Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government says parents shouldn't be worried about school funding

136 replies

noblegiraffe · 29/03/2023 22:07

Gillian Keegan, current Education Secretary (you might not know this as there have been a few recently) was just interviewed by Sophy Ridge and said that parents shouldn't be worried about school funding.

School funding has been below 2010 per pupil levels for 13 years now. This has resulted in redundancies of TAs, support staff and teachers. It has resulted in subject choices being cut at GCSE and A-level. It has resulted in the school estate crumbling to the point where some school buildings are officially at 'imminent' risk of collapse, and there have been injuries to children and school staff where ceilings have fallen in.

Headteachers had to make further cuts last summer due to a late-announced unfunded teacher pay rise for September.

There is a shortage of TAs as schools can't hire due to being unable to afford competitive pay levels and TAs are choosing to work in supermarkets instead of schools.

There is a shortage of exam invigilators, again partly due to uncompetitive pay, and the government has been forced to relax ratios to allow exams to go ahead.

There is a shortage of teachers and now this year and next there is a devastating shortage of people training to be teachers, for various reasons including workload and lack of flexible working, but also uncompetitive pay.

Schools are also having to prop up the gaps left by the collapse of local services such as CAMHS and SEN support services who are now largely inaccessible.

We had a pandemic which adversely affected the education of children, and yet school funding levels remain below that of 2010.

How can parents possibly not be concerned about school funding?

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 02/04/2023 07:53

I just wanted to add to the large class sizes. My son was in a mixed year group of 42 in the room for several years. There literally wasnt room for them all to sit down and work. They had to use windowsills

Casilero · 02/04/2023 03:51

@BOYBANDLOVER I admire you for home educating. I really wanted to with my youngest daughter but didn't because my marriage wasn't solid enough.

My 3 kids did actually do ok in school academically, but only because I arranged a lot of additional private tuition, as well as putting in a lot of extra support in myself. My 3 all have specific learning difficulties and the eldest 2 in particular had a miserable time at school and now at the age of 22 they still struggle socially It's a big regret of mine that I didn't home school. If I could go back and have my time again, I would have home schooled all 3 of them.

BOYBANDLOVER · 02/04/2023 03:09

forgot to add. my nephew is 6 months older than my son and in y8

hes in a class of 50. yes 50

its the only comprehensive around here for 10 miles

BOYBANDLOVER · 02/04/2023 03:05

there are millions and millions of us home educating in the uk.

imagine if we all put our kids in schools.

there's no way it could happen

no where near enough places or money

on one of my Facebook groups alone there's 6.5k.
that's just one group alone. imagine if every kid were counted and i know many families with 5+kids.

one in my meet up group has 11 kids

my boys are disabled and since 2015 ive saved my council thousands and thousands of pounds by educating my kids by myself and as my youngest is still only y7 thousands in the future

both have disabilities and would be in special school with a full time 1-1 each, taxis provided x2 for a far distance as we don't do special schools around here(rural Wales)its the local village school or none.

if that's not suitable hard lines, in our case it was, i was told my school cant deal with my kids issues(he was 4) and when i asked where do i go next my council told me i don't have a answer for you.

this is when i discovered the world of home education, and that was from a asd support group

if i didn't go down the H.E route i have no idea what we would have done.

all lockdowns my kids went through zero stress

Casilero · 02/04/2023 00:43

I've just read on Twitter that the Government is spending 8 million on "free" portraits of King Charles to be distributed amongst schools. So maybe you can use that to patch up the holes in the roof?

wonkylegs · 01/04/2023 10:31

DS1s class sizes pre GCSE were shocking, for maths & English they were 38 & 36 respectively, now at GCSE they are down to 30 "so they get more attention in critical years"
The classrooms are literally not big enough for the numbers of students with extra chairs added to the ends of tables.
School is short staffed and overcrowded and I can't see that changing before he leaves.

Lougle · 31/03/2023 21:37

DD1 was in a class of 11, then 12, then 13, then 14 at special school. It destroyed her. Her needs were unmet and she ended up hospitalised and is still under psychiatric care now. I was at CAMHS this week and there was a boy from her old school. I heard him complain to his Mum that he'd asked for help and didn't get it. The Mum said "Well remember there are 18 in your class..."

That's a special school. Budgets are so stripped that class sizes are bulging. TA support shrinking.

Easterfunbun · 31/03/2023 21:13

I am concerned about my youngest twos primary school. They had multiple buckets today in their classrooms due to the heavy rain. Their school is however being completely rebuilt next year. Genuinely worried about a roof caving in.

Jules912 · 31/03/2023 20:51

Our school has been asking for a voluntary donation for a while. This year it went from a suggested £20 a year to £50. I actually expect they're doing better than most as we're in a nice middle class area and most parents can and do pay.
DS's new high school is asking for between £50 and £100 a month, although as a grammar school I expect they'll get it as a lot of parents see it as a cheap alternative to private.

Ginflinger · 31/03/2023 20:43

We had a letter from the school today asking if any parents were in a position to make regular direct debit donations. So actually yes I am worried about school funding.

MrsHamlet · 31/03/2023 20:43

We don't even have full time one to one for the kids with that in their EHCP.
Yes we know that's illegal.
But we can't afford them even if they exist. Which they don't.

