Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go straight to CMS?

240 replies

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 07:16

My baby is a week old. Father and I are no longer together. He contributed nothing, and I mean absolutely nothing during my pregnancy. He's bought not a single thing.

He has seen baby twice since the birth and did appear to dote on them... has asked for photos every day however has made it clear he is busy for the next week or so with work so won't be seeing baby again for a while.

He also turned up empty handed on both visits (I'm not sure if I WBU to expect he might turn up with a small gift for baby).

Anyway- money isn't an issue. He earns 6 figures.

AIBU to go straight to CMS (I am registering baby this week)?

OR should I wait a month or so a give him a chance to make an offer to help support her?

OP posts:
Scont · 05/06/2023 15:44

Your texts would have no bearing on his requirement to pay via cms.

Morningcoffeeview · 05/06/2023 15:42

No, whatever you said is irrelevant he is the father and therefore owes CMS. There’s no legal “out” for him here.

Netcam · 05/06/2023 15:41

I would just go to CMS. It means you don't need to spend the next 18 years discussing this with him. There is an external decision maker. Wish I'd done the same with my ex when we split, I did in the end but it would have been much easier if I'd done it at the start.

zzzzebra · 05/06/2023 15:38

Updating as CMS has finally contact him and I need advice.

He's had sporadic contact with baby and went over 6 weeks without seeing them. We recently met in a public place for him to see baby and CMS happened to phone him while we were together!

He became extremely angry with me, and threatened to "take me to court". He said he has text messages saved where I have said I will continue the pregnancy and have the baby without his help therefore I shouldn't be going to CMS.

Can he do anything with this?

OP posts:
Mumsanetta · 29/03/2023 17:34

@zzzzebra i wouldn’t bother engaging with goady fuckers. Like all trolls, they feed off attention and disappear when they’re ignored.

Naunet · 29/03/2023 17:01

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 16:20

@TwinsAndTiramisu where on earth have I said arguments throughout? Inventing things again.

Where have I said I asked for money which I'm not entitled to? I never asked for money at all.

I simply said along the lines of "are you planning on supporting her or helping me get anything ready?" And he was vague and said he'd help where he could (but never did).

I called the police because I was genuinely scared. I'm not going to be made to feel bad about protecting myself and my baby.

I'm not going to be made to feel bad about not reconciling with someone who scared me and wanted me to abort my baby.

Despite me not wanting to reconcile, he did say at times he wanted to be involved but this went hot, cold, hot, cold and his actions never demonstrated that he was reliable.

I NEVER blocked him from the pregnancy, I said I kept contact minimal.

It's MY birth and I am the patient, I wasn't comfortable having him there. He came straight after. I'm not going to be guilted for that either.

Like you want my life story or something!

You are completely missing the point here- his actions at the moment don't match up. Take away all the above. Right now he is playing doting Dad and saying how much he loves her and life is amazing, even said he will never let her down. But not making any plans to financially support in her upbringing.

You were 100% right not to have him at the birth, how would that have benefited you or the baby at all? It probably would have made it much harder for you.
Some women just bend over backwards to make excuses for dickhead men, just ignore it.

rwalker · 29/03/2023 16:36

The thing is it’s different and it’s real now

have a blunt chat about everything from access to money

as stupid as it sounds until the babies there it doesn’t seem real to some guys

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 16:29

He has seen baby twice since the birth and did appear to dote on them... has asked for photos every day however has made it clear he is busy for the next week or so with work so won't be seeing baby again for a while.

He's turned up twice and is now busy for the foreseeable. They are your words. I wouldn't call that doting dad.

I'm not inventing anything. From your previous discussions about money you said they didn't go down well. It's not an invention to interpret that as an argument.

This isn't about misrepresentation of guilt or someone trying to make you feel bad. If someone was that appalling you had to call the police, and told you to abort you child, you disregarded for the rest of the pregnancy, refused at the birth, why are you then discussing him as doting dad that you don't want to cause friction with? Why is it even a question?

Daleksatemyshed · 29/03/2023 16:29

Just a thought Op, when he suddenly turned on you in your pregnancy, I wonder if there was someone else. If a man's been lying to another woman that his relationship has been over for ages then a baby on the way is hard to cover.

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 16:20

@TwinsAndTiramisu where on earth have I said arguments throughout? Inventing things again.

Where have I said I asked for money which I'm not entitled to? I never asked for money at all.

I simply said along the lines of "are you planning on supporting her or helping me get anything ready?" And he was vague and said he'd help where he could (but never did).

I called the police because I was genuinely scared. I'm not going to be made to feel bad about protecting myself and my baby.

I'm not going to be made to feel bad about not reconciling with someone who scared me and wanted me to abort my baby.

Despite me not wanting to reconcile, he did say at times he wanted to be involved but this went hot, cold, hot, cold and his actions never demonstrated that he was reliable.

I NEVER blocked him from the pregnancy, I said I kept contact minimal.

It's MY birth and I am the patient, I wasn't comfortable having him there. He came straight after. I'm not going to be guilted for that either.

Like you want my life story or something!

You are completely missing the point here- his actions at the moment don't match up. Take away all the above. Right now he is playing doting Dad and saying how much he loves her and life is amazing, even said he will never let her down. But not making any plans to financially support in her upbringing.

OP posts:
taxpayer1 · 29/03/2023 16:13

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 16:10

@zzzzebra I have to concur, it is weird.

You were trying for a baby. Conceived. All was fine, then at the 12 week point, he said the reality was, he wasn't ready for this, which ended up with the police involved. 8 weeks later he wants to reconcile. You don't want that. Arguments throughout when you ask for money which you're not entitled to, (because you've decided you don't want to be with him, and he's got no obligation to pay for your lone pregnancy) He asks to be at birth. You refuse. Wonder if it's unreasonable to have expected him to turn up with a teddy for "HIS CHILD". Now you're wondering if it will upset the apple cart to go directly to CMS. I think given the history, blocking him from the pregnancy, the birth, the police involvement, that's a horse that's pretty much bolted.

I think you need to ask yourself what you seriously want from this guy. Do you want him as a co parent, after having to call the police on him? I guess you must be hoping he plays this role or you wouldn't be querying whether he gets upset due to CMS action. Maybe take a few more days to let your body and mind heal from birth, to ascertain if this person is someone you are happy to leave your child with, for extended periods. From what you've said, yes, he'll get shitty if you involve CMS. You need to ask yourself, in the bigger picture and future of your child, does that matter?

It is clear what she wants. Money.

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 16:10

@zzzzebra I have to concur, it is weird.

You were trying for a baby. Conceived. All was fine, then at the 12 week point, he said the reality was, he wasn't ready for this, which ended up with the police involved. 8 weeks later he wants to reconcile. You don't want that. Arguments throughout when you ask for money which you're not entitled to, (because you've decided you don't want to be with him, and he's got no obligation to pay for your lone pregnancy) He asks to be at birth. You refuse. Wonder if it's unreasonable to have expected him to turn up with a teddy for "HIS CHILD". Now you're wondering if it will upset the apple cart to go directly to CMS. I think given the history, blocking him from the pregnancy, the birth, the police involvement, that's a horse that's pretty much bolted.

I think you need to ask yourself what you seriously want from this guy. Do you want him as a co parent, after having to call the police on him? I guess you must be hoping he plays this role or you wouldn't be querying whether he gets upset due to CMS action. Maybe take a few more days to let your body and mind heal from birth, to ascertain if this person is someone you are happy to leave your child with, for extended periods. From what you've said, yes, he'll get shitty if you involve CMS. You need to ask yourself, in the bigger picture and future of your child, does that matter?

curtaintwitcher23 · 29/03/2023 16:03

You have expressed your situation perfectly and I think you must be incredibly strong to have gone through your pregnancy and birth alone while facing such heartbreak and your baby will be inspired by you when she eventually understands.

Personally I'd send him a link to the calculator and schedule a formal chat in a neutral public setting preferably without baby where you can discuss the future for your daughter and what part (financial and otherwise) he's going to play in it.
Make it clear in writing what the agenda of the chat will be so he can't act surprised.
If it goes badly then you can go straight to CMS.

Out of interest is his family not interested in playing a role in their granddaughter/ niece / nephew's life
If this was my son I'd be mortified and offering you all the support I possibly could to have a relationship.

Comii9 · 29/03/2023 16:00

Aftjbtibg · 29/03/2023 07:23

Before you go to CMS why don’t you ask him what he is going to provide rather than waiting for him to offer

Legally as a parent you have a moral obligation to contribute to the upbringing on your own child. One would think this is quite obvious, no?

OP should not have to ask or tell anybody this. She's waited 9 months during the pregnancy. Go to CMS because it will be more reliable OP.

whattodo22222 · 29/03/2023 15:49

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 13:16

I don't understand the posters at all that are saying that I shouldn't have continued with the pregnancy because he changed his mind?

It seems awful to me to abort a baby after 12 weeks that was planned?

And this wasn't what my post was about at all.

Some people just want to find a way to blame women for everything. Call it internalised misogyny.

Congratulations on your new baby OP.

I would agree with PP and say get in touch with CMS ASAP. If you feel up to it, have one conversation with him where you ask him to pay willingly but don't let this issue consume your time with your baby and ruin your maternity leave.

I'm going back to work in May and it goes so quickly! I know everyone says that but it's so true, try and create a life with as little stress as possible and outsource this particular stress to CMS. Good luck

Daleksatemyshed · 29/03/2023 15:27

He made a bad choice but he may feel differently now there's an actual baby but that's not your problem. I'd get the money issues sorted and not let him dictate to you about contact. If he wants to be a Father now he'll have to change his ways. Don't let him dictate to you about photos or when he sees the baby, sort out proper arrangements. He's either in or he's not

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 15:24

@TwinsAndTiramisu you've completely gone off on a tangent here, and a weird one at that.

All I was asking was about financial support, for a child he helped create, willingly.

The mention of the fact he hasn't contributed to preparing for her or made any gestures such as a token teddy or "something" since she has been born, is for context. These actions say to me that he probably isn't going to willingly contribute.

All I was asking was if I WBU to go to CMS now or should I give him more time given he's doing his doting Dad business rn.

And BTW- you have absolutely NO IDEA what happened. He didn't simply tell me nicely he didn't want her and ask me to consider abortion. He ruined what should have been one of the most special days of my life by cornering me inside the dining room and screaming in my face to have an abortion and that I was ruining his life. He's never scared me or been abusive or aggressive but I was so scared that I called the police.

So before you keep inventing things, making assumptions and putting words inside his and my mouth- maybe stop and think.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 29/03/2023 15:17

Fluffodils · 29/03/2023 08:01

Yeah just say you don't want it to become a contentious issue so are just going to ask CMS to handle it.

I'd also do this. But let him know if baby needs anything.

Naunet · 29/03/2023 15:10

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 15:04

He's entitled, to say, I made a mistake, I'm not ready for this, I can't do this. But he can't make a choice, nor expected too. That's solely OP. He just told her what he wanted, not demanded or forced her to go along with it.

When I was expecting DTwins, I was so sick, I genuinely thought of a termination. DH was aghast. And there would have been sod all he could have done if I'd decided too. That's all men can do. State how they feel, then that's it, they get the decision we make. Two people conceive, absolutely. Then one person holds all the power. It's right that women do, but women then have to be equally accountable for that, not just "well, he got me pregnant."

No, that’s not all he did, he told her that he wasn’t going to be a parent (in so many words) as it was her choice to have the baby. That’s bullshit, that’s tricking a woman into pregnancy and being a single mother. That’s bringing a life into this world that you then intend to just abandon, and that does seem to be a choice for men, just opt out.

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 15:04

Naunet · 29/03/2023 14:58

He sure as hell seemed to think it was.

He's entitled, to say, I made a mistake, I'm not ready for this, I can't do this. But he can't make a choice, nor expected too. That's solely OP. He just told her what he wanted, not demanded or forced her to go along with it.

When I was expecting DTwins, I was so sick, I genuinely thought of a termination. DH was aghast. And there would have been sod all he could have done if I'd decided too. That's all men can do. State how they feel, then that's it, they get the decision we make. Two people conceive, absolutely. Then one person holds all the power. It's right that women do, but women then have to be equally accountable for that, not just "well, he got me pregnant."

Naunet · 29/03/2023 14:58

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 14:58

Abortion is not a male contraceptive choice.

100% correct. No one said it should be.

He sure as hell seemed to think it was.

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 14:58

Abortion is not a male contraceptive choice.

100% correct. No one said it should be.

Naunet · 29/03/2023 14:56

zzzzebra · 29/03/2023 13:16

I don't understand the posters at all that are saying that I shouldn't have continued with the pregnancy because he changed his mind?

It seems awful to me to abort a baby after 12 weeks that was planned?

And this wasn't what my post was about at all.

They’re dick panderers who think men should have the right to plan a baby with a woman and then force her to get an abortion when he later changes his mind, because women are just vessels after all.

Abortion is not a male contraceptive choice.

Naunet · 29/03/2023 14:54

Jesus OP, shrug this guilt off your shoulders! He planned for and wanted this baby, abortion isn’t a contraception choice for flakey men. He doesn’t get to not pay for the baby he planned and helped make, he doesn’t get to change his mind afterwards, it’s too fucking late. You should feel angry, not guilty. Angry that he planned to bring this life into the world and then changed his mind as if it was a dish at a restaurant, he then tried to push you into having an abortion, and then declared he wasn’t going to be a proper parent to this life he helped create. He’s had 9 months to get used to it, he doesn’t need any more time.

I think women these days are so terrified of being labelled a gold digger that they keep fucking themselves over to prove to shithead men that they aren’t one. But this money isn’t for you, it’s for your baby and you are simply your baby’s advocate. I’d text him and tell him you’re just about to put in a CMS claim but thought you’d run it past him first to see if he would prefer a private arrangement - if he does though, do NOT accept any less than the CMS amount.

TwinsAndTiramisu · 29/03/2023 14:53

I mean, what if instead of changing his mind at 12 weeks pregnant he had changed his mind after the birth? Would he still have been able to shirk his responsibilities as a father at that stage?

Well, yeah? Why are we all doing this faux pretence that men don't just walk away from children? Why the surprise and indignation that they guy who said "I don't want this child" is "too busy" to turn up and hasn't even bought a teddy.

He can't ever walk away from the CMS deducting money from his account, no. Unless he's goes self employed and creative accounting.

But why the whole "so he can just shirk everything else eh????!!!!" when we all know, yes, absolutely, he can, many do, and there's nothing OP can do about that.

You don't have to like it. But it's the truth.