Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go straight to CMS?

240 replies

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 07:16

My baby is a week old. Father and I are no longer together. He contributed nothing, and I mean absolutely nothing during my pregnancy. He's bought not a single thing.

He has seen baby twice since the birth and did appear to dote on them... has asked for photos every day however has made it clear he is busy for the next week or so with work so won't be seeing baby again for a while.

He also turned up empty handed on both visits (I'm not sure if I WBU to expect he might turn up with a small gift for baby).

Anyway- money isn't an issue. He earns 6 figures.

AIBU to go straight to CMS (I am registering baby this week)?

OR should I wait a month or so a give him a chance to make an offer to help support her?

OP posts:
StylishM · 29/03/2023 11:29

Just go to CMS, it's the best thing for your child to have financial security and he's not done anything throughout pregnancy or her first week of life to support her. He could've turned up with nappies, wipes, clothes and offered to purchase some of the baby equipment. He's already shown you his intention is not to contribute unless he has to!

Do it for your daughter.

Limer · 29/03/2023 11:23

Just go to CMS and don't feel a shred of guilt about it. Your baby, via you as her sole resident parent, is entitled to money from her father.

2bazookas · 29/03/2023 11:21

FIRST, you have a conversation with him and say "We're going to talk about both of our financial support for our baby." CMS is a back up, don't go to war yet.

The fact a man brought no present is nothing. If he's thought at all it would be something like "What the hell does a newborn like? No idea, so I'll play safe and wait till she asks".

If you can come to a willing, consensual agreement about maintenance, contact etc it will be so much betteer for your baby (and sanity) in the long run.

Be pleased he's doting; and encourage it.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 29/03/2023 11:18

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 08:11

I find it hard to talk to him about money. And as I've said when I brought it up when I was pregnant it didn't go down overly well and he was very vague.

He wanted me to have an abortion so had made quite a few comments a long the way about how if I chose this I would need to support the baby. I don't want to go into whole back story but we were in a long term relationship and mainly split up because of his desire for me to have an abortion (after 12 weeks when he decided he didn't want the baby).

I guess that's why I'm so reluctant to bring it up myself. I could definitely do with some help supporting her. I could do it myself but would be very tight.

He had sex with you, presumably he realised that pregnancy was a risk.

He's earning 6 figures... You shouldn't just have to 'scrape by'.

Look at the cms calculator... Know what the bear minumum he should be paying... Id open negotiating... And ask for more than this... (to account fir hus lack of support during pregnancy /set up costs).

If you think jes unlikely to pay, go CMS all the way... Hes presumably relying on your anxiety about discussing this to get out of paying a reasonable amount.

His helping 'where he can' may be like a friends' exes... One offered her 20£ weekly 🤣🤣... Where he should have been paying many times this.. The other promised 200£.monthly and paid it for 6.months, then stopped... The child is now at uni.

CrotchetyQuaver · 29/03/2023 11:16

I think bearing in mind the background you should tell him when the birth registration appointment is and ask him if he wants to come too so he can be put on the birth certificate as the father.

As he made comments in the past about you going it alone afterwards if you continued with the pregnancy then I would just go straight to CMS as I would expect him to be difficult. If he isn't on the birth certificate then he'll possibly insist on a DNA test first...

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 11:10

I'm far more comfortable personally if CMS sort things out as I don't want to deal with him directly and would rather keep it all official.

I just didn't know if I was jumping the gun by not giving him the chance to offer/step up.

Seems like the general consensus is just to go to CMS.

OP posts:
Netcam · 29/03/2023 11:04

The other difficulty is if you don't go through the CMS, you will have to renegotiate the amount each year with him as his salary increases. CMS will automatically base the amount on a percentage of his salary.

KatherineJaneway · 29/03/2023 11:02

Sorry you are going though this.

It sounds like he has convinced himself that by telling you he won't contribute and doesn't want the baby, that he won't have to pay. Expect him to be very angry when you contact CMS and he gets that letter. But this is not just about you anymore, he needs to provide for his child and regardless of how he reacts, you are doing the right thing.

He is only taking photos and wanted to be at the birth to try and show his family and his mates that he is a 'good guy'. Nothing else. He will not change now and step up and fulfil his responsibilities so best to banish any hope of that occurring.

Netcam · 29/03/2023 10:58

I would go through the CMS. They do the calculation based on his income which they obtain from HMRC. As long as he pays what they say he should there is no surcharge. And if he refuses to pay you can go back to them and they will add 20% and collect it from his salary. That should be a good enough incentive to pay, it certainly was for my ex. I think using the CMS puts a boundary between you and him so you don't have to discuss finances directly, which is useful if things are difficult between you.

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:45

Just wanted to say thank you for all the responses as well, it's really helpful to read everyone's thoughts.

I'm finding it such a tough situation and not sure what to do for best.

OP posts:
taxpayer1 · 29/03/2023 10:43

Tarantella6 · 29/03/2023 07:38

If he owes you £100, he'll have to pay £120 to CMS. If he's a high earner that 20% could be quite a lot, maybe enough to motivate him to just do the right thing?!

Just text him and say you're going to use CMS. If he earns 6 figures he's capable of using Google and figuring out the amount due.

As usual, the wrong information was provided. 20% is added only if he is moved to Collect and Pay if he misses any payment. The correct approach would be to use the CMS calculator and ask him to provide maintenance based on that figure as a minimum. Once you go to CMS, he will pay you that but don't be surprised if he doesn't contribute to anything else. CMS is a terrible organization that pitches one parent against the other to collect its 24% fee (20% from the paying parent and 4% from the receiving parent

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:43

@ozoruk1 he's not self employed thankfully.

