Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Jourdain11 · 05/04/2023 19:45

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 05/04/2023 09:28

And that is why it is so difficult to make war criminals accountable, most of the witnesses are dead or stay silent either for their own safety or to avoid sharing the blame.

It doesn’t mean that she is innocent.

Neither does what you say prove she is guilty.

I should think there are any number of former ISIS members trying to get repatriated who'd be only too happy to shop her in order to ingratiate themselves with their countries of origin.

I've yet to see evidence or strong and meaningful suggestion that she committed any crime other than travelling to join a terrorist organisation. Which is of course a crime.

nothingcomestonothing · 05/04/2023 17:00

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 16:51

Whether or not she should be our responsibility, there are thousands of people more deserving of the limited capacity we have to help everyone who needs help.

As I said upthread, it'd be amazing if homeless veterans got even close to the amount of sympathy this 'ex' terrorist gets.

But it's not about 'helping' her - we have dumped the responsibility for a citizen of this country, onto another country. That's both morally wrong (to her but also to a poorer country we've offloaded our problem to), and setting a dangerous precedent when we expect to be able to deport criminals from other countries back where they came from if they commit crime here.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 16:51

Whether or not she should be our responsibility, there are thousands of people more deserving of the limited capacity we have to help everyone who needs help.

As I said upthread, it'd be amazing if homeless veterans got even close to the amount of sympathy this 'ex' terrorist gets.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 05/04/2023 12:58

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 09:29

This. I think most ten year olds would know beheading is wrong. Her life is completely fucked whatever happens to her. She wouldn’t be safe in prison here unless she was in solitary and she could never show her (now very wellknown) face in public in this country. She has no future.

Clearly neither of you have any idea about how indoctrination and radicalisation work.

You only have to look at social media, politics, or religion to see that what someone 'knows is wrong' is entirely subjective and dependant on the sphere of influence they live in.

Many people think it's fine to bomb innocent people, as long as the intended target was an enemy combatant. Many people think the summary execution or imprisonment without trial of 'terrorists' is justified. Many people believe it would be morally right to hang a terrorisrt / murderer / rapist / paedophile / etc.

If you asked any mother of a 10-15 year old boy if they thought their son knew it was wrong to abuse women, the vast majority would say "yes, of course he knows how wrong that is". Yet, Andrew Tate and his brand of excessive / overt misogyny is built almost entirely on the backs of you boys/men and domestic violence / abuse is still sadly common place.

It's all well and good to say a 10-15 year old should know X is wrong, but that's wishful thinking at best, and reality is completely different. Without the right boundaries and checks in place (which people like Begum do not have) there's always a risk they'll not know X is seen as wrong, or be able to be convinced that X is acceptable in this situation or that situation.

mycoffeecup · 05/04/2023 12:10

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 05/04/2023 09:28

And that is why it is so difficult to make war criminals accountable, most of the witnesses are dead or stay silent either for their own safety or to avoid sharing the blame.

It doesn’t mean that she is innocent.

True, however in this case there are several witnesses who say that she largely stayed at home being pregnant (5 pregnancies while she was out there, 2 miscarriages and 3 babies), including those who are still ideologically committed to ISIS and who would have applauded her for a more active role.

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 05/04/2023 09:28

And that is why it is so difficult to make war criminals accountable, most of the witnesses are dead or stay silent either for their own safety or to avoid sharing the blame.

It doesn’t mean that she is innocent.

mycoffeecup · 05/04/2023 09:24

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 04/04/2023 21:09

The age of criminal responsibility is 10yo. Most 15yo would know that stitching somebody into a suicide bomb jacket to ensure they can't escape is wrong.

Do show me the proof that she stitched people into suicide vests? Because as far as I'm aware that comes from an article in the Telegraph which said 'it was reported that' and extensive efforts by investigative journalists have not been able to find any reliable source.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 04/04/2023 21:09

TruthsAndALie · 02/04/2023 22:27

How can someone say 15 year olds ‘know what they’re doing’ when they haven’t reached the age of consent for pretty much anything? There is being book smart and there is being worldly. Her husband even described her as a blank page as she had such little experience of almost anything. This is not someone with middle class parents regularly travelling and having deep philosophical debates over dinner. This is a conservative immigrant family living at/near poverty conditions.

The school highlighted she and her friends were at risk but an assessment by the police didn’t agree. The parents weren’t told any of this.

She’s said in interview her social media profile and interactions can and have been reviewed so I think they know what’s been said/received.

The age of criminal responsibility is 10yo. Most 15yo would know that stitching somebody into a suicide bomb jacket to ensure they can't escape is wrong.

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 18:44

@TruthsAndALie
It's been accepted that the authorities failed to act appropriately. We know that Sharmeena, the girl who went first, is still an active member of Isis. We know as @Bepis says that in the interview with her husband that she had to obey him and he beat and raped her. He admits that she lost their children due to being malnourished. She doesn't want to return to him.

We don't know what expectations she had as a schoolgirl in Tower Hamlets, she says she never met men at home. From February this year in Britain marriage is illegal for anyone under 18, a law which Sajid Javid supported. If she returns to the UK no doubt she would be detained and questioned under the terrorism acts.

FullaSpjäll · 03/04/2023 18:37

I think Truths is right; I'm of a similar age and have never seen a beheading video or any violent IS footage, despite being an avid consumer of current affairs. Having seen how easily various conspiracy theories took hold of formerly clear-thinking people during the pandemic, why are we surprised that radicalised young people were able to discount the portrayal of IS in the western media, rationalising it like "...Well, that's what they want people to think... They would say that, wouldn't they... They are serving their own agenda..." Phrases like these have caused untold suffering in the post-truth West. All it takes is a bit of mental gymnastics and a suspension of critical faculty in place of faith, which is a key feature of most organised religion, let alone radicalised groups.

I work with refugee communities and, as stated in the podcast, it is not uncommon for young people in war zones to give an exaggerated impression of their own resilience. I see this a lot in the children and young people I work with; heartbreaking, life-changing stories or snippets of gruesome, violent events passed off with a shrug, as if in passing, with a smile, even; "Don't worry about me, it's OK." I'm not at all surprised that Shamima, in the situation she found herself in, giving that first interview, may have come across as aloof or detached from the horrors of the regime.

I think Shamima should be permitted to return to Britain, her citizenship reinstated, and the extent of her culpability investigated here under the close scrutiny of professionals and agencies expert in radicalisation, trafficking and coercive control and who able to advocate for her interests.

Bepis · 03/04/2023 17:31

Did anyone hear her husband saying that her role was to please the husband, obey the husband and he openly said that it's not an equal relationship. What he says goes 😳

Technonan · 03/04/2023 17:28

Or maybe we treat someone who mutilated and murdered other women for fun and has shown no remorse past crocodile tears as the criminal they are.

There's no evidence at all that she did that. You've been reading too many dodgy 'news' sources.

She had three children and they all died; her husband (and it was effectively a forced marriage) was abusive. She's still very young. At worst, she's guilty of being stupid and naive - hands up anyone who wasn't at 15.

People say 'Of course she knew what ISIS was like, but they were told again and again that all the anti-ISIS stuff was propaganda. It's very wrong that our government has taken her citizenship. Even if she had committed a crime, she is our responsibility.

Bepis · 03/04/2023 17:25

Jourdain11 · 03/04/2023 17:22

To be honest, I think I just said I'd had a miscarriage and didn't refer to losing anything. But it's personal, isn't it? If you're already thinking about the baby your pregnancy will result in, it's very reasonable to feel you've lost a child.

You are completely right, it's personal to each woman and each woman will feel differently.

Jourdain11 · 03/04/2023 17:22

To be honest, I think I just said I'd had a miscarriage and didn't refer to losing anything. But it's personal, isn't it? If you're already thinking about the baby your pregnancy will result in, it's very reasonable to feel you've lost a child.

Bepis · 03/04/2023 17:14

@chocandchurro I, and all women I know would say they had lost a baby/child.

chocandchurro · 03/04/2023 17:06

Jourdain11 · 03/04/2023 13:19

You really do seem to be a most horrible person. I hope you're never called for jury service, but unfortunately lack of intellect and compassion doesn't disqualify people.

Would you honestly tell someone you know who'd miscarried that it wasn't a child? I'm sorry for your acquaintances if so!

As you say, evidence is put before decision-makers. I'd assume they're happy with what they see re her children, as no one has disputed it.

I've had miscarriages and I (and most women I know) would say they had lost a pregnancy rather than a child?

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 13:30

I think your point about seeing it through your own lens is a valid one @TruthsAndALie. And the effect of radicalisation.

You can accuse me of lacking compassion if you like @Jourdain11, by your standards I probably do, I’m not a sentimentalist. There’s nothing wrong with my intellect though.

TruthsAndALie · 03/04/2023 13:23

*brutal

TruthsAndALie · 03/04/2023 13:22

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 09:29

This. I think most ten year olds would know beheading is wrong. Her life is completely fucked whatever happens to her. She wouldn’t be safe in prison here unless she was in solitary and she could never show her (now very wellknown) face in public in this country. She has no future.

I agree children know what is right/wrong to this extreme but isn’t the point about being radicalised and brainwashed that she was told they weren’t real or it’s a misrepresentation or is somehow justified as women/children were being bombed - whatever their story was. People are viewing it through their own lens and how they would think.

I’m mid 40’s and have never seen any of the brut ISIS videos, why would I have? I totally believe it to be true but find it odd the view is everyone has seen a video of someone being beheaded.

Jourdain11 · 03/04/2023 13:20

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 12:44

Fine. They don’t count as children legally or in any other sense for the vast majority of us.

That's absolutely vile.

Jourdain11 · 03/04/2023 13:19

You really do seem to be a most horrible person. I hope you're never called for jury service, but unfortunately lack of intellect and compassion doesn't disqualify people.

Would you honestly tell someone you know who'd miscarried that it wasn't a child? I'm sorry for your acquaintances if so!

As you say, evidence is put before decision-makers. I'd assume they're happy with what they see re her children, as no one has disputed it.

TruthsAndALie · 03/04/2023 13:18

bellabasset · 03/04/2023 07:42

@TruthsAndALie

The parents were sent letters except instead of posting them they were given to the pupils who didn't give them to their parents. They should have been posted but it's cost saving. She does say that she never mixed with men at home and her father was living in Bangladesh with his new wife and family so he wasn't there to monitor her computer usage, she's of a generation where the kids know more than the parents. Also if Sajid Javid is right she'd be detained for a long time in the UK

I’m aware she didn’t pass the letters on but the question why school/police didn’t deal directly with the parents for someone under 16 and who school think is at risk. Teenager doing something their parents don’t know about and doesn’t pass communication on - shocking 🤨

Bepis · 03/04/2023 12:54

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 12:44

Fine. They don’t count as children legally or in any other sense for the vast majority of us.

But what I meant is that they were still her children so she has technically lost 5 children, 3 by death and 2 by miscarriage.

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2023 12:44

Fine. They don’t count as children legally or in any other sense for the vast majority of us.

Bepis · 03/04/2023 12:27

@Blossomtoes They count as children to me, from the moment of conception.