Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Nopinnogin · 02/04/2023 07:50

I remember being 15. Peer pressure is huge and can be awful. I was lured into dangerous situations because I wanted to be popular, I did and said things I totally disagree with now because my friends did and said them. And that was without being love bombed, groomed and bombarded with texts and videos.

There is no doubt that she was groomed. If you read the posts of adults whose kids have been groomed into county lines it's a similar thing.

Once she was there, she probably had to act a certain way to survive. If she has harmed another human being then she is wrong. However, in the first place she was a victim.

Theconceptoftime · 02/04/2023 07:48

She is both. In fact I would argue that a huge majority of criminals have started off as victims and the impact of this lasts a long time and takes a while to unpick. The same could be said for many other criminals in youth offending institutes and prisons here. It's a fine line between helping people to turn their lives around after negative experiences and punishing the outcome of the behaviour that is often a result of those negative experiences. I don't think it is a one size fits all.

TruthsAndALie · 02/04/2023 07:46

I’ve watched the documentary, listened to all the I’m Not A Monster podcasts and have done some of my own reading.

I don’t think it’s black and white at all and on balance believe she is a victim of many things. Situation with her mum dying, dad remarries, isolated socially, no worldly experience of anything, wants to do something to belong, gets radicalised by a friend and ends up there where it’s too late and goes from bad to worse.

Seeing strong opinions that are only based on media headlines makes me annoyed. It’s so contradictory - people are suspicious of the media on so many things but are willing to believe everything they write about this case. Journalists waiting outside the delivery room?! Journalists live recording her reaction to having her citizenship revoked and determining guilt by her reaction?! The media is not a court of law.

In the recent review the judge themselves said people could look at the evidence and it would be reasonable to determine she had indeed been trafficked (paraphrasing) but the UK Government was within its right to take away citizenship because that is at the discretion of the Home Secretary (and could be a political play as much as anything).

It’s incredibly naive of the UK government to think there isn’t huge radicalisation happening with children in those camps. That alone poses a risk as they are the next generation of ISIS fighters who remember growing up in a camp - what do you think that does to a person.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/04/2023 07:38

123rainbow · 02/04/2023 07:04

I wouldn't trust her. She has a constant smirk on her face. The people that say she is victim (maybe she is to a point) would likely change their tune
If she was to blow up their family. We can't take that chance. Keeping her out sends a message to others that are thinking of doing the same.

Maybe she Is to a point?

Recruited at 15 on promise of all kinds of shit, engineered by governments no less, held by a violent and dangerous groups of dissidents, forced to marry and bear multiple children, watching each of her children die, the last one dying while begging our government for help?

Absolutely shocking that anyone is seeing a 'smirk' on her face, she's in a place where it's so dangerous for her to even be contacting the media to say she wants to come home.

Absolutely horrendous that we as a country have done that to her.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/04/2023 07:36

Ylvamoon · 28/03/2023 10:40

I don't know much about her story other than the main news items.

I think a bit of both. At the time she was recruited, it was a well known fact how ISIS gromed young people.

So she/ her friends/ family ect should have been aware.
However, she was only 15, wanting to be free from the constraints of being a UK teenager and fitting in somewhere.

It became a well known fact that white girls in Manchester were being groomed. Should their parents have been aware? Or are you victim blaming and racist?

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 02/04/2023 07:24

Both, trafficked victim, criminal in that she supported terrorism!

123rainbow · 02/04/2023 07:04

I wouldn't trust her. She has a constant smirk on her face. The people that say she is victim (maybe she is to a point) would likely change their tune
If she was to blow up their family. We can't take that chance. Keeping her out sends a message to others that are thinking of doing the same.

FLDS · 02/04/2023 06:39

She can be both a victim and a risk to the UK. Which she's been assessed to be.

BorisisaLune · 02/04/2023 06:28

Florenz · 02/04/2023 00:50

She's out of the country, and to me, there has to be a very good justification to let her back in, and I cannot see what that could be.

