Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad the Guardian have stopped describing the school shooter as a woman?

265 replies

Greatly · 28/03/2023 10:48

They headlined with the shooter being a woman yesterday.

Today of course we learn the shooter is transgender.

They would have known this yesterday.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ItIsFiat · 28/03/2023 13:23

Boudicasbeard · 28/03/2023 13:13

Here is a link for doubters. It encourages attendees to admire the use of molatov cocktails at the original Stonewall riots. And asks that people organise events in their hometowns. Looks like someone took that seriously.

https://www.struggle-la-lucha.org/2023/02/09/washington-d-c-trans-day-of-vengeance-march-31-april-1/

UK public servants aren't having special days for all protected groups only certain ones, who get special treatment, despite the equality act stating such behaviour causes bad feelings between protected characteristics and shouldn't happen.

Look at the crime stats. The public servants keep bending the knee to woke ideologies that harm other groups, it is a form of worship as it makes others sacrifices to this idol they worship.

This is an excellent thread on this religion that's taken over.

mobile.twitter.com/ConceptualJames/status/1640413801609609225

Haffiana · 28/03/2023 13:22

She was a woman who identified as a mass murderer.

I do not see what she felt about her gender has any relevance to anything or why it should be reported.

GailBlancheViola · 28/03/2023 13:21

SidewaysOtter · 28/03/2023 12:40

Maybe then it would be more helpful if people were just referred to as their biological sex regardless of how they "identify". Then there would be no confusion.

Precisely.

And the crimes committed recorded as perpetrated by the biological sex the person is.

Mangling language, definitions and pronouns is why there is confusion surrounding the perpetrator of this crime and their motive.

Keep it simple, straightforward and factual, report the truth, record the truth.

amyneedssleep · 28/03/2023 13:20

The largely right wing American and UK media feel it is important to perpetuate the belief that female violence can be just as brutal as male violence. That way they do not have to report the reality that we are living in a patriarchal hellscape.

When a perpetrator of violence is trans, their pronouns are either respected (for transwomen) or disregarded (for transmen.) Bob's your uncle, more and more women are seen in the public eye as being criminals regardless of either their gender expression or their biological sex. There are no winners here, not trans people nor gender critics.

It is fundamentally transphobic to state that the shooter is female if you're also going to say in the same breath that they're trans. If their gender expression isn't important, neither is their trans status. It's at best a clarifying paragraph later in the article, not part of the headline.

I expect this absolute rubbish from right-wing-and-proud tabloid rags, but when coverage is meant to be impartial, it's absolutely infuriating to see blatant, harmful misinformation which is then recycled on here by people who hate transwomen and saw this as an easy win.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 13:17

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 13:10

I think it’s way too early to be trying to instil any kind of sympathy or empathy towards the killers’ mental state. I do get where you’re coming from. Her family will be grieving too, but it has to be said that all Americans are a product of their environment, and not everyone who has problems with their mental state shoots their way into a school and guns children down. And if they had close contact with her, surely her family must have had their concerns - if so, why didn’t they act on them ? There have been many, many school shooting tragedies, and each one has provided an opportunity for gun law reform. Nothing has changed, so you have to accept the status quo. I’m sure all of these issues will come out in time as the investigation continues, but now isn’t the time.

First I haven’t tried to “instill” anything. Secondly I didn’t suggest sympathy or empathy towards the killer, merely analysis.

There’s no such thing as the right time: the time is when these events occur.

I don’t agree that anyone has to accept the status quo on guns in the US. Every latest shooting increases the importance of challenging the might gun lobby.

SpidersAreShitheads · 28/03/2023 13:17

Brefugee · 28/03/2023 12:35

I don't know what it will take for the US to agree to reform their gun control laws. And when I saw reform, I mean radically reform. How many more children are going to have to die before someone says enough?! Utterly tragic

well, they won't so it's just a fact of life in the same way that plane crashes or car accidents are a fact of life (but more frequent than the former, mass shootings fewer than the latter but individual shootings? who knows)

It is interesting that in the UK after Dunblane there was decisive action, after Sandy Hook? we know what happened after that. The most tragic thing about all these mass shootings is that we know each time that it won't be the last.

It is perfectly legitimate to look into press reporting of events. I see pp thought it would be a good idea to not report on the shooter at all. I find that interesting (pretty much like the conventions now on reporting on suicide).

