Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this really what 'friends' do?

191 replies

hollypolly12 · 28/03/2023 22:01

Dh and I had our first night out with some friends at weekend since having our 2 year old.

Group of 15 or so of us booked an air bnb in a city about 2hrs from us to celebrate a birthday of one of the friends.

Friday night we had a group message from one friend asking if we can chip in an extra £5pp for the air bnb as one friend had dropped out and not yet paid the air bnb. Fine, whatever. I was a bit put out initially as i didn't get why the friend that dropped out hadn't paid when it was booked months ago. This wasn't a surprise for this particular friend as they often drop out of things last minute.

We had a good night over all. Dh and I have a joint account for things like this so all our spending went on there. We bought lots of round of drinks for friends if we were going to the bar etc. I was only bought a drink once. We in the end spent a small fortune but we didn't mind as it was good to see our friends and we hadn't been out with them for a while.

We drove the 2hrs and took 4 people with us. Friend that asked for air bnb money, in the car said not to pay as we drove. Fine, however still Not sure why it was up to us to cover cost of other friend. Other 3 didn't make a peep about chipping in for fuel or parking.
Again, we actually weren't bothered as that's what friends do?

Until we got a group message from another friend in the group last night asking if everyone could send them £4 each as they went to the shop on the way back to the air bnb and bought some drinks which they offered to share.
I did ask them to get milk so we could have coffee the next morning and they bought the smallest one which I offered money for and at the time they said no.
It's really not about the amount of money, it's the principle of it.

I know for certain that non of them are strapped for cash as we have open conversations about money etc. I know times are hard though but I would never in a million years message the group to ask everyone to pay us back for all the drinks we bought?

Aibu?

OP posts:
rookiemere · 29/03/2023 10:02

How much did you actually spend on drinks that night?

PinkSyCo · 29/03/2023 10:01

If I threw my money around like you did at the weekend I’d feel a bit weird about quibbling over a couple of quid now, unless the person asking for the money is one of the people you gave a lift to and/or bought a lot of drinks for, in which case I might refuse to pay up out of principle.

Emptyandsad · 29/03/2023 10:00

KeepingKeepingOn · 28/03/2023 22:14

I think you could legitimately send a text back to say ‘come on, we don’t really want to do it this way, do we? I mean, I can work out exactly what everyone owes for the rounds of drink we bought, but I’d rather not start trying to account for everything as it changes the dynamics. If people disagree, can I suggest next time we all just pay for ourselves and then we don’t have to keep track?’ Or some such - if you don’t address it, it will set a precedent and it might not be one that the majority actually feel comfortable with.

This - with knobs on

OnlyFannys · 29/03/2023 09:57

I think you have to view the rounds and the other costs differently. You offered to buy people drinks and that is really your treat (personally I would reciprocate but some people are tight).
Parking and petrol you should have asked for a contribution as others did for their costs. The drinks at the end of the night should only have been split between those who had some.
The cost for the unused place should be split if the original drop out wont pay.
I would just match the tone and request petrol and parking contribution fronthose who did not offer anything but I dont think its appropriate to ask for reimbursement for rounds.

rookiemere · 29/03/2023 09:57

Actually I find myself agreeing with @MasterBeth . You were happy to pay for those drinks, an extra £8 is annoying but not worth souring the whole friendship group for.

Pay it up and for next group trip suggest splitwise and ask for petrol money and split parking costs.

hollypolly12 · 29/03/2023 09:56

Lamelie · 29/03/2023 09:41

How much did the weekend cost you?

We spent approx 225+ including fuel and parking. Plus the cost of the air bnb a few months ago.

Honestly, I am over it. I hadn't thought twice about what we spent until we were chased for more money after we got home.

Next time we will just sort ourselves out then there is no confusion 😊

OP posts:
ign0re · 29/03/2023 09:53

Also just to add even though what I said about the round of drinks, it is pretty shitty for people to accept drinks with no intention of buying them back!

ign0re · 29/03/2023 09:52

I think ultimately you’re annoyed at yourself here for buying rounds when that didn’t seem to be the done thing so you just screwed yourself over.

it’s really common that everyone chips in to household goods when using self catering accommodation and honestly I just couldn’t find myself getting annoyed over such little amounts of money!

I say this as someone who recently dropped out of a similar weekend and lost £200, it would’ve been nice if everyone had chipped in and paid me back especially as my partner ended up sharing a room and one of the girls then got a room to herself, but some things you just don’t bother with! Especially amongst friends!

CheshireCat1 · 29/03/2023 09:52

It’s done now, you enjoyed yourself, just move on and don’t put a cloud over it.

NeedToChangeName · 29/03/2023 09:45

We use this app for weekends away with friends. You record what you spend, who is sharing the cost & at the end, it does all the arithmetic to work out the sums due. Really helpful https://www.splitwise.com/

I suppose the difficulty in OP's group is that some people are "we'll all pay bits and pieces and it probably evens out", whereas others are "keep a note of what you spent and ask everyone to pay their share". Both approaches are probably OK, but OP's group aren't consistently applying one rule or the other

Splitwise logo

Split expenses with friends.

Splitwise is a free tool for friends and roommates to track bills and other shared expenses, so that everyone gets paid back. On the web, iPhone, and Android!

https://www.splitwise.com

Lamelie · 29/03/2023 09:41

How much did the weekend cost you?

GordonsAFGirl · 29/03/2023 09:38

I hate this type of situation. I have recently lost a friend because of it. I paid her share of a very expensive birthday lunch £100+. Next time we were out it was me, her and her hungry 18 year old daughter. She asked to spilt the bill, I said no as I no longer drink and didn't want to pay for at least half of her daughter's lunch. Never seen her again socially!
I now just pay for my family.

Itsbytheby · 29/03/2023 09:32

reply, "x, y an z can cover my £4 from their petrol money contribution!"

I couldn't do with having such tight friends. How annoying. That said, it wouldn't have been fair on the booker to have to cover the cost of the friedn who didn't come, I think it's fair enough this is split out.

SpookyBlackCat · 29/03/2023 09:30

I also wonder if the person who asked for the money was someone who you gave a lift to or was someone who you bought drinks for and didn't reciprocate? I think, if so, it's ok to mention it to them and say you'll call it quits, but I think, if not, then just because you bought drinks for others in the group or gave lifts to others in the group, that doesn't really mean anything to the person who bought drinks and snacks for everyone expecting to be paid back.

Time4achangeagain · 29/03/2023 09:29

MasterBeth · 28/03/2023 23:43

Hi,

Not bothered about this at all. Barely thinking about it. Just thought I'd write a passive aggressive note rather than sucking up the £4 extras bill you sent me and feeling slightly superior to you. I think it's much healthier to bring things into the open and pretty much call you money-grabbing and mean when I could just let it go. Also, next time, let's count every penny off on a spreadsheet because that sounds like fun.

Love you lots,

😂

MasterBeth · 29/03/2023 09:26

hollypolly12 · 29/03/2023 09:02

Thanks everyone! Seems majority agree that's. It the done thing.
I agree we were too generous. But like I said, it was nice to be out and they are our friends so regarding petrol and parking and al the drinks we bought we didn't

I think you were generous. I don't think you were too generous.

People like generous people. Generous people are kind. So much better to be thought of as generous rather than mean AND to be generous rather than mean.

Sending out passive aggressive post-event notes moaning about buying rounds makes you look mean when you are actually generous. They are your friends. You had a great time. Don't spoil it now by overthinking it.

The correct response is to suck it up, bitch a bit abut how mean your frineds are and feel morally kind and generous.

ijustneedanamefgs · 29/03/2023 09:25

It depends. Is the person asking someone who returned drinks or not? Someone you drove who didn’t offer fuel money? It could be they are in the same boat as you, and just trying to recoup some of the money because they are feeling hard done by.
If they are one of the cf then ignore it. Though you don’t want bad feelings hanging over the next outing. Maybe just put it down as a cost of learning and know better next time.

Snapdragonsoup · 29/03/2023 09:24

How much did you spend on drinks between how man6 friends (ie how much per person?). I would mention something about this in reply -eg didnt think among friends we were accounting for expenditure like this but if that’s how you want to do it then can I have £x from each of you for the drinks last night please? Great shame it has come to this as it changes the dynamic but if this is how everyone wants to do it from now on then how about next time we all pay for our own drinks and food individually? Any views from everyne else on this please? …. Here are my bank details for BACs transfer and to friend x who wants £4 please deduct that off the amount youneed to transfer to me. Many thanks, Hollypolly.

rookiemere · 29/03/2023 09:23

Thinking about though,even if you had used something like splitwise , OP would still be paying over the odds because heavy drinkers were drinking late when they got back.

It's really hard to have parity in big groups like these, key lessons learned are to clarify at the start what's happening on most costs and don't extend any largesse on the expectation it will be reciprocated.

I'd find it hard to ask friends for petrol money, but easier to say "who wants to pay for the parking?" as it's more obviously a shared expense,

Noicant · 29/03/2023 09:22

I’d say “oh didn’t know we were doing it that way, can everyone send me a tenner for the rounds I bought, you can take that 8 quid off there, don’t worry about petrol it’s our treat”

AppleandSpice · 29/03/2023 09:21

Let this be a lesson to you for the future.

If you don’t think you should cover the cost of the missing guest speak up
If you’d like a contribution towards petrol and parking then say so before hand.
If you are in a large group then be clear before going to the bar whether everyone in participating in rounds ‘before’ buying a round.
If someone has bought alcohol to share and they didn’t specify that it was a shared cost at the time, then ignore the ‘bill’ afterwards.

Next time iron out all the creases beforehand, as you were buying drinks for 15 people and it wasn’t being reciprocated, it’s no wonder you were out of pocket

MelsMoneyTree · 29/03/2023 09:18

It seems like the dynamic of the group has changed from one where you wait for people to offer money - to one where you ask if you want reimbursed. You seem a bit put out they didn't offer petrol money. But also put out that others who did pay for stuff, just asked to be reimbursed. In future ask for petrol money before they even get in the car. Or chalk it and the drink money request, etc, up to another cost of the night and let it go.

Blueuggboots · 29/03/2023 09:17

I hate stuff like this! A group of friends went away for a few days and one of the group kept ordering expensive drinks and then insisting the bill was split equally - cheeky cow!
I always refuse to do rounds because I don't drink alcohol and I end up subsidising everyone else's drinking habits.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2023 09:16

It honestly never fails to surprise me how even very close friends can do this.

That and the insistent bill-splitters, who will cheerfully have the lobster, multiple side orders and numerous cocktails - and then aggressively tell the person who had the pasta salad and a couple of Diet Cokes, who doesn't want/can't afford to massively subsidise them, that "You shouldn't have come to eat out if you couldn't afford it!"

hollypolly12 · 29/03/2023 09:15

MarieRoseMarie · 29/03/2023 09:12

I absolutely hate people like the OP who are always trying to buy rounds and force everyone else to do so. It’s so annoying. Now we have to track when and what everyone else is drinking. It’s pressure to drink more because you have to keep up (even with soft drinks) and it’s a complete waste of money.

I feel like over the last few years most people I know (professionals in their 30s/40s) are just drinking less. People are also just generally eating and drinking at their own pace.

“Generous friend” but whining over £4. Just stop being overbearing and buy your own drinks.

I've already explained it wasn't a round's situation but more of if we went to the bar we would offer, if someone said no that was fine. But a lot of times people said yes. Which was also fine at the time.
I wasn't forcing anybody to do anything 😂

We bought our friends drinks and didn't think twice about it until we were chased for money the night after we got home

OP posts: