Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Itsbytheby · 28/03/2023 16:38

roarfeckingroarr · 28/03/2023 16:30

Im sorry but there's no way she thought ISIS were a utopian community. Beheadings and rape were well publicised and yet off she went.

I am not saying she wasn't aware. But apparently only 10% of their recruitment marketing is about the voilence. The majority is about community, inclusion, purpose etc. Obviously this is coupled with ideology, and joiners will be aware of the violence, but it's packaged up as being about community and purpose. Since the ISIS Caliphate was disbanded people interested in joining have declined massively. Part of that is of course that ISIS isn't doing so well, but apparently a big part of it is considered by experts to be because they are no longer able to offer this community element.

roarfeckingroarr · 28/03/2023 16:30

Itsbytheby · 28/03/2023 11:45

Again, listening to the interviews with her, what she seemed attracted to was the community that it was offering. More so than the violence or even the cause. She also barely talks about her religion factoring in. She was groomed/ indoctrinated into thinking of it as some kind of utopia community. From what I can gather she was very quickly brought down to earth when the reality hit, e.g. when she was married off.

Im sorry but there's no way she thought ISIS were a utopian community. Beheadings and rape were well publicised and yet off she went.

frazzledasarock · 28/03/2023 15:28

She’d be out of her mind to openly condemn ISIL or say they’re bad or anything negative about them on open media, whilst sittting in a refugee camp in the middle of nowhere with no protection.

Kanaloa · 28/03/2023 15:15

Dotjones · 28/03/2023 14:04

She's a criminal, plain and simple, and deserves to be stripped of her citizenship. A person like her has no place in our society. Is it right to expect another country to give her residence? No, but that doesn't mean she has to be allowed to return here.

To me there's no issue with making someone stateless if their behaviour justifies it. So she has no right to go anywhere, so what, if no country will accept her that just rams home the message that what she did was unacceptable to every country in the world.

Citizenship shouldn't be considered an automatic right - if it were, I could just choose to become a citizen of the US or Australia and someone in Madagascar could just choose to become a citizen here.

It’s to do with responsibility. It’s easy to say ‘if no country will accept her that’s her fault’ but what you’re really saying is ‘our country doesn’t have to deal with things we can’t be bothered with - an impoverished war torn country will be stuck with her.’

Unless of course you’re proposing we pay for a spaceship to launch her off of planet earth, she will have to live in some country or other. That country should be the one who made her.

Kanaloa · 28/03/2023 15:13

Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 13:51

The problem is that those two little boys were accepted quite rightly not as monsters or demons or any other silly rhetoric, but as products of OUR society

Really? Clearly you don’t remember the news coverage at the time.

Well they were tried in a court setting. Trying them in a British court accepts them as a product of our society. And for what it’s worth I think most normal people realise that two children who commit a murder makes three tragedies.

mycoffeecup · 28/03/2023 15:10

potniatheron · 28/03/2023 15:04

Agreed. She (Begum) was a member of the ISIS morality police - women who went about enforcing ISIS' version of 'morality' on other women and girsl, in between torturing Yazidi women and girls.

And your source for that is?
We don't know if she was or wasn't - there's just no evidence either way

verdantverdure · 28/03/2023 15:05

Ofcom says GB "News" isn't a news channel so it's not subject to the same rules as actual news channels.

SB was a child victim of grooming and sex trafficking.

That's just a fact.

I think people have their own reasons why they don't see it that way, and I do tend to assume it's racism at worst and ignorance at best.

Brexit's done more harm to this country than SB.

potniatheron · 28/03/2023 15:04

Rapapampam · 28/03/2023 14:10

Now there’s some vids on YouTube about a Yazidi sex slave who was eyewitness to SB’s true behaviour in Syria.
Anyone who is defending this dumb, violent criminal is blind and equally dumb. Who in their right mind is thinking about joining a terrorist group at 15? At that age your biggest worry is your grades and whether your crush likes you, not an effing terrorist organisation.
You join a terrorist group, then don’t expect to be taken back to the UK. She can live in no-man’s land her whole life for all I care.

Agreed. She (Begum) was a member of the ISIS morality police - women who went about enforcing ISIS' version of 'morality' on other women and girsl, in between torturing Yazidi women and girls.

MissMaple82 · 28/03/2023 15:04

She is both

mycoffeecup · 28/03/2023 15:03

Livelovebehappy · 28/03/2023 15:02

Did you see the first interview she did when tracked down? She was cold, unapologetic and seemed to wear it as a badge of honour that she agreed with every barbaric killing of Westerners. This was the true Shamima. Not the one we see now, ‘groomed’ by her lawyers and sympathetic supporters to say what needs to be said to get her foot back in the door. People saying she was unapologetic in the first interview because she was scared of repercussions - what’s changed now? She’s still in Syria, surrounded by the same dangerous people she was then. She’s manipulative, and there’s no doubt she still hates Britain, and will be grooming others if she was ever welcomed back. It’s just not worth the risk. Let her rot in the bed of her own making.

She was just out of the desert, malnourished, traumatised, 9 months pregnant and just watched her two children die. And living in a camp with violent ISIS sympathisers. Do you honestly think judging her on one interview in that situation is valid?

Livelovebehappy · 28/03/2023 15:02

Did you see the first interview she did when tracked down? She was cold, unapologetic and seemed to wear it as a badge of honour that she agreed with every barbaric killing of Westerners. This was the true Shamima. Not the one we see now, ‘groomed’ by her lawyers and sympathetic supporters to say what needs to be said to get her foot back in the door. People saying she was unapologetic in the first interview because she was scared of repercussions - what’s changed now? She’s still in Syria, surrounded by the same dangerous people she was then. She’s manipulative, and there’s no doubt she still hates Britain, and will be grooming others if she was ever welcomed back. It’s just not worth the risk. Let her rot in the bed of her own making.

