Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My fault but should I pay for the damage?

365 replies

CountryGirl17 · 28/03/2023 12:57

I can admit that it was totally my fault that I drove accidentally into my employee’s VW Transporter in the car park at work. When I told him, I was devastated and he was obviously annoyed.

As I am insured with a social, domestic and commuter policy, I thought the process would be very straightforward, but it’s not. When my employee looked into his policy, he only had social and domestic insurance and then immediately changed his policy to include commuting after the incident. When he told me, my heart sunk as I had technically hit an uninsured driver as he was using his car to travel to work. Though, as it wasn’t his fault, my insurance would cover it. I told him that it wouldn’t be an issue, but he wasn’t confident or comfortable about that.

But, that wasn’t the only issue, as he advised me that he made some modifications to his vehicle, increasing its value and I am not 100% sure that he notified his insurer (that’s my suspicion). He did say to me that he was concerned that any repairs may not factor in the cost of the modifications or could effectively right off the vehicle. Another reason to not go through insurance. Again, my insurance should cover the cost of the damage.

The damage to my car is over £1,500, so I have to make a claim and I am okay pay the £250 excess. Though, my colleague has been really paranoid and doesn’t want to go through his insurance for the reasons that he wasn’t insured at the time and his car was modified. He doesn’t want to take any risks. As he doesn’t want to go through insurance, he has decided to get his car fixed by recommended bodyshop repairer. This repairer offered to do my car too, but they are not recommended by my insurer. This is his choice.

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague. They haven’t questioned it and the claim is going through just fine, which is good. My colleague isn’t bothered that I not telling the complete truth to my insurance company. Now, our HR department has gotten involved because my employee is upset about paying for the damage that my insurance would have covered. I can understand his annoyance, but the complications are not my fault and it was his choice to not go via insurance. If we went through insurance then he wouldn’t need to pay anything! The company has offered to loan me the money to pay for his damage, but I would have to pay it back, which basically means they are encouraging me to pay for his damage. It’s a lot of money and this is a nightmare!!!

AIBU to not pay out as I am insured or should I pay out as he works for me and it’s not his fault? I don’t know what the right thing is? Thanks.

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 28/03/2023 14:25

all these posters syaing theyve never been asked if tghey commute in their car well that poilcy obviously includes it but plenty of others dont

ive always had to choose brtween social only or adding commuting

i still fail to see what it has to do with HR none of their business but you sholdnt have lied to your insurance provider to save him

MandyMotherOfBrian · 28/03/2023 14:23

Blimey, so you’ve committed insurance fraud by wilfully lying about the circumstances of an accident. If/when your insurance company find out that you omitted to declare you’d hit another vehicle, in order to get your vehicle repaired under the policy, I doubt they will care about the reason why. Paying for the damage to the van you drove in to could end up being the least of your worries.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 14:23

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 14:20

Many insurances keep the claim open in case there turn out to be any 3rd parties who later want to claim.

If OP has lied to her insurance and said her vehicle didn’t hit another vehicle or there was no 3rd party invovled and the claim is being settled on that basis, to now say there is a 3rd party is problematic. The lie will be clear.

I’m actually re-thinking this. The colleague was in the wrong to encourage her not to mention him. However, OP is at fault for going along with this. Being honest with the insurer is always key. She has effectively dug herself into a hole that was wholly avoidable. The colleague and HR are in her case, and she’s got herself into a position where telling the insurance what happened will be very difficult. She might well find herself having to pay. That’s not because the colleague was right to say she should pay, but purely because SHE chose to go down the wrong route of lying to the insurance.

She mistakenly thought she was helping colleague, but didn’t think through the consequences.

I actually don’t think the colleague is wholly to blame. Their vehicle has been damaged. They had the right to ask for it to be settled privately, but not for OP to agree. They have a right to be compensated for the damage. If OP wasn’t going to go through her insurance, exactly how did she plan to compensate him for the damage? It either needed to be her paying up or the better option of go8 g through insurance. But she’s closed that door off to herself now. Big error.

So she’s foolishly got herself into the position where colleague needs to be compensated for damage, but she can’t claim on her insurance, so she might well need to lay out if her own pocket. But that is a result of her own choices.

His faulty insurance and irregularities with his vehicle are entirely his responsibility.

It would have come up as an issue at some point for him - it would have been worse if he had hit someone.

