Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being quiet in lessons? Year 12 report

81 replies

Stugs · 29/03/2023 07:29

Dd is in year 12. She's just had a written report which her school does once a year. She's doing PE A level and one of the teachers wrote that "Snugsdd is quiet in lessons, and one if the quieter pupils in the class, however despite this she has an excellent grasp of the topic and performed well in the recent tests".

She had a really good report with Excellent for learning for all subjects/topics apart from that one which was Good.

I'm really happy with her report and she knows I'm proud of her for getting her head down and working hard (she's been unwell). She's working at grades B mostly with the odd A. She's needled by the comment as she doesn't think she is quiet at all!

This is just a question to (genuinely!) ask if you are a teacher why is being quiet in lessons a bad thing? She says there are two very loud girls who play solitaire (!) in lessons and shout out who the teacher really likes as they do the sport that he teaches- this is just what dd has told me obviously not sure how true that is.

OP posts:
booksbooks8 · 29/03/2023 11:28

I'd personally look at it like this and if offering feedback to my daughter I'd attempt to phrase it in this way.

There's nothing inherently wrong in your daughter's learning style, we all learn in different ways, but to get the best out of a group of students, all with their own personalities, and for a teacher to give their best,( again every teacher is different), sometimes a teacher may imply that students need to learn to slightly modify the behaviour that comes most naturally to them to achieve the best overall outcome.

So while in her other classes her type of intervention is fitting really well with both the teacher and the other students, in PE slightly less so.
It's not a case of right and wrong just that maybe the PE teacher would appreciate her input as it would improve the class dynamic as a whole, both in the students' ability to learn but also the teacher's ability to engage with her or possibly hear and comment on new and varied ideas.

Adaptation to your environment is a positive skill to have, and while it can seem frustrating to be told/asked different things from different people if you focus on that, rather than it being a criticism on her character, then she may feel been about the report.

2bazookas · 29/03/2023 11:26

"being quiet in lessons" can translate as " Rarely asks questions, or puts her hand up to answer them". Or it could just mean she's a grafter who gets her head down and works well, undistracted by daft loud girls.

She's doing well. that's all that matters

Streamside · 29/03/2023 11:13

Redminionpenguin · 29/03/2023 08:42

I wish teachers would think before they put/say comments like this. It can be very detrimental.
Dc1 was told this in every report and every parents evening. Has asd, struggles with communication, never was a behavioural issue, just wanted to be invisible in class. It caused issues with not wanting to go to school because felt had to speak but couldn't.
Dc2 also asd and selective mutism (although has improved lots). Was distraught last parents evening because every teacher said she needed to speak in class. She had been trying her best and when possible aiming to answer one question a lesson. She's doing exceptionally well academically (gcse predictions of all 8s but expected higher). It's actually done the opposite of what the teachers want she's stopped answering questions at all because the pressure is to much.

So true, why has the teacher not focused on trying to involve her more.
I was a very quiet child from a troubled background and always remember a school report saying I was quiet but not always good.This was from a teacher who assaulted several pupils in our class.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 29/03/2023 11:09

So, your perfect DD is pissed off at her teacher because she didn’t perform well enough to get a prize and it’s the teacher’s fault for not saying she’s better than she actually is rather than her fault for not doing enough?

She’s so perfect that she’s taking three subjects that aren’t particularly academic but you look down on the other students in her class because they aren’t particularly academic?

She’s so perfect and so surrounded by people beneath her yet she’s not working at her target grade?

And you believe the teacher has lowered her effort grade and given negative feedback on her report because she’s actually doing everything she’s supposed to do perfectly but the teacher wants her to piss about and not pay attention instead?

Does that sound reasonable and logical to you?

Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 11:00

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:58

Well they often haven't done the work tbf. But apologies if I've triggered you.

Triggered? How do you figure that? Just because I think your attitude stinks?

Why don't you concern yourself with what's best for your daughter (which is, afterall why the teachers have given you the feedback) rather than looking down on other children to get her to compare favourably?

Chickenly · 29/03/2023 10:59

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:54

Thanks. Dd is pretty sure she does contribute- just doesn't shout over people.

Respectfully, do you really think a teacher is complaining that your DD contributes but doesn’t shout over others? You’re very defensive here and seem to think any comment other than that she’s entirely perfect in every way is some kind of attack. Why would the teacher want your DD to shout over others?

