Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Jourdain11 · 30/03/2023 22:02

Bepis · 30/03/2023 21:50

This!

Priti Patel also said that she stands firm in her decision due to all the intelligence information she has seen, that we will never be privy to.

Priti Patel, that paragon of legislative and diplomatic competency. So committed that she even holds meetings when she's on holiday! Such a good grasp of international law.

greenacrylicpaint · 30/03/2023 22:01

the 'bad people' episode on this was very interesting as well.

I think both things can be true - she was a vulnerable teenager and was groomed and trafficked but also that she poses a risk now.

howevr, I profoundly disagree with the passport issue. it is wrong on so many levels to remove citisenship and to leave a person stateless.

babybythesea · 30/03/2023 22:00

Bepis · 30/03/2023 21:12

I just listened to the podcast and it was very interesting. Made me appreciate more how young girls or boys can get into these situations but I have to agree with the journalist, that she was still part of it and there are still consequences for that.

Does anyone have the link to the full interview with Shamimas husband that the journalist makes reference to?

It appears in the podcast “I am not a monster.” There’s two series. The first one concentrates on an American woman who took her children there. They are all now back in the USA and she is in jail there. The second series is all about Shamima Begum. They spend a lot of time trying to corroborate her version of events, speaking to people who knew her wile in Syria etc. And there is a long interview with her husband. Each series is about 10 episodes long. It’s on BBC sounds.

Kanaloa · 30/03/2023 21:57

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 30/03/2023 21:52

Yes obviously I believe anything they both say 😒

Boris Johnsons government would never lie for political expedience!

I was just going to say this 😂 why does everyone suddenly trust the government to tell the truth?

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 30/03/2023 21:52

Yes obviously I believe anything they both say 😒

Boris Johnsons government would never lie for political expedience!

Bepis · 30/03/2023 21:50

BashfulClam · 28/03/2023 20:00

Sajid Javid had said that if the public knew what the security forces knew we would not want her back. If she wasn’t seen as a risk she would be back here but there is some reason they believe her to be a massive risk.

This!

Priti Patel also said that she stands firm in her decision due to all the intelligence information she has seen, that we will never be privy to.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 30/03/2023 21:14

I agree with you. If she was white she would be seen for what she is, a victim of grooming and child exploitation.

Bepis · 30/03/2023 21:12

I just listened to the podcast and it was very interesting. Made me appreciate more how young girls or boys can get into these situations but I have to agree with the journalist, that she was still part of it and there are still consequences for that.

Does anyone have the link to the full interview with Shamimas husband that the journalist makes reference to?

steppemum · 30/03/2023 11:51

Another thing which reflects shockingly on us as a nation:

If she was not eligble for a Bangladesh passport, then it would have been illegal to strip her of her British citzenship.

So we are running a 2 tier system. If your parents were born elsewhere, so technically you are entitled to a passport from another country, then obviously you are not properly British. Not British enough to belong enough for us to deal with you.

She was born and brought up here. She has never lived in Bangladesh. She is a full British citizen - except she isn't

My kids are half Dutch. They were born and brought up here. Technically that means they are entitled to hold a Dutch passport.

So my kids are second class British citzens. Not protected fully under British law, and not entitled full to all the benefits and responsibilities of being British, (including that she needs to stand trial here) because at any point, the Home secretary can turn round and say - nope, stripping you of your citizenship.
We know it is legal, it is just massively immoral, and it has huge implications for all the thousand of Brits who naively thought they held British citizenship.

Deep rooted racism at its worst.

Climbles · 30/03/2023 10:48

GoodChat · 30/03/2023 08:05

We do treat children found guilty of murder differently than an adult who commits the same crime, an u18 wouldn't even be named before a trial and Begum has not been found guilty of anything at all.

She wasn't under 18 when she chose to raise children into that world though. She defends a lot of ISIS actions; and does so as an adult.

She’s in a camp full of ISIS where non believers, including women, are murdered regularly. She may be afraid to completely denounce them. The reason so many ISIS members have been allowed back and not her is she was on TV a lot for being a young girl. Then pissed everyone off by not sounding like a ‘proper’ victim.

BorisisaLune · 30/03/2023 10:07

GoodChat · 30/03/2023 08:05

We do treat children found guilty of murder differently than an adult who commits the same crime, an u18 wouldn't even be named before a trial and Begum has not been found guilty of anything at all.

She wasn't under 18 when she chose to raise children into that world though. She defends a lot of ISIS actions; and does so as an adult.

She was 15 when she went to Syria, married within 10 days, all her 3 children died shortly after birth, her youngest child died when she was 19, so i expect she had her first at 16 or 17?

I don't know about you but that would send many women into severe depression.

I don't doubt at all she did what many say she did but thats not the point, she is a UK citizen and should face trial in the UK, she is our responsibility & why was she treated differently to male ISIS fighters allowed to return here and with no trial?

babybythesea · 30/03/2023 08:20

Jadviga · 30/03/2023 03:12

Shipping off elsewhere someone who committed crimes in the UK is completely different from someone who left and committed crimes in other countries. A quick google tells me that 2335 UK nationals are imprisoned abroad so that's hardly a new concept, even if she had kept her citizenship.

Presumably they are detained after trials in that country. There has been no trial there, only an announcement from the UK that we aren’t having her back.
So Syria haven’t said “we’re keeping her in prison because we’ve found this to be necessary.” They’re keeping her because we’ve said “Not our problem- you deal with it. We don’t want her.” Not the same as most other UK nationals detained abroad.
So again. Why do we think that’s ok? Dumping our problem on another country? What do we do if they say no, not doing this any more? Do we really think this is keeping us safer? Because if you listen to people who been to those camps they are described as ticking time bombs. People kept in terrible conditions with resentment festering. It leaves it wide open for a group like ISIS to step in and say “See - the west is bad. They didn’t care. They left you to rot. They left the children in here to rot. We can offer you this instead…”

GoodChat · 30/03/2023 08:05

We do treat children found guilty of murder differently than an adult who commits the same crime, an u18 wouldn't even be named before a trial and Begum has not been found guilty of anything at all.

She wasn't under 18 when she chose to raise children into that world though. She defends a lot of ISIS actions; and does so as an adult.

BorisisaLune · 30/03/2023 07:28

mumofboys8787 · 30/03/2023 04:40

Of course she is both, unfortunately for her that's not a valid defence.

Many rapists were victims of sexual abuse in the past, it doesn't excuse their actions.

Many murderers were victims of abuse in some capacity, or witnessed violence in their childhood or in their past. Behaviours such as these are hugely disproportionately down to learned behaviours, but this cannot and should not be used as a defence for committing crimes later on in life. We will never know for sure what she did, or what she was directly involved with. However, she didn't escape at the first opportunity or when she realised what it was she had gotten herself into. Instead she stayed and created a family and birthed multiple children into a life of radicalism. Weighing all this up, she's simply too much of flight risk to allow back into this country.

We do treat children found guilty of murder differently than an adult who commits the same crime, an u18 wouldn't even be named before a trial and Begum has not been found guilty of anything at all.

For me, she is as British as Sunak, Javid, Johnson or Braverman, all of whom could claim citizenship else where, so she should be here in the UK, subjected to the UK's justice system.

But the biggest reason she should be here is equality, so many male ISIS fighters have been allowed back into the UK, without even a trial, so why is a female, who as far as we know never fought for ISIS (based on the number of pregnancies she had, was used for sex) being treated so very differently?

ImAGoodPerson · 30/03/2023 07:25

Jadviga · 30/03/2023 03:07

That's because a 15-yo engaging in sex with an older man is hurting no one but themselves.

A 15 yo supporting a terrorist organisation is hurting a lot of people.

There may be mitigating circumstances but personal responsibility does start somewhere, when your decisions hurt others.

She joined a terrorist organisation. Whether she had a supporting role or a more active one doesn't change that she was working for them. She supported their goals and their methods. So she shouldn't go free.

As for who should take custody of her, there is precedent for criminals being detained in the country where they committed their crimes. I don't necessarily think she should be repatriated even if she had retained her citizenship. There are foreign nationals in UK prisons too.

I do think the children should be removed from the camps (with or without the mothers' consent) and sent to their biological grand-parents /aunts/uncles/cousins if any would have them, or to social services if not. If Shamima's baby had been removed he'd potentially still be alive. In her place I'd have begged for him to be allowed either to the UK or the Netherlands, even if I had to stay behind. Though to be fair there wasn't a lot of time to consider any such application even if she'd made one (which I don't believe she did).

You're missing the point of what I'm saying (and I've probably worded it badly). I am not suggesting she shouldn't be punished at all. The question was around whether she's a victim or criminal. She is clearly both, she would have been groomed IMO, thats the bit I'm questioning . Quite rightly that makes little difference in the eyes of the law, I have not said otherwise but we cant pick and choose whether 15 yos are old enough to have 100% sound judgement or not. We all know even vulnerable adults are groomed by extremists.

Bepis · 30/03/2023 07:15

I think what bothers me with this, is that a 15 year old travelled to an airport, boarded and aircraft and travelled to the Middle East by herself. That's no easy feat, especially for a 15 year old so it clearly took some sort of planning on her part. It's not something you just accidentally do.

However, saying that, I do think she is a victim in the sense that 15 year olds are not mature, they make stupid decisions and do not think of consequences. I know my 16 year old is currently in the mind set of 'it won't happen to me' or 'I can handle it' which is perhaps the mindset Shamima had.

What she did though was still very serious. Even just being involved with a terrorist organisation is a crime so whether she actually harmed anyone or not, she still committed a crime that affected the national security.

I think she should be allowed back but on the basis that she is placed on remand until trial.

mumofboys8787 · 30/03/2023 04:40

Of course she is both, unfortunately for her that's not a valid defence.

Many rapists were victims of sexual abuse in the past, it doesn't excuse their actions.

Many murderers were victims of abuse in some capacity, or witnessed violence in their childhood or in their past. Behaviours such as these are hugely disproportionately down to learned behaviours, but this cannot and should not be used as a defence for committing crimes later on in life. We will never know for sure what she did, or what she was directly involved with. However, she didn't escape at the first opportunity or when she realised what it was she had gotten herself into. Instead she stayed and created a family and birthed multiple children into a life of radicalism. Weighing all this up, she's simply too much of flight risk to allow back into this country.

