Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FLDS · 02/04/2023 15:33

nothingcomestonothing · 02/04/2023 15:28

I can’t comment on not bringing her back to face justice in this country .It would be the right thing to do in normal circumstances but without access fully to all info it’s hard to say . Right or wrong but the safety of the greater good comes before 1 individual.

But that's the thing, is it likely that Shamima Begum is a bigger risk to the public than the hundreds of men who were part of ISIS that the government have allowed back? Is it likely a teenage girl with no Arabic was high up or did the worst atrocities? It just seems so unlikely to me that SB is such a danger, more than 100s of men who we have accepted back and who are walking free in the UK after fighting for ISIS.

She absolutely should be tried for her crimes, but not punished worse than men who actually killed for ISIS.

It could just be there was no option to keep them out whereas there was with her.

nothingcomestonothing · 02/04/2023 15:28

I can’t comment on not bringing her back to face justice in this country .It would be the right thing to do in normal circumstances but without access fully to all info it’s hard to say . Right or wrong but the safety of the greater good comes before 1 individual.

But that's the thing, is it likely that Shamima Begum is a bigger risk to the public than the hundreds of men who were part of ISIS that the government have allowed back? Is it likely a teenage girl with no Arabic was high up or did the worst atrocities? It just seems so unlikely to me that SB is such a danger, more than 100s of men who we have accepted back and who are walking free in the UK after fighting for ISIS.

She absolutely should be tried for her crimes, but not punished worse than men who actually killed for ISIS.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 15:05

I don't think it's feasible that she could have been morality police in Syria without having a decent grasp of Arabic or the relevant instruction, neither of which she appears to have had

I don’t understand why you think that. I don’t suppose Sally Jones had a decent grasp of Arabic either.

FLDS · 02/04/2023 14:53

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 14:42

If someone can’t/won’t speak Arabic, how can ISIS radicalise them? Because it has plenty of English speakers is how. Of course she could have played an active role. No matter how she accessed the news it was obvious that ISIS was barbaric and existed to torture and murder people. There had been two years of highly publicised attacks before she left the UK.

Yep. She knew it was a terror group and she knew she would be getting married - that was the main purpose of her going. Yes she was radicalised and exploited but she engaged in significant planning and covering her tracks and knew what ISIS was and what her role would be.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 14:53

Oh, sure, but I'm not talking about radicalisation. I don't think it's feasible that she could have been morality police in Syria without having a decent grasp of Arabic or the relevant instruction, neither of which she appears to have had.

Even among the foreign ISIS recruits, many came from Arabic-speaking backgrounds (although not all). Second-gen North African, etc.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 14:42

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:45

But if someone can't/couldn't speak Arabic, how can they play an active role in ISIS? I take your point about awareness, but the way teenagers access news is very different to how adults access news. Now even more so, but certainly back then too.

If someone can’t/won’t speak Arabic, how can ISIS radicalise them? Because it has plenty of English speakers is how. Of course she could have played an active role. No matter how she accessed the news it was obvious that ISIS was barbaric and existed to torture and murder people. There had been two years of highly publicised attacks before she left the UK.

babybythesea · 02/04/2023 14:32

Sallydimebar · 02/04/2023 14:14

Well I was 14 at the time of James bulger murder .The whole school knew about it and were horrified .
Yes the earthquakes probably would of escaped my son 14 only they were talked about in geography.
I can’t remember sitting down with my Dd 16 at anytime talking about isis , she would of been around 9 when they were active , but she is fully aware of what they stand for now at 16 and she doesn’t watch the news that’s just stuff she’s picked up on over time . Ds 13 might not know to much about them as it’s not front page now . Having been described as bright and a straight A pupil at school SB in my opinion would of been fully aware of isis and all they stood for .

The whole school knew - that’s kind of the point. Everyone was talking about it and had the same viewpoint.
Your Dd may well know about what ISIS stands for but what if she had friends out there saying “They are lying to you. I’m here and I’ve seen it. Look at this video of everyone having an amazing time in the park - how family orientated it is.” I can totally see how a teenager could be swayed by that.
After all, how many adults say “I’ve got a mate who works in this area/has been there and they say…”

Sallydimebar · 02/04/2023 14:14

babybythesea · 02/04/2023 13:46

“I’m fully positive she was aware of what she was stepping into .”

I’m not!
I would have said it was not possible to be unaware of big news stories until I talked to my own 14 year old. I have the news on all the time - in the car, at home. I talk to my kids about it. And even so, she missed hearing about the earthquake in Turkey for over a week. It wasn’t talked about by her friends, it didn’t appear on her social media feeds, and she doesn’t go looking for news. So it passed her by. I can easily see how a 15 year old who searched for ISIS had a news feed on her social
media dominated by the ‘positive’ aspects and if her friend was sending back glowing endorsements, why would she come across much negative stuff? If she’s getting her news from social media, the ultimate echo chamber, then I can see how her views were skewed.
In addition, her friend was there. When she did query anything her friend told her it was lies. So she had the ‘my mate is there and she says…’ to counter it. And adults are hugely susceptible to that, never mind teenagers.

