Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My fault but should I pay for the damage?

365 replies

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

OP posts:
Twofortheteam · 30/03/2023 18:41

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 15:02

...but they still aren't going to pay more for somebody else's property that was damaged by one of their policyholders than they can justify/claim that it was worth.

Just because you were the wronged party doesn't mean that you can name your price to the other person's insurance company and they will pay it without quibble.

But he won't be unjustifiably plucking a number out of thin air.

His camper will go to a body shop. They will quote for the damage repairing.

If it has fancy paintwork that will cost £2,000 to fix, they will quote for that. If it has plain paintwork that will cost £500, they'll quote for that. If it has a bent wheel that will cost £500 to replace they will quote it, as they would if it had a basic standard wheel that costs £100

The point is, they will pay to fix the damage to his particular vehicle. Not to fix a completely standard one just because that's what it's insured as (if that really is the case).

This is correct, up to the "fair" value of the vehicle. If the repairs cost more than the reasonable value of the vehicle, the insurer will pay that amount, and then they own the damaged vehicle.

The owner can't argue that it's especially valuable to him, and therefore he should be able to get it repaired regardless of cost.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 30/03/2023 15:33

Tell him it goes through on the claim or it doesn't. That's the only options. Problem now is if you contact your insurance they will want to know why you lied to begin with not telling them about his car being involved. Seperate claim is seperate excess. If he wants he can claim on his insurance saying someone hit him when parked outside his home.

Oblomov23 · 30/03/2023 15:26

I can't believe you didn't tell your insurers the truth. This is a big mistake. Did you lie? How did you explain to insurance damaging yours without mentioning another car. You are liable.

What damage did you do to your car re the £1500. What damage to his? And how much to repair.

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 15:02

...but they still aren't going to pay more for somebody else's property that was damaged by one of their policyholders than they can justify/claim that it was worth.

Just because you were the wronged party doesn't mean that you can name your price to the other person's insurance company and they will pay it without quibble.

But he won't be unjustifiably plucking a number out of thin air.

His camper will go to a body shop. They will quote for the damage repairing.

If it has fancy paintwork that will cost £2,000 to fix, they will quote for that. If it has plain paintwork that will cost £500, they'll quote for that. If it has a bent wheel that will cost £500 to replace they will quote it, as they would if it had a basic standard wheel that costs £100

The point is, they will pay to fix the damage to his particular vehicle. Not to fix a completely standard one just because that's what it's insured as (if that really is the case).

xogossipgirlxo · 30/03/2023 15:01

Do not pay. It's his fault he was too cheap to pay few pounds extra.

T1Dmama · 30/03/2023 14:51

why do people bother to ask for advice / opinions on here if they’re not even going to bother to answer questions or respond?!…. If people have taken the time to give advice (as some people who work in insurance have), then the least @CountryGirl17 could do is take a few minutes to update the thread and respond to people!

DMLady · 30/03/2023 14:50

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2023 22:44

Does he know what he's doing?

If he does, presumably he knows the difference between non-disclosure and misrepresentation, before he starts throwing words like "fraud" around.

Yes, he knows what he’s doing, thanks. Good of you to check, though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 30/03/2023 14:46

You are conflating issues with payouts from your owninsurance policy and the 3rd party cover which covers damage you do yourself to someone else's property.

No, I do get it. In this scenario, OP's insurance company would indeed be liable for all damage caused by their policyholder, regardless of whose loss (if all had been declared) - but they still aren't going to pay more for somebody else's property that was damaged by one of their policyholders than they can justify/claim that it was worth.

Just because you were the wronged party doesn't mean that you can name your price to the other person's insurance company and they will pay it without quibble.

Obviously, the vouchers were referring to cases such as burglaries where jewellery or electronic devices or similar are stolen/damaged and claimed for on home insurance - not claims for car insurance.

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 14:20

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 30/03/2023 13:42

More incorrect assertions and assumptions about what camper van may or may not have done with his insurance, and what he may or may not get paid out.

It's categorically incorrect to say OP's insurance would only pay for a standard vehicle if the camper was written off. If he claims against OP he is entitled to have his property returned to its pre-accident state or he compensated for its pre-accident value.

I hope the first paragraph wasn't aimed at me saying clearly what some people do and thus what this person might have done.

You must be lucky enough never to have had to make a significant claim on insurance. Companies will do anything they possibly can to pay as little as they can - what do you think loss adjusters are there for? If you lose something out of the ordinary, they will expect you to accept vouchers for a generic store that sells 'that kind of thing' (which they of course get at a discount) or otherwise take a lower payout if you 'choose not to accept' their wholly unacceptable solution. They go on market values - as assessed by them - which frequently do not leave you in the same position as you were before the loss.

For example, suppose you have an immaculate well-kept 25yo car that you have owned since it was new, so that you know all of its foibles and history, their only solution will be to give you the same value as you would pay for a similar money-pit 25yo car bought from a complete stranger, which is absolutely not a like-for-like replacement at all.

You are conflating issues with payouts from your own insurance policy and the 3rd party cover which covers damage you do yourself to someone else's property.

Camper Van Man doesn't need to have any insurance whatsoever on his vehicle for OP's insurance to need to payout to repair it. And it's the same story whether it's a £30k camper or a £1m Bugatti. Her insurance would still have to pay for the damage.

It's no different to OP having crashed into the office reception doors and smashed them. Her insurance would pay to fix them.

Vouchers don't come into this.

T1Dmama · 30/03/2023 14:10

It’s simple really, you go through your insurance and let them deal with it! Whether he had taken out the appropriate insurance or not is his issue and not yours.
you tell your company that you offered to claim through your insurance and if he doesn’t want to go down that route then you won’t be paying as can’t afford to pay and don’t want a loan… so it’s insurance or not at all.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 30/03/2023 13:42

More incorrect assertions and assumptions about what camper van may or may not have done with his insurance, and what he may or may not get paid out.

It's categorically incorrect to say OP's insurance would only pay for a standard vehicle if the camper was written off. If he claims against OP he is entitled to have his property returned to its pre-accident state or he compensated for its pre-accident value.

I hope the first paragraph wasn't aimed at me saying clearly what some people do and thus what this person might have done.

You must be lucky enough never to have had to make a significant claim on insurance. Companies will do anything they possibly can to pay as little as they can - what do you think loss adjusters are there for? If you lose something out of the ordinary, they will expect you to accept vouchers for a generic store that sells 'that kind of thing' (which they of course get at a discount) or otherwise take a lower payout if you 'choose not to accept' their wholly unacceptable solution. They go on market values - as assessed by them - which frequently do not leave you in the same position as you were before the loss.

For example, suppose you have an immaculate well-kept 25yo car that you have owned since it was new, so that you know all of its foibles and history, their only solution will be to give you the same value as you would pay for a similar money-pit 25yo car bought from a complete stranger, which is absolutely not a like-for-like replacement at all.

Beautiful3 · 30/03/2023 12:19

I personally would have ignored him and gone through my insurance, and told them about hitting his vehicle. However you've now filed the claim, its too late to change it. I'd tell hr, you offered to use your insurance but he refused, because he wasn't supposed to be using his vehicle for work. You cannot afford to do it any other way. Make hr aware.

Funkyslippers · 30/03/2023 12:05

pussycatinfluffyslippers OP does not need to tell her insurers that he doesn't have the correct cover or has modified his vehicle. They will make their own investigations and it might not even be relevant to his claim

Twofortheteam · 30/03/2023 11:23

Many people here are making this waaaay too difficult.

  1. the op was negligent and caused damage. That’s a tort and is actionable in court.
  2. the owner of the other car sues the op for negligence, and wins damages in court
  3. the op pays up.

It makes no difference if she damaged his car, his bicycle, or his wall, or whether or not he has or had insurance of his own.

She has 3rd party liability insurance, so she can (not must) allow her insurance company to take over her defence and they will pay the damages for her.

Done.

SparklyShoesandTutus · 30/03/2023 10:24

**over complicated

SparklyShoesandTutus · 30/03/2023 10:23

Sounds like he has really over conlkicated things.
You have said you were at fault so the whole thing can go through your insurance.
His insurance only need to be informed which is probably the bit he is uncomfortable about but as they won't be paying anything out it really shouldn't matter.
The reality is his costs would have been paid if he'd agreed to go through your insurance.
I am really surprised HR have got involved and are suggesting loaning you the money. That's just strange.
Tell both HR and him that your are 100% willing to incur the costs BUT only through an insurance claim through your insurance. This is why we have insurance

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 10:21

More incorrect assertions and assumptions about what camper van may or may not have done with his insurance, and what he may or may not get paid out.