The shooter being trans or not (aside of the manifesto which i hadn't read about) is also neither here nor there, in the grand scheme of things apart from 2 points. One is that this is so rarely a crime committed by a biological woman that the sex of the shooter is hugely relevant. The fact that the shooter claims a trans identity is also hugely relevant. And clear and consistent reporting is definitely required here.

I agree with you on all those points. I included a reference to the gun control laws really for completeness, but yes, we know how pointless it is and that there's no real appetite for any change in the US.

The rest of my post was making the point that accuracy and consistency in language is important. According to some sources, the shooter had been living as a male called Aidan and presented physically as a male so the reporting of them as female is not consistent with how trans women criminals have been reported - and that's extremely relevant for crime statistics and data.

I read someone questioning whether the shooter was taking testosterone - we don't know how far they'd transitioned. If they were taking T, again that could be relevant because as we know from bodybuilders, supplementing with testosterone can cause serious aggression.

It's all relevant. For many different reasons.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 13:16

Boudicasbeard · 28/03/2023 13:04

Are people missing the fact that major US trans orgs called openly for Trans Vengance and then this happened?

The politics of this is key to why it happened. Children are dead because online activists have convinced mentally vulnerable people that they are under threat and now one of them has lashed out in real life.

How is this any different to right wing shooters, Islamic terrorism or any ideologically driven act of violence.

It isn’t.

I missed this totally, yes. If that’s the case, it’s chilling to think that this woman has acted on that and changes the whole scenario to an act of terrorism.

Gincan · 28/03/2023 13:15

TheHoover · 28/03/2023 12:48

Except they aren’t being reported as a woman. They were initially reported as a woman because the police initially said they were a woman because they look like a woman and are named Audrey. Then, the police clarified and media outlets changed their reports. So, this biologically female person committed murder and is not being reported as a woman, hence the OP. It’s completely incorrect to claim “when women who think they are men commit crimes, they are reported as women”*

I agree but hey let the outraged have their moments of outrage…..

Exactly....why let facts get in the way of outrage

AssignedNorthern · 28/03/2023 13:15

FourTeaFallOut · 28/03/2023 10:55

What you need to know is that, in the media, when a man declares himself to be a woman - then he is a woman. And when women declare herself to be a man - they are still a woman. This is abjection. Men get to have a sex class that excludes men who won't acquiesce to gender norms and also excludes the women who come knocking on their door.

Thus, whenever a transgender person commits a crime - regardless of their sex - it is always a woman's crime.

This is 100% - shows the whole thing to be an absolute pile of misogyny

ItIsFiat · 28/03/2023 13:12

FourTeaFallOut · 28/03/2023 10:55

What you need to know is that, in the media, when a man declares himself to be a woman - then he is a woman. And when women declare herself to be a man - they are still a woman. This is abjection. Men get to have a sex class that excludes men who won't acquiesce to gender norms and also excludes the women who come knocking on their door.

Thus, whenever a transgender person commits a crime - regardless of their sex - it is always a woman's crime.

It seems so.

FourTeaFallOut · 28/03/2023 13:11

Where is this Trans Vengeance call to arms - is this a real thing or one of those joke mistruths spread from disrupting corners of the internet just to see how far the lie can travel?

CuriousD · 28/03/2023 13:11

Shocking isn't it.

Six people where murdered in cold blood, three of them children.

But all the "med'ja" attention will be on the killers right to have their choice of pronouns used.

Whiteroomjoy · 28/03/2023 13:10

Ok, here’s a thought…given male pattern violence stems from testosterone (ok then culture adds to differences), do we know if this transgender male was taking testosterone? It is so very rare that women kill and even rarer for them to take multiple random lives .

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 13:10

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 13:00

I’m sorry to hear it. You don’t think the perpetrator’s family is in mourning for the child they thought they knew?

Airbrushing the event as “evil” without any reference to the wider society in which the crime was committed, the gun laws that made it possible, the mental state of the perpetrator - is deeply simplistic.

I think it’s way too early to be trying to instil any kind of sympathy or empathy towards the killers’ mental state. I do get where you’re coming from. Her family will be grieving too, but it has to be said that all Americans are a product of their environment, and not everyone who has problems with their mental state shoots their way into a school and guns children down. And if they had close contact with her, surely her family must have had their concerns - if so, why didn’t they act on them ? There have been many, many school shooting tragedies, and each one has provided an opportunity for gun law reform. Nothing has changed, so you have to accept the status quo. I’m sure all of these issues will come out in time as the investigation continues, but now isn’t the time.

