’t UTC or walk in centres, just minor injuries units so it could be an hours drive each way for an appropriate treatment option

ancientgran · 01/04/2023 09:55

Paracetamol does nothing for me, the main reason I've ever taken pain meds is for head aches and asprin works best, paracetamol does nothing, ibuprofen helps, if I take one codeine tablet you'd think I'd injected heroin. Don't know why but I'm always surprised that people bother with paracetamol but obviously we aren't all the same.

Someone told me it might be to do with having red hair (well I did back in the day) but I don't know what. She said red heads feel pain differently and some pain killers work really well for them and some don't work. I ought to google it really.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/04/2023 08:18

Cazareeto1 · 01/04/2023 02:26

I’m very late to reply, but most will not give any pain meds until a dr has seen the patient. So that the pain meds don’t mask any pain symptoms.

if someone is in severe pain then paracetamol will only take the edge off. The patient can still pinpoint the pain, say whether it is sharp or dull etc. can describe when they had the paracetamol, how much they had etc so doctors should be able to give any further pain relief around that. People wait so many hours at A and E that any paracetamol taken when they first go in has probably worn off by the time they get seen anyway.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/04/2023 08:08

lemmein · 01/04/2023 01:50

The whole system is broken.

My DD had a kidney infection through the week - it came on suddenly and she was sent home from work. She phoned her gp, no answer, so she called 111 and was told to go to urgent care. She got to UC to discover there was no more spaces to be seen so she had to go to A&E where she sat in the waiting room for 8 hours in horrific pain. She has chronic kidney disease so has been through this many times - a course of antibiotics normally clears it up but ffs, the palaver to simply get a prescription is ridiculous.

Posters on here often criticise people for going to A&E needlessly but there is often no other option - primary care doesn't seem to exist anymore! You don't realise how bad the system is until you need it, or you're unfortunate enough to work in it - scary times.

That’s just one example of needless inefficiency. How easy would it be to have a prescription already on the system for your daughter so that as soon as her usual symptoms appeared she could just go and pick it up? I remember years ago my mum having a lot of UTIs. She was able to collect a prescription as soon as she needed it, without even talking to the GP.

Cazareeto1 · 01/04/2023 02:26

I’m very late to reply, but most will not give any pain meds until a dr has seen the patient. So that the pain meds don’t mask any pain symptoms.

lemmein · 01/04/2023 01:50

The whole system is broken.

My DD had a kidney infection through the week - it came on suddenly and she was sent home from work. She phoned her gp, no answer, so she called 111 and was told to go to urgent care. She got to UC to discover there was no more spaces to be seen so she had to go to A&E where she sat in the waiting room for 8 hours in horrific pain. She has chronic kidney disease so has been through this many times - a course of antibiotics normally clears it up but ffs, the palaver to simply get a prescription is ridiculous.

Posters on here often criticise people for going to A&E needlessly but there is often no other option - primary care doesn't seem to exist anymore! You don't realise how bad the system is until you need it, or you're unfortunate enough to work in it - scary times.

SuffolkUnicorn · 01/04/2023 01:43

crikey OP hope you and your son are ok xx

poppettypop · 01/04/2023 00:59

LuluBlakey1 · 01/04/2023 00:07

You can pay your way. You can have private health insurance- that's an option. However, Britain must continue to run an NHS for the majority who can't afford private health insurance and don't want a private system.

You do realise that a private healthcare system is about making profit, not about healthcare. It makes billions for the owners of insurance and private equity companies, charges a fortune for every single tablet, sticking plaster and bag of saline given, is afforded by the rich and well-paid and leaves the poor and less well-off, disabled, unemployed, single parents, elderly, those with health conditions, way behind receiving poorer treatment, patch-up treatment, unable to be treated, or not actually going to see Drs because they can't afford it. It spends multi millions on admin staff in hospitals to produce and argue out claims, Drs spend hours trying to speak to insurers to get treatments approved. The same companies that own the insurance sell the supplies and own the hospitals- the whole chain is about profit.

Healthcare should be a state responsibility, along with social care, social housing, water, energy, education and childcare. They are not about profit. If there is money in the system it should be about quality for 'customers' nit about profit for Tories.

This is the best post I have seen today.

Iwannabeacrocodilehunter · 01/04/2023 00:56

LuluBlakey1 · 01/04/2023 00:07

You can pay your way. You can have private health insurance- that's an option. However, Britain must continue to run an NHS for the majority who can't afford private health insurance and don't want a private system.

You do realise that a private healthcare system is about making profit, not about healthcare. It makes billions for the owners of insurance and private equity companies, charges a fortune for every single tablet, sticking plaster and bag of saline given, is afforded by the rich and well-paid and leaves the poor and less well-off, disabled, unemployed, single parents, elderly, those with health conditions, way behind receiving poorer treatment, patch-up treatment, unable to be treated, or not actually going to see Drs because they can't afford it. It spends multi millions on admin staff in hospitals to produce and argue out claims, Drs spend hours trying to speak to insurers to get treatments approved. The same companies that own the insurance sell the supplies and own the hospitals- the whole chain is about profit.

Healthcare should be a state responsibility, along with social care, social housing, water, energy, education and childcare. They are not about profit. If there is money in the system it should be about quality for 'customers' nit about profit for Tories.

I would love to pay my way and have private health insurance, but I can’t afford it on top of my huge NI bill. I’m basically paying for my health insurance plus probably another couple of people and getting absolutely crap service for that money.
If gladly stop paying NI and take out my own private insurance! I’d be quits in at the same time.

Iwannabeacrocodilehunter · 01/04/2023 00:50

I too have spent time in the USA and used their health system. It is far far superior to ours. Many jobs offer health insurance as part of their benefits package, otherwise, what I would pay over there is actually cheaper than my NI contribution.