It's categorically incorrect to say OP's insurance would only pay for a standard vehicle if the camper was written off. If he claims against OP he is entitled to have his property returned to its pre-accident state or he compensated for its pre-accident value.

It makes zero difference whether it was insured as standard, but in reality had a fighter jet engine and 24ct gold taps on its diamond encrusted sink, or even whether it wasn't insured at all.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 30/03/2023 10:07

Personally, I think he's only done this because he's actually uninsured. Either that, or the insurance on the vehicle is in someone else's name. If he claims on your insurance, they will automatically check he has a valid policy

I think this is quite likely too. Although not unheard-of, most people with camper vans also have a standard car for everyday use - that's one of the reasons why a decent 30yo camper can still be worth a considerable amount of money: because it might only have done 500 miles a year.

It could also be something to do with the tax, as a lot of people with camper vans and motorhomes only tax them for half the year and SORN and keep them off-road during the colder months. Maybe his everyday car was in the garage for a couple of days, so he thought he'd chance it using his untaxed camper van to go to work for a day or two. In fact, that would make perfect sense for somebody not to also insure a vehicle that is specifically designed for use for leisure/holidays for commuting to work.

I'm still not sure whether his issue with the modifications is that he could have invalidated his insurance by not telling the insurer, or if they're just more interior fittings that he's spent a lot of money on and is concerned that, should his van be written off, he will only get a payout based on the value of the standard van, without all the extras he's spent loads of money on.

Most fully comp insurance policies always used to include as standard commuting and third-party cover when driving other borrowed cars (often only once you're over 25, granted), but it seems like these are being quietly taken away now, unless you pay extra. I suppose shrinkflation is so rife everywhere else, we probably shouldn't be surprised that the insurance industry is getting in on the act as well!

MibsXX · 30/03/2023 09:54

Not lately it hasn't, you have to actually tick the box stating you are using for travel to and from place of work in most cases now.. one of many sneaky changes in last couple of years

SofiaSoFar · 30/03/2023 09:35

This all must go through insurance or its akin to fraud.

What do you mean by "akin to fraud"?

Dibbydoos · 30/03/2023 06:11

His insurer won't be bothered about anything as it's your fault.
He though is a DH for modifying his vehicle and not declaring it and not declaring his use of the vehicle properly.

This all must go through insurance or its akin to fraud. Your HR dept are OOO suggesting you pay out of your own pocket, wtf is wrong with them?

Confirm you will use your insurance and his probs with his insurer are his probs. End of.

I'd also give a lawyer a quick call if you have an employee assistance programme to get the full sp on the law here.

Good luck.

Moser85 · 30/03/2023 01:40

@Nanaof1
I was assuming she lied to the insurance company, based on her saying this in her OP.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good.

But maybe you're right, and maybe she did tell them that she hit someone, but he didn't want to go through her insurance because the car was modified so he wanted to get it fixed himself 🤔
I suppose if they hadn't heard from the man or his insurance company then they would have no reason to question her version of events!

So maybe I've got it wrong!

Nanaof1 · 30/03/2023 01:17

Moser85 · 30/03/2023 00:10

@Grrrrdarling
You hit his vehicle so you go though your insurance to fix it.

I don't think she can now as her claim is already being processed. She can't really go back and say "actually I hit another car".

Well she can, and she might have to, but there could be serious consequences for her.

What if she tells them that she thought he was going to use his own insurance but now he isn't, so she has to use hers?

Sorry, I really don't understand how UK auto insurance works. But I am suspicious that he wants it done at a certain place, no quotes from other car repair shops and wants to not put the claim through her insurance.

Nanaof1 · 30/03/2023 01:13

PomonaPomona · 29/03/2023 22:54

"I can admit that it was totally my fault"

Just pay up for your mistake and stop trying to wriggle and writhe your way out of it.

She has insurance to cover her mistake. If he doesn't want to go through her insurance, it's on him. She is responsible for his irresponsibility.
Why doesn't he want to go through her insurance? Something is fishy.

LocSeeTan · 30/03/2023 00:46

To never ever work for another effing charity again

I'm not going to elaborate on my current position.
Just wabt8ti allow you lovely folks to have a vent.