Wanderingowl · 28/03/2023 13:10

Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 13:05

So society will accept this behaviour because they are trans? ... it feels like the motive behind this is given a pass because they are trans ? its no different from a male or female (neither trans) with mental health issues who go and do these things. it doesnt matter what they identify as , its mental health not their pronoun that did this. mental health signs should be looked for

A major US trans organisation has been calling for Trans Vengeance due to the passing of House Bill 1 in Tennessee. There have been calls online by trans activists to say that if trans kids aren't 'safe' your kids aren't safe. A trans identifying person in Tennessee shot of an elementary school, murdering 3 children, and has left behind a detailed manifesto. I don't know what's in the manifesto, but it's being implied that those are linked. If that is true, do you really think that's unimportant or just boils down to a 'mental health' issue no different to non-trans mental health issues? Because it fucking well doesn't.

Mirabai · 28/03/2023 13:09

Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 13:00

a million percent agree ! Its sickening people are discussing the evil person who did this, rather than giving respect and dignity to the families who have suffered a huge loss in their families. makes me so angry people arguing over pronouns of this person

Forensic psychologists and criminal profilers should just resign then?

JaneJeffer · 28/03/2023 13:06

Please stop using this evil act as a springboard for your opinions
How is anything going to be learned if no one is allowed to express an opinion? Keep sticking your head in the sand and these mass killings of innocent children will never end.

Jusmakingit · 28/03/2023 13:05

Wanderingowl · 28/03/2023 13:00

It matters because their trans identity appears to have been their motivation. Knowing a killer's motivation is actually extremely important because it's how society learns to recognise signs that may help them prevent further tragedies.

So society will accept this behaviour because they are trans? ... it feels like the motive behind this is given a pass because they are trans ? its no different from a male or female (neither trans) with mental health issues who go and do these things. it doesnt matter what they identify as , its mental health not their pronoun that did this. mental health signs should be looked for

Boudicasbeard · 28/03/2023 13:04

Are people missing the fact that major US trans orgs called openly for Trans Vengance and then this happened?

The politics of this is key to why it happened. Children are dead because online activists have convinced mentally vulnerable people that they are under threat and now one of them has lashed out in real life.

How is this any different to right wing shooters, Islamic terrorism or any ideologically driven act of violence.

It isn’t.

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/03/2023 13:04

The shooter WAS a woman.

A transman is a woman.

What the Guardian should be doing is describing transwomen as men.

I've seen a lot of discussion regarding the shooter's pronouns etc as if it's disrespectful to the shooter for getting it wrong.

Many people do think this. They think that "misgendering" and "dead naming" are "literal violence".

You know what is disrespectful? Killing people.

You know what is literal violence? Killing people.

News reports suggest she hadn’t transitioned.

If she had declared herself male, then she had transitioned. Men with full gentilia are apparently women because they declare themselves to be. This means that women who declare themselves to be men, are men.

but if it was a trans woman rather than a trans man she would be identified as a woman not a man. You can't have these things both ways. I wait with bated breath for the next trans woman rapist to be referred to as a man...

This. ⬆

My heart ached for those who have been murdered, and fr their families.

My heart aches for the shooter's family.

The whole thing is horrific.

FourTeaFallOut · 28/03/2023 13:02

Oh, of course it matters. The only reason why we are hearing about this shooting in a school over all the other shootings which happen week in and out in America is because this is a man-bites-dog event for a woman to commit this kind of offence.

HoneyPotBee · 28/03/2023 13:01

The shooter is a woman!

DotAndCarryOne2 · 28/03/2023 13:01

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 28/03/2023 12:55

You should not be giving the shooter the satisfaction of trying to have a balanced discussion around this issue.
I promise you nobody in Nashville cares about what pronouns they used or what they identified as.
I know one of the victims families, they care that 3 teenage boys have lost their baby sister forever.
Please stop using this evil act as a springboard for your opinions, we are a community in deep mourning and everyone's focus should be on the families and friends of the victims not the evil that perpetrated this.

I think the only relevant point about the transgender issue is the reported testosterone therapy and whether it contributed to state of mind. I think even that’s a stretch, given that she was a former student at the school. Unless/until there’s more information as to the relevance of sex/gender, as the investigation continues, discussion only detracts from the tragedy and wider issues surrounding gun control.