OP posts:
Minfilia · 29/03/2023 10:42

Do you know how much he should be paying?

If so you could sound him out with a polite message along the lines of “Hi X, I have looked into the amount of child maintenance that we should set up and it’s £X per month, would you like to set up a direct debit now or would you prefer to do it through CMS?”

However the comment of “he will contribute where he can” makes me wonder if you should just go straight to CMS as it doesn’t seem that he has any intention of regularly paying…

Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 10:41

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:36

@SpinningFloppa we were together 3 years and the baby was planned. We tried for a baby for 5 months. We are both in our 30s. I didn't pressure him or anything like that.

He decided after we went for the 12 week scan that he actually wasn't ready and asked me to have an abortion.

Gosh, he sounds like a dick.

OP don't feel bad telling him he needs to contribute. It's the least he cn do. I would probably try work out what CMS would tell him to pay and say to him you expect maintenace payments of xxx a month, and it would be handy for him to start next week. If he refuses/ doesn't respond then go to CMS without a moment's hesitation. The reason I would do it that way is to give him a heads up before the CMS claim comes to him. Not because you owe it to him, but you are going to have to coparent together for the next 18 years or so, so I would at least try to start off with some line of communication between you.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 10:41

100% CMS straight away, you just don't to want to ever be in the position many people are where the baby's father just doesn't bother paying.

My cousin has had terrible issues with her ex not contributing enough, she asked for a tiny amount more after over 10 years of no increases (£20 a month that's all) he refused so she went to CMS and they are making him pay £150 a month more now which of course he's unhappy with, he offered to pay £100 instead but she said no that he had his chance and couldn't even be bothered to pay £20 when she asked so tough! He wanted to go travelling with his new partner (who he had cheated on my cousin with) so didn't want to pay any more maintenance!

BelleMarionette · 29/03/2023 10:39

I would say talk to him first, but you updated to say you did mention it in pregnancy.

Maybe ask him to pay as per CMS rates again, otherwise you will need to use CMS?

CMS does have fees, so it would be better for that money to go to the baby.

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:36

@SpinningFloppa we were together 3 years and the baby was planned. We tried for a baby for 5 months. We are both in our 30s. I didn't pressure him or anything like that.

He decided after we went for the 12 week scan that he actually wasn't ready and asked me to have an abortion.

OP posts:
zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:35

Daleksatemyshed · 29/03/2023 10:24

@BeExcellent2EachOther made my point about photos much more clearly. He's not helping but he's probably showing off his baby to his mates and letting them think he's being a good Dad. Why should he get to take any credit and do nothing

I agree with this and this is probably what he is doing... he was desperate to be at the birth and I couldn't understand why given he hasn't given me and help at all during the pregnancy. I think it was because he wanted to be able to tell people he was there and look like a good Dad.

OP posts:
Sunsetandsmiles · 29/03/2023 10:33

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:05

@Sunsetandsmiles we aren't/weren't married so I can't put him on the BC anyway without him being there.

I know he can go on this at a later date if he goes down that route and I'm prepared for that.

I understand if he denies to CMS that it may go to a DNA test etc. but my understanding is they would backdate it to the date I contacted them so even if it takes some time to sort it won't mean he gets out of paying?

They will backdate it but all that will do is add an arrears onto your claim. From personal experience, They’ll give a monthly amount to be paid and add a very small percentage on each month to chip away at the arrears but unless he is earning a lot that amount is usually negligible.

Daleksatemyshed · 29/03/2023 10:24

@BeExcellent2EachOther made my point about photos much more clearly. He's not helping but he's probably showing off his baby to his mates and letting them think he's being a good Dad. Why should he get to take any credit and do nothing

Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 29/03/2023 10:22

Do you know roughly how much he earns? If so put it into the cms calculator and send him the screenshot and see what his reply is. If he gets mad then go straight to cms, if he wants to have a calm, rational chat about it then hear him out , then decide what route you want to go down. Is he an employee or self employed?

SpinningFloppa · 29/03/2023 10:21

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:03

@SpinningFloppa I know he wouldn't have had to pay CM until baby born... I just assume a decent person would have offered to buy some baby bits before she got here, but he left it all to me.

Yeah but I’m guessing since you’ve already broken up the baby wasn’t planned? So perhaps that’s why he hasn’t wanted to contributed during the pregnancy as he wasn’t happy about it?

ozoruk1 · 29/03/2023 10:19

is he self employed OP? Be wary if so as if makes it much easier for them to get away with paying the bare minimum even if they earn 6 figures

Pink139 · 29/03/2023 10:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as we do not believe that the poster is genuine.

AwayThenBack · 29/03/2023 10:15

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 10:03

@SpinningFloppa I know he wouldn't have had to pay CM until baby born... I just assume a decent person would have offered to buy some baby bits before she got here, but he left it all to me.

But he’s clearly not a decent person. You already know this from his behaviour during your pregnancy , both when together and when your split. He has bought nothing for his child and hasn’t mentioned paying his way. He’s not decent. You should go via CMS and receive what your baby is entitled to from their father. I would use PP wording and email/write to him saying you wish to keep things neutral and have therefore applied to CMS to sort maintenance to keep it easier for you both however this is the minimum and he should contribute to other costs of the baby as and when needed. He sounds delightful 🙄