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 15:02

Rapapampam · 28/03/2023 14:56

Why don’t you go and give her a hug, then house her in your property?
If she comes back here, will you pay the 24/hour security she will clearly need? No?
Will you keep, clothe and fed her? Because she won’t be able to work or do anything productive while constantly threatened.

Strange post!

OP posts:
Justanotherlurker · 28/03/2023 15:00

dancinfeet · 28/03/2023 14:52

she is a victim, if she were white she would be portrayed as such in the media, but it’s too easy to throw blame instead

Yeah like Jack Letts.

Just like you have no problem when it is a white male...

Rapapampam · 28/03/2023 14:56

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 28/03/2023 14:23

She’s a victim. She was a child when she was groomed by an extremist organisation. If this was a white British girl of 15 years old there’d be no question on whether she was a criminal or a victim. Young girls who were victims of grooming gangs were always reported to be the victims… how can the same not be true for Shemima

Why don’t you go and give her a hug, then house her in your property?
If she comes back here, will you pay the 24/hour security she will clearly need? No?
Will you keep, clothe and fed her? Because she won’t be able to work or do anything productive while constantly threatened.

Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 14:55

dancinfeet · 28/03/2023 14:52

she is a victim, if she were white she would be portrayed as such in the media, but it’s too easy to throw blame instead

Don’t think so.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-41593659

Sally Jones

British IS recruiter Sally-Anne Jones 'killed by drone'

IS recruiter Sally-Anne Jones, the widow of an IS fighter, was reportedly killed in Syria in June.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-41593659

dancinfeet · 28/03/2023 14:52

she is a victim, if she were white she would be portrayed as such in the media, but it’s too easy to throw blame instead

mycoffeecup · 28/03/2023 14:43

Rapapampam · 28/03/2023 14:10

Now there’s some vids on YouTube about a Yazidi sex slave who was eyewitness to SB’s true behaviour in Syria.
Anyone who is defending this dumb, violent criminal is blind and equally dumb. Who in their right mind is thinking about joining a terrorist group at 15? At that age your biggest worry is your grades and whether your crush likes you, not an effing terrorist organisation.
You join a terrorist group, then don’t expect to be taken back to the UK. She can live in no-man’s land her whole life for all I care.

The video I've seen (GB news footage so to be taken with a pinch of salt maybe) just says that she was seen at a training camp, which I assume was compulsory for all new arrivals.

What 'true behaviour' are you talking about - can you link to the video?

begoneday · 28/03/2023 14:40

I guess if you feel your daughter would be a victim if she was groomed online by a group of paedophiles, then trafficked to another country, then surely she is too ? Unfortunately for her, her name is not Florence or Mia, so the Daily Mail etc have vilified her.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/03/2023 14:36

I think the thing that annoys me about the Shamima situation is the interviews she gave in the refugee camp have influenced peoples opinion of her...'she should stay there, she showed no remorse!'

Firstly she was physically suffering (malnourished, walked miles to a refugee camp, heavily pregnant etc) and secondly most people in a war zone who have witnessed atrocities and seen their own children die would be mentally traumatised.

Secondly the camp is full of ISIS, it is a violent place and people were at risk of being killed if they denounced ISIS. I'm not sure she could speak freely. It's like asking someone who suffers DV infront of their abusers family if they still love them...they're not going to say no if they think it's a risk it will get back to them.

Peoples views can change over time and people have a million reasons for not saying what they actually mean.

Lastly this was not a police interview (if it was they may have found she was not fit to answer questions). And even if it was, I'm not sure that 'remorse' equals 'criminally guilty' though I believe it can be taken into account in sentencing. She could be glad about all the isis atrocities. But legally that doesn't mean that a. She is guilty of a crime and b. She should be made stateless. There isnt as far as I'm aware a rule that if you seem sorry, you're allowed back in.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 28/03/2023 14:33

I think under the law, she should be returned to the UK, but I struggle to have sympathy with her.

DeeCeeCherry · 28/03/2023 14:25

15 is a child. Think how naive we were at that age.

But adultification of non-White children, Islamophobia, and the convenience of being the poster-girl for Tories to show 'Look! We are dealing with terrorism!' (Meanwhile male terrorists languish here) has conspired against her unfortunately.

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 28/03/2023 14:23

She’s a victim. She was a child when she was groomed by an extremist organisation. If this was a white British girl of 15 years old there’d be no question on whether she was a criminal or a victim. Young girls who were victims of grooming gangs were always reported to be the victims… how can the same not be true for Shemima

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/03/2023 14:22

"My sympathy lies with the young Yazidi victims of the violent, misogynistic cult she was a member of."

I agree with this. But think you can have sympathy with others, and still want to see proper legal process followed, simultaneously (without 'supporting' Shamima or agreeing or downplaying what she did).

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/03/2023 14:20

"Shamima didn’t attempt to come home when she realised it wasn’t all it was made out to be! When she experienced the first horrible event over there she never reached out to try and return… but she did reach out to recruit others."

People who even assisted people trying to leave, were brutally tortured and killed. Her friends who did want to leave, didn't dare attempt it, because others who tried were publicly killed as examples

You can blame her for many things but not attempting to leave when she had an abusive husband (that we know from here is hard enough to leave when there is support available) and there was a very high chance of being killed is not fair.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 28/03/2023 14:19

My sympathy lies with the young Yazidi victims of the violent, misogynistic cult she was a member of.

Swipe left for the next trending thread