Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I complain to the supermarket?

88 replies

OhGodNotNow · 29/03/2023 22:32

Sorry about the length...Husband and I called at local supermarket on the way home from work (large national chain), at around 5:30pm; very busy time. I had bought some sherry for cooking and one or two other items, and we went through the self checkout bit. When you're ready to pay, it asks for the assistant to confirm your age; the lady who was looking after the self-service bit was obviously really busy, but she came over and signed in with her card, and approved the purchase. I stepped forward and presented my contactless card, but at that very moment, she darted in and took the bottle off the 'tray' bit to remove the security collar, before replacing it on the tray so we could pack our things, including this bottle. This must have confused the machine, because it began to say repeatedly "has something been removed from your bag? Please replace the item". I just ignored this, because the item had been replaced, the payment had gone through, and the till had generated a receipt; we left the shop. A few moments later, just as we got outside, we heard a commotion behind us; the cashier was running after us shouting "Your payment hasn't gone through, you haven't paid". As I said, very busy time, everyone turns round to look at us (and I should say that this is a small town, where everyone knows everyone else...). I was surprised, and said that the payment had gone through, and we had the receipt to prove it - I dug it out of the bag and showed her, but she insisted that we had to return to the shop "because that's not what the till says". We were marched back to the till we had used, with everybody staring at us - lots of people queueing and also waiting for the cashier on the self-service tills; she said very loudly "Sorry, everyone, I'm back now, just need to sort this out, so sorry..." She then scanned her staff card to sign in to the till, and it immediately resolved the issue and it was apparent that we were right and had actually paid. By this time, another assistant had arrived and they looked at each other, said "Oh it must have got stuck", shrugged and went on with what they were doing. We were free to leave, but no apology, and everyone still looking daggers at us.

I felt absolutely humiliated and angry; should I complain? What I would like the shop to consider: 1.) If you need to challenge someone about something like this, could you say "Excuse me, I think you've forgotten something" rather than yelling that the customer hasn't paid? 2.) Since we had a valid receipt (which the cashier didn't dispute), could we have been asked to wait at the customer services desk by the entrance while she nipped back to check the till, so we weren't being paraded in front of everyone? 3.) Am I being unreasonable to think that an apology would have been nice?

I spend a lot of time and money in this store, and have done for many years; I'm sure the cashier was just rushed and a bit thoughtless, but I don't feel I want to go back.

OP posts:
TottyKnickers · 30/03/2023 15:26

Must have been a proper jobsworth as they don't normally bother

CrappyJob · 30/03/2023 09:00

FrogsWormsandButterflies · 30/03/2023 07:01

Have you not seen people scan shopping and keep stuff back in their bag/trolley to steal? So it looks like they’re paying for everything? I work in a supermarket and it’s a weekly occurrence

Of course. That's not the issue here though. So I didn't see any point in mentioning it.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 30/03/2023 08:07

the reason I ignored it is because the item had been returned to the tray, everything was present and correct before we started to pack, a till receipt had been generated, and the main screen behind the bagging alert clearly said the payment was OK.

But you still knew there was an issue and left anyway - that's really not the fault of the supermarket staff.

I get why you did it (because the payment had gone through) but now you know for next time!

JorisBonson · 30/03/2023 07:56

I would not give this a second thought, never mind post on the internet about it.

OhGodNotNow · 30/03/2023 07:54

For those saying it's my own fault for ignoring the till: as I said in the post, the reason I ignored it is because the item had been returned to the tray, everything was present and correct before we started to pack, a till receipt had been generated, and the main screen behind the bagging alert clearly said the payment was OK. Anyway, thanks for all the replies, it has helped me get a bit of perspective and I'll leave it behind!

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 30/03/2023 07:17

You're embarrassed but I'm not convinced it's entirely the fault of the staff.

You knew the machine was saying there was an error and instead of waiting/asking for help, you chose to walk out anyway. That's nobody else's fault but yours.

Yes, an apology would have been nice when they found out there was a machine error but it's not their fault you walked out instead of asking them for help in the first place!

Anycolouryoulike · 30/03/2023 07:15

This stuff happens all the time. I'd be a bit annoyed at best. Then I'd get on with my day.

Florissante · 30/03/2023 07:14

Minor issue. Move on.

Fairyliz · 30/03/2023 07:10

I would vote with my feet and if possible shop at a different supermarket. It won’t make a lot of difference in the grand scheme of things, but if everyone did that it would.
I would also tell everyone I know about my experience and perhaps encourage them to use manned checkouts to avoid this sort of problem.

thegrain · 30/03/2023 07:09

They didn't go OI THIEF GET BACK HERE YOU CHEEKY FUCKER

NoSquirrels · 30/03/2023 07:08

I'm sure the cashier was just rushed and a bit thoughtless,

There you are, then. A politely worded email about staff training to handle these incidents better in future - yes. Including mentioning that an apology at the time would have been appreciated as a gesture.

Anything else - no. It was a till error, no more no less.

FitAt50 · 30/03/2023 07:08

Wouldn't bother me in the slightest.

ScentOfAMemory · 30/03/2023 07:05

Out of curiosity, apart from being made to wait at CS to have the problem caused by herself not taking any action when the machine said "there seems to be a problem", how was the OP negatively impacted? She got her booze, the problem with the machine was resolved. Nobody died.
@CrappyJob I despair of what people think you guys are responsible for. Brew

thegrain · 30/03/2023 07:03

and everyone still looking daggers at us. were they really?! I doubt it they were probably like oh somethings happening there and then getting on with their day. If not then I'd consider moving as you clearly live in a town with well nosey parkers who have no life.

