Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants to return home

137 replies

Aussiewife · 29/03/2023 21:35

My first ever post so forgive any mistakes. I am from the UK, my husband is Australian. We have been together 11 years and married 5. We have 2 kids under 5.
We have lived in the UK for the last 7 years. Before that we lived together in Australia for 3 years. We met while he was travelling the UK and I moved to Australia to be with him.
When we moved to the UK he never saw it as a permanent thing and I always agreed we would one day return to Australia. However every time he has suggested returning, he has always agreed to stay in the UK for a few more years.
Now he is desperate for us to move there in 2 years when our mortgage ends. I feel sick at the thought of it. We have a good life here, a nice house, well paid jobs and our children are very happy. I just can't imagine moving them, especially our eldest away from all his friends and everything they know.
We are in South England and all my family in Scotland so we have no family support nearby. Although we see my parents monthly and the kids are very close to them. I have one sibling and they live in Australia so moving to Australia would mean being closer to them and it would be nice for our kids to grow up with their cousins. We would living in the same city as my sibling. My husbands parents would be 2 hours away.
I just can't imagine leaving our life here. Aibu to tell my husband I don't want to go?
Sorry its for the long post.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
endoftheworldniteclub · 03/04/2023 12:48

@Holly60 To ’just pop over’ would be £9000 just for the flights for our family of four. It’s not like it used to be.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/04/2023 11:19

@Holly60 that's not always the case though. Just paying for popping to Australia isn't like popping to Spain - I have friends who haven't seen their parents face to face for 5 years. They can't afford to go

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 03/04/2023 07:37

I've lived in Perth for ten years and don't recognise the Australia that litterbox is describing either. As for the OPs dilemma, I had no interest in emigrating until I was in my 40s, and changed my mind. It was the best decision I ever made, just wish I'd done it sooner! But its a personal decision for everyone, and not a decision that can be forced. My husband never forced a decision on me, if he had tried we would still be living in Ireland.

Holly60 · 03/04/2023 07:34

I feel so sorry for both of you, but especially for him to be honest.

The scenario that everyone is warning you about, being trapped in a country you don't want to be in because of your children, is the scenario he is already facing.

To be completely honest, I would move. You have family out there, including your own sibling and their cousins on your side. Your parents are far away anyway and can come to visit you and your sibling together a few times a year.

Your children are young and will settle well.

You owe to your DH to try - you've been over here for a while and he's not happy

Thelittlekingdom · 03/04/2023 07:31

Why does your husband want to move back? It sounds like what you have in the UK is better than what you could have in Oz?

But you need to have a conversation with him and be honest that you feel settled and don’t want to move.

ImAvingOops · 03/04/2023 07:30

The OP isn't unreasonable for changing her mind - no one can say for certain how they will feel before they've actually had children. It does change things. She isn't lying, she's mulling over her thoughts snd feelings before discussing it.
It's unreasonable to hold people to agreements they made when children were theoretical and not real!

Lots of people come to realise that their parents are ageing and might need support and decide not to moves as far away as they can get, while still being on the same planet! I wouldn't leave mine.

This is a danger in marrying someone from a different country and that's a risk the OP's husband took too. And let's be real - if the relationship goes pear shaped, it's usually the woman who has the kids and the financial struggles of being a single parent. A sensible woman wouldn't risk that in a country where her new job is less well paid than her existing one. Already posters have suggested he might return to Australia without her and the kids, as if that's an acceptable thing. No one really considers seriously a mother leaving her kids to return to her home country because realistically mothers rarely do.

I wouldn't move - the disadvantage is all yours. Leaving parents, leaving well paid job, not having freedom to return home. Aging parents and having the responsibility of children does change things.

Tourmalines · 03/04/2023 07:27

CallItLoneliness · 03/04/2023 06:33

The absolute irony of people calling all of Australia "racist". Yes, there is a lot of racism here, but I've seen plenty in the UK too--one of my dearest friends was called a "bogtrotter" at an elite London university by the support staff there (in fairness they didn't realise he was in the room, so that makes it ok, I guess?!). Yes, people (not me) are into sport here but they don't have to separate team supporters in sport grounds. Some Dads are useless here, but nearly every other post on Mumsnet is about a useless Dad. Yes, things are expensive, but I earn double in dollars what I would earn in pounds for the next level up in my job in London.

None of this helps the OP, of course, who needs to have a tricky conversation with her DH to figure out what they will do next. But FFS, get a hold of yourselves and your superiority complex.

