Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD has taken on way too many pets?

137 replies

ImBusyWondering · 28/03/2023 14:01

DD is 22 and moved out 2 years ago which is when she got her first cat, which I thought was quite nice for her as me and her dad personally never wanted animals while she has been a big animal lover. She later added another cat and has now taken in a puppy and older dog… I feel a bit sad for her.

Her disposable income is now going on these pets and she isn’t able to save and I feel like she was in a really good spot with a decent grad job where she could have been saving some. She rarely ever goes out with her friends now and isn’t particularly interested in dating and I know she is a bit stressed as she often forgets to call me and tells me she has been “too busy” and I ask in what way and it’s always just the pets.

I’ve reasssured her it’s not a bad decision to rehome if it feels too much and she has a go at me, but I’m just looking out for her. She says she will have more time when the puppy is older but I’m not convinced, that’s still 2 cats and 2 dogs and a huge tie at 22 as a solo person?

I realise it’s probably not my business but I am just worried

OP posts:
Nevermind31 · 28/03/2023 15:05

Her life, her choice. But… does she have enough space for the animals? Does she work from home or are they left by themselves? If she is in rented accommodation it could be difficult to find a home for all of them. Is she safe taking the dogs out at night?

IngGenius · 28/03/2023 15:02

Dont feel sad for her! I feel sad for you that you do not have the joy of pet ownership.

I went to uni dog less and at the end of my three years had rescued 4 dogs.

I changed my degree to include an animal msc and not looked back. To help you out I also meet my future husband through my animals.

My social life was different to some students but I had the best time.

Pets enhance many peoples lives and not hinder them as you think.

She can have a very active social live if involved with dogs .

Puppies and dogs can be hard work at first.

If you really care maybe offer to give her an evening off rather than just criticise her life decisions

Konfetka · 28/03/2023 14:57

You got it right in your OP: It's not your business.
And besides, you and her dad never wanting animals is what sounds sad to me.

Boltonb · 28/03/2023 14:57

Yep, agree with PPs - she’s not too busy to call you, she just chooses not to because you’re judgmental and negative.

It’s none of your business how she chooses to spend her time or money. You wouldn’t allow her a pet, maybe she’s overcompensating now with 4 pets, but it’s STILL none of your business.

Are you very lonely/bored? Can you find something to occupy yourself instead of criticising your daughter and her choices as your main hobby?

HamBone · 28/03/2023 14:57

Well, if she finds that she’s unable to do what she wants to due to her pets, like travelling or socializing as much as she’d like, she’ll have to work out a solution.

You can’t control this situation, OP, she’s an adult now. You’ve voiced your concerns, now leave it.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/03/2023 14:50

I think you need to stop being sad for her - and she is probably very aware that you are sad for her and consider her life to be a bit sad. You should also stop gently suggesting she re-home her animals, and please stop sighing that she isn't actively chasing a relationship, letting her know that you are sad that she is not in a relationship, and telling her that her animals will stand between her and having children (and a husband) in the future. She is 22 years old, she is working things out as a 22 year old should be, and she wants different things from you, at least for now.

Also be aware that when she says she is "too busy" to call you, she probably procrastinates calling because she feels a little bit worse after talking to you and having you undermine her choices and let her know you don't think she is failing in some way. She would call you more often if you could relax and stop telling her to be different.

WildAloofRebel · 28/03/2023 14:49

It would be a lot for me. I have 3 kids but at least they come on holiday with us and grow out of the needing help with every poo phase.

mrsjackrussell · 28/03/2023 14:48

Please stop worrying. Your daughter is an adult and capable of making her own decisions and her own mistakes.

My mum still goes on like this and I'm 49. It really gets me down and I keep my distance a lot. It makes me feel like a child and an idiot that can't make their own decisions. It erodes your confidence. Don't underestimate how your daughter may be feeling.

Luckily I have learned from this and did the opposite with my children. They are very independent and confident.

