Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have wanted to put my horse to sleep before she became a “welfare case”

94 replies

blinkybell · 28/03/2023 10:49

This happened a couple of months ago now, but it made an awful time so much harder than it needed to be.

I had an elderly horse with arthritis. She retired about 4 years ago now. We managed her pain with regular pain relief and supplements and the odd top up if she’d been titting about. She had slowly declined over the last year and found this winter hard going so I’d kind of made up my mind that I’d let her have a last spring and then think about PTS before the ground got too hard/heat/flies in summer.

A few weeks ago she was really uncomfortable and we struggled to get her field sound again. We’d had periods before where she was uncomfortable and after a couple of days on extra pain relief she was fine. I’d never got any sense from her before that she’d had enough. This time I did so I made the appointment.

The vet arrived, she checked my old girl over and asks me if perhaps we could try some different pain relief, some different supplements and that my horse wasn’t “a welfare case” yet.

The whole conversation was horrible - I pointed out that I wanted to give her a calm, peaceful and dignified end, before the pain became too much to bear, and most certainly before she became a welfare case. I’d always had a bit of a fear that I’d find her down in her field, unable to get up and it would be stressful and chaotic. She’d been the most amazing horse, and that I owed it to her to give her the best end I could and not just keep her going for the sake of it. We’d tried so many different supplements and pain relief over the years and I didn’t think anything would magically cure her arthritis.

I ended up feeling like I was arguing with the vet about killing my horse and, (this is probably going to sound mad) but it upset me that this whole conversation was in front of her.

Deep down, I made the right decision, I gave her the ending she deserved but, rightly or wrongly, the whole time I felt like I was being judged.

OP posts:
ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/03/2023 20:39

@PrincessofWellies and @Ratatouille1
sorry, hadn’t seen your posts.

exactly agreed- slaughter man. And yes, still available and will do individual or group cremation and return ashes in a box, urn or scatter tube.

ChrisTrepidation · 28/03/2023 20:38

I'm so sorry for the loss of your lovely mare.

You did the right thing. Please don't doubt yourself. You did what a loving sensible owner would do and have your horse a dignified end.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/03/2023 20:36

Caveat- my horses are at home and this pony never suffered laminitis, and had free roaming barn shelter from sun and a stream to walk in. Summer was his favourite and he had been retired many years.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/03/2023 20:34

And I’m afraid this is why I prefer a very experienced slaughter man. They never make you feel bad, they never try to talk you into or out of anything and they deliver instant pain free death.

im so sorry for your loss. As someone who has spent many years caring for the elderly and infirm horses and dogs, I confirm you did nothing wrong and I would and have done exactly the same.
the last one for me was October, one of the kid’s arthritic ponies. We gave him one last summer and said goodbye before he spent the winter slipping in mud and stiff in the cold.

Floralnomad · 28/03/2023 20:29

Sorry for your loss 💐. Perhaps she wasn’t a very experienced horse vet , is it a purely equine practice ? I’ve lost 4 equines over the years and I’ve never had an issue with a vet about it . Was she foreign as I have had some peculiar dealings with European vets and horses .

QuestionableMouse · 28/03/2023 20:23

Better a day too soon than an hour too late.

Your vet wasn't unreasonable to offer other options though either.

BrokenWing · 28/03/2023 20:10

I know a young vet who just lurves animals 🙄 and the stories she tells of owners who in her opinion PTS too early are ridiculously naive and patronising. I put it down to a lack of life experience.

I love my dog, he is a huge part of my family. But I hope when the time comes I have the strength and courage to do what you have done for your horse. Animals dont know why they are in pain or feeling shite zonked out on drugs, they live in the moment, and they dont know they are on a downward slope healthwise and or is never getting better. They deserve not to have their lives cruelly extended beyond what is comfortable for misplaced human feelings.

holachicas · 28/03/2023 20:08

Disclaimer, I do understand the vet making you aware of alternative options but they sounded argumentative/trying to push you in another direction

holachicas · 28/03/2023 20:07

You 100% have done right by her…I cared for a horse that I’d regularly find unable to get up and it was horrific each time. I was relieved when they moved yards but I wish they’d had him PTS. He’d been an international Showjumper and deserved more dignity in his twilight years.

I’m really surprised at your vet, most promote owners making tough decisions in order to be kind, especially with horses so they’re not passed around, etc.

Sorry for your loss but please take comfort in knowing you’ve done her proud 💐

Cheesyfootballs01 · 28/03/2023 19:54

2bazookas · 28/03/2023 14:18

The vet is professionally obliged to inform the animal owner what treatment options are possible, so the owner can decide which to pursue.

The vet did that, and you made your decision.

Don't blame the vet for your grieving.

The Vet did give her opinion on what options were available and the OP decided that PTS was the correct and right decision- the Vet should respect that and not argue.

Horses can go downhill very quickly and as owners it is up to us to make the right decision to let them go with dignity- especially if the OPs horse has gone down in the field and struggled to get up.

OP I would contact the Practice and mention that you wasn’t happy with the Vet that came out. But you made the right decision. You know your horse.