Jadviga · 30/03/2023 03:12

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 08:31

Okay, so rape isn’t really compatible with UK values, is it? So tbh they’re not home grown problems and we shouldn’t be arsed with rapists, we could ship them off to other countries, preferably poor and war torn ones.

Do people realise how stupid they sound when they babble this nonsense?

Shipping off elsewhere someone who committed crimes in the UK is completely different from someone who left and committed crimes in other countries. A quick google tells me that 2335 UK nationals are imprisoned abroad so that's hardly a new concept, even if she had kept her citizenship.

Jadviga · 30/03/2023 03:07

ImAGoodPerson · 28/03/2023 21:56

I don't know either way really TBH but what I don't understand is that why a 15 yo messaging an adult footballer offering blow jobs etc is a victim and too young to consent as its considered grooming but this 15 yo is a criminal. How can there be a blanket rule of any 15 engaging in sex is groomed but when it's radicalisation they aren't.

That's because a 15-yo engaging in sex with an older man is hurting no one but themselves.

A 15 yo supporting a terrorist organisation is hurting a lot of people.

There may be mitigating circumstances but personal responsibility does start somewhere, when your decisions hurt others.

She joined a terrorist organisation. Whether she had a supporting role or a more active one doesn't change that she was working for them. She supported their goals and their methods. So she shouldn't go free.

As for who should take custody of her, there is precedent for criminals being detained in the country where they committed their crimes. I don't necessarily think she should be repatriated even if she had retained her citizenship. There are foreign nationals in UK prisons too.

I do think the children should be removed from the camps (with or without the mothers' consent) and sent to their biological grand-parents /aunts/uncles/cousins if any would have them, or to social services if not. If Shamima's baby had been removed he'd potentially still be alive. In her place I'd have begged for him to be allowed either to the UK or the Netherlands, even if I had to stay behind. Though to be fair there wasn't a lot of time to consider any such application even if she'd made one (which I don't believe she did).

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 17:11

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 17:03

While loads of people would prefer she was somewhere else it doesn’t answer the issue of why we think it is morally ok to make another country responsible for
someone born here.
Woild we be happy if other countries did it to us or would we want to deport an individual back to where they were born? If the answer is we would want to deport them, then we need to be careful of setting a precedent. Other countries could well say “They committed a crime in your country. You keep them. We are revoking their citizenship and they can’t come here. They can rot in your country - it’s your problem now.” If we don’t want that we need to tread carefully.

Yes good point
but I do believe more was said in court and the decision wasn’t taken lightly. I really don’t know enough about the case . It’s been done in line with national security .
Like the other case Jack the terrorist, I’m not sure how’s his case is going , If Canada have to now take him back . This case isn’t done yet so we will have to see.
I mean in a lot of cases criminals are brought back and tried here and police make a big effort in bringing them back , but as there’s info being kept private here, I don’t know.

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 17:03

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:51

Well while she’s still appealing, I’m pretty safe in the knowledge she will stay where she is . From the interviews she’s doing she’s still there.

While loads of people would prefer she was somewhere else it doesn’t answer the issue of why we think it is morally ok to make another country responsible for
someone born here.
Woild we be happy if other countries did it to us or would we want to deport an individual back to where they were born? If the answer is we would want to deport them, then we need to be careful of setting a precedent. Other countries could well say “They committed a crime in your country. You keep them. We are revoking their citizenship and they can’t come here. They can rot in your country - it’s your problem now.” If we don’t want that we need to tread carefully.

mycoffeecup · 29/03/2023 16:56

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:51

Well while she’s still appealing, I’m pretty safe in the knowledge she will stay where she is . From the interviews she’s doing she’s still there.

and what is her incentive to stay if the appeal fails? Honestly I do despair at this government. She's our problem and will become much more dangerous the longer she is left out there. Look at the US and Sam Elhassani. They brought her back, put her on trial, put her in prison.

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:51

mycoffeecup · 29/03/2023 16:47

oh bless. what a lovely sweet naive view of the world

Yes, I'm sure that in a refugee camp where loads of other people have escaped from, in a poor country who are pissed off that we won't take back our citizens, they are keeping a close eye on her.

Well while she’s still appealing, I’m pretty safe in the knowledge she will stay where she is . From the interviews she’s doing she’s still there.

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 16:51

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:45

So what would be the evidence given in court that can’t be made public be about?

I don’t know. I’ll google in a bit but I’m sure the end of the podcast about her linked to up thread mentioned this. Just sorting dinner though!!

mycoffeecup · 29/03/2023 16:47

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 14:47

I’m sure she’s under surveillance over there . I can’t fully protect my kids no but I do hope this is a big lesson for anyone thinking of travelling to join terrorist groups .

oh bless. what a lovely sweet naive view of the world

Yes, I'm sure that in a refugee camp where loads of other people have escaped from, in a poor country who are pissed off that we won't take back our citizens, they are keeping a close eye on her.