...because if she is as dangerous as they say she is, she may well be planning attacks in the UK and beyond.

..because she is a product of British society, born and raised here, as British as you, i, Sunak or Bravermann and therefore our responsibility.

On failing to condemn the Manchester bombing, did people like McGiuness or Adams condemn, 100%, IRA bombings? nope, yet they went on to form the GFA and bring peace to NI.

Kanaloa · 02/04/2023 00:58

Florenz · 02/04/2023 00:50

She's out of the country, and to me, there has to be a very good justification to let her back in, and I cannot see what that could be.

Because she is our responsibility. That’s the good reason. And since you think it’s appropriate to suggest bombing people without even checking who you’ll be bombing, I don’t think your opinion on it is all that relevant to be honest.

Florenz · 02/04/2023 00:50

She's out of the country, and to me, there has to be a very good justification to let her back in, and I cannot see what that could be.

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 23:17

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:10

@Jourdain11 Yes, when I listened to what she said there, she was saying that's how ISIS justified it, not that she thought it was justified.

I agree regarding the Al Hol (not sure on spelling) camp. She had to be very careful. And a woman had been pulled out of some water beheaded for speaking against ISIS.

I'm glad it's not just me! That was definitely how I heard it, but I also thought straight away, bad choice of words. But also, someone who's been in a place where people are getting killed every day, they're not going to have the same shock in their reaction to a terrorist atrocity in Manchester as someone who hasn't been in that environment.

She's now in another camp (Al-Roj) as she was considered to be at too much risk in Al-Hol. If the ISIS sympathisers want to harm someone for being an apostate, it's probably a reasonable indication that they are not overly extreme in their beliefs...

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:13

I know this is a bit of a sideline but I find it awful how US led air strikes bombed Raqqa but then have left people to rebuild by themselves, which is a practically impossible task for someone with no money or machinery. No help whatsoever.

Kanaloa · 01/04/2023 23:11

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:06

@Kanaloa I have to admit that I was uneducated about the story when I first commented on this thread but since then, I've listened to numerous podcasts, watched the BBC documentary and I genuinely believe that she didn't have a clue what she was getting into.

Then when she was already there, there's zero chance of being able to leave and survive so you just do what you can to get through the day.

She has paid a very high price, both friends dead who she went out there with, all 3 children dead, and her former best friend calling her a traitor and apostate.

Oh I don’t think there’s any shame in being uneducated about something! We all are, aren’t we? In that post, I was more just saying think if you haven’t even watched the news coverage of a situation it’s a bit stupid to be suggesting bombing a country. How does that make you any different to ISIS really? If you think the answer to any problem is to immediately suggest bombing other countries when you don’t even have a clue about what you are talking about, you really can’t claim moral superiority. It’s very telling.

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:10

@Jourdain11 Yes, when I listened to what she said there, she was saying that's how ISIS justified it, not that she thought it was justified.

I agree regarding the Al Hol (not sure on spelling) camp. She had to be very careful. And a woman had been pulled out of some water beheaded for speaking against ISIS.

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 23:09

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:06

@Kanaloa I have to admit that I was uneducated about the story when I first commented on this thread but since then, I've listened to numerous podcasts, watched the BBC documentary and I genuinely believe that she didn't have a clue what she was getting into.

Then when she was already there, there's zero chance of being able to leave and survive so you just do what you can to get through the day.

She has paid a very high price, both friends dead who she went out there with, all 3 children dead, and her former best friend calling her a traitor and apostate.

Interesting that the British government hasn't taken away Sharmeena Begum's citizenship! At least not as far as I'm aware.

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 23:07

Bepis · 01/04/2023 22:56

When I watch that interview, which was conducted as soon as she had surrendered, she appeared to still be indoctrinated with ISIS mentality. If you watch more recent interviews, you can tell she has has completely changed her thought process. She doesn't seem like the same woman who said those things. Also, she was surrounded by ISIS women who would have killed her and her child for denouncing ISIS. That could have potentially played a role.

I just don't think it's black and white.