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:58

Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 10:54

Jeez OP, defensive much? Your DD got good feedback with some polite comments re contributing more. And that leads you to slag off other students suggesting anyone who does speal up in class is doing so becuase they've not done their work and PE is the only subject they can manage. Shitty attitude.

Fact is at some point your daughter's "queitness" [reluctance to contribute in discussions] may work against her. Wouldn't it be better to positively look at how you can develop her confidence to do that rather than feel offended and proceed to be horrible about people who aren't like her?

Well they often haven't done the work tbf. But apologies if I've triggered you.

OP posts:
Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 10:54

Jeez OP, defensive much? Your DD got good feedback with some polite comments re contributing more. And that leads you to slag off other students suggesting anyone who does speal up in class is doing so becuase they've not done their work and PE is the only subject they can manage. Shitty attitude.

Fact is at some point your daughter's "queitness" [reluctance to contribute in discussions] may work against her. Wouldn't it be better to positively look at how you can develop her confidence to do that rather than feel offended and proceed to be horrible about people who aren't like her?

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:54

Chickenly · 29/03/2023 10:49

Classrooms are a collaborative learning environment and are often discussion driven. By “quiet”, they may mean she doesn’t contribute to discussion, which is an important learning tool. Being “quiet” in her personality is fine but it’s an expectation that students attempt to contribute verbally just as it’s an expectation that students contribute to written work or contribute to practical sessions in practical subjects. Discussing things in class benefits everyone, helps with comprehension and with memory.

It’s not an insult, it’s just a comment.

Thanks. Dd is pretty sure she does contribute- just doesn't shout over people.

OP posts:
Chickenly · 29/03/2023 10:49

Classrooms are a collaborative learning environment and are often discussion driven. By “quiet”, they may mean she doesn’t contribute to discussion, which is an important learning tool. Being “quiet” in her personality is fine but it’s an expectation that students attempt to contribute verbally just as it’s an expectation that students contribute to written work or contribute to practical sessions in practical subjects. Discussing things in class benefits everyone, helps with comprehension and with memory.

It’s not an insult, it’s just a comment.

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:47

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/03/2023 10:45

Gobshites ... Why are you using insults to refer to other pupils? Pupils who are apparently meeting expectations of this level of study that your daughter isn't?

Because this world is full of people who have too much to say for themselves. Quietness is disregarded. I’m totally sick of people who are gobby and full of themselves.

AFWIW my dd is predicted A*. So quiet people can engage🤷🏼‍♀️

Well, there's this. She's predicted an A and working currently at a B. She's one of two predicted As (and funnily enough the other one is also quiet!)

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/03/2023 10:46

And when l was teaching, every class always had people who want to use answering questions as an excuse to disrupt the class. Even at 6th form.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/03/2023 10:45

Gobshites ... Why are you using insults to refer to other pupils? Pupils who are apparently meeting expectations of this level of study that your daughter isn't?

Because this world is full of people who have too much to say for themselves. Quietness is disregarded. I’m totally sick of people who are gobby and full of themselves.

AFWIW my dd is predicted A*. So quiet people can engage🤷🏼‍♀️

Stugs · 29/03/2023 10:36

Bellevu · 29/03/2023 10:28

Gobshites ... Why are you using insults to refer to other pupils? Pupils who are apparently meeting expectations of this level of study that your daughter isn't?

Acknowledge the differences between learning styles and encourage your daughter without putting down others. There's nothing special or superior about leaving the social lifting to others.

Sorry i was replying to a Pp who had said it. I think you've over reacted a bit as she's not having these issues in any other class.

OP posts:
Bellevu · 29/03/2023 10:28

Gobshites ... Why are you using insults to refer to other pupils? Pupils who are apparently meeting expectations of this level of study that your daughter isn't?

Acknowledge the differences between learning styles and encourage your daughter without putting down others. There's nothing special or superior about leaving the social lifting to others.

Stugs · 29/03/2023 09:59

I think part of the problem is that dd knows the difference between interesting and measured discussions- RS and Psychology where both mention her valuable input - and gobshites trying to deflect the course of the lesson because they haven't done the work - PE. I suppose this is inevitable as PE probably appeals to the less academic student (even though its actually quite interesting and rigorous). I realise this makes me sound a bit up myself about dd who is not a huge academic brain but is diligent and hard working (and possibly a bit boring for this teacher!)