Well I was 14 at the time of James bulger murder .The whole school knew about it and were horrified .
Yes the earthquakes probably would of escaped my son 14 only they were talked about in geography.
I can’t remember sitting down with my Dd 16 at anytime talking about isis , she would of been around 9 when they were active , but she is fully aware of what they stand for now at 16 and she doesn’t watch the news that’s just stuff she’s picked up on over time . Ds 13 might not know to much about them as it’s not front page now . Having been described as bright and a straight A pupil at school SB in my opinion would of been fully aware of isis and all they stood for .

Sallydimebar · 02/04/2023 13:49

“It's exceedingly politically difficult for any future HS from the same party to say "yes, this was a mistake, “

yes I get that or their quite confident with the evidence, it’s the right decision . Time will tell .

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:47

It's naturally a complex case because of the elements involved. But I don't think she's got the capacity to completely mislead. Where she was evasive about the Egyptian, for example, it was very obvious that she wasn't being truthful.

babybythesea · 02/04/2023 13:46

“I’m fully positive she was aware of what she was stepping into .”

I’m not!
I would have said it was not possible to be unaware of big news stories until I talked to my own 14 year old. I have the news on all the time - in the car, at home. I talk to my kids about it. And even so, she missed hearing about the earthquake in Turkey for over a week. It wasn’t talked about by her friends, it didn’t appear on her social media feeds, and she doesn’t go looking for news. So it passed her by. I can easily see how a 15 year old who searched for ISIS had a news feed on her social
media dominated by the ‘positive’ aspects and if her friend was sending back glowing endorsements, why would she come across much negative stuff? If she’s getting her news from social media, the ultimate echo chamber, then I can see how her views were skewed.
In addition, her friend was there. When she did query anything her friend told her it was lies. So she had the ‘my mate is there and she says…’ to counter it. And adults are hugely susceptible to that, never mind teenagers.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:45

But if someone can't/couldn't speak Arabic, how can they play an active role in ISIS? I take your point about awareness, but the way teenagers access news is very different to how adults access news. Now even more so, but certainly back then too.

Sallydimebar · 02/04/2023 13:35

nothingcomestonothing · 02/04/2023 12:46

And again - we have allowed back 100s of ISIS fighters who were men.
Has the government ever explained why they have allowed some back but not her?
No, because they can't there is no justification.

This. Whatever crimes she committed, is it likely that a 15 year old girl did worse things that the 300 or so males from the UK who went to fight for ISIS and who we've taken back? With the views ISIS hold on the roles for men and women? I would really like the government to explain how those men who fought for ISIS are fine to come back here and walk the street free, but SB isn't. She's being made an example of, while more dangerous people are here and free.

The case has been described as a complex case. I don’t know what crimes she committed in the 7yrs she’s been over there , apart from the big one of joining the enemy .

Even bypassing her comments on the Manchester attack ,the attacks isis were committing in the months before she went , the journalist, the aid worker and countless others which had huge press/tv coverage at the time , at 15 , I’m fully positive she was aware of what she was stepping into . I have to go with trust in the security forces which her own family seem to have accepted.

I can’t comment on not bringing her back to face justice in this country .It would be the right thing to do in normal circumstances but without access fully to all info it’s hard to say . Right or wrong but the safety of the greater good comes before 1 individual.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:21

Bottom line, I think Sajid Javid made a decision in a rush and under pressure (and probably, as a non-practicing Muslim, concerned about his reputation and image). It's exceedingly politically difficult for any future HS from the same party to say "yes, this was a mistake, and sorry that an innocent baby died potentially as a result of said mistake." So they've doubled down. I'd be interested to hear Yvette Cooper's take on it.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:16

BTW, the summary document from the Supreme Court makes reference to where closed material has been considered. It's mostly in relation to aspects such as who she communicated with before/during her time in ISIS, her travel, her husband's involvements, awareness among different agencies. It seems it doesn't refer so much to her activities while being there.

babybythesea · 02/04/2023 13:02

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/04/2023 12:20

Could be, Sallydimebar; after all the whole point is that we're not aware of all the info the security services have so it's hard to say

Overall though there doesn't seem much doubt that there's a lot more to this than meets the eye

I agree there is stuff that we haven’t been told.
But I cannot think of any reason good enough to strip someone if citizenship and effectively make another, far poorer, country responsible for them.
And my big concern is that one of the things we are not being told is the calculations going on in terms of politics. I think a big part of this is to do with Tories looking for easy votes - and I think this very simplistic ‘leave her to rot’ approach will appeal to some people who don’t look beyond deadlines, or listen to reports concerning security in the camps etc.
Bottom line / I don’t trust the Tories to look beyond their own political gain, whatever the long term consequences.

nothingcomestonothing · 02/04/2023 12:46

And again - we have allowed back 100s of ISIS fighters who were men.
Has the government ever explained why they have allowed some back but not her?
No, because they can't there is no justification.

