Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government says parents shouldn't be worried about school funding

136 replies

noblegiraffe · 29/03/2023 22:07

Gillian Keegan, current Education Secretary (you might not know this as there have been a few recently) was just interviewed by Sophy Ridge and said that parents shouldn't be worried about school funding.

School funding has been below 2010 per pupil levels for 13 years now. This has resulted in redundancies of TAs, support staff and teachers. It has resulted in subject choices being cut at GCSE and A-level. It has resulted in the school estate crumbling to the point where some school buildings are officially at 'imminent' risk of collapse, and there have been injuries to children and school staff where ceilings have fallen in.

Headteachers had to make further cuts last summer due to a late-announced unfunded teacher pay rise for September.

There is a shortage of TAs as schools can't hire due to being unable to afford competitive pay levels and TAs are choosing to work in supermarkets instead of schools.

There is a shortage of exam invigilators, again partly due to uncompetitive pay, and the government has been forced to relax ratios to allow exams to go ahead.

There is a shortage of teachers and now this year and next there is a devastating shortage of people training to be teachers, for various reasons including workload and lack of flexible working, but also uncompetitive pay.

Schools are also having to prop up the gaps left by the collapse of local services such as CAMHS and SEN support services who are now largely inaccessible.

We had a pandemic which adversely affected the education of children, and yet school funding levels remain below that of 2010.

How can parents possibly not be concerned about school funding?

OP posts:
wonkylegs · 30/03/2023 11:05

I think with the current government as soon as they tell me not to worry about stuff I'm immediately worried
DS1s school is seriously overcrowded in old buildings with issues left right and centre and a distinct lack of staff but so are all the other schools in the area unless you go private.
DS2s village primary school thankfully is fairly well funded due to the Church trust it's in making up the shortfall, they also rent out the buildings to the 'church' - I'm not keen on the huge religious push but it's what's keeping it all together atm so I'm not going to complain.

Whinge · 30/03/2023 09:02

donttellmehesalive · 30/03/2023 03:28

I'm a teacher. I think our parents will have a shock in September.

Two teachers and four TAs are being made redundant, affecting class sizes in two year groups and SEN support across the school.

SEN children will only be supported for the hours we receive funding for. In some cases, children used to having support from a TA in every lesson will only get 2 hours per day.

We have had a small surplus for emergencies in recent years but that's gone and we'll be in deficit.

The number of trips will be cut in half. Increasing numbers of parents can't or won't pay and we can't cover it any more.

They won't necessarily know about the building repairs that won't happen (again).

It's a similar situation at my school. 1 teacher and 3 TAs are being made redundant, and we all know more will follow in the next year or 2. Sad

Locally, I don't know a single school that isn't in deficit.

ApocalypseNowt · 30/03/2023 08:57

School used to fundraise for nice things like visits, school trips & fun playground equipment.

Now we're doing it for school books and basic maintenance. Yes, I am worried.

noblegiraffe · 30/03/2023 08:50

Changechangechanging · 29/03/2023 23:12

@noblegiraffe are you aware of any templates available for emailing our MPs worth educational concerns? The type that backs up anything said with up to date stats and/or research?

Not aware of anything, There really should be, shouldn't there?

I can get some links together later if that's any use.

OP posts:
Mookie81 · 30/03/2023 08:14

What Covid (and 16 years teaching) has shown me is that there are an awful lot of parents who aren't that bothered about what happens at school as long as their children are in and they don't have to have them at home or sort childcare.

Inthedarkagain · 30/03/2023 08:04

I am very worried about my youngest starting school this year. He has has some moderate hearing issues, is virtually non verbal and rarely settles into activities or follows instruction at nursery. Apparently he doesn't qualify for 1 to 1 care at nursery. I'm expecting the usual kicking of can down the road by his EHCP assessors for enhanced care. He is due an assessment in a couple of months, but there is no guarantee he will get a diagnosis. Because he isn't aggressive they don't care, even if his life chances and wellbeing are impacted.

So much money is wasted on putting off, postponing and fobbing people off. I know extra care is expensive, but I wonder what a lack of funding costs in the long run in terms of mental health care, admin and all the professionals trying to refer to one another because they don't want to deal with a patient? It's madness. This system is very much broken. Not proactive at all and failing children spectacularly.

If snyone has been in this position, what do I do if his school can't cope with him when he starts? We both work full-time and can't drop hours or collect him all of the time, nor do I think we should. I think he still has a right to an education, it is the schools and LA job to place him properly and put support in place. As far as I'm concerned I have done my bit as a parent by seeking support for my child so the transition is as smooth as possible and it is between the LA snd school now.

Hailtheteam · 30/03/2023 07:55

I’m not a parent but am worried. Even just selfishly we all should be, these are the doctors, plumbers, cleaners, nurses, artists etc of the future and I need those.

SushiGo · 30/03/2023 07:42

I am incredibly worried about my child's secondary. Recent incidents:

  • a ceiling fell in.
  • around 1/3 of my yr9s lessons are taught by substitutes
  • despite a report saying my child puts in loads of effort, great behaviour, does homework etc and started the school with really high test scores apparently they are now predicted only just passing grades at gcse in most subjects. (Wtf are the ones who started the school struggling predicted??)
  • all extra curricular are at the absolute bare bones, there is no funding
  • massive behaviour problems around sex and drugs
  • not enough SEN staff and huge numbers of SEN and otherwise vulnerable children with significant needs coming up from primary due to not getting the support they needed there or from social services etc at a younger age.
  • SEN and vulnerable kids frequently being involved with the behaviour problems and staff having no effective tools to deal with it due to lack of funding, staff and other services available to help

I have a child with SEN due to start in September. Dreading it.

Feel like this government has flushed my children's education down the toilet. I am really angry at how cavalier and callous it is.

This is not just a few bad schools. This is so many schools across the entire country. It's a major, major issue that we're going to have a really poorly educated workforce in a few years time.

MushMonster · 30/03/2023 07:28

It is not only parents who should be concerned, is the whole of society. And very concerned.

MushMonster · 30/03/2023 07:05

Yeap, we do HAVE to worry, because the education issue is not only about funding.
The attitude is there too.
And I agree with this poster, I have been more than shocked by the lack of basic knowledge of people with a brand new degree in a subject, really basic staff that I was told was not taught, but the attitude to training was the worst.
I am praying my DD does get a better approach

MrsHamlet · 30/03/2023 06:56

We already have 7 fewer TAs than we had this time last year, which is probably 10 fewer than we need.

megletthesecond · 30/03/2023 06:53

The government can piss off then can't they. My MP is getting an email this weekend telling them to increase teacher pay and conditions.

Tuppenyhapeny · 30/03/2023 06:43

I am a governor of a primary school and we finish this financial year with a substantial deficit, entirely as a result of the unfunded pay awards to teachers and support staff. Both of which were awarded after the budgets had been set. We have a building that requires substantial work, externally and internally, furniture and equipment that requires replacing or updating and not a chance in hell that there will be any money available for this apart from the miserly annual amount we receive for capital expenditure. Since becoming a governor some 12 years ago, I have seen the fabric of our school deteriorate to its current state with sadness and anger. Our pupils and staff deserve better, but it's just getting worse.

spanieleyes · 30/03/2023 06:28

My school is literally falling to pieces, bricks dropping off into the car park, holes in the roof, buckets everywhere when it rains. It's a disgrace. But there's no money to fix it.
That's nothing to worry about though, is it?

MrsMurphyIWish · 30/03/2023 06:20

My school has had porta-loos for the last 4 months because we have nearly 2000 pupils in a building which was originally designed for 600 (Victorian). The pipe system can’t cope but we can’t afford to have the pipes replaced.

Cynically, I don’t think parents will worry. We have not had one complaint about shared porta-loos (All years and staff use them - like a festival!). We only have complaints for closure.