HikingforScenery · 28/03/2023 14:22

What did you say happened to your car? How do you cause £1500 worth of damage to your own car by driving into a stationary car. Were you on your phone?

You need to tell the insurers the truth. You’re committing fraud

Samsungwasher · 28/03/2023 14:21

Well at this stage we don't know what Op has told her insurer, we don't know she lied. She might have told them exactly what happened, accepted responsibility and told them that the other car owner refuses to supply his insurance details. If he refuses to deal with the claim through his insurance then he pays for the repairs himself. He should have notified his insurance company and then, if his insurer came back and said he wasn't covered, it would still be his problem, not Op's. I wonder if he's lying and isn't insured at all.
My insurance company classes travel to work as business use I think, maybe that's where this commuting thing comes from, but it's not Op's problem.
Op - you tell your HR people that this is nothing to do with them and you absolutely will not take out a loan to pay for damage that would have been covered by your insurance.

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 14:20

Many insurances keep the claim open in case there turn out to be any 3rd parties who later want to claim.

If OP has lied to her insurance and said her vehicle didn’t hit another vehicle or there was no 3rd party invovled and the claim is being settled on that basis, to now say there is a 3rd party is problematic. The lie will be clear.

I’m actually re-thinking this. The colleague was in the wrong to encourage her not to mention him. However, OP is at fault for going along with this. Being honest with the insurer is always key. She has effectively dug herself into a hole that was wholly avoidable. The colleague and HR are in her case, and she’s got herself into a position where telling the insurance what happened will be very difficult. She might well find herself having to pay. That’s not because the colleague was right to say she should pay, but purely because SHE chose to go down the wrong route of lying to the insurance.

She mistakenly thought she was helping colleague, but didn’t think through the consequences.

I actually don’t think the colleague is wholly to blame. Their vehicle has been damaged. They had the right to ask for it to be settled privately, but not for OP to agree. They have a right to be compensated for the damage. If OP wasn’t going to go through her insurance, exactly how did she plan to compensate him for the damage? It either needed to be her paying up or the better option of go8 g through insurance. But she’s closed that door off to herself now. Big error.

So she’s foolishly got herself into the position where colleague needs to be compensated for damage, but she can’t claim on her insurance, so she might well need to lay out if her own pocket. But that is a result of her own choices.

Comefromaway · 28/03/2023 14:20

We discovered very recently (when my mum bought a new car last month) that not all policies do include commuting like they used to. We very nearly missed that fact.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 14:19

Changing the story is of course problematic. And what a shame if OP finds she voids her own insurance through lying. Yes, she caused the accident but had insurance and is willing to use it.

I know. Why would you risk your insurance policy for the sake of dodgy colleague.

Fansandblankets · 28/03/2023 14:18

Something fishy here. All policies are covered for travel to and from work.

KatherineJaneway · 28/03/2023 14:18

My view is that you should give your insurance company all the details as they are. If he is not insured to commute to work and has modified his car without telling them, then that is his issue to deal with.

Rosula · 28/03/2023 14:18

There doesn't seem much point commenting till this mysterious no-commuter insurance is dealt with. I've never been asked on an insurance form whether I use my car to commute to work, and have always understood that it was fine to do so.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 14:17

I can’t get my head around not being fully honest with your insurance about the incident.

Why MNers get themselves into these scrapes?

You pranged his vehicle of course he will be upset. But accidents happen. You owned it, offered to pay through your insurance, if he’s done something dodgy with his own insurance it’s not even remotely your responsibility.

WombatChocolate · 28/03/2023 14:12

The reason this is problematic is because OP hasn’t been entirely straight with her insurer about what happened. She was foolishly trying to help her colleague and colluding in him hiding information.

All OP can do is to tell her insurer what happened and pass on the details of the person she hit.

There will be no payout without naming him and his vehicle and whatever insurance he does or doesn’t have, coming to light anyway.

The colleague is ooorly informed if he thinks his insurer won’t have to know what has happened. The claim will be on OPs insurance as she is responsible. It won’t be on the colleagues insurance, but his insurer willbe notified of what happened.

I think it is worth OP ringing her insurer again. She can start by asking what will be the process for repairing her car and the colleagues. If she has withheld anything about the accident, it is fairly easy to add further information. Changing the story is of course problematic. And what a shame if OP finds she voids her own insurance through lying. Yes, she caused the accident but had insurance and is willing to use it.