99victoria · 31/03/2023 20:42

When our caretaker left last year we didn't replace them because we are already operating at a deficit. Our HT, AHT and cleaner share the unlocking and locking up of the school every day. We get parents and governors to help out with small maintenance jobs etc. When it was icy recently, our HT had to go into school and spread grit on all the paths before the children arrived.
And, to the PP who suggested cutting the 1-2-1 TAs - if a child has an EHCP, the school HAS to provide 1-2-1 for the hours in the plan. The plan comes with funding BUT the school has to fund the first £6k out of it's existing budget. That's 6k for every child who has an EHCP

Jules912 · 31/03/2023 20:40

I can't imagine 2 TAs per class, are you sure some of them aren't 1-2-1's for children with EHCPs? DCs school only has class TAs for reception, two TAs ( one of whom is part time) for KS1 and two or three for KS2. There are two TAs in DS's year 6 class, for the two children with EHCPs. Ironically if they had a full time class TA my DD probably wouldn't need an EHCP ( the ongoing battle to get one us a whole other thread!)

Cantseethewindows · 31/03/2023 20:34

Casilero · 31/03/2023 20:20

This thread's a bit of an eye opener. I knew there were issues with staffing and retention but really shocked to hear about buildings falling apart and just how bad the staffing levels are in some schools. My daughter's in Year 10 so I only tend to know about things she feeds back, so I know they've had to drop a language as they couldn't rectuit a language teacher and that they're a maths teacher down so have supply cover, but don't know about whether or not TAs and support staff have been cut.

Please shout it from the rooftops! Spread the word far and wide! We need more people to know how shit it is! I have a class with 18 pupils, all with SEND, behavioural, emotional or safeguarding issues. We're on the fifth TA of the year. That's one TA for a class in which only a few pupils are capable of any independent work. And that's at a school with an amazing socialist head, who finds money from god knows where. We currently have the best reputation of all state schools in the local area. It is way, way worse at other schools. And we still struggle to find staff. Our cover supervisors are 19yos who finished our Sixth Form last year...

Casilero · 31/03/2023 20:20

This thread's a bit of an eye opener. I knew there were issues with staffing and retention but really shocked to hear about buildings falling apart and just how bad the staffing levels are in some schools. My daughter's in Year 10 so I only tend to know about things she feeds back, so I know they've had to drop a language as they couldn't rectuit a language teacher and that they're a maths teacher down so have supply cover, but don't know about whether or not TAs and support staff have been cut.

noblegiraffe · 31/03/2023 20:18

Lord Adonis went around schools to try to find ways that they could make efficiency savings years ago. It's been done. There are no easy cuts left to make after 13 years of cuts.

My school has cut GCSE and A-level options. It has cut TA support staff. It has cut teachers. These all have impacted the quality of education on offer.

OP posts:
donttellmehesalive · 31/03/2023 20:18

Suggesting we 'trim the fat' is a joke. What do you think we've been doing for the last 13 years? There's nothing left to trim.

Perfect28 · 31/03/2023 20:15

I need not have bothered replying. The reply is so bloody obvious. The worrying thing though is that lots of people think like you.

Perfect28 · 31/03/2023 20:12

So support for students with SEND that is legally mandated (btw already cut to the bone, we have one TA per 200ish students), paper that students need to write and draw on (?), Admin staff who literally keep the school running, food for children (many of whom this is their only hot meal each day and is already of poor quality). I think my original comment stands, when was the last time you were in a school? It's like you're imagining an education system that hasn't had its funding decimated for 13 years.

Spendonsend · 31/03/2023 20:09

MadridPark · 31/03/2023 20:01

@Perfect28

One to one TAs, office staff, cleaning, paper use and school kitchens are all areas I’d be looking to cut spending.

Thats hilarious.

MrsHamlet · 31/03/2023 20:09

MadridPark · 31/03/2023 20:01

@Perfect28

One to one TAs, office staff, cleaning, paper use and school kitchens are all areas I’d be looking to cut spending.

Explain to me how my autistic year 10 could access any lessons without his one to one. Clue: he can't.
Explain to me which of the office or cleaning or kitchen staff you'd cut.
Explain to me how I do my job without paper.

DanglingMod · 31/03/2023 20:07

MadridPark · 31/03/2023 20:01

@Perfect28

One to one TAs, office staff, cleaning, paper use and school kitchens are all areas I’d be looking to cut spending.

You are having an absolute giraffe. There is nothing to trim any longer. Trimmed to the absolute bone in our school.

Cantseethewindows · 31/03/2023 20:07

99victoria · 29/03/2023 23:42

What reason did she give for not needing to worry? 🙄
I'm a Governor at a local primary school and we have cut everything we possibly can. We are looking at a signicant deficit budget next year

£58.5bn is a lot of money was the main reason. Oh, and the £1000 one-off payment hush money to teachers, which was mentioned so often it was strongly reminiscent of Vote Leave's £350m a week...

Notonthestairs · 31/03/2023 20:07

1-2-1 TA was the only way my daughter could stay in mainstream schooling whilst she waited 2 years for a place at a SEN school came up.

Would you accept your child being left to flounder in a school that even the authorities recognised wasn't a fit for them? I doubt it.

And that's repeated all over England.