Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

shit, EHCNA refusal, aibu to feel mad at school & SENCO?

90 replies

sillygames · 28/03/2023 18:14

EHCNA just refused after the first 6 weeks? It was a parental request.

Can't believe it. I feel sick. DS has a long list of complex SENDs (ADHD/ASD/SPLD/SEMH) and chronic anxiety. He's at one of those super strict Academies. We only discovered SEND issues after joining. It's totally inappropriate for him as many professionals within it agree. I thought the SENCO agreed.

ECHP co-ordinator said the "Panel felt from the evidence provided that DS is making progress with the support provided by the school Panel felt that the school can use more strategies from EP’s recommendations to support DS social needs."

I feel sick. He's so anxious because of all the rules and his failure to do well that he's suicidal. The school & SENCO is know this. WTF did they say to the EHCP team?

How long do tribunals take?
If we take him out of school for the sake of his sanity will it make a tribunal and (hopefully) resulting EHCNA take longer or take less time?

OP posts:
Skiphopbump · 28/03/2023 19:52

Think really carefully about a reduced timetable. What would the goal be?
When DS was in year 8 he really struggled to get back into school after the second lockdown. We implemented a reduced timetable, instead of increasing the hours we were reducing them rapidly until just coming in at break was seen as a win.

DS started year 9 in another school and never needed any reduced hours.

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:51

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:50

EHCNA are based on need diagnosis. You need to show what the needs are that may need provision in line with an EHCP. The vast majority of children with the diagnoses your son had don’t have EHCPs a diagnosis does not equal an EHCNA

First sentence should read ‘need NOT diagnosis’

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:50

sillygames · 28/03/2023 19:47

@FourBoysAndAFeline we submitted reports from Psychiatrist about ASD/ADHD diagnosis, and from school about SPLD.

EHCNA are based on need diagnosis. You need to show what the needs are that may need provision in line with an EHCP. The vast majority of children with the diagnoses your son had don’t have EHCPs a diagnosis does not equal an EHCNA

Icmdiba · 28/03/2023 19:48

Just appeal. My LA refused to assess my daughter. I appealed. The LA conceded before the tribunal. The original request to assess was July, her EHCP is now in place. It’s still a shit show and I might have to appeal the plan and even then it’s hard to ensure school is actually doing it. But you have to take it step by step.

So my advice is go straight to appeal. Buy the SOS SEN £10 webinar on appealing a refusal to assess. This was invaluable to me. And look at IPSEA too.

good luck

sillygames · 28/03/2023 19:47

@FourBoysAndAFeline we submitted reports from Psychiatrist about ASD/ADHD diagnosis, and from school about SPLD.

OP posts:
sillygames · 28/03/2023 19:44

@TheCaddieisaBaddie yes, the recommendations from the EP don't sound like they need an EHCP but also I think they're inadequate. They don't look like they'd really help address his needs at all. Even so, one of them can't be met by the school which will not accept reduced homework.
He needs a reduced timetable, they won't do that either.
He needs an environment that is nurturing and supportive, and where he can exist without having to mask his ND or risk punishment.

OP posts:
FourBoysAndAFeline · 28/03/2023 19:39

OP what evidence did you send them when you requested an assessment?

TheCaddieisaBaddie · 28/03/2023 19:32

The request is based on has or may have SEN and whether or not special educational provision in line with EHCP needs to be made. The provision suggested by EP above can be put into place without an EHCP.

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:27

MWT · 28/03/2023 19:26

It depends on the area. It is true for my local area. Even with children who have significant needs.

What are your LA stats?

MWT · 28/03/2023 19:26

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 18:45

This is not true, in broad terms more than 75% of requests to assess are granted. LAs are far more likely to assess than not.

It depends on the area. It is true for my local area. Even with children who have significant needs.

Soontobe60 · 28/03/2023 19:21

isthisreallyit70 · 28/03/2023 18:29

I'm speaking from experience . Piss people off , you know what's best for your child.

When I was fighting for an EHCP. I included the following people in the email

Head of local SEND
Local Educational psych / or dept
Headteacher of current school
SEN Teacher at current school
Virtual head for area
Any other professionals involved

The following Carry clout
Head of OFSTED
Education Minster
Local MP

people who scream the loudest will get what they need. I did (normally not obtrusive) and got my child into a school that charges between 70-100k a year. They don't like to pay but they don't like having MP's involved . I would also make contact with MP about Thai anyway.

Don't give up , they normally automatically reject parental requests . It's all about money obviously but people who don't give up can get through it . Push the school to get an Ed psych assessment too.

Some of the people you have mentioned carry absolutely NO clout!

JustKeepBuilding · 28/03/2023 19:19

Think about what evidence you have. Submitting SARs to school and CAMHS may help you gather more evidence. Consider if you need independent assessments - if you are eligible for legal aid this can fund them, if not but you can’t afford them contact Parents in Need as they can sometimes help fund them.

<waves at @EmmatheStageRat>

sillygames · 28/03/2023 19:17

he's in year 8 i mean, not year 9

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 28/03/2023 19:16

Ralphschocolate · 28/03/2023 18:30

I'm assuming he started year 7 in September?

Our local authority ask for 3 one plans to be completed before even considering a needs assessment so it can be shown what the school have done to support the child and what works and what doesn't. We're only at the end of the 2nd term so that's only 2 one plans.

That is unlawful.

JustKeepBuilding · 28/03/2023 19:11

Sadly many are refused as a matter of course. Appeal, the vast majority of appeals are upheld. Don’t bother with mediation, just get the certificate and submit to SENDIST. LAs often use mediation as a delaying tactic, if they are going to concede they will do so regardless of whether you actively partake in mediation or just get the certificate.

Don’t deregister. Parents often find it easier, although not easy, to get support when their DC remains on the school’s roll even if they can’t attend. Crudely you are someone’s ‘problem’ whereas if you deregister it is easier for professionals to sweep DC’s needs under the carpet. If DS can’t attend school full time the LA must provide alternative education. But if you deregister and EHE you relieve the LA of their duty.

Be careful with SENDIASS, some are good but too many repeat the LA’s unlawful policies. IPSEA and SOSSEN are better.

sillygames · 28/03/2023 19:07

DS is 12, in year 9, we had him diagnosed privately with ADHD/ASD because otherwise wait times would have been too long.
School diagnosed SPLD.

the support offered so far includes

  • permission to stand out side class when distressed, but in view of the class (which anxious ASD child do you know would find this helpful?)
  • permission to carry and fiddle with bluetack, under desk, out of sight of others so not causing any distraction (okay!)
  • he's not allowed to carry a compass because of his suicide ideation (i don't know whose policy this is, but i think its quite clear that only the schools lawyers would see any benefit)
  • guidance on where he can go and what he can do in unstructured times
  • ND mentor and TA mentor

The EP could not complete formal assessments because his level anxiety was so high, but they did make the following recommendations

  • continued access to specialist support form camhs (the last of his 6 CBT sessiosn is next week)
  • multi-agency liason to discuss how to support him at home and school
  • stop teachers relying on visual communication with him - they need to speak
  • help packing his school bag and being organise (i started doing it for him because he was getting too many detentions)
  • learn mindfulness
  • have reduced homework and end of sanctions for incomplete homework (this is not happening and its not negotiable according to SENCO - the most they can offer ie extra time to complete homework, other than the normal detention. )

Honestly moving him to some other, less structured mainstream school would be distressing for him, more chaotic and more boisterous NT children would not help. He does not want to do that. The current environment is based on fear and sanctions, the EP's recommendations won't change that.

OP posts:
jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:04

Hankunamatata · 28/03/2023 18:58

Parental or school based requests?

It's an overall figure. If you have the discrete category data that would be interesting.

EmmatheStageRat · 28/03/2023 19:02

@JustKeepBuilding can you help here?

cantkeepawayforever · 28/03/2023 19:01

Appeal - and be prepared to appeal many times over the coming years.

Knocking back applications at different stages seems, unfortunately, to now be part of the process. So you need to see it as ‘a necessary stage’ not ‘the end of the road’.

Get the school to try the things not yet tried and document the results, then appeal with that extra evidence.

EmmatheStageRat · 28/03/2023 19:01

sillygames · 28/03/2023 18:14

EHCNA just refused after the first 6 weeks? It was a parental request.