We also have to bear in mind that she was in a camp filled with ISIS members and her life could've been in danger if she'd spoken against them. In that camp, 4 'apostate' women were murdered in the last month. The camp she is in now is more secure, but it could easily go downhill.

Also, I don't believe she ever supported the Manchester attacks. She said she was shocked and thought it wrong that innocent people get killed, but that children and women were being killed in Baghuz and "that is the justification". She doesn't actually say "that justifies it" - it sounds more like, "this is the way the organisation justifies doing these things" than an indication of personal approval, but not very well expressed.

Bepis · 01/04/2023 23:06

@Kanaloa I have to admit that I was uneducated about the story when I first commented on this thread but since then, I've listened to numerous podcasts, watched the BBC documentary and I genuinely believe that she didn't have a clue what she was getting into.

Then when she was already there, there's zero chance of being able to leave and survive so you just do what you can to get through the day.

She has paid a very high price, both friends dead who she went out there with, all 3 children dead, and her former best friend calling her a traitor and apostate.

Kanaloa · 01/04/2023 23:02

It’s also astounding that so many posters just cannot possibly believe that a teenager may have been indoctrinated with false information or just so stupid she went along with atrocities, when one of those very posters is either so very misinformed or so devoid of empathy that ‘just bomb them’ in relation to a refugee camp is an appropriate answer to ‘we should deal with British people who have been accused of crimes.’

Jourdain11 · 01/04/2023 22:58

Florenz · 01/04/2023 22:16

It'd be easier just to bomb the camps.

That's a terrible thing to say!

confusedallthetime1 · 01/04/2023 22:58

DojaPhat · 28/03/2023 10:55

Shamima's main issue is that she isn't white.

Bullshit. Nobody would support Samantha Lewthwaite coming back either

Bepis · 01/04/2023 22:56

RocketIceLollie · 01/04/2023 22:45

Criminal. It's her lack of compassion to the Manchester bombing amongst other things that sends alarm bells for me.

When I watch that interview, which was conducted as soon as she had surrendered, she appeared to still be indoctrinated with ISIS mentality. If you watch more recent interviews, you can tell she has has completely changed her thought process. She doesn't seem like the same woman who said those things. Also, she was surrounded by ISIS women who would have killed her and her child for denouncing ISIS. That could have potentially played a role.

I just don't think it's black and white.

Kanaloa · 01/04/2023 22:53

didsburymanchester · 01/04/2023 22:49

There is a rumour she ended her own children's lives.

That isn’t relevant to what I asked. The poster was busy giving their opinions about what we should and shouldn’t do about Shamima, but apparently had no clue she lived in a camp with small children, despite those kids being shown in basically all new coverage about her current situation. But we should ‘just bomb them.’ I think if you have no absolutely clue where she is or what situation she is in to the point that you accidentally suggest bombing innocent children (which Shamima is being denigrated for saying is justified) then you probably don’t know enough about the situation to form an educated opinion.

didsburymanchester · 01/04/2023 22:52

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/04/2023 13:59

Admittedly this is a side issue, but where are Shamima's family in all this?
I wouldn't expect to hear from them all the time, but during periods when there's another hearing it's perhaps surprising that there's not much coming from them along the lines of "Please bring her back, we're sure she's learned her lesson"

Mum apparently shared a bedroom with her daughter and was so sure she wasn't involved.

No idea how 15 year olds could leave the country without an adult.

Yes very bizarre the parents aren't on tv or the Bangladesh/Muslim community aren't campaigning for her.

Maybe they are but the British media don't care.

I really think it's brave what the government has done but I'm sure there are plenty of men who have been allowed back.

didsburymanchester · 01/04/2023 22:49

Kanaloa · 01/04/2023 22:30

Have you not watched any of the interviews with her? What have you formed your rather harsh opinions on if you literally haven’t seen any? Every one that I’ve seen shows small kids walking around the refugee camp while she speaks. The first one showed her holding her own newborn child.

There is a rumour she ended her own children's lives.