Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 11:41

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/04/2023 11:29

She's been abused, almost starved to death and had 5 of her children die over their due to malnutrition and poor healthcare

Oh look, the story's expanding to FIVE children now ... and still no actual evidence that they ever existed Hmm

Miscarriages count as children now apparently. 🙄

I really hope none of her defenders are ever called for jury service. The mental gymnastics employed to excuse her are unbelievable.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/04/2023 11:29

She's been abused, almost starved to death and had 5 of her children die over their due to malnutrition and poor healthcare

Oh look, the story's expanding to FIVE children now ... and still no actual evidence that they ever existed Hmm

ShamimaBegu · 03/04/2023 10:20

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 08:44

@ShamimaBegu
No I'm not, Shamima's father moved back to Bangladesh leaving her mother with their 4 daughters. He has a new family. He was interviewed from Bangladesh and he had to tone down his criticism of the UK removing her citizenship explaining that if she was sent to Bangladesh she'd be hanged.

Sharmeena's mother died when she was 8 and her father remarried.

@bellabasset Thank you for this information. I didn't realise.

OP posts:
123rainbow · 03/04/2023 09:49

Why does she want to come back to Bri tain? she spoke openly about how much she hated it. Does she think she will be welcomed with open arms? What about her husband's family? Would she be able to go there? I doubt she would consider coming back if things hasn't turned out the way they had. The amount of security and protection she would need if she came back. Bangladesh certainly wouldn't see her as a victim, even though some of her family are there.

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 09:29

chocandchurro · 03/04/2023 08:21

I think most 15yr olds know it's not okay to chop people's heads off or rape women. This stuff was on the front pages of newspapers before she travelled.

This. I think most ten year olds would know beheading is wrong. Her life is completely fucked whatever happens to her. She wouldn’t be safe in prison here unless she was in solitary and she could never show her (now very wellknown) face in public in this country. She has no future.

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 08:44

@ShamimaBegu
No I'm not, Shamima's father moved back to Bangladesh leaving her mother with their 4 daughters. He has a new family. He was interviewed from Bangladesh and he had to tone down his criticism of the UK removing her citizenship explaining that if she was sent to Bangladesh she'd be hanged.

Sharmeena's mother died when she was 8 and her father remarried.

chocandchurro · 03/04/2023 08:21

TruthsAndALie · 02/04/2023 22:27

How can someone say 15 year olds ‘know what they’re doing’ when they haven’t reached the age of consent for pretty much anything? There is being book smart and there is being worldly. Her husband even described her as a blank page as she had such little experience of almost anything. This is not someone with middle class parents regularly travelling and having deep philosophical debates over dinner. This is a conservative immigrant family living at/near poverty conditions.

The school highlighted she and her friends were at risk but an assessment by the police didn’t agree. The parents weren’t told any of this.

She’s said in interview her social media profile and interactions can and have been reviewed so I think they know what’s been said/received.

I think most 15yr olds know it's not okay to chop people's heads off or rape women. This stuff was on the front pages of newspapers before she travelled.

ShamimaBegu · 03/04/2023 08:18

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 07:42

@TruthsAndALie

The parents were sent letters except instead of posting them they were given to the pupils who didn't give them to their parents. They should have been posted but it's cost saving. She does say that she never mixed with men at home and her father was living in Bangladesh with his new wife and family so he wasn't there to monitor her computer usage, she's of a generation where the kids know more than the parents. Also if Sajid Javid is right she'd be detained for a long time in the UK

I think you may be confusing Shamima Begum with her friend Sharmeena Begum. It was Sharmeena's Dad who remarried. Sharmeena was the one who went to Syria first and encouraged Shamima to come as well.

OP posts:
bellabasset · 03/04/2023 07:42

@TruthsAndALie

The parents were sent letters except instead of posting them they were given to the pupils who didn't give them to their parents. They should have been posted but it's cost saving. She does say that she never mixed with men at home and her father was living in Bangladesh with his new wife and family so he wasn't there to monitor her computer usage, she's of a generation where the kids know more than the parents. Also if Sajid Javid is right she'd be detained for a long time in the UK

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 07:31

@Blossomtoes

3 live births from 5 pregnancies over 4 years is abuse. The recommendation is 18 months between pregnancies to give the womb time to heal.

TruthsAndALie · 02/04/2023 22:27

How can someone say 15 year olds ‘know what they’re doing’ when they haven’t reached the age of consent for pretty much anything? There is being book smart and there is being worldly. Her husband even described her as a blank page as she had such little experience of almost anything. This is not someone with middle class parents regularly travelling and having deep philosophical debates over dinner. This is a conservative immigrant family living at/near poverty conditions.

The school highlighted she and her friends were at risk but an assessment by the police didn’t agree. The parents weren’t told any of this.

She’s said in interview her social media profile and interactions can and have been reviewed so I think they know what’s been said/received.

Badbudgeter · 02/04/2023 21:58

There does seem to be an othering of victims if they don’t fit the mould of victim hood. So if you’re not white or are white but are poor and growing up in challenging circumstances. Then you are somehow expected to be older than your years.

I don’t know about Shamima, yes she was a victim. However has she been radicalised and is possibly a danger to others? I do think the government wants to discourage teenagers from thinking you can Join terrorist groups and then return. It’s unfair that she has to be the unwilling poster girl of a policy decision.

I think stripping someone of citizenship is a bit questionable in international law.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 21:55

It was Amira Abase's father who went on the march, not Shamima Begum's.

Of course it's never possible to know 100% of the story (in any case) but it's certainly possible to ascertain beyond reasonable doubt. It would also be possible that she's found guilty of having committed crimes but not a risk to radicalise others in prison, if her own mindset has changed.

I do agree that it's difficult to imagine her having much of a normal life, whatever the outcome. But it's essentially a similar decision to those which parole boards make - the risk to the public vs the best interests of the individual. For many who are let out on parole, it would be 'easier' to keep them inside, but it's also a question of whether it's morally justifiable.

Danielle9891 · 02/04/2023 21:35

It's a hard one. If she was to come back she'd either be found guilty (15 year olds know what they are doing, she was described as a very smart kid) and she will have to be kept in isolation in prison as to not influence others. Or she would be found not guilty, released but she would never be safe to walk the street for her own safety. She would get hounded by the press and people thinking she was guilty.
This will cost the tax payers million, look at how much has been spent on the two kids (now adults) who killed James bulger.

I don't understand how we can be 100% sure if she is guilty or not. We definitely don't have 100% of the the story.

It's impossible to say how much she was groomed by people online or how her family or friends influenced her (father was at anti-British march)

But still she is our problem and we need to do something.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 20:54

What I'd be interested to know is, if it's the Home Secretary's decision, does a new Home Secretary automatically have the power to overrule it (without going back to court)?

Yvette Cooper wrote at the time that the three girls leaving to Syria was a child protection issue. I'd be interested to know what her take is on it now, although I don't know if she would be privy to the closed information. Politically, it would be easier for a Home Sec from a different party to reverse the decision.

I feel desperately sorry for the woman. She made a terrible, wrong choice. But she was a child. At 15, in this country, you cannot legally marry, leave school, vote, drink. There are reasons for that. Now her friends are dead, or being repatriated to their home countries. The friend who played a big part in persuading her to come to Syria denounced her as a 'dog' and says she was essentially socially awkward and useless. Her life is pretty screwed - even if she were allowed to return, she'd never have a normal life because she's notorious. But imagine sitting in that camp, day after day, knowing it could be forever or until she meets some unfortunate end.

Many of the teenagers and young men left the UK to go to ISIS did do terrible things. But I see them as victims too. Many of them were vulnerable, many of them actually had learning disabilities. Sure, some of them were just criminal. But they were just cannon fodder for the organisation - a body to strap a bomb to. Most of them are now dead.

I don't say Shamima Begum should be excused responsibility. She should be tried and prosecuted for any crimes she may have committed. But all this "eye for an eye" stuff I find really distasteful and I'm sorry, but I do think there's a racist element to it too.

TruthsAndALie · 02/04/2023 19:53

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 13:47

It's naturally a complex case because of the elements involved. But I don't think she's got the capacity to completely mislead. Where she was evasive about the Egyptian, for example, it was very obvious that she wasn't being truthful.

I agree it seemed like there were details she was skirting over regarding the Egyptian and isn’t good at concealing lies.

He was allegedly quite senior and an arms dealer. She lives in a camp, in a tent. Anyone could get to her at any time and reprisals are a real thing. I would probably keep schtum as well.

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 18:05

3 children born, 2 miscarriages. That's 5, so I'm not sure what your point is?

Zanatdy · 02/04/2023 18:03

A victim. My DD is 15, she’s no where near full maturity. The girl was groomed, how anyone can think otherwise I don’t know

Bepis · 02/04/2023 18:00

She had 5 pregnancies but only gave birth to 3 children. Miscarried 2.

Blossomtoes · 02/04/2023 17:58

gkhg · 02/04/2023 16:09

You can't even begin to form a comment if you don't know about her case then. Proof of what I said above

That’s rich coming from someone who thinks she had five children.

gkhg · 02/04/2023 16:09

toastofthetown · 28/03/2023 10:46

Someone can be both. I’m not knowledgeable about Shamima Begum to say for certain about her case, but it’s not an either/or and assuming that someone who has victimised other people cannot have been a victim themselves (and acknowledging the role that might have led in their offending) doesn’t help anyone.

You can't even begin to form a comment if you don't know about her case then. Proof of what I said above

gkhg · 02/04/2023 16:08

She's a victim. She's been abused, almost starved to death and had 5 of her children die over their due to malnutrition and poor healthcare. It's barbaric that she hasn't been brought back. People saying she's a criminal usually have no clue of her actual story

SophiaSW1 · 02/04/2023 15:54

I don't think it's a simple case of her being one or the other

Jourdain11 · 02/04/2023 15:46

The grounds for the decision are that the Home Secretary made it and it's within their gift to make such a decision. At the time, SB would have been a de facto Bangladeshi citizen, subject to technicalities which the HO admit they didn't investigate fully. SB's right to Bangladeshi citizenship would have lapsed as she's now over 21. The report establishes that, to anyone's knowledge, she has no links to Bangladesh and has never visited the country.

It's essentially a technical ruling. The mechanism by which her citizenship was revoked is correct. It's not a ruling on the facts of the case itself.

123rainbow · 02/04/2023 15:44

We probably don't know the full extent o r reasons why the government believe she is a high risk. She wasn't 15 when she said the bombings were justified.