This. Whatever crimes she committed, is it likely that a 15 year old girl did worse things that the 300 or so males from the UK who went to fight for ISIS and who we've taken back? With the views ISIS hold on the roles for men and women? I would really like the government to explain how those men who fought for ISIS are fine to come back here and walk the street free, but SB isn't. She's being made an example of, while more dangerous people are here and free.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/04/2023 12:20

Could be, Sallydimebar; after all the whole point is that we're not aware of all the info the security services have so it's hard to say

Overall though there doesn't seem much doubt that there's a lot more to this than meets the eye

Sallydimebar · 02/04/2023 11:38

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/04/2023 10:08

Very bizarre the parents aren't on tv or the Bangladesh/Muslim community aren't campaigning for her. Maybe they are but the British media don't care

Very possibly, yes; after all they don't say much about the efforts much of the community's making to keep youngsters away from terrorism either

But as you say I was thinking about the family and the fact that a weeping relative's usually catnip to the media
Perhaps they're disinclined after catching a cold with Amira Abase's dad, or just maybe the family have good reason to wish to avoid drawing attention to themselves?

Maybe aware of the evidence that had been kept from public view and understand like the security forces and three Home Secretary’s why she can never step on uk soil . Could be in their interest to stay quiet.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/04/2023 10:08

Very bizarre the parents aren't on tv or the Bangladesh/Muslim community aren't campaigning for her. Maybe they are but the British media don't care

Very possibly, yes; after all they don't say much about the efforts much of the community's making to keep youngsters away from terrorism either

But as you say I was thinking about the family and the fact that a weeping relative's usually catnip to the media
Perhaps they're disinclined after catching a cold with Amira Abase's dad, or just maybe the family have good reason to wish to avoid drawing attention to themselves?

babybythesea · 02/04/2023 09:39

123rainbow · 02/04/2023 07:04

I wouldn't trust her. She has a constant smirk on her face. The people that say she is victim (maybe she is to a point) would likely change their tune
If she was to blow up their family. We can't take that chance. Keeping her out sends a message to others that are thinking of doing the same.

Not a single person who advocates bringing her back is saying that happens with no security attached to it.
But she was born in the UK, raised here, and it was ultimately our security that messed up and let her travel.
She needs to come back and face a proper trial and face the consequences here. Not be left somewhere else where the security risk is arguably greater, without a trial.

NameOchangeO1 · 02/04/2023 09:17

Victim. She wasn't the first teenager to think she was more grown up than she was and to make a terrible decision in trying to find her place in the world. She ended up married at 15 to a virtual stranger, having one pregnancy after another and having three children die, all before reaching an age when many kids first leave home.

There is no evidence she has committed crimes in Syria or the Syrians would have charged her. They have not been slow in imprisoning and punishing people they think have committed crimes while part of Isis.
Even if you fear that she is radicalised, she is a British woman and was radicalised here. We should not dump our problems on poorer countries to deal with. When the government tried to make her Bangladesh's problem that was absolutely shameful.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 09:05

Bepis · 01/04/2023 22:56

When I watch that interview, which was conducted as soon as she had surrendered, she appeared to still be indoctrinated with ISIS mentality. If you watch more recent interviews, you can tell she has has completely changed her thought process. She doesn't seem like the same woman who said those things. Also, she was surrounded by ISIS women who would have killed her and her child for denouncing ISIS. That could have potentially played a role.

I just don't think it's black and white.

I don’t think she’s changed in the slightest, she’s playing her western audience. She’s highly intelligent and highly manipulative. She’s still surrounded by ISIS women, that hasn’t changed. In fact nothing has changed apart from the way she dresses (where is she getting her western clothes from?) and the way she presents herself. Radicalised leopards don’t change their spots, as Usman Kahn amply demonstrated on London Bridge in 2019.

Kanaloa · 02/04/2023 08:25

@TruthsAndALie

Shamima Begum’s mother is not dead. She is still alive. I think you are confusing her with Sharmeena Begum who is a totally different person, and was a friend of Shamima Begum.

Nopinnogin · 02/04/2023 07:54

Theconceptoftime · 02/04/2023 07:48

She is both. In fact I would argue that a huge majority of criminals have started off as victims and the impact of this lasts a long time and takes a while to unpick. The same could be said for many other criminals in youth offending institutes and prisons here. It's a fine line between helping people to turn their lives around after negative experiences and punishing the outcome of the behaviour that is often a result of those negative experiences. I don't think it is a one size fits all.

I agree with this. If your family has always hit or abused you then you hit someone and get prosecuted then where is the justice? Many criminals were originally victims but their story was never heard and nobody cared. Then they get labelled “bad”. Life can be very unfair.