RobinRobinMouse · 30/03/2023 06:13

@echt Exactly, I am very, very concerned. The impact on society as a whole if children are not well educated is massive. Our children deserve better.

echt · 30/03/2023 03:35

Government says parents shouldn't be worried about school funding

I'm guessing they missed out the second sentence which should read: They should be shitting themselves.

donttellmehesalive · 30/03/2023 03:32

Also can't get supply teachers, or afford them. Teacher absence will be coveted by a TA or we will split the class and send to other classes.

Nice enrichment activities, visitors, art/D&T/science lessons that used expensive resources will be changed or we will have to ask parents to contribute.

donttellmehesalive · 30/03/2023 03:28

I'm a teacher. I think our parents will have a shock in September.

Two teachers and four TAs are being made redundant, affecting class sizes in two year groups and SEN support across the school.

SEN children will only be supported for the hours we receive funding for. In some cases, children used to having support from a TA in every lesson will only get 2 hours per day.

We have had a small surplus for emergencies in recent years but that's gone and we'll be in deficit.

The number of trips will be cut in half. Increasing numbers of parents can't or won't pay and we can't cover it any more.

They won't necessarily know about the building repairs that won't happen (again).

MrsHerculePoirot · 30/03/2023 01:41

They are totally deluded. The strength of feeling from everybody in school these last two days is huge. Anyone who was a bit ambivalent before is angry.

noblegiraffe · 30/03/2023 00:20

99victoria · 29/03/2023 23:42

What reason did she give for not needing to worry? 🙄
I'm a Governor at a local primary school and we have cut everything we possibly can. We are looking at a signicant deficit budget next year

This is the graph that she has been wheeling out to justify it.

Schools were absolutely shafted last year by the late announcement of an unfunded pay rise after budgets had been set for the year, so the government placated school leaders by announcing an extra £2 billion for schools in the Autumn statement. But not till next year.

That money that was desperately needed this year to pay for the running of schools (schools had to make further redundancies, cancel planned spending on building works, IT equipment etc) is now being touted as the money that will be used to fund the offered pay rise for next year.

The argument is that energy price predictions have halved since they submitted evidence to the independent teacher pay review body recommending 3% next year. They're saying that the difference can be used to pay for the pay rise and support staff pay rise. Don't worry parents, it's all covered.

HOWEVER.

It assumes that schools will benefit from the predicted reduction in energy prices, which they won't if they fixed their tariff recently. I'm also not sure why their energy cost prediction differs so much from the one they submitted to the pay review body, given that was only a few weeks ago.

It also assumes that schools were already adequately funded, so that the £2 billion can be used to pay for these additional costs, rather than fill a pre-existing funding black hole. As we know, schools have been underfunded for over a decade so there are many things that need to have money spent on them that have been pushed back and staff that are needed who we haven't been able to hire or who have had to be made redundant.

So basically, if you were happy with schools being underfunded like they have been the last decade, it's business as normal.

If you think that schools need more money than that, it's bad news.

Government says parents shouldn't be worried about school funding
OP posts:
SausageinaBun · 29/03/2023 23:55

Our primary has benefitted over the last few years from the minimum funding guarantee. This means our budget has gone up, but also means that we were historically poorly funded compared to other schools. It has given us a bit more capacity to support children with significant needs. But we seem to be at the end of that phase of growth and about to slide back due to unfunded pay awards.

This gives me a different perspective on schools that have seen their funding shrink. When people say "we won't be able to have a TA in every class anymore", I think "but we've never had that, it sounds like a luxury". I have to remind myself that it isn't a race to the bottom and schools like ours should have been levelled up, rather than other schools levelled down.

99victoria · 29/03/2023 23:42

What reason did she give for not needing to worry? 🙄
I'm a Governor at a local primary school and we have cut everything we possibly can. We are looking at a signicant deficit budget next year

Changechangechanging · 29/03/2023 23:12

@noblegiraffe are you aware of any templates available for emailing our MPs worth educational concerns? The type that backs up anything said with up to date stats and/or research?

riskybiznisses · 29/03/2023 23:08

Our school is in dire need of repairs & the lack of support for children needing extra help is shit. This is what happens with a conservative government.

Their abilities appear to be particularly focused on dodgy deals and sex assaults these days. Every week there is a new scandal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread