Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My fault but should I pay for the damage?

365 replies

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 29/03/2023 17:24

Not your fault his insurance is messed up. Go through your insurance.

PortmeirionTiles · 29/03/2023 15:16

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2023 11:10

There'll be no exclamation marks left for everyone else to use before long, if this thread continues as it is.

Once again, he doesn't need to contact his own insurer. He can get OP's insurance details either directly from her or even without her knowledge by putting her reg' number through askMID and then simply start a claim directly with her insurer.

I struggle to understand why people post 'advice' which they've just made up in their heads by deciding that their way of thinking something works must be correct, just because it should be that way in their opinion.

Motor insurance policies have very specific conditions, processes and procedures which aren't open to opinion. MNers deciding that the 3rd party is going to be in some sort of trouble, or that OP's insurance won't pay out "because private property" are incorrect.

I'm so relieved to hear this, I was starting to think that I must not understand how insurance works after all. A number of people had said the colleague was going to be in trouble with the police, and I wondered how on earth when his car was parked off-road and he was nowhere near it!

Anyway the OP never came back, I wonder if this was simply a 'wind 'em up and watch 'em go' exercise. 💆

anon90210 · 29/03/2023 11:46

He wasn't uninsured.

Someone crashed into me at uni, I contacted my insurance told them what happened and they changed my policy to cover business too as social and domestic doesn't cover you for travelling to a place of work or education.

SVRT19674 · 29/03/2023 11:26

I would not pay a cent, through insurance or nothing. His choice. And HR are a load of incompetent idiots.

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2023 11:24

As a friend of mine memorably wrote 'The internet is like having Guernica explained to you by a troupe of clowns'.

@WalkingOnTheCracks That's a brilliant way of describing it. 😂

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/03/2023 11:20

@SofiaSoFar

I struggle to understand why people post 'advice' which they've just made up in their heads by deciding that their way of thinking something works must be correct, just because it should be that way in their opinion.

It's not only infuriating - it's sometimes dangerous. People give advice that's not true because they think it's 'common sense'. The problem with forums is that there's no one fact-checking the content.

As a friend of mine memorably wrote 'The internet is like having Guernica explained to you by a troupe of clowns'.

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2023 11:10

There'll be no exclamation marks left for everyone else to use before long, if this thread continues as it is.

Once again, he doesn't need to contact his own insurer. He can get OP's insurance details either directly from her or even without her knowledge by putting her reg' number through askMID and then simply start a claim directly with her insurer.

I struggle to understand why people post 'advice' which they've just made up in their heads by deciding that their way of thinking something works must be correct, just because it should be that way in their opinion.

Motor insurance policies have very specific conditions, processes and procedures which aren't open to opinion. MNers deciding that the 3rd party is going to be in some sort of trouble, or that OP's insurance won't pay out "because private property" are incorrect.

Margarita45 · 29/03/2023 10:10

I mean if you’ve fabricated another story to your insurance in order to settle your own claim for your damage, then I don’t think you have the option to go through insurance for colleagues car now. Going back to tell them you did in fact hit another vehicle and withheld that info would probably void your whole policy and leave 2 unfixed cars.

The way I see it you can either tell your colleague you’re paying nothing and hope they accept that, or you agree on a value you are happy to contribute to their repairs.

You’ve got yourself in quite the pickle now. In future just tell your insurance the truth and advise them that the involved party does not want their vehicle fixed or to be part of the claim.

Hadalifeonce · 29/03/2023 10:06

Please, do not lie to your insurance company.
Go through your insurance company for everything, it is not your fault if his insurance company are not aware of modifications he has made. If you don't keep this above board at your end, it will get very, very messy
That's why you have insurance.

mcdog · 29/03/2023 10:06

Absolutely do not pay out!!!! It's not your fault his insurance isn't fit for purpose.

Have you told HR that you offered to go through insurance and he refused? I am gobsmacked that they think they can make you pay!!!

GettingStuffed · 29/03/2023 10:01

Insurance companies must pay out if there are grounds for doing so. If they don't pay you can make a complaint and pass it on to the ombudsman if you are not happy with the decision.

I think you should contact the insurance company and give them the full story. If not and they find out you could be put on the insurance fraud register and will only be able to buy insurance from an expensive specialist company.

Chickenly · 29/03/2023 09:55

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:43

”hysterical” is a misogynistic phrase. But you think what you want and I’ll think what I want 👍 enjoy your Wednesday 🫶 ciao

So is “smug”. It comes from insulting women who were pretty as superior to women who were smart. How embarrassing for you.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 29/03/2023 09:51

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:27

Well it is what I said. Sorry if you read it in a different way 🤷‍♀️ I said “you’ll have done nothing wrong” aka “you will have done nothing wrong” if she tells her insurance. Future tense. I didn’t mention anything to do with the original incident.

Maybe I shouldn’t have carried it on, but it’s hardly being invested taking 2 seconds to write a reply 😜

And she will have done something wrong. Future tense 😂She will have done plenty wrong even if she phones her insurance now. The whole post is about the original incident.

I read it in the only way that anyone would read your comment. There’s a big difference between “if you tell your insurance then you’ll have done nothing wrong” and “if you tell your insurance then you’ll have done nothing wrong by telling your insurance but will have still done lots of other things wrong”.

You were either completely wrong and are now backtracking or you communicated what you meant so badly that no reasonable person would understand what you meant. Either way, it’s no one else’s fault and there’s no need for you to start throwing shade and insulting posters who politely clarified your advice.

Biker47 · 29/03/2023 09:44

OP, not your issue to have to pay for it, you could offer to do so if you want to avoid an insurance claim, which many people will do, but given you've already started a claim yourself, it's of no benefit to you to pay for the damage yourself now, tell him to take it up with your insurer. Just have to hope you haven't lied about not damaging another car when you've put the claim in for your own car.

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:43

Chickenly · 29/03/2023 09:35

Ridiculous insults don’t make you right either.

”hysterical” is a misogynistic phrase. But you think what you want and I’ll think what I want 👍 enjoy your Wednesday 🫶 ciao

Biker47 · 29/03/2023 09:38

AndEverWhoKnew · 28/03/2023 20:07

Am I the only one wondering how fast OP was driving or how expensive their car is, to cause £1500 of damage to her own car from hitting a stationary vehicle?

Before painting, the front bumper of my old car was £900, the grill inserts were £700.

Chickenly · 29/03/2023 09:35

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:24

Okay ms misogynist.

Ridiculous insults don’t make you right either.

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:27

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/03/2023 18:50

That’s not what you said and having a tantrum isn’t convincing anyway that it is what you said. Not sure why you’re so invested that you’ve decided to carry this on.

Well it is what I said. Sorry if you read it in a different way 🤷‍♀️ I said “you’ll have done nothing wrong” aka “you will have done nothing wrong” if she tells her insurance. Future tense. I didn’t mention anything to do with the original incident.

Maybe I shouldn’t have carried it on, but it’s hardly being invested taking 2 seconds to write a reply 😜

PuddlesPityParty · 29/03/2023 09:24

Chickenly · 28/03/2023 18:48

CAPITAL LETTERS DON’T MAKE YOU RIGHT.

You look ridiculous.

You said if she tells her insurance then she’ll have done nothing wrong. That is patently incorrect and flatly false. You then decided to be smug on top. And for hysterical when you were knocked back for it. I assume you’re used to be people just shutting up when you flip your lid?

Okay ms misogynist.

Butterfly44 · 29/03/2023 07:05

What @Nookable said

You are doing the right thing. Reiterate to HR it's to go through insurers. Not your fault he's paid out. You are not to pay!

MinnieGirl · 29/03/2023 06:54

To be frank, the whole situation could have been avoided if you had been honest with your insurance company… it’s not your problem whether or not he declared modifications to his vehicle. You need to get this sorted out immediately.
Phone your insurance company, apologise profusely and tell them you were trying to do him a favour as he didn’t want to go through his insurance, but it’s not sitting well with you and you need to disclose the whole situation. You won’t be the first person to do this, and while they may be a bit cross, it’s better to tell them now. They could demand repayment if they later find out you haven’t been truthful.
As for the other driver, it’s down to him if he tells his insurance company but you’ve done your it.

And why the hell are HR getting involved?! If it’s mentioned again tell them it is none of their business, not work related and you don’t wish to discuss it any further.

ComeOnNumber100 · 29/03/2023 06:38

AdobeWanKenobi · 29/03/2023 02:00

Absolutely. You can play demolition derby to your hearts content 😂

I seem to recall for the purposes of the road traffic act Supermarket Car parks, whilst privately owned, are still bound by the law because they are freely accessed from the highway by the public. This is why you can still be prosecuted for drink driving etc on land accessible to the public.

If the work car park is also freely accessible, and I assume by the fact the OP and the guy she hit drove in there that it is, then that’s not going to wash.

You’re correct about the road traffic act and car parks the exception being gated or those with a barrier that you have a permit or pass to enter/use. So for example our local hospital car park has areas for staff that have barriers and there are no barriers in the areas where patients park. So the police wouldn’t investigate a bump in the staff area but would the patients section of the car park.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 29/03/2023 03:33

cestlavielife · 28/03/2023 13:57

How did you explain the damagexwithout giving his details number plate?

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague.
So you omitted to say another vehicke was damaged?
That was daft
And now potentially problematic

But
Not your issue to pay out
Just tell him to claim on his insurance giving your details.
His insurer will get the money from yours

But he won't do this...will he? ! This ks what he's frightened of!

If he tells his insurance to action it... They'll ask where the car was hit... "In the work car park", won't run, as he's not insured for commuting!

He will incriminate himself!

Twofortheteam · 29/03/2023 03:31

On the question of modifications: that’s irrelevant too. Given the damage is entirely the OP’s fault, she (or her insurer) has to make the injured party whole, either by paying for repairs or else by “buying” the damaged car at its fair value. Of course it’s up to him to establish the price of repairing things to the status quote ante, or to provide evidence of the value, but that shouldn’t be hard.

Twofortheteam · 29/03/2023 03:11

I’m not sure anyone here understands insurance.

The other car owner absolutely doesn’t have to contact any insurance company at all. He simply asks the OP to make him whole (as he did), and if she refuses he issues proceedings against her in the small claims court.

If she wishes to be indemnified by her insurer (which is what she’s paying premiums for) the tells her own insurer who will defend her, and pay the damages if she loses.

Alternatively her insurer will examine the facts and concede the claim, and pay it, if (as in this case) it’s clearly her fault and a court battle will cost them money.

if she doesn’t turn the case over to her own insurer to settle then they can (and will) refuse to cover her losses making the other party whole because she’s not complying with the the terms of her policy. When she loses in court, the other party can also claim the judgement from her insurer who can then reclaim the payout back from her.

allowing two insurers to settle between themselves is merely a courtesy to avoid extra costs.

If he wishes to, he can conduct all correspondence through her insurer (and she may invite him to do so - it will certainly make her life easier) but he’s absolutely not obliged to: she’s at fault and he needs to communicate with nobody but her, if he so chooses.

what his own insurer (should he have one) demands of him in respect of notifying them of this accident is irrelevant to the OP.

You should never admit liability after an accident; it prejudices your insurer’s options to defend your claim (that they will have to pay) if they wish to, and can put you outside the terms of your policy.