Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Florenz · 01/04/2023 12:06

I don't understand why this is even an issue. Even if she is reformed, which I do not believe is true at all. Weigh up the pluses and minuses. The liabilities greatly outweigh the positives. There's no good reason to let her return to the UK.

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 12:05

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 11:40

Agreed. And the security services have information about Begum’s activities we’re not party to which helped form the basis for her citizenship to be revoked. To say it’s because she’s a woman is puerile.

I never did say it was because she was a woman. I do think it is in no small part due to the fact that she's from a minority ethnic background.

I'd be cautious of this apparent information held by security services, given that little is known about ISIS actions and participation except where individuals are actually documented in participation.

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 11:40

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 11:05

Letts also committed violent acts of terrorism and he holds a passport for another country, which doesn't have the death penalty.

Agreed. And the security services have information about Begum’s activities we’re not party to which helped form the basis for her citizenship to be revoked. To say it’s because she’s a woman is puerile.

EnthENd · 01/04/2023 11:37

Well, our government has decided to never answer the question.

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 11:05

Letts also committed violent acts of terrorism and he holds a passport for another country, which doesn't have the death penalty.

Angelonthewall · 01/04/2023 11:00

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:54

It kind of puts paid to it being because she’s a woman, wouldn’t you say?

If that's your only proof? Not really!!! 😂

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:54

It kind of puts paid to it being because she’s a woman, wouldn’t you say?

Angelonthewall · 01/04/2023 10:52

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:40

Of course she’s not being punished for being a woman. Jack Letts is a man who also had his citizenship revoked.

What makes you so sure? - what has John Letts got to do with it? - more than 2 people have had their citizenship revoked, will listing all of them prove anything?

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:40

Of course she’s not being punished for being a woman. Jack Letts is a man who also had his citizenship revoked.

Angelonthewall · 01/04/2023 10:37

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:25

True though and it’s not helping her.

Someone's fate should not be decided on their likability. I feel she is being punished for being a woman - somehow a woman who does something criminal - usually to support a man, gets a harder time - needs to feel extreme punishment by the media especially. Like she let down society's fantasy of the pure maternal figure. She's up against misogyny, and racism and I suspect she is not NT - which doesn't help either.

Blossomtoes · 01/04/2023 10:25

Angelonthewall · 01/04/2023 10:20

This is such a depressing statement.

True though and it’s not helping her.

Angelonthewall · 01/04/2023 10:20

bottleofbeer · 31/03/2023 23:29

The problem with her is that she's extremely unlikeable.

She's a victim but she acts like an utter arse, she's young.

This is such a depressing statement.

Untitledsquatboulder · 01/04/2023 08:53

@bottleofbeer since when did anyone's right to citizenship or a fair trial depend on being likable?

bottleofbeer · 31/03/2023 23:29

The problem with her is that she's extremely unlikeable.

She's a victim but she acts like an utter arse, she's young.

Kanaloa · 31/03/2023 22:35

Jourdain11 · 31/03/2023 22:22

Have you heard the final episode, in which Baker has traced and contacted Sharmeena Begum? She reportedly escaped from the camp and is fundraising for ISIS from Syria. She (assuming it really is her) spoke disparagingly of Shamima, calling her a 'dog' and essentially saying she was useless and a drain on the state because she never did anything, she just stayed at home because her husband told her to. Her husband sounds like a total creep, but considering he was imprisoned by ISIS and accused of being a spy, I suspect he was also a bit of a cast out and that they (as a couple) weren't privy to much.

The episode with Kadiza Sultana is horrible. She sounds like a little kid on the phone recordings and was obviously terrified but didn't dare to try to escape in case she was caught.

The point I found SB most evasive on was the Egyptian arms dealer. It seemed to me that she knew who and what he was but she doesn't want to admit it because it would make her look worse.

They don't strike me as having gone into it with their eyes wide open. Even Sharmeena, who seems to be very radicalised still, has a sad back story. Lost her mum and hated her father remarrying a few months later, left her father's home at 15 and got sucked into extremism. Of course she could and should have known better, but someone should have noticed. They were all minors - and everyone around them failed in their duty of care.