OP posts:
NewShoes · 29/03/2023 09:59

At A Level it’s more important than lower down the school that students participate in discussions. It’s what helps deepen understanding for everyone in the class. This year I have one A level group who are very quiet- studious but not terribly keen to participate - and one who are equally as bright but far more talkative. The latter are getting far more out of lessons and covering ideas much faster.

lanthanum · 29/03/2023 09:56

Maybe we need to be feeding back tips to the teachers on how to get our kids speaking more. One teacher, having said DD was quiet, explained that she would ask her easy questions so she could be more confident about answering. DD's response was that easy questions were the worst, because it was more embarrassing if you got them wrong. She was an able pupil, so it's unlikely the harder questions would have been a problem for her.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/03/2023 09:55

Gymrabbit · 29/03/2023 07:39

If I said a child was quiet in class it wouldn’t mean they didn’t chat, it would mean they never contribute to discussion or attempt to answer questions. This is not a good thing, especially at A level as it suggests a lack of engagement and interest in the subject.
you can be a quiet person and still attempt to answer questions and/or contribute especially when working in pairs or small groups.

See my daughter has ASD and is quiet as a mouse in class. Hates group work. She is however engaged and enjoys her subjects.

27 years as a secondary teacher and l hate ‘so and so is quiet in class’ as if it’s a bad thing. When you’ve got 30 gobshites in a class it’s a nightmare. Quiet people are as important as noisy people. It’s disgusting the way school kids are described as ‘quiet’ like it’s a bad thing.

Oysterbabe · 29/03/2023 09:51

My DD is only 7 but her teachers say this about her too. She's very bright and has lots of good ideas and they want her to contribute more to class discussions, put her hand up and answer more questions. She's a bit shy and doesn't like attention so would prefer to sit back and watch.
She's getting better at it.

Stugs · 29/03/2023 09:46

AtomicBlondeRose · 29/03/2023 09:45

That’s not making life easier for me as a teacher, it’s about making the learning environment in the classroom better for all students. Trust me, a class full of silent writing students is the easiest thing!

OK I will talk to her about speaking up although I suspect she is now slightly mutinous!

OP posts:
AtomicBlondeRose · 29/03/2023 09:45

That’s not making life easier for me as a teacher, it’s about making the learning environment in the classroom better for all students. Trust me, a class full of silent writing students is the easiest thing!

Stugs · 29/03/2023 09:41

AtomicBlondeRose · 29/03/2023 09:36

From a teacher's point of view it's massively frustrating (especially in a small class) to have someone sitting there, taking everything in, listening, and knowing the answers and having good points to make but not offering them. A successful class relies on everyone playing their part and someone sat silently in a corner isn't contributing anything. Sure, some people have a quieter personality - you don't think teachers know that? But it can be a huge drawback in life as well as at school and we are trying to teach life skills as well as our subjects!

A piece of feedback I often get in observed A-level lessons is that the same students answer the questions/dominate discussions. It's true and not ideal but at the same time they're the students who are happiest to speak out and will quickly chip in with opinions. They're not the cleverest students necessarily or have the right ideas but they are sparky and keep discussion going when otherwise it would be me droning on. Sitting passively making notes or writing might look like being a "good" student but actually it's not. Quietness is not a proxy for learning.

I can totally understand this but then again it's about making life easier for you as a teacher - dd likes to take everything in. I know she's said that particular lesson often gets derailed by discussion of the local school hockey results and she's worried they are going to miss something. It's PE, so on the surface discussing results is fine - it's not the sport she does but I suppose it is relevant

OP posts:
Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 09:39

Well presumably it's meant to be a comment on not contributing in class - in dicsussion, answering questions etc. Which could suggest that she doesn't understand it. So what they are saying it that even though she doesn't contribute she still is doing well.

Also being able to contribute to group discussion and answering questions is a beneficial skill (although not one that should be expected at 12)

AtomicBlondeRose · 29/03/2023 09:38

By the way I am an introvert who would like to be left alone to work quietly but it's never worked out that way. At school/uni I was often the only person who would contribute to discussions at all. It was annoying for me as I would have liked to bounce my ideas off someone other than just the teacher.

Swipe left for the next trending thread