FrogsWormsandButterflies · 30/03/2023 07:01

CrappyJob · 30/03/2023 06:40

Nobody thinks that someone that has put their shopping through the till it's trying to steal. It's not a thing.

What does happen sometimes is that people try to pay contractless, the machine aks for chip and pin and the customer walks off not having noticed. What I have also seen happen is someone scan their loyalty card and have a brain fart and think they've paid.

It will have looked to the shop assistant that that is what happened. They won't think you were attempting to steal - I promise you, people that are shoplifting don't put their shopping through the till first! And neither will other customers.

As for asking you to wait at the customer service desk - to do that either they need to explain to the person on the desk what happened (and they will be confused as all hell as to why you are leaving then there when it appears that you need to pay at a self scan till), or they run the risk of you walking off, potentially leaving money unpaid.

Honestly, nobody cares. I've stopped many people from walking off when their payment hasn't been successful. I don't remember a single one. It's just not that interesting to anyone other than you. It happens. And yes, an apology would have been nice - but the shop assistant was, by your own words, busy - and by this point probably had other customers to deal with. When you are on self scan you can be pulled in six different directions at once. She was probably trying to get everything dealt with as quickly and efficiently as possible. It's unfortunate. And I understand you feel embarrassed - but everyone else will have forgotten about it.

Feel free to make a complaint if you wish, but nothing will change as a result. 'Your payment hasn't gone through' is a completely accepted way of dealing with this situation.

Have you not seen people scan shopping and keep stuff back in their bag/trolley to steal? So it looks like they’re paying for everything? I work in a supermarket and it’s a weekly occurrence

ScentOfAMemory · 30/03/2023 07:01

TheTeenageYears · 30/03/2023 06:33

If you don't complain the same thing is very likely to happen again. The member of staff needs training to deal with issues so you the customer isn't negatively impacted by their behaviour. They can't treat everyone as if they are criminals and humiliate them just because there are people who try to cheat the system. Yes people make mistakes but they also need to learn from them and at this point the person in question is possibly blissfully unaware that her actions caused you distress.
@ScentOfAMemory it was the member of staff who removed the bottle to remove the security tag, not OP so can't really be held responsible for ignoring the machine.

Well the machine then told her there was a problem. In her own words, she ignored it.

Albiboba · 30/03/2023 06:47

No there is nothing to complain about. All that happened is someone trying to do their job.

Crumpetdisappointment · 30/03/2023 06:45

no dont complain
they were following procedure

Dibbydoos · 30/03/2023 06:42

Yes complain. It costs nothing to show manners, she should have apologised, loudly.

CrappyJob · 30/03/2023 06:40

Nobody thinks that someone that has put their shopping through the till it's trying to steal. It's not a thing.

What does happen sometimes is that people try to pay contractless, the machine aks for chip and pin and the customer walks off not having noticed. What I have also seen happen is someone scan their loyalty card and have a brain fart and think they've paid.

It will have looked to the shop assistant that that is what happened. They won't think you were attempting to steal - I promise you, people that are shoplifting don't put their shopping through the till first! And neither will other customers.

As for asking you to wait at the customer service desk - to do that either they need to explain to the person on the desk what happened (and they will be confused as all hell as to why you are leaving then there when it appears that you need to pay at a self scan till), or they run the risk of you walking off, potentially leaving money unpaid.

Honestly, nobody cares. I've stopped many people from walking off when their payment hasn't been successful. I don't remember a single one. It's just not that interesting to anyone other than you. It happens. And yes, an apology would have been nice - but the shop assistant was, by your own words, busy - and by this point probably had other customers to deal with. When you are on self scan you can be pulled in six different directions at once. She was probably trying to get everything dealt with as quickly and efficiently as possible. It's unfortunate. And I understand you feel embarrassed - but everyone else will have forgotten about it.

Feel free to make a complaint if you wish, but nothing will change as a result. 'Your payment hasn't gone through' is a completely accepted way of dealing with this situation.

Oblomov23 · 30/03/2023 06:39

I agree, I think it was handled really badly, and they are clearly very short staffed and under pressure.

TheTeenageYears · 30/03/2023 06:33

If you don't complain the same thing is very likely to happen again. The member of staff needs training to deal with issues so you the customer isn't negatively impacted by their behaviour. They can't treat everyone as if they are criminals and humiliate them just because there are people who try to cheat the system. Yes people make mistakes but they also need to learn from them and at this point the person in question is possibly blissfully unaware that her actions caused you distress.
@ScentOfAMemory it was the member of staff who removed the bottle to remove the security tag, not OP so can't really be held responsible for ignoring the machine.

FiveShelties · 30/03/2023 06:31

There seem to be so many threads where the OP only posts once - I wonder why?🤔

GoodChat · 30/03/2023 06:21

ScentOfAMemory · 30/03/2023 06:19

Also, if you'd put the bottle back when the machine asked you if something had been removed (instead of, in your words, "ignoring" it) then all this trauma would have been avoided. The bottle had been registered, then it was removed for the tag, then it didn't go back on the tray so the machine removed it from your bill.
So because you ignored the machine, you had to go back.

It didn't remove it from her bill. That's not how it works nor what has happened. The machine just glitched after payment.

ScentOfAMemory · 30/03/2023 06:19

Also, if you'd put the bottle back when the machine asked you if something had been removed (instead of, in your words, "ignoring" it) then all this trauma would have been avoided. The bottle had been registered, then it was removed for the tag, then it didn't go back on the tray so the machine removed it from your bill.
So because you ignored the machine, you had to go back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread