Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many people are barely surviving Life in uk is unsustainable!

261 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 28/03/2023 18:54

To think a normal standard of living is out of reach to the majority of the population. People are barely surviving as is.They have cut back as far as they possibly can and it's still not enough.Next month prices are rising even more. I know most people would say cut your cloth accordingly dont live beyond your means. If you stopped netflix and takeout coffee everything will magically be solved. That's not realistic there is people out there stressed wondering how they will afford the Bill's barely eating sitting in a cold house as they cant afford to heat the house. Yes there will be people on their high horse saying things are not that bad. But the uk has gone to pot. Wages arent high enough. Food prices are too high. This is just a general rant as its constantly on the news. And some people are just oblivious to the fact people in uk can actual be in poverty and really suffering right now even though we arent a third world country. And it seems will only get worse.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anotherparkingthread · 01/07/2023 17:25

Insiderknowledgepls · 01/07/2023 09:08

Genuine question: how come you’re living in social housing when you can afford as a couple to save £2000 a month? I don’t understand how social housing allocation is prioritised or how eligibility changes over time

Not the person you're asking, but I think social houses is given out when people need it but they have a policy of not removing people from their homes. Like any other tenancy as long as the rent is paid and the property treated well.
I think if it was changed so that a change of circumstances meant you could lose your very stable and safe home (a lot of rentals are at the whim of landlords who may wish to move back in or sell up) it would incentivise staying on low income, on benefits, out of work, etc.

Insiderknowledgepls · 01/07/2023 09:08

Genuine question: how come you’re living in social housing when you can afford as a couple to save £2000 a month? I don’t understand how social housing allocation is prioritised or how eligibility changes over time

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 30/03/2023 20:36

LadyAstor · 30/03/2023 07:27

Interesting that OP never came back.

Yep. Light that match.

1offnamechange · 30/03/2023 10:34

to be fair, the people who are accused of being 'I'm alright Jacks' 'insensitive' 'dismissive' etc are probably replying to OPs opening sentence "To think a normal standard of living is out of reach to the majority of the population. People are barely surviving as is." Which is clearly an exaggeration. Doesn't mean people don't understand that there are some people who might be barely surviving and a lot more who are struggling, just that they are refuting that it's the majority of the population. Which is fair enough.

I actually think it's really valuable to get threads like these with examples from a wide variety of the population. Otherwise people only get their information from their own close circle (which is almost always a bit of an echo chamber, just look at the millions of posts on here that include "I don't know anyone who...." "Everyone I know...." "where I live...." etc.). or the media, which vastly misinforms and overexaggerates.

Just look at some of the crises of the last few years - everyone mass piling loo roll etc at the start of the pandemic - entirely led by media photos of empty shelves, there was actually sufficient products for everyone (or would have been if people hadn't panicked). Same with the ridiculous queues and fights for petrol - there were minor, short, disruptions to the supply chain, in a very few parts of the country, if the media hadn't published it and escalated it to mass panic, the rest of the country wouldn't even have known about it and wouldn't have bought any more than normal.

It's actually really useful to have realistic first hand accounts of other people's experiences - from a wider overview, information that actually the majority of the country might be cutting back a little but is generally managing ok could influence where help should be targeted - e.g. the energy payment of £400 per household was probably the 'fairest' way to do it but should it instead have been aimed at giving more help to the lowest income brackets?

But also from an individual perspective - people have been mocked on this thread for the 'you just need to retrain' suggestions (and same for 'just move to a cheaper area' neither of which are a magic fix all solution without any drawbacks) - but generally people have very little idea of the variance in wages between different sectors/house prices in other parts of the country etc. So it is useful to see someone else who might be in otherwise similar circumstances to you (similar age, DC, qualifications etc.) who is doing okay and think 'okay, how do I get there, are there options I haven't considered,' etc. Even if when you do consider them they might not work for you!

E.g. I used to work in a job with several London and various regional offices. Because a lot of them came from London/the south east their 'norm' was that owning a house was completely out of reach for anyone their age. Everyone they knew except for the odd person in a really good job was still living with parents or in houseshares. They obviously weren't stupid, they knew that property was probably slightly cheaper outside of London, but thought that the London weighting allowance basically counteracted that, so even if housing was more affordable elsewhere it would still be out of reach unless you bought somewhere completely rough or in the middle of nowhere. It was a bit of a shock when they did placements in the regional offices (themselves in nice, big, cities with lots to do) to realise that not just a few, but the vast majority of staff the same age as them doing the same role COULD easily afford to buy houses and generally live a much nicer lifestyle on the same wage.

Does that mean they all should move straight out of London, obviously not. For some the benefits of living there, whether it be for the London lifestyle/experience, or staying close to their families, or the better career options, was worth it. Which is fine! But at least they were aware that the were other options out there that they could bear in mind. Otherwise it's too easy to just read the headlines stating that house ownership is impossible for millennials and just accept it.

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 30/03/2023 07:49

It is scary. The amount of people using food banks. Made worse now by rocketing utility bills. The three major costs now are: rents, gas/electric and childcare. Even if you are earning a decent wage a lot of people still cannot afford to buy a 2 bedroom in some areas. A lot of houses you can bid above the asking price and still not get it. This is what is going on in the rental market also. 100s of viewings for a 2 bedroom house and you need to out bid others. It is scary I cannot see things improving in the next 5 years (childcare will soar, utility bills will probably keep rising and the government aren't really building new houses and if they are they go to developers or rich foreign investors who leave it empty and just use it with the hope that it sky rockets in the future.

LadyAstor · 30/03/2023 07:27

Interesting that OP never came back.

MissyB1 · 30/03/2023 07:14

TheGuv1982 · 30/03/2023 07:07

While it’s fantasy land stuff to claim life is unsustainable for the majority in a financial sense, my god, people setting the bar at “it’s worse being poor in x third world country” really are missing the point of what life should be like in a rich, western nation.

I know! It’s like they think we should accept anything as long as we aren’t living in a tin hut and walking 5 miles to get water 🤦‍♀️
Do these people really think we should be grateful for having all of our public services destroyed, sky high energy bills, highest inflation for years, and highest food prices for years, oh and all happening at once!

TheGuv1982 · 30/03/2023 07:07

While it’s fantasy land stuff to claim life is unsustainable for the majority in a financial sense, my god, people setting the bar at “it’s worse being poor in x third world country” really are missing the point of what life should be like in a rich, western nation.

Beezknees · 30/03/2023 06:45

Avarua2 · 29/03/2023 21:44

We don't know how the bottom 20 percent live. MN users are not representative of the population as a whole. MN users are highly literate (e.g. they're able to write in, on a public board, on the internet).
The general public, particularly the working poor, are not that literate. They'll be on certain corners of FB and shit social media like tiktok, that's it.
Their voices won't be on here, at all.

Bit stereotypical. I'm one of "the working poor".

magicthree · 30/03/2023 06:33

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:05

If people are struggling why don't they retrain and get better jobs. Absolutely no shortage of jobs out there, quite the opposite.

Why do people continually come out with this rubbish???? If everyone in a low paid job decided to "retrain" (and what would you like them to live on while they do this?) then there wouldn't be anyone left to do all the menial jobs. Who would be first in line moaning about basic work not being done - why, people like you of course.

Delectable · 30/03/2023 03:52

Something has to give. We need a government that will drive production; especially of food and energy. These are national security issues. Sadly our country is infiltrated with what can be deemed hostile/enemy agenda. We are prepared to be poor and die on the cross of 100% green energy.

Govt was busy giving shady contracts and bribing the pubic to stay home and still get paid. Of course after the lock down people had so much money and spent on holidays, eating out etc. Then Russia stepped in so we now have the perfect mix.

The take out business has never done better than it's doing now.
We're not growing more food or exploring better energy sources closer to home.
Illegal migrants are housed in hotels yet we wish to discourage them arriving.

Evacuees are camped in expensive hotels for years and not allowed to work even for their own upkeep; some doctors, some nurses etc.

We have an expensive coronation round the corner and that will make it better.

donttellmehesalive · 30/03/2023 03:06

Well when people feel that their standard of living is going backwards, through no fault of their own, they are going to feel disappointed and grumble about it aren't they.

You don't have to be in a desperate situation to feel miserable right now. You might feel relieved that you can absorb increased costs by cutting back on non-essentials but also feel miserable that you are cutting back on the things that make life a little bit nicer in order to pay your mortgage and energy company hundreds of pounds more each month.

If you are used to getting your hair and nails done, having tv subscriptions and an annual holiday then it is sad to give them up to pay more interest to your mortgage provider.

Purpleberet · 30/03/2023 00:28

I think there’s a lot of people complaining about the cost of living while feeling entitled that they can’t possibly cut back on their lifestyles. For example, they absolutely can’t give up their holiday abroad, buy takeout every week, drive the car for the shortest journey instead of walking, hair regularly coloured and nails done, multiple tv subscriptions - these are not people who are really struggling, they absolutely can cut back but they don’t want or actually need to.
I actually find it really poor taste when people like that constantly bang on about the price of their food shop going up 🙄 The people who are really struggling have to pick between eating and heating, or skip meals so their kids can eat.

Avarua2 · 29/03/2023 21:44

We don't know how the bottom 20 percent live. MN users are not representative of the population as a whole. MN users are highly literate (e.g. they're able to write in, on a public board, on the internet).
The general public, particularly the working poor, are not that literate. They'll be on certain corners of FB and shit social media like tiktok, that's it.
Their voices won't be on here, at all.

XenoBitch · 29/03/2023 21:32

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:05

If people are struggling why don't they retrain and get better jobs. Absolutely no shortage of jobs out there, quite the opposite.

Is this the new "why don't you take in ironing?".

Dragonsmother · 29/03/2023 21:27

After bills, mortgage and food I have £80 disposable income a month. Before the price rises it was £500 a month.
if the prices go up then we will have to reduce what we buy.
I am sick of being told how to budget. It’s not possible if what you get in just about covers the out going’s.

SoBoredHelpMe · 29/03/2023 20:55

Also I see a lot of vacancies which require qualifications but still only pay NMW or just over

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:32

Babyroobs · 29/03/2023 20:11

What are they meant to live on whilst retraining? Retraining seems to involve going to Uni meaning a potential severe reduction in income, or doing an apprenticeship. Are there an abundance of jobs where you can retrain on the job and miraculously come out a few months later with a much higher wage?

You're right, after reading my comment back it's ridiculous and ill considered. I retract it fully!

AllOfThemWitches · 29/03/2023 20:12

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:05

If people are struggling why don't they retrain and get better jobs. Absolutely no shortage of jobs out there, quite the opposite.

LOL. You know 'retraining' takes time and money?

Babyroobs · 29/03/2023 20:11

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:05

If people are struggling why don't they retrain and get better jobs. Absolutely no shortage of jobs out there, quite the opposite.

What are they meant to live on whilst retraining? Retraining seems to involve going to Uni meaning a potential severe reduction in income, or doing an apprenticeship. Are there an abundance of jobs where you can retrain on the job and miraculously come out a few months later with a much higher wage?

Callmenat · 29/03/2023 20:05

If people are struggling why don't they retrain and get better jobs. Absolutely no shortage of jobs out there, quite the opposite.

UsernameMcUsername · 29/03/2023 18:29

I do think it varies massively by area. I won't go into detail because too outing, but I volunteer regularly in a local community organisation which helps low income people in my socio-economically mixed corner of the small town north, and its worse than pre-Covid, but also not as bad you'd assume from national cost of living coverage TBH. I think it probably comes down to pretty affordable housing, including a reasonable supply of council housing. I have no idea how a single parent family on a minimum wage income copes in the south-east though.

donttellmehesalive · 29/03/2023 18:11

Lots of pp have said 'there are always people at the bottom who will struggle' but come on, it's a long time since it's been this bad. Inflation at 10%, energy bills at record highs, mortgages rates and rents soaring, wages not keeping pace. Even if you think it's all down to Brexit, Covid and Ukraine, that they're all unprecedented events and nowt to do with the tories, you can see that these once-in-a-lifetime events have conspired perfectly to make life pretty tough, much tougher, for people below or near the poverty line.

Mimilamore · 29/03/2023 17:47

Depends where you are and who you are comparing too. Some people are able to pay more for everything without even feeling it, others, well every penny is counted. I would say that the gap has widened....,

SilverGlitterBaubles · 29/03/2023 17:31

AvySt · 29/03/2023 13:02

I posted upthread about the poverty I see working with schools, economic poverty meaning childrens’ basic needs are not met.

Thinking further, there are also families who economically their childrens’ basic needs are met, but emotionally those basic needs are not.
The other side of the ‘ I am doing fine financially, I see people with plenty of money to spend’

There is such an increase in attachment disorders, increase in children without the relationships and emotional stability to meet their basic needs. An emotional poverty caused by so many parents having to work such long hours. Children of parents who haven't the time or energy to spend with them, read to them, eat around a table together, talk. Children who are passed between providers, clubs and relatives.
The effects of not meeting these basic needs are as much a cause for concern as lack of money.

I also see this. There is also the impacts from Covid and lockdowns, increasing reliance on screens as babysitters for busy parents, health issues such as obesity which will be exacerbated by rising food costs and increased MH issues with huge waiting lists. Whether you are feeling the pinch or not these things will impact us all as a system already broken is stretched further.