Spot on

Alondra · 03/04/2023 06:59

OP, you need to have a frank conversation with your DH with complete honesty. You don't want to leave the UK and have strong reasons why you don't want to do it. In your case, I'll do the same.

But he needs to know.

Alondra · 03/04/2023 06:55

emptythelitterbox · 02/04/2023 12:01

And there you are proving my point with the bog standard ignorant xenophobic Aussie cry of, fuck off were full!

I'm a citizen hun so no matter what you think of my skin colour or country of birth, I'm still a citizen.

And we all know what xenophobic and racist "your kind" means.

So ODFOD

Do you think we are different? What makes you think the classic "Australia is racist and sexist" is not ignorant, xenophobic and demonstrates a complete lack of understanding about Australians?

We all react emotionally when we are insulted for no apparent reason except personal phobias, intransigence and lack of engaging in a mature conversation without slagging off 22 million people as racist and sexist.

MN is a classic for the usual posters insulting anyone from any country - France, EU countries, America, Canada, India etc etc, in their nationalistic frenzy supporting being British. They are ignorant, they don't know what they are talking about, they usually quote a friend of a friend, living in OZ 20 years ago/ arriving with a student/working visa, or keep bleating the same stereotypes they read in the DM.

So yes, if someone calls me a racist and sexist for no reason, my first response is "don't come then". Surely it's a logical consequence for the insult?

CallItLoneliness · 03/04/2023 06:33

The absolute irony of people calling all of Australia "racist". Yes, there is a lot of racism here, but I've seen plenty in the UK too--one of my dearest friends was called a "bogtrotter" at an elite London university by the support staff there (in fairness they didn't realise he was in the room, so that makes it ok, I guess?!). Yes, people (not me) are into sport here but they don't have to separate team supporters in sport grounds. Some Dads are useless here, but nearly every other post on Mumsnet is about a useless Dad. Yes, things are expensive, but I earn double in dollars what I would earn in pounds for the next level up in my job in London.

None of this helps the OP, of course, who needs to have a tricky conversation with her DH to figure out what they will do next. But FFS, get a hold of yourselves and your superiority complex.

Anycrispsleft · 03/04/2023 05:40

Don't do it OP. Stay where you are. The hit to your earnings will all too easily become "it's not worth for you to work" and then you're stuck in his home country with two small kids, and you may not be allowed to return home.

Tourmalines · 03/04/2023 05:21

HoppingPavlova · 02/04/2023 13:33

@emptythelitterbox might be the socioeconomic circle you are in or maybe they do things in public but nothing in private. I've seen that too

I think the issue here is the circles you are moving in! I don’t know any Aussie woman who would put up with the behaviour you have described! I’ve not seen this, no Aussie man would dare pull that, it would not be a pretty ending and they know it😂.

true, think litterbox hangs out with the wrong crowd !

Valeriekat · 03/04/2023 05:12

Shane Warne used to take his kids to their local school in Melbourne! That was always a treat.

HoppingPavlova · 02/04/2023 13:33

@emptythelitterbox might be the socioeconomic circle you are in or maybe they do things in public but nothing in private. I've seen that too

I think the issue here is the circles you are moving in! I don’t know any Aussie woman who would put up with the behaviour you have described! I’ve not seen this, no Aussie man would dare pull that, it would not be a pretty ending and they know it😂.

MattDamon · 02/04/2023 12:42

This happened to friends of ours - Brit husband, Aus wife.

They started married life in London, then had a deal to live in Oz for 5 years, then move back to the UK. The wife kept quiet until the 5 years in Oz was up, then turned around and told him she'd file for divorce and do everything possible to keep the kids from him if he tried to force a move.

They stayed together, but their marriage is dead to him. He's been encouraging both kids to consider uni in the UK and is planning on leaving once the youngest is 18. He's been staying in touch with work contacts here, etc. Wife has no idea.

I don't like to be a pessimist, but think about the worst possible outcome and how you'd cope if it happened.

emptythelitterbox · 02/04/2023 12:01

Mouse82 · 02/04/2023 06:46

Good, we don't need your kind here.

And there you are proving my point with the bog standard ignorant xenophobic Aussie cry of, fuck off were full!

I'm a citizen hun so no matter what you think of my skin colour or country of birth, I'm still a citizen.

And we all know what xenophobic and racist "your kind" means.

So ODFOD

Mouse82 · 02/04/2023 06:46

emptythelitterbox · 30/03/2023 05:13

No way would I move to sexist and racist Australia.

Good, we don't need your kind here.

Codlingmoths · 02/04/2023 04:29

But I agree socioeconomic could be a factor

Codlingmoths · 02/04/2023 04:28

That is not what happens around here, either the school friends or my various work colleagues who are mostly male and live further spread around Melbourne than the school friends. As we do half wfh there is a lot of insight into peoples lives, and a lot of logging off for a couple of hours because the wife isn’t well, taking the 3yo to a class, late into the office as dc have an appt, etc etc.

emptythelitterbox · 02/04/2023 02:45

Codlingmoths · 01/04/2023 07:52

Really?? I may moan about my husband sometimes but that is not what dads do around here. We see them at school drop off and pick up, mine is on parental leave so I don’t see them anymore as he does everything right now! He’s taken the 3dc all shoe shopping in the last few weeks, etc etc, dads coach football and basketball teams, dads cook dinner, the dads are more likely than the mums to be working big jobs but they are pretty present.

might be the socioeconomic circle you are in or maybe they do things in public but nothing in private. I've seen that too. Make a big presence at school, activities, outings but wouldn't even bother to get their own child a cup of water. Watches his wife struggling carrying in a bunch of things and then the last small item, asks she if needs help. Wife who also works gets up early to clean their massive home while he takes the kids out for breakfast.

endoftheworldniteclub · 01/04/2023 08:01

Valeriekat · 31/03/2023 16:45

I have to admit that the people I know who have moved back are very rich! And retired.

Yeah, I bet. You’d want a nice house in a nice location to live there. I think since we’re in a Scandinavian country many have become used to free nurseries and schools, free healthcare, great maternity leave etc and also being able to travel in Europe as everything is so close. And the older they get, the more you appreciate things like that. But, it is a beautiful country no doubt.

Codlingmoths · 01/04/2023 07:52

emptythelitterbox · 31/03/2023 23:02

Agree. The weather is nice but that's about it. I got here before prices on houses rose drastically.
I bought at 300k and sold at over 2 million so I lucked out that way before I left.

A nice house is over 1 million.
It's very blokeish still and quite sexist, racist, xenophobic.

It's funny you mention being Americanized and it is but not something you'd dare say out loud as you may get punched. Americans are hated there.

If she did go back, I suspect her Aussie husband would fall right back into that bloke culture where he'd be acting like a single man hanging out drinking with his mates and she'd be stuck with all the childcare and everything to do with the home

Really?? I may moan about my husband sometimes but that is not what dads do around here. We see them at school drop off and pick up, mine is on parental leave so I don’t see them anymore as he does everything right now! He’s taken the 3dc all shoe shopping in the last few weeks, etc etc, dads coach football and basketball teams, dads cook dinner, the dads are more likely than the mums to be working big jobs but they are pretty present.

emptythelitterbox · 31/03/2023 23:02

Crikeyalmighty · 31/03/2023 21:26

@emptythelitterbox I have a friend out there with Aussie husband, she likes the weather but that's it really -she described it as Essex in the sun and to live in what we (and she) consider a nice ish area is London money . She too said it's very much about booze and sport and quite blokeish (although not as bad as it was) - and very American too in many ways.

Agree. The weather is nice but that's about it. I got here before prices on houses rose drastically.
I bought at 300k and sold at over 2 million so I lucked out that way before I left.

A nice house is over 1 million.
It's very blokeish still and quite sexist, racist, xenophobic.

It's funny you mention being Americanized and it is but not something you'd dare say out loud as you may get punched. Americans are hated there.

If she did go back, I suspect her Aussie husband would fall right back into that bloke culture where he'd be acting like a single man hanging out drinking with his mates and she'd be stuck with all the childcare and everything to do with the home

Hairyfairy01 · 31/03/2023 21:40

Nope, I don't blame you for getting cold feet. Having children puts a different perspective on things. You aren't close to your sister, you are close to your parents. Your parents will have no one near by to advocate for them if needed. Your dc will quickly not want to come back to the UK and you will be stuck there indefinitely, unless you chose to leave your dc in Australia and potentially miss out on grandchildren etc. you will have no rights to bring your dc back to the UK without your dh's permission. I just wouldn't risk it. But you do need to be honest with your dh and be prepared for him to be very disappointed.

Crikeyalmighty · 31/03/2023 21:26

@emptythelitterbox I have a friend out there with Aussie husband, she likes the weather but that's it really -she described it as Essex in the sun and to live in what we (and she) consider a nice ish area is London money . She too said it's very much about booze and sport and quite blokeish (although not as bad as it was) - and very American too in many ways.