Stugs · 28/03/2023 14:48

I had three dogs and two horses when I met dh. God knows why they didn't put him off

KissesTasteLikeWhiskey · 28/03/2023 14:47

ImBusyWondering · 28/03/2023 14:41

She is a very good owner and I’d say that’s half the problem, she stresses over them having the best and her doing the best and then she isn’t focusing on herself at all and then when she does it’s always an ambitious thing relating to a relationship/children or a country she wants to visit and I just remind her she has 4 pets. It’s not like I just go on and on all the time without any sort of prompt.

I think she does thrive off the responsibility as she loves doing all the meal planning and prep and puppy classes and other stuff BUT I’m just worried she sees that as great for the next couple years and isn’t thinking she has these for the next 15 or so

She knows. She doesn’t need you to tell her.

My friends mum is like this and she calls her the Prophet of Doom. She dreads her visiting and calling and avoids her where possible.

Let your daughter live her life, be supportive of her decisions. She sounds lovely, kind hardworking and independent. You could really damage your relationship if you continue.

Echobelly · 28/03/2023 14:47

Two dogs and cat isn't excessive - cats tbh hardly count in my book as, unless they have special health needs, they're very low maintenance. Plenty of people have two dogs and manage. Agree with PPs that it's her money to spend if she wants - and pets are at least a meaningful thing to spend on.

Ratatouille1 · 28/03/2023 14:46

Also if you are not a nightclub type dog ownership can be very sociable. You can meet lovely like minded people out dog walking , at agility classes etc. She might meet the man or woman of her dreams at dog training! (Or be very happy to stay single of course)

Chesneyhawkes1 · 28/03/2023 14:46

When I met my ex I had 3 dogs and 2 horses. Didn't stop me dating.

When I met my current husband I had 4 dogs and 3 horses.

What a strange thing to say to her.

Lastnamedidntstick · 28/03/2023 14:46

Pets are a good filter when dating. Gets rid of all the selfish knobbers pretty quickly.

I remember being told when I bought a flat at 21 it was a “big commitment” and what if I wanted to go travelling/met someone etc.

they we’re all wrong.

your dd might meet a lovely person who loves animals as much as she does and they bond over it. Who clearly has nurturing qualities and would be a great parent.

then you’d be wrong.

leave her alone.

i am lucky that my mum actually helps me out by taking care of my dog when I’m away, and I get a pet sitter for the cat/rodents.

maybe help her out a bit, you might find you like the animals.

anyone who doesn’t like animals is a psychopath

IkeNoNo · 28/03/2023 14:46

You sound very negative and critical. Stop commenting on her choices. The more you criticise her the less she'll want to talk to you.

KissesTasteLikeWhiskey · 28/03/2023 14:43

ImBusyWondering · 28/03/2023 14:35

Oh I am very proud of her but I just think the pets thing could have come later. She knows I think she does well and I do admire her taking it all on and I do only say those things to her so she realises she can change her mind before the dogs get too settled.

And the conversations I have with her are helpful I think because she does then realise some things and will say things like well I’ve committed to them now and I wouldn’t have been happy until I experienced a dog. Which sounds quite negative for someone who truly wants this, that’s the only reason I’m still going on as don’t want her to feel like she is trapped.

the money that could have been saved is shocking

No wonder she sounds negative though, you’re going on at her about decisions she had made and is taking responsibility for. That’s very straining for her I imagine.

And the money that could be saved? You aren’t an animal lover so you don’t get it. I don’t begrudge anything I spend on my animals, they’re a huge part of my life.

Catnuzzle · 28/03/2023 14:43

AlmostSummer21 · 28/03/2023 14:26

Just stop.

this is HER life, not a re run of yours.

It's not 'sad', it's her choice.

she's not 'forgetting' to ring you, or 'too busy' she just doesn't want to face more of your negativity & criticism of her choices, not even when you pretend to wrap it up in 'care & concern'

honestly, just stop, busy yourself with your own life & stop trying to control hers. You don't know best, she does. you're doing all kinds of damage to her, implying she doesn't know her own mind, needs to do xyz to be happy & abc as you know better.

I'm 54, my mum STILL carries on like this, then wonders why I don't tell her stuff & I don't call her regularly (she lives overseas, well technically I do I suppose) and it's not by accident.

This. In spades. She doesn't need you pointing anything out to her. She knows already. And yes it is to late to remove the animals she committed to, because they're hers now. Her money to spend how she wants, doesn't need your approval. She's making her own choices as an adult. And she's not forgetting to ring you, she genuinely doesn't want your input which is why she avoids calling.

ImBusyWondering · 28/03/2023 14:41

She is a very good owner and I’d say that’s half the problem, she stresses over them having the best and her doing the best and then she isn’t focusing on herself at all and then when she does it’s always an ambitious thing relating to a relationship/children or a country she wants to visit and I just remind her she has 4 pets. It’s not like I just go on and on all the time without any sort of prompt.

I think she does thrive off the responsibility as she loves doing all the meal planning and prep and puppy classes and other stuff BUT I’m just worried she sees that as great for the next couple years and isn’t thinking she has these for the next 15 or so

OP posts:
KissesTasteLikeWhiskey · 28/03/2023 14:39

She sounds perfectly happy but you keep going on at her. Leave her alone.

Animals make some people very happy, including me. If someone told me to rehome them so I could travel or because I wasn’t phoning them enough, they’d be politely told to fuck off.

Newusernameaug · 28/03/2023 14:37

I agree about it being a lot of work - I also have 2 cats and 2 dogs and they all want plenty of my time and attention but i wouldn’t be without them either - however I don’t agree with the dating thing, for me it’s a really good indicator as if someone doesn’t like my pets they’re no good anyway 😂

amylou8 · 28/03/2023 14:37

Is she happy and are the pets looked after properly? If so I'm not sure what the issue is. I spend more money feeding my 3 cats than I do myself. I prefer their company to any person. I'm aware that dogs are more responsibility than cats but maybe that's what she wants.

JudgeRudy · 28/03/2023 14:37

It is a lot of responsibility yes......which she's chosen ir, and its doable. I mean, she could easily have a child instead!
She might be quite a stressed person in general anyway and find your chats good, but very stimulating. If she's quite insular it's likely that the pets bring her a great deal of comfort. Yes they're hard work but probably more rewarding than people atm. It's doesn't sound like she's at a stage where she can't cope. Be mindful how you phrase things. I feel your letting her know that if she had to remove a pet you'd understand. There's a subliminal judgement there and it's 'you cant look after them propely'. ...a bit like telling her you've noticed she's put weight on, but if she wanted gastric surgery you'd support her.
It's good though you're staying connected. Are you able to visit her, maybe take dogs for a walk and have lunch (Easter). This will give you a better sense of how she is than a frazzled phone call.

ImBusyWondering · 28/03/2023 14:35

Oh I am very proud of her but I just think the pets thing could have come later. She knows I think she does well and I do admire her taking it all on and I do only say those things to her so she realises she can change her mind before the dogs get too settled.

And the conversations I have with her are helpful I think because she does then realise some things and will say things like well I’ve committed to them now and I wouldn’t have been happy until I experienced a dog. Which sounds quite negative for someone who truly wants this, that’s the only reason I’m still going on as don’t want her to feel like she is trapped.

the money that could have been saved is shocking

OP posts:
Milkand2sugarsplease · 28/03/2023 14:30

Blimey, 22yo moves out of home, funds her own home and lifestyle and has a good grad job to boot and you're still pulling her to pieces because it's not the life you would have chosen.

She's an adult, let her adult - sounds like she's doing an ok job at it.

Vegemite001 · 28/03/2023 14:30

Oh god, you sound a bit like my mum! She goes on and on and on about how hard our lives are going to be when we get a puppy. And that it's not too late to change our minds. We know it'll be hard ... but we are grown ups, have a house and careers and children. Perfectly capable of making informed decisions.