Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My fault but should I pay for the damage?

365 replies

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

OP posts:
AdobeWanKenobi · 29/03/2023 02:00

viques · 29/03/2023 01:25

So if I drive into your car in a supermarket car park I can drive off with impunity. Good to know.

Absolutely. You can play demolition derby to your hearts content 😂

I seem to recall for the purposes of the road traffic act Supermarket Car parks, whilst privately owned, are still bound by the law because they are freely accessed from the highway by the public. This is why you can still be prosecuted for drink driving etc on land accessible to the public.

If the work car park is also freely accessible, and I assume by the fact the OP and the guy she hit drove in there that it is, then that’s not going to wash.

viques · 29/03/2023 01:25

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/03/2023 18:13

She may not be if it is a private car park.

So if I drive into your car in a supermarket car park I can drive off with impunity. Good to know.

WigglyWaggly · 28/03/2023 23:44

This is a really weird situation. It's dumb to lie to your insurance

Dammitthisisshit · 28/03/2023 22:37

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 28/03/2023 13:01

Are you in the UK? I've never heard of a policy not covering commuting. It's business use (which doesn't include commuting) that you often need to add separately.

Anyway assuming this is a weird policy and he was uninsured, that's all on him. You don't pay.

I’ve known it in the UK. It’s usually negligible cost but I’ve definitely had to add it on before.

But agree, it’s his choice to not go through insurance.

kirinm · 28/03/2023 21:34

@Redebs he isn't uninsured! He isn't anything at all since he hasn't claimed against his insurance company.

He may or may not have had cover declined but he doesn't know that - or it didn't sound like he did.

whynotwhatknot · 28/03/2023 21:26

bloody hell how many times are posters going to come on and say commuting isnt an added option when loads of us says it is

ThisIsWednesday · 28/03/2023 20:54

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 28/03/2023 13:01

Are you in the UK? I've never heard of a policy not covering commuting. It's business use (which doesn't include commuting) that you often need to add separately.

Anyway assuming this is a weird policy and he was uninsured, that's all on him. You don't pay.

SDP coverage is absolutely a thing. In fact, many insurance companies use you clicking the SDP option and not especially checking that you can commute too as a get out of paying loophole.
A friends son was pulled over once and the police (policeman known by all the locals to target and even harass young male drivers in the village) seized his car because he happened to mention he was on his way to work and wasn't some boy racer prick who the policeman must have issues with.

OP, your colleague lying to their insurer took that gamble. And lost. That is what happens when you take risks for lower premiums. Do everything by the book and do not pay a penny out of pocket besides your excess and your increased premiums when you renew.

BCfan · 28/03/2023 20:17

This is bizarre. Why would HR be involved let alone offer to loan you the money?

The option of going through insurance is still open to colleague. Suggest they take it and discuss no further

CombatBarbie · 28/03/2023 20:12

Cryingovernothing · 28/03/2023 20:09

Wouldn't take much if she's in an expensive car and she's scraped every panel down the side of her car for instance.

Or crushed her back end..... I don't think people realise how expensive cosmetic jobs are.

Cosmos123 · 28/03/2023 20:11

Don't pay.
Ring you insure and tell them all what happened.
Tell your employer it is an insurance issue.
And the other person can claim from your insurers.

Cryingovernothing · 28/03/2023 20:09

AndEverWhoKnew · 28/03/2023 20:07

Am I the only one wondering how fast OP was driving or how expensive their car is, to cause £1500 of damage to her own car from hitting a stationary vehicle?

Wouldn't take much if she's in an expensive car and she's scraped every panel down the side of her car for instance.

ChocSaltyBalls · 28/03/2023 20:08

Many years ago I worked in motor claims and the one piece of advice I’d always give anyone is never piss around trying to sort things with third parties yourself. Always just pass it to your insurer and let them deal with it.

My car insurance covers social, domestic and pleasure, commuting and business use. I’m always very cautious about making sure I have the right insurance .

AndEverWhoKnew · 28/03/2023 20:07

Am I the only one wondering how fast OP was driving or how expensive their car is, to cause £1500 of damage to her own car from hitting a stationary vehicle?

Cakeandcookies · 28/03/2023 20:03

Oh dear! I hope you are okay. Going through the insurance company is the right thing but be completely honest with them as they can refuse to pay out, send you the bill or later start court proceedings if you have not told the truth. It isn't worth it. Your colleague will be annoyed but also sounds like he is hiding something. As others have said you have offered to sort through insurance do not start writing cheques it will get messy. As for your HR department encouraging it.. that is appalling advice and do not be swayed. If you need more support contact citizens advice but remember anything in haste repent at leisure!!!! Good luck op.

Cryingovernothing · 28/03/2023 20:01

How many of us have just gone and checked our car insurance policies after reading this thread? 😂

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 19:54

What we need to know from OP, is whether colleague has had his car repaired privately? Has it actually happened?

And did he choose to do that after OP clearly said he could claim on her insurance?

Did OP (wrongly) suggest to him that he would be in trouble if he claimed on her insurance, as his own insurance might not have covered commuting? Ie. Did OP persuade him not to claim through insurance?

The suggestion in OPs post that he wasn’t keen to go through insurance and chose not to, choose to arrange his own repair and then later got cross and got HR invovled to try to make her pay up, doesn’t really quite ring true and make sense.

Again, his insurance is irrelevant here. Op caused the damage and so it’s her insurance which can be claimed in by both her and him. Unless he was totally clueless and thought he couldn’t claim, it is extremely odd that he chose to arrange and pay himself.

If OP genuinely made it clear that he could claim on her insurance (and didn’t try to mislead that he couldn’t with ref to aspects of his own insurance and car) and also made clear she wasn’t going to pay for the damage from her own funds, then if he chose to range repair himself, then that would be an odd choice, but his choice to make.

As Sofia says upthread, he actually has 6 months to claim. OP’s car will be repaired well before then. Op can tell colleague that he can still claim. He can do it via his own insurance company or direct to hers without involving his own company if he wants. No doubt OPs insurance Co will be in touch with her to confirm details,and they will ask why she didn’t declare the damage she did to him. She can say she chose to settle it outside of insurance if she wants, but now the other party must have changed mind. That does happen….people change their minds both towards and against making insurance claims, adjusting what they originally thought they would do.

When they come to renew insurance, both OP and the colleague should be declaring the incident and fact someone else was invovled.

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 19:44

nomoremerlot · 28/03/2023 18:45

I don't think so....

mum11970 is right.

Trekkingaway · 28/03/2023 19:09

Either he goes through insurance or he pays himself and that's what I'd be telling him if I was HR (I am) too. I can't believe HR have got involved to the extent of offering loans or "advising" you to pay.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/03/2023 18:50

PuddlesPityParty · 28/03/2023 17:32

Can you read? I never said anything about the hitting! I was saying IF SHE TELLS THE INSURANCE NOW SHES NOT DOING ANYTHING WRONG BY DOING SO. I am not talking about prior events. And the smug and clever part has a question mark at the end - this means it was a question, aimed towards you, not a statement. Get it now? (That’s a question aimed towards you BTW just so we are clear Chicken xx)

That’s not what you said and having a tantrum isn’t convincing anyway that it is what you said. Not sure why you’re so invested that you’ve decided to carry this on.

CocoFifi · 28/03/2023 18:48

Do not pay. He has been driving his car illegally. You should follow normal procedures and it is his loss

Chickenly · 28/03/2023 18:48

PuddlesPityParty · 28/03/2023 17:32

Can you read? I never said anything about the hitting! I was saying IF SHE TELLS THE INSURANCE NOW SHES NOT DOING ANYTHING WRONG BY DOING SO. I am not talking about prior events. And the smug and clever part has a question mark at the end - this means it was a question, aimed towards you, not a statement. Get it now? (That’s a question aimed towards you BTW just so we are clear Chicken xx)

CAPITAL LETTERS DON’T MAKE YOU RIGHT.

You look ridiculous.

You said if she tells her insurance then she’ll have done nothing wrong. That is patently incorrect and flatly false. You then decided to be smug on top. And for hysterical when you were knocked back for it. I assume you’re used to be people just shutting up when you flip your lid?

nomoremerlot · 28/03/2023 18:45

mum11970 · 28/03/2023 17:58

The OP is liable for the damage even if the other person wasn’t insured, as it is a claim on her insurance not his. It’s no different from hitting and damaging absolutely anything, whether it’s an insured object or not.

I don't think so....

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 28/03/2023 18:45

Astrabees · 28/03/2023 18:05

Of course you should pay if the accident was your fault. He could just take you to the county court to get judgement where insurance would not be an issue.

If county court proceedings were issued against the OP, she'd just pass them to her insurer who would either pay up or defend.

nomoremerlot · 28/03/2023 18:44

Astrabees · 28/03/2023 18:05

Of course you should pay if the accident was your fault. He could just take you to the county court to get judgement where insurance would not be an issue.

Don't be ridiculous 🙄

ComeOnNumber100 · 28/03/2023 18:43

Astrabees · 28/03/2023 18:05

Of course you should pay if the accident was your fault. He could just take you to the county court to get judgement where insurance would not be an issue.

The county court would throw it out if the OP told them her colleague was offered the insurance details to claim from and declined.