I waited a year here for an eye treatment, bouncing between Opthamology and Opticians. Eventually I went back to the US and was treated within a couple of days. Went back home and showed my Opthamologist my medication and they pretty much said ‘Oh this stuff is great! We can’t prescribe that over here’.

The NHS is free at the point of service, but we are paying and we are paying a lot. I pay not far off £6000 annually for NI and DH pays about the same. The service we (don’t) get for that is terrible.

BashfulClam · 01/04/2023 00:48

Husband had chest pains and tightness in his arm etc. went to a&e on the advice of NHS 24, waited 5 hours in triage after he had an ECG and blood taken. In the cubicle next to us (we could hear everything due to it only being a curtain to separate bedd), 7 people came with mild things, were treated and sent off and we saw no one. One of them was an elderly nun who felt a bit faint at dinner!!! That was out if the ordinary so it sticks in my mind. Eventually I went and asked for a timescale and we were miraculously seen.

Mum23girlies · 01/04/2023 00:37

I was in urgent care for 6 hours with a baby having an allergic reaction, it was very hard not to kick off. It was so busy and there was so many people who were with someone else taking up all the seats we stood up the whole time. A lady was standing up breastfeeding no one thought to offer her a seat 😤

Mercury2702 · 01/04/2023 00:36

TheSnootiestFox · 31/03/2023 22:15

Can I just say in my defence, now that I've completely outed myself geographically 🤣 that our local a and e is in the arse end of Hull, full of drunks and drug addicts and has just been found unsafe during an inspection, whereas the UTC was a 2 minute drive from home in a leafy market town and this did affect my decision making - but I've now learnt from my mistake!

I work where you’re on about and our waiting times are the worst in the UK!

LuluBlakey1 · 01/04/2023 00:07

TheSnootiestFox · 30/03/2023 12:08

I didn't actually vote, not that its any of your business actually, but very unlike me because as a woman I'm aware other women died for me to have the privilege. I don't like what the Tories have done to the Nation but there was no way that Labour was a credible option at the time either. Currently worrying about the next election as I feel the same now!

Also, I am one of the few in the UK that have lived in the US and due to a no fault road accident experienced quite a lot of the American health care system. I'm not sure where the fear of people paying for insurance comes from but I'd be more than willing, I already have basic private health care here but of course there's no private a and e provision apart from that one mentioned up thread. The NHS can't go on as it is, so let those of us willing to pay our way do so!

You can pay your way. You can have private health insurance- that's an option. However, Britain must continue to run an NHS for the majority who can't afford private health insurance and don't want a private system.

You do realise that a private healthcare system is about making profit, not about healthcare. It makes billions for the owners of insurance and private equity companies, charges a fortune for every single tablet, sticking plaster and bag of saline given, is afforded by the rich and well-paid and leaves the poor and less well-off, disabled, unemployed, single parents, elderly, those with health conditions, way behind receiving poorer treatment, patch-up treatment, unable to be treated, or not actually going to see Drs because they can't afford it. It spends multi millions on admin staff in hospitals to produce and argue out claims, Drs spend hours trying to speak to insurers to get treatments approved. The same companies that own the insurance sell the supplies and own the hospitals- the whole chain is about profit.

Healthcare should be a state responsibility, along with social care, social housing, water, energy, education and childcare. They are not about profit. If there is money in the system it should be about quality for 'customers' nit about profit for Tories.

chimayrah1 · 31/03/2023 23:46

Leaving a child (or anyone) without pain relief for 4 hours is beyond inexcusable. I hate the way every failing in the NHS is explained away by the lack of funding. Yes, it is shockingly underfunded, but basic empathy and compassion should still be there. I was treated for a missed miscarriage today in an EPU where the staff were run ragged, so busy I doubt any of them had time to even go to the loo, and yet I was still treated with kindness and made to feel that I mattered. There is just no excuse.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 31/03/2023 23:36

of Course he’ll be fine - but at the moment he’s in great pain and his mother is naturally distressed by this. I hope you don’t have that attitude with your own kids, hard attitude lacking in compassion.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 31/03/2023 23:35

angela99999 · 31/03/2023 22:43

I spent 10 hours in A&E recently (for myself not a child) having called 111 who called me an ambulance. The Ambulance said it would be quicker to go in ourselves so we did.

Also waiting for almost the same time was a man with suspected heart problems and a woman who was wearing a hospital ID band having been discharged earlier that day but brought back by ambulance.
During our wait we did see serious injuries including two people stabbed in street brawls, but the largest number were young women who were totally drunk and were seen immediately.

They probably wanted them out of the way quickly. Probably easy and quick to assess and get rid of.

londonmummy1966 · 31/03/2023 23:35

TheSnootiestFox · 30/03/2023 13:07

Exactly! Zero empathy and zero candour.

Your problem was taking in a 12 year old - they're not cute enough for the nurses to care. I took my 15 year old who had suffered a head injury and concussion to the paediatic A&E at a major London teaching hospital. They cba with her or the teenager with a clearly broken arm who had to try and support its weight when all she needed was a pillow on her lap (and there was a pile on a cupboard near the nurses station), or the boy with a misshapen leg as a result of rugby. However, cute little blond girl with a sore thumb was seen really quickly. DD was temporarily allowed a bed but then kicked back into the general waiting area (without anyone checkin whether or not there was a chair for her to sit on - there wasn't). As we walked out of the ward we walked past 4 cubicles where the beds were unoccupied other than tablets/ipads being used to entertain toddlers in buggies.

Totally clear than nurses don't give a shit about older children no matter how much pain they're in. Truly shocking and I worry that this attitude is being taught to medical students coming through the system.

Swipe left for the next trending thread