Can't believe it. I feel sick. DS has a long list of complex SENDs (ADHD/ASD/SPLD/SEMH) and chronic anxiety. He's at one of those super strict Academies. We only discovered SEND issues after joining. It's totally inappropriate for him as many professionals within it agree. I thought the SENCO agreed.

ECHP co-ordinator said the "Panel felt from the evidence provided that DS is making progress with the support provided by the school Panel felt that the school can use more strategies from EP’s recommendations to support DS social needs."

I feel sick. He's so anxious because of all the rules and his failure to do well that he's suicidal. The school & SENCO is know this. WTF did they say to the EHCP team?

How long do tribunals take?
If we take him out of school for the sake of his sanity will it make a tribunal and (hopefully) resulting EHCNA take longer or take less time?

@sillygames I really feel for you; it took me three years to secure an EHCP for my DD1, mainly because her grammar school wouldn’t support the application. My DD(15) is blind, adopted and is diagnosed with neonatal abstinence syndrome (related to drugs in the womb) as well as autism and ADHD. If any child ‘deserved’ an EHCP, it is my DD. I rejected mediation and would have taken my LA to Tribunal but then my beloved dad died unexpectedly and suddenly during the pandemic and I hadn’t the resilience or heart to fight.

A year on, when I’d gained my equilibrium, I put in another EHCNA, but this time I researched to the hilt and I knew the language to use. The Needs Assessment request was granted and my LA employed an independent EP (probably because they don’t have their own any more). The subsequent report was overwhelmingly undeniable. My DD was issued with a draft EHCP (which was utterly crap) but I consulted with an SEN expert at a residential college for the blind who helped me tighten it up. It’s not perfect and I’ve had some help on here for my next review.

There is a brilliant poster on here (I will think of her name and post it) who is an expert on EHCPs. She/they are remarkable for the help they give parents.

Please don’t give up!

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 19:00

isthisreallyit70 · 28/03/2023 18:56

@jenandberrys

maybe you're an MP yourself. Again. Have you been through this yourself? Have you got children that need this help??

This process is horrible for parents and even harder for the kids. You'd do anything to make things better for your child. If it means annoying people off then so be it . Experience tells me this. I have 3 child with SEN. People don't like being held accountable in the hope that they can refuse and that most won't appeal. Most don't, but the ones that do get much further

Believe me I understand the system better than you can imagine. I totally agree with being the squeaky wheel, annoying people etc. You talk about people being held accountable and I agree and that is why I didn't respond to your first post as I know full well that flagging your case up with senior people is key. However none of the decision makers in this circumstance are accountable to the Head of OFSTED or the Education Minister and IMO copying those parties into your emails at a point when you haven't even lodged an appeal will make you look absolutely unhinged and the exact opposite of a parent who should be taken seriously.

Hankunamatata · 28/03/2023 18:58

jenandberrys · 28/03/2023 18:45

This is not true, in broad terms more than 75% of requests to assess are granted. LAs are far more likely to assess than not.

Parental or school based requests?

isthisreallyit70 · 28/03/2023 18:57

@Spambod please don't Spend this money fighting it you shouldn't have too and don't have too . Spend that on something beneficial for your child instead .

If I can offer any help I'm more than happy to but you shouldnT have to spend your own money to get the education your child needs

isthisreallyit70 · 28/03/2023 18:56

@jenandberrys

maybe you're an MP yourself. Again. Have you been through this yourself? Have you got children that need this help??

This process is horrible for parents and even harder for the kids. You'd do anything to make things better for your child. If it means annoying people off then so be it . Experience tells me this. I have 3 child with SEN. People don't like being held accountable in the hope that they can refuse and that most won't appeal. Most don't, but the ones that do get much further

Spambod · 28/03/2023 18:54

Hi op, me and DH will need an ehcp for our daughter, we know this. She is non verbal and in nappies. We also know that the LA will refuse. We have set aside 10k to spend on legal help to appeal on our behalf, attend the ehcp tribunal appeal and then enforce the help that is in the final ehcp as I know many parents struggle to get the legal document adhered to post ehcp. We are considering it as school fees. In law our daughter needs this and is entitled to it but in practice I know from so many parents that la’s fight very hard and I also know lots of parents and kids who have been so broken by the send system. We have sourced a send solicitor already for this work and our dd is only 3. For her primary education it seems a small price to pay for our sanity and mental health. I am sure secondary will be another fight and legal fees.