ADHDVet · 28/03/2023 19:51

Oh bless you!
I wasn’t there of course but the vet probably just worded that badly. So many owners want to throw everything at their pet just to squeeze an extra few days out of them. I think they were just trying to offer another option but they should have dropped it as soon as you made your point clear.

Euthanasia means good death. Your lovely horse just lived day by day. They don’t look forward to spring or Christmas, they just live in the moment. You making the decision to let them go with dignity is nothing but a kind thing.

You made a selfless decision. Please don’t beat yourself up over a comment that the vet made.

Lastnamedidntstick · 28/03/2023 19:49

RandomMess · 28/03/2023 12:09

I think vets are obliged to give all the options.

It's horrible to have to listen to them when you know the time has come and you are heartbroken 💔😢

this.

Do you think the vet was making sure you knew you had made the right choice?

they gave you your options, you knew none of them were right for your horse, leaving the one option you decided on?

surely better than finding out after there were other things you could have done?

MisgenderedSwan · 28/03/2023 19:42

Better a week too soon than an hour too late.

I am so sorry for your loss. I think you made the best decision for your horse and I'm sorry the vet was not supportive.

Cherrysoup · 28/03/2023 19:41

You totally made the right call. I would have been furious if my vet had wanted to try any more treatments with my aged arthritic horse. No way was I going to let him suffer. I absolutely hate the ‘let’s give them the last summer’ when the ground will be hard and the heat and flies will harass them. You did the right thing. If you get another, consider which vet you want/maybe change practices.

SoShallINever · 28/03/2023 19:37

So sorry for your loss OP.
You did the right thing.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/03/2023 19:18

I have been through this decision with cats and dogs, and my maxim has always been that I’d rather make the hard decision a week early than a day late.

As you say, @blinkybell, you wanted your beloved horse to have a peaceful, calm death, without pain - and that was your final gift to her.

LikeAnOldFriend · 28/03/2023 19:06

Flowers to you. I'm so sorry for your loss. My boy is 27 and has had arthritis for years - it's managed at the moment with supplements and medication but I know that the day will come when it can't be anymore and I only hope I can be calm enough and brave enough to help him say goodbye in the best possible way. I think it's wonderful that you have done that. Hope you're doing ok. Flowers

BodgerBadgerMashup · 28/03/2023 14:52

Another one to say you did exactly the right thing. We know our animals so much better than the vets do, we see them every day and see the decline when they are old or ill. I had mine (aged 33) put down last year due to laminitis. The vet did offer treatment options but the chances of success were not high and all came with a massive impact on her quality of life, and she was already in a lot of pain. It was so hard to make the call, even though i knew in my heart of hearts it was right. Thankfully I had a friend to call who helped me make sense of it and having talked it through the vet also agreed, and was wonderful, which helped.

I think there might be a couple of things at play...

  1. Vets don't enjoy putting animals down and like treating them so will always favour treating if there is any option over PTS. But they don't have to witness the daily struggle for the animal during treatment which might just be dragging or the process with the same end result.
  2. Lots of owners really don't want to make the call so it will be a surprise to the vet that you had already thought through and made the decision so somewhat unexpected.
  3. Perhaps they also worry you might regret your decision later and complain they didn't encourage you to try something else?

Regardless a truly brave and compassionate vet should be there to support you through that process and not make it more difficult.

I thought about it a lot for a long time after, but I think a year on I have made peace with it I hope the same happens for you. X

2bazookas · 28/03/2023 14:18

The vet is professionally obliged to inform the animal owner what treatment options are possible, so the owner can decide which to pursue.

The vet did that, and you made your decision.

Don't blame the vet for your grieving.

Howmanycatsistoomany · 28/03/2023 14:00

The vet was totally out of order. You'd made the decision and booked the appointment. I'd actually have a firm word with the senior partner at the practice - it was absolutely not the vet's place to make you defend your decision to put an end to your old, arthritic horse's suffering.

MeinKraft · 28/03/2023 13:59

YANBU but I imagine the vet was letting you know treatment options were available to cover them in case you came back later and said you hadn't realised your horses life could have been prolonged with this or that treatment.

Tlittle · 28/03/2023 13:55

You did the right thing for sure 100%. We were in this situation with our dog. I said she did not have long left a year tops to warn my kids as I just had a feeling she was not going to be around much longer. I thought about getting her pts. Throughout December she deteriorated then got better and then deteriorated and died in her sleep just after Xmas but we made sure she had a lovely last Xmas. 😥

Bobshhh · 28/03/2023 13:55

We (me and owner) chose to have the horse I loaned put down after he couldn’t get up in the field a couple of times and showed signs that was becoming the new norm. It was absolutely the best thing that we could have done for him and would have been horribly cruel to pump him full of more drugs to see if that helped.

KohlaParasaurus · 28/03/2023 13:52

You've made a wise and compassionate decision in good time rather than waiting until it was "too late" and your horse was suffering, which is a tricky call for anyone who cares for an animal, and I'm sorry you were made to feel otherwise. I hope you find peace.

Reddickyouless · 28/03/2023 13:49

Stop questioning yourself @blinkybell , you know your horse, if there's no quality of life then it's unkind to prolong their suffering
I'm so sorry you've been through this, it's a heartbreaking decision to make

Swipe left for the next trending thread