Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My fault but should I pay for the damage?

365 replies

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 28/03/2023 16:00

Email HR and your colleague, telling them that you accept the accident was your fault and apologising. Then tell them you will go through your insurance for everything, as you need to be honest with them about the vehicle you damaged in order to claim. Point out that your insurance company will then deal directly with colleagues insurance company, and for you to lie about what you hit in your car would be illegal anyway. If colleague chooses not to notify his insurance company (is that illegal?) then thats up to him, but it does mean he will need to pay as your insurance wont deal with him directly. Give them the name of your insurers if they want to follow up with them.

IF you told your colleague you'd pay if they had the work done privately, and theyve gone ahead and had work done on that basis then really youre in a tricky position if you dont now pay them back. Your colleague is going to hr because you said youd pay them £2k (or whatever) and now youre refusing to.

Shz · 28/03/2023 15:58

Also HR have said the business can loan you money to pay for his car???? Is that legal? Are they authorised and licensed to give financial loans??

I think they are actually dipping into acting illegally tbh.

SofiaSoFar · 28/03/2023 15:55

Im definitely no expert in motor insurance but I take a keen interest in it as I've had quite a few expensive/fast cars including modified/restored ones and have avoided company cars where possible (for tax reasons) so do a lot of business miles in my own cars.

It always surprises me how little a lot of people know about motor insurance and the legalities/clauses/procedures, etc. Not because everyone should be a car nerd, but because it's a very serious (or very expensive!) matter if you get this stuff wrong.

As an example, if you have a car and sell it while you have a couple of months insurance remaining and aren't transferring your insurance policy to another car, you should ALWAYS cancel the existing policy and not just let it run on even if you get £0 back.

If you do that and the new owner hasn't taken out a policy (which would take precedence over yours you left running) any claim would be paid out against YOUR still running policy and at best leave you with a claim against you, but at worst the insurer could come after your to recover their loss if they have to pay a claim they wouldn't have covered normally. If anyone doesn't believe that, read up on it. It's how the MIB works.

fainallyhere · 28/03/2023 15:55

This reply has been deleted

We don't believe that this was posted in good faith.

NewNovember · 28/03/2023 15:54

Have you lied about what you drive into op if so it's insurance fraud and will affect avert insurance in the future , car home, life etc. Best to own uo now to mitigate the consequences.

fainallyhere · 28/03/2023 15:53

This reply has been deleted

We don't believe that this was posted in good faith.

Rebel2 · 28/03/2023 15:53

mum11970 · 28/03/2023 15:49

If you are in the UK this doesn’t make sense. There is no extra insurance for commuting to work but that is beside the point, you hit his parked vehicle so you and your insurance company are liable. The insurance he had on his vehicle doesn’t come in to it at all. If you hit any stationary object, whether it is a vehicle, a brick wall or person YOU are liable; whether the object is insured or not makes absolutely no difference.

Read the thread, there is! Not on all policies, but on some you have to choose to add commuting

My fault but should I pay for the damage?
AldiorLidl · 28/03/2023 15:52

mum11970 · 28/03/2023 15:49

If you are in the UK this doesn’t make sense. There is no extra insurance for commuting to work but that is beside the point, you hit his parked vehicle so you and your insurance company are liable. The insurance he had on his vehicle doesn’t come in to it at all. If you hit any stationary object, whether it is a vehicle, a brick wall or person YOU are liable; whether the object is insured or not makes absolutely no difference.

My insurance has extra for commuting to work.

It's social and domestic as a basic then I pay more to add commuting on.

mum11970 · 28/03/2023 15:49

If you are in the UK this doesn’t make sense. There is no extra insurance for commuting to work but that is beside the point, you hit his parked vehicle so you and your insurance company are liable. The insurance he had on his vehicle doesn’t come in to it at all. If you hit any stationary object, whether it is a vehicle, a brick wall or person YOU are liable; whether the object is insured or not makes absolutely no difference.

Redebs · 28/03/2023 15:47

OP if you told your insurer that you hit another vehicle. Then you can contact them again with proof and tell them which vehicle it was. They will contact his insurers and will sort it out.

It's not your concern as to what policy he has, nor what value he thinks it is. That will depend on what he submitted to his insurer.

You don't have to pay him anything directly if he feels your insurance isn't enough.

You don't have to pay him anything if he doesn't want to go through insurance.

I hope you didn't lie to your insurer. I hope he isn't trying to blackmail you into paying him personally. Both of those might be fraud.

SofiaSoFar · 28/03/2023 15:45

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 15:37

OP's insurer won't then contact his insurer, they will deal with it all themselves. It's in their interests to not involve the other insurer at all as that's often when they end up paying more out.

@SofiaSoFar ...picking g yoyr brains here.

Could this be open to abuse, as in someone can send in my number plate saying I'd caused damage to their car when infact its a lie?

Yes, as people have replied above, it could be open to abuse but your insurer will always contact you and check what you know first before doing anything else.

They may actually choose to believe the other driver over what you say, though, as obviously dishonesty works both ways and people aren't always truthful about behaving caused damage to someone else's property!

Blanketpolicy · 28/03/2023 15:44

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague.

Tell your insurance the whole story and let him deal with his insurance. Tell HR it is in the hands of insurance and it is none of their business.

I can't understand why they think it is anything to do with them or why they are even getting involved.

farnhamgal · 28/03/2023 15:43

Scarlettpixie · 28/03/2023 13:02

I also though that social/domestic use covered travel to and from work.

It does, doesn't it?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/03/2023 15:42

You need Class 1 business insurance for that, not commuting insurance.

If you carry anything in your car related to the business, other than your personal work laptop, etc. - so products, equipment, anything like that, you need more than Class 1 business insurance.

It doesn't matter how many times a year you do it, either. If it's once, you still need it.

This is very important so I'd get it sorted asap!

Thank you. I haven't got anything planned for a few months but I'll sort it before then.

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 15:41

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 15:37

OP's insurer won't then contact his insurer, they will deal with it all themselves. It's in their interests to not involve the other insurer at all as that's often when they end up paying more out.

@SofiaSoFar ...picking g yoyr brains here.

Could this be open to abuse, as in someone can send in my number plate saying I'd caused damage to their car when infact its a lie?

I suppose they always contact the person who has been accused of causing the damage to confirm that they actually did. Some people will lie. In that case I supposed a damaged car owner has a choice of sucking it up themselves or claiming on their own insurance.

drpet49 · 28/03/2023 15:40

MyPurpleHeart · 28/03/2023 15:08

This just got worse and worse as it went on. His lack of accurate insurance is not your problem. I'd tell him you go through insurance or nothing at all. This is an expensive lesson for him to learn about not telling lies to your insurance company for cheaper cover.

The quote from his chosen garage that HR are pressing you to pay sounds dodgy to me. I wouldn't be paying that. The reason we have insurance is because its in their best interests to fully investigate everything they pay and they are very good at making sure its all legit and above board.

This. Just go through your insurance to protect yourself.

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 28/03/2023 15:40

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 15:37

OP's insurer won't then contact his insurer, they will deal with it all themselves. It's in their interests to not involve the other insurer at all as that's often when they end up paying more out.

@SofiaSoFar ...picking g yoyr brains here.

Could this be open to abuse, as in someone can send in my number plate saying I'd caused damage to their car when infact its a lie?

It is open to abuse. But, if you haven't notified your insurer of an accident they will contact you for your version of events. We often get claims where someone has taken down a registration incorrectly and meet a plausible denial from the third party's insurer.

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 15:38

picking your brains

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 15:37

OP's insurer won't then contact his insurer, they will deal with it all themselves. It's in their interests to not involve the other insurer at all as that's often when they end up paying more out.

@SofiaSoFar ...picking g yoyr brains here.

Could this be open to abuse, as in someone can send in my number plate saying I'd caused damage to their car when infact its a lie?

QOD · 28/03/2023 15:36

@HeyDemonsItsYaGirl it absolutely is either social domestic and pleasure OR social domestic and pleasure plus commuting (to one place of work)

Business if if you went to varied places for or about work

I wfh so just have sdp

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 15:35

Redebs · 28/03/2023 15:28

If he's driving to work without a commuting addition on his insurance. Then he might be uninsured, which is illegal

It won’t mean OPs insurance won’t pay out for the accident SHE caused him. His insurance will be irrelevant to the claim via her insurance.

JudgeRudy · 28/03/2023 15:35

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

Sounds like he wasnt insured properly. You don't need separate insurance to commute to work, anymore than to the gym or Tescos. You do need business insurance if driving between venues during your shift is part of your duties. He's your employee. Does he use his van 'for' (not) getting to work.
Have you lied to the insurers or just not told the whole truth? If you say you bumped into a van but gave no details it's odd they didn't ask more. If you said the driver wasn't bothered as it was insignificant damage...maybe. lf you said you bumped into a car but didn't get details you might be safe....
It's his responsibility to ensure he's adequately insured. Did you see his policy? Could it be it's actually insured under someone else's (Dad?) name? Let's say for example his Dad had driven to your place of work to drop off his mobile/sandwhiches/wallet....and parked. Yd hit him, you asked around and no-one knew who's van it was....then when you returned to car it was gone...You've since found out who the owner is.
Has he actually had the work done?
BTW, no idea why HR are getting involved. Do not answer any questions or give further information. Ask for all correspondence to be emailed (personal email). Save all messages inc screen shots.
Do not pay. Remind HR of their duties under GDPR and let it be known that you are looking into their policy on harassment or bullying. If at any stage he's referred to your gender eg Bloody useless women drivers etc flag that too. He had his chance. He blew it.

Redebs · 28/03/2023 15:28

kirinm · 28/03/2023 13:30

The other guy does not have 'dodgy' insurance! He's just not covered for certain things. That's perfectly normal and doesn't mean he's done anything wrong!

If he's driving to work without a commuting addition on his insurance. Then he might be uninsured, which is illegal

MarchMadness23 · 28/03/2023 15:27

Process it all through insurance. It's not your fault he's modified his car & fucked up his insurance.

if the company thinks it should be paid orivately to stop him suffering the consequences of his chouces, tell them they can pay for it!

why should you pay for his (stupid) choices?

yes, you hit him, but that's why you have insurance!!

(how did you hit him?)

SofiaSoFar · 28/03/2023 15:26

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/03/2023 15:19

I didn't know that you need SDP and C on your insurance to drive to work. I WFH pretty much all the time but does it mean I need it if I'm doing a one off drive (for e.g. driving to a show to help out at a stall)?

You need Class 1 business insurance for that, not commuting insurance.

If you carry anything in your car related to the business, other than your personal work laptop, etc. - so products, equipment, anything like that, you need more than Class 1 business insurance.

It doesn't matter how many times a year you do it, either. If it's once, you still need it.

This is very important so I'd get it sorted asap!