I mean somebody did notice. It had been flagged that these three girls were at risk of radicalisation and leaving the country just as their friend had done. The police were aware. So it’s not that nobody noticed, more that nothing was done. Part of me wonders if that is part of the reason it is being pushed so hard that she is so awful/must never come back/she is being made into a terrifying villain. It definitely deflects from the massive safeguarding failings of our society in their duty of care to these children.

tulippa · 31/03/2023 22:31

She was a groomed and trafficked child and has also committed crimes. She should be returned to the UK to be tried for her crimes, served her sentence and undergo rehabilitation. She should not have had her citizenship revoked.

Jourdain11 · 31/03/2023 22:22

Bepis · 31/03/2023 21:13

So I have listened to quite a few of these podcasts now and I am starting to form a different viewpoint/theory on what could have happened.

SB was a young, naive teenager who already had her best friend in Syria who had joined IS. Her best friend, Sharmeena, initially did not want to travel to Syria alone and wanted all her friends to go with her. At this point, the other 3 girls said they were not going. Once Sharmeena was in Syria, she was telling SB that it was great out there and that she should come out to be with her. At this point, Sharmeena was still living in the Madafa alongside other unmarried women. By this point, she will likely have not seen what ISIS were capable of and the life that she would end up living. She managed to convince SB to join her and they were reunited in the Madafa.

All the girls were then married off as that was the ONLY way out of this Madafa and by this point, there was no way the girls could have decided to return to the UK as their passports and documents had been taken off them. Even if SB had made it to the Syria border, she would not have been able to travel anywhere. When SB was married off to Yago, he was essentially in charge. She had to obey him and what he said is what went whether SB liked it or not. It appeared she also lived with a very dangerous man who was an armourer for ISIS while Yago was in prison. She developed a loyalty to these people as she literally had no one else to turn to. You could perhaps compare it to Stockholm Syndrome where you form close alliances with the dangerous people in order to survive. I would imagine that if her husband told her to do something, like sew suicide vests, she had very little choice to do that otherwise she would have most likely been tortured in the Black Stadium or killed.

I think I am leaning more towards she was a naive, young girl who had no idea what she was getting herself into (how can you know unless you have experienced it?) and she was also trusting in her best friend telling her that it was a good life, which she probably believed herself at that point.

SB has been through trauma that most women could not comprehend and whilst I do not believe she should be allowed to come back to the UK and be a free woman, I do believe that she should come back and be tried here in the UK. However, I appreciate that there is perhaps a lot of intelligence information that would alter my view. I can only go on the information that is available to the public.

Have you heard the final episode, in which Baker has traced and contacted Sharmeena Begum? She reportedly escaped from the camp and is fundraising for ISIS from Syria. She (assuming it really is her) spoke disparagingly of Shamima, calling her a 'dog' and essentially saying she was useless and a drain on the state because she never did anything, she just stayed at home because her husband told her to. Her husband sounds like a total creep, but considering he was imprisoned by ISIS and accused of being a spy, I suspect he was also a bit of a cast out and that they (as a couple) weren't privy to much.

The episode with Kadiza Sultana is horrible. She sounds like a little kid on the phone recordings and was obviously terrified but didn't dare to try to escape in case she was caught.

The point I found SB most evasive on was the Egyptian arms dealer. It seemed to me that she knew who and what he was but she doesn't want to admit it because it would make her look worse.

They don't strike me as having gone into it with their eyes wide open. Even Sharmeena, who seems to be very radicalised still, has a sad back story. Lost her mum and hated her father remarrying a few months later, left her father's home at 15 and got sucked into extremism. Of course she could and should have known better, but someone should have noticed. They were all minors - and everyone around them failed in their duty of care.

Bepis · 31/03/2023 21:13

So I have listened to quite a few of these podcasts now and I am starting to form a different viewpoint/theory on what could have happened.

SB was a young, naive teenager who already had her best friend in Syria who had joined IS. Her best friend, Sharmeena, initially did not want to travel to Syria alone and wanted all her friends to go with her. At this point, the other 3 girls said they were not going. Once Sharmeena was in Syria, she was telling SB that it was great out there and that she should come out to be with her. At this point, Sharmeena was still living in the Madafa alongside other unmarried women. By this point, she will likely have not seen what ISIS were capable of and the life that she would end up living. She managed to convince SB to join her and they were reunited in the Madafa.

All the girls were then married off as that was the ONLY way out of this Madafa and by this point, there was no way the girls could have decided to return to the UK as their passports and documents had been taken off them. Even if SB had made it to the Syria border, she would not have been able to travel anywhere. When SB was married off to Yago, he was essentially in charge. She had to obey him and what he said is what went whether SB liked it or not. It appeared she also lived with a very dangerous man who was an armourer for ISIS while Yago was in prison. She developed a loyalty to these people as she literally had no one else to turn to. You could perhaps compare it to Stockholm Syndrome where you form close alliances with the dangerous people in order to survive. I would imagine that if her husband told her to do something, like sew suicide vests, she had very little choice to do that otherwise she would have most likely been tortured in the Black Stadium or killed.

I think I am leaning more towards she was a naive, young girl who had no idea what she was getting herself into (how can you know unless you have experienced it?) and she was also trusting in her best friend telling her that it was a good life, which she probably believed herself at that point.

SB has been through trauma that most women could not comprehend and whilst I do not believe she should be allowed to come back to the UK and be a free woman, I do believe that she should come back and be tried here in the UK. However, I appreciate that there is perhaps a lot of intelligence information that would alter my view. I can only go on the information that is available to the public.

DancingWithBroccoli · 31/03/2023 17:15

Trying again with hopefully no typos! ..

She is both.

The majority of criminals have had shit lives.

For some the route to criminality is grooming. For others it's a coping mechanism for trauma and abuse. For others it's what they've learnt from parents.

There are many many routes to criminality but trauma, neglect, abuse or grooming pretty much unite them all

DancingWithBroccoli · 31/03/2023 17:14

She is both.

The majority of criminals have had shit lives.

Foursome the route to criminality is grooming. For others it's. Coping mechanism fro trauma and abuse. For others it's what they've learnt from parents. There are many many routes to criminality but trauma, neglect, abuse or grooming pretty much unite them all

Jourdain11 · 31/03/2023 17:09

Wasn't aware she had to provide public "evidence" of her children.

Like I said, with a coercive husband, no birth control and a duty to provide children for the caliphate, I'd be more surprised if she hadn't had multiple children!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 31/03/2023 14:30

I believe that ISIS actually kept amazingly good records of things like medical care - these may be in the hands of coalition forces, I'm not sure. So I'd imagine that the 3rd baby could be verified beyond doubt, at a minimum

This could well be true, and if so it's all the more surprising that Shamima's not produced anything except a photo - which as you rightly say could be of anyone

I realise of course that the authorities may not share records with her unless it suits, but all the same I'd have thought there'd be something, even if was just just a witness account from someone reputable

Maybe she doesn't feel it's necessary though; after all countless people seem prepared to take her word for it with no evidence at all, so why bother?

mycoffeecup · 31/03/2023 13:18

Kadiza died in a bomb strike before ISIS fell - Shamima and Amira identified her body

Recent interview of Sharmeena Begum by Josh Baker - Sharmeena said that Amira died fighting

Abhannmor · 31/03/2023 13:11

Correction. Her friends Amira and Kadiza. Presumed dead I suppose ?

mycoffeecup · 31/03/2023 13:10

Puzzledandpissedoff · 31/03/2023 12:18

Do show me the evidence that she helped stitch people into suicide jackets? As far as I'm aware that is all hearsay

I believe you're right, mycoffeecup, but it's very noticeable that you've chosen this allegation to ask for proof and neglected the countless claims about the children she lost ...

I'm assuming that the camp would be able to verify that she gave birth to a child and that he died - he was taken to hospital outside the camp in his last night of life and there would be a record of that. I think she showed photos to Josh Baker in the podcast, though of course I agree they could have been any children. I believe that ISIS actually kept amazingly good records of things like medical care - these may be in the hands of coalition forces, I'm not sure. So I'd imagine that the 3rd baby could be verified beyond doubt, at a minimum.