I don’t actually think the fact he’d driven to work will be an issue as OPs insurance will be paying. Worrying about modifications etc and worrying that his insurer will be involved does make me wonder if there’s more going on….does he actually have insurance or is he fully uninsured? He’s hiding something.
Regardless, OP should tell her insurance what happened and go through the official route.

It is not up to someone who has had an accident done to their car to decide how it will be paid for. OP has insurance so it covers her. She can and should claim on her insurance and not pay out if her own pocket. She can tell colleague, that even if that’s what he would like (for whatever reason) she wants to go through insurance and that’s what she will be doing.

Frabbits · 28/03/2023 14:11

You should have put it all through your insurance, whether the person you hit is properly insured is none of your concern.

DahliaMacNamara · 28/03/2023 14:08

Your colleague's right to be annoyed extends only to the inconvenience caused by your driving error. I don't blame him for that. But the dicking around with insurance companies and unnecessary costs incurred due to his own fuck-up is entirely on him.

Shz · 28/03/2023 14:04

Go through the correct and honest insurance protocol- lying will only come back to haunt you and could end up with them not paying out. His insurance is his issue, not yours - he is the one to blame for having insufficient insurance for his own car and for not disclosing to the insurer.

As for HR being involved - contact ACAS for advice but I suspect they are overstepping.

cestlavielife · 28/03/2023 14:01

If you are hit you claim via your insurer
I just did that for rear bump
My insurer arranged everything and claimed back from theirs

He claims via his insurance which will talk to hers
His issue to go via his insurer
if he chooses to pay put himself he can
If he wants op to pay op is insured to pay out but he goes via his insurer

Chickenly · 28/03/2023 14:01

PuddlesPityParty · 28/03/2023 13:43

I would just tell your insurance and let them sort it out. You’ll have done nothing wrong OP.

Nothing except hit someone’s vehicle and then lie to her insurance about it.

Ktime · 28/03/2023 14:00

kirinm · 28/03/2023 13:29

@PortmeirionTiles I did miss that! That's definitely a bit weird since the guy didn't do anything wrong.

He's doing plenty wrong. Why are you not getting this?

Ktime · 28/03/2023 13:59

This is what insurance is for. Do not pay him out of your own pocket, that would be madness.

Crumpleton · 28/03/2023 13:58

kirinm · 28/03/2023 13:29

@PortmeirionTiles I did miss that! That's definitely a bit weird since the guy didn't do anything wrong.

I think what he's done wrong is answer no to his insurance company when questioned whether he uses the vehicle for commuting to work, also that no modifications have been done to the vehicle when they have, which in itself is an offence and will void his insurance.

cestlavielife · 28/03/2023 13:57

How did you explain the damagexwithout giving his details number plate?

To protect him, I’ve submitted my claim but not involved my colleague.
So you omitted to say another vehicke was damaged?
That was daft
And now potentially problematic

But
Not your issue to pay out
Just tell him to claim on his insurance giving your details.
His insurer will get the money from yours

skyeisthelimit · 28/03/2023 13:57

It's not your fault that he did not have the correct insurance. He should have included commuting and didn't. It is made quite clear when you get a quote what you are covered for. I have to have SDC and Business use due to travelling to various client sites.

He underinsured it deliberately to save money and that has now backfired on him. Modifications add on extra insurance as it can make it more stealable.

Yes, you hit his vehicle, but you should have claimed it off your insurance and whatever happens to him is not your problem.

It is not a matter for HR.

If you are able to change your insurance claim then I would advise the employee that the only way that it can be done is via insurance. Whatever happens beyond that is nothing to do with you.

Yes you hit him and caused the damage, but HE was under insured, HIS problem.

Dotjones · 28/03/2023 13:55

Aside from the obvious point that anything that "could" lead to a claim usually needs to be declared to your insurer even if it doesn't actually lead to one, why does he need to claim on his insurance at all? You're to blame for the accident, you're insured, he needs to claim against your insurance not his.

MrsPinkCock · 28/03/2023 13:52

I’ve always had to add commuting and/or business use to my car insurance policies as appropriate, I’m really surprised this isn’t common knowledge! Weirdly sometimes adding commuting and business use has actually brought my insurance cost down…

Anyway - I’m gobsmacked that HR felt the need to get involved. Did you not tell them that him driving without adequate insurance is his problem, not yours, and that it’s his own stupid fault if he doesn’t get a payout on his uninsured vehicle?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread