Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad the Guardian have stopped describing the school shooter as a woman?

265 replies

Greatly · 28/03/2023 10:48

They headlined with the shooter being a woman yesterday.

Today of course we learn the shooter is transgender.

They would have known this yesterday.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 13:00

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 28/03/2023 12:55

You should not be giving the shooter the satisfaction of trying to have a balanced discussion around this issue.
I promise you nobody in Nashville cares about what pronouns they used or what they identified as.
I know one of the victims families, they care that 3 teenage boys have lost their baby sister forever.
Please stop using this evil act as a springboard for your opinions, we are a community in deep mourning and everyone's focus should be on the families and friends of the victims not the evil that perpetrated this.

a million percent agree ! Its sickening people are discussing the evil person who did this, rather than giving respect and dignity to the families who have suffered a huge loss in their families. makes me so angry people arguing over pronouns of this person

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 13:00

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 28/03/2023 12:55

You should not be giving the shooter the satisfaction of trying to have a balanced discussion around this issue.
I promise you nobody in Nashville cares about what pronouns they used or what they identified as.
I know one of the victims families, they care that 3 teenage boys have lost their baby sister forever.
Please stop using this evil act as a springboard for your opinions, we are a community in deep mourning and everyone's focus should be on the families and friends of the victims not the evil that perpetrated this.

I’m sorry to hear it. You don’t think the perpetrator’s family is in mourning for the child they thought they knew?

Airbrushing the event as “evil” without any reference to the wider society in which the crime was committed, the gun laws that made it possible, the mental state of the perpetrator - is deeply simplistic.

Wanderingowl · 28/03/2023 13:00

Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 12:58

I dont think it matters if it was a male or female, humans lost their lives, as PP's have said. these children who died and whose parents, mothers, brothers etc died are not going home.

again , media putting more attention on what the shooter identifies as really is the last thing they should be doing. perhaps thats why they didnt specify in the news.

It matters because their trans identity appears to have been their motivation. Knowing a killer's motivation is actually extremely important because it's how society learns to recognise signs that may help them prevent further tragedies.

Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 12:58

I dont think it matters if it was a male or female, humans lost their lives, as PP's have said. these children who died and whose parents, mothers, brothers etc died are not going home.

again , media putting more attention on what the shooter identifies as really is the last thing they should be doing. perhaps thats why they didnt specify in the news.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 12:58

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 12:42

What are you implying? That she was biologically female or that she only identified as male online but not in real life? Because there are photos of her clearly presenting herself as male in real life - ie male clothing and short hair.

To be fair, this has been reported on in exactly the same way by some news outlets - some were suggesting that she had detransitioned IRL but was still using different pronouns on social media.

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 28/03/2023 12:55

You should not be giving the shooter the satisfaction of trying to have a balanced discussion around this issue.
I promise you nobody in Nashville cares about what pronouns they used or what they identified as.
I know one of the victims families, they care that 3 teenage boys have lost their baby sister forever.
Please stop using this evil act as a springboard for your opinions, we are a community in deep mourning and everyone's focus should be on the families and friends of the victims not the evil that perpetrated this.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 12:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Then maybe trans activists should have a look at the coverage of this tragedy to remind themselves what violence actually looks like.

Blueisthecolour1 · 28/03/2023 12:50

@PuttingDownRoots

Or we could concentrate more on the tragedy that three 9yos didn't go home last night, plus three staff members.

Jesus, 100% this. Why the hell have people latched onto this as an excuse to start a gender-war topic. Who cares, whether this murderer was male or female or halfway in between? It's so far off focus it deserves a comment like Roots has said.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 12:50

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 28/03/2023 12:41

I have outlined several times here that the crime itself is devastating but since the US are completely unwilling to attack the source of the problem, i'll continue to look at some details more than others

Regards this, there's fuck all point in UK women wringing their hands over American gun crime. America does not care what we think of it's insane gun laws, health care policies and approach to religion. America cannot understand British Left Wing politics or feminism, let alone see itself the way other countries do.

I feel sad for US the same way I feel sad for other countries whose citizens suffer unnecesarily. The difference is that US has a global influence that many of these other countries don't have. As a citizen of a country which - just about - remembers what Left Wing politics actually are, what feminism is and universal health care, I have an interest in untangling the pervasive influence of the US on UK culture.

Yep. In America they view our NHS as a ‘socialist’ institution and hold it up as a perfect example of why they don’t want or need universal health care. More and more, the are exerting their own influence over it, enabled by a Tory government intent on ‘reforming’ it out of existence.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 12:50

DinnerThyme · 28/03/2023 12:44

Except they aren’t being reported as a woman. They were initially reported as a woman because the police initially said they were a woman because they look like a woman and are named Audrey. Then, the police clarified and media outlets changed their reports. So, this biologically female person committed murder and is not being reported as a woman, hence the OP. It’s completely incorrect to claim “when women who think they are men commit crimes, they are reported as women”.

I don’t believe the police didn’t know she was trans early on. I don’t think it was a mistake I think it was Nashville - which is fairly conservative.

Audrey don’t look particularly female from the coverage of the event, she could be a teenage boy.

TheHoover · 28/03/2023 12:48

Except they aren’t being reported as a woman. They were initially reported as a woman because the police initially said they were a woman because they look like a woman and are named Audrey. Then, the police clarified and media outlets changed their reports. So, this biologically female person committed murder and is not being reported as a woman, hence the OP. It’s completely incorrect to claim “when women who think they are men commit crimes, they are reported as women”*

I agree but hey let the outraged have their moments of outrage…..

MushroomQueen · 28/03/2023 12:47

I made the same mistake as initially bbc or sky said transwoman not transman but then said female- terrible reporting and shows the need for clear language- there are men, women, transmen and transwomen. Muddying the waters with ID as a man female just confuses it. Sex based language with gender descriptions ie transwoman tells you what sex the person is as well as their gender

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 28/03/2023 12:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Wanderingowl · 28/03/2023 12:45

happydappy2 · 28/03/2023 12:42

One has to ask how testosterone affects the female brain, did it make the killer more unstable & violent?

We don't know if Hale was on testosterone at this point. But we do know that artificial testosterone that increases testosterone above normal levels, can massively increase aggression. (I'm not referring to men and women who take artificial testosterone due to deficiency, to bring them to normal levels.)

DinnerThyme · 28/03/2023 12:44

TreesAtSea · 28/03/2023 12:40

Exactly

Except they aren’t being reported as a woman. They were initially reported as a woman because the police initially said they were a woman because they look like a woman and are named Audrey. Then, the police clarified and media outlets changed their reports. So, this biologically female person committed murder and is not being reported as a woman, hence the OP. It’s completely incorrect to claim “when women who think they are men commit crimes, they are reported as women”.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 28/03/2023 12:44

Starburst8 · 28/03/2023 11:24

Not wanting to be ignorant but what does it matter? The shooter went into a school, shot and killed innocent people. I've seen a lot of discussion regarding the shooter's pronouns etc as if it's disrespectful to the shooter for getting it wrong. I think our concern should be with the victims families.
Also as a side note, an article with the shooter's mother was released where she is quoted as saying "I think I've lost my daughter".

Our concern absolutely should be with the victims and their families. But that doesn’t mean that accurate reporting by the msm is therefore not important, does it?

ancientgran · 28/03/2023 12:42

Brefugee · 28/03/2023 12:35

I don't know what it will take for the US to agree to reform their gun control laws. And when I saw reform, I mean radically reform. How many more children are going to have to die before someone says enough?! Utterly tragic

well, they won't so it's just a fact of life in the same way that plane crashes or car accidents are a fact of life (but more frequent than the former, mass shootings fewer than the latter but individual shootings? who knows)

It is interesting that in the UK after Dunblane there was decisive action, after Sandy Hook? we know what happened after that. The most tragic thing about all these mass shootings is that we know each time that it won't be the last.

It is perfectly legitimate to look into press reporting of events. I see pp thought it would be a good idea to not report on the shooter at all. I find that interesting (pretty much like the conventions now on reporting on suicide).

The shooter being trans or not (aside of the manifesto which i hadn't read about) is also neither here nor there, in the grand scheme of things apart from 2 points. One is that this is so rarely a crime committed by a biological woman that the sex of the shooter is hugely relevant. The fact that the shooter claims a trans identity is also hugely relevant. And clear and consistent reporting is definitely required here.

On the news this morning they were saying that the shooting stats vary between states, the said New York and New Jersey have low rates as they have stricter gun control. I have no idea if that is true but if it is then shame on the states that won't follow their example.

Wanderingowl · 28/03/2023 12:42

DinnerThyme · 28/03/2023 12:37

It’s quite amusing watching all the usual “if you’re born as a woman/man, then you’re a woman/man” try to argue that this time doesn’t count and she was actually a man. Make up your mind!

Nobody at all is arguing that. So I'm not sure what you are laughing at. Maybe your won ability to understand what people are saying in your rush to own the terfs or something. People are arguing for consistency. When transwomen (ie men) commit crimes, they are reported as women's crimes. This transman (ie woman) is being reported as a woman/female. It's accurate with regard to her but not accurate with regard to transwomen (men). We want consistency.

Mostly we want accurate reporting, if a transwoman commits a crime, I want to know that a man identifying as a woman has committed the crime. Especially if their chosen identity is relevant due to their motivation or access to victims. In this case a woman identifying as a man committed the crime and it appears that her trans identification could have been a motivating factor in her murder to 6 people, including 3 nine year olds. (And it's pretty sick that you are laughing at anything involving that, tbh.)

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 12:42

ancientgran · 28/03/2023 12:32

So she was transgender on social media but female in real life?

What are you implying? That she was biologically female or that she only identified as male online but not in real life? Because there are photos of her clearly presenting herself as male in real life - ie male clothing and short hair.

happydappy2 · 28/03/2023 12:42

One has to ask how testosterone affects the female brain, did it make the killer more unstable & violent?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 12:41

ancientgran · 28/03/2023 12:32

So she was transgender on social media but female in real life?

Confusing isn’t it ? Just when you thought it couldn’t get any more so !!

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 28/03/2023 12:41

I have outlined several times here that the crime itself is devastating but since the US are completely unwilling to attack the source of the problem, i'll continue to look at some details more than others

Regards this, there's fuck all point in UK women wringing their hands over American gun crime. America does not care what we think of it's insane gun laws, health care policies and approach to religion. America cannot understand British Left Wing politics or feminism, let alone see itself the way other countries do.

I feel sad for US the same way I feel sad for other countries whose citizens suffer unnecesarily. The difference is that US has a global influence that many of these other countries don't have. As a citizen of a country which - just about - remembers what Left Wing politics actually are, what feminism is and universal health care, I have an interest in untangling the pervasive influence of the US on UK culture.

FourTeaFallOut · 28/03/2023 12:40

SidewaysOtter · 28/03/2023 12:40

Maybe then it would be more helpful if people were just referred to as their biological sex regardless of how they "identify". Then there would be no confusion.

Sounds good to me.

TreesAtSea · 28/03/2023 12:40

RenegadeMistress · 28/03/2023 11:08

When women who think they are men commit crimes, they are reported as women. When men who think they are women commit crimes, they are reported as women. It really is a men's rights movement. They want people to think women are as statistically likely to commit violent crime as men are. Why is that.

Exactly

SidewaysOtter · 28/03/2023 12:40

Maybe then it would be more helpful if people were just referred to as their biological sex regardless of how they "identify". Then there would be no confusion.