Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 10:13

Was 19 when she said the Manchester attack was justified, she had a choice at 15 to not get on that plane. Even at 19 to maybe change her views . Poor 8yr old Saffie-Rose Roussos had no choice and many others who were killed that night in Manchester.
Changed her opinion when it all started going shit over there and she lost everyone close to her . And please stop bringing race into it, many white people have not been aloud back . Il quote here as not listened to pod but many security issues with her that have not been made public. Her dad should maybe take some responsibility for the views he had also .

badgermushrooms · 29/03/2023 10:11

She's both, obviously, we do generally expect 15 year olds to take some responsibility for their own actions. The question we should be asking is, is any crime severe enough to justify stripping someone of their citizenship? And if so, why are people like Levi Bellfield and Myra Hindley still British citizens?

discobrain · 29/03/2023 10:10

100% victim.

verdantverdure · 29/03/2023 10:10

Do racists get an extra charge out of Home Secretaries being "brown".

Or does it just give political cover?

Or is it just a coincidence that our last three have been?

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 10:02

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:56

It wasn’t the current Home Secretary who removed her citizenship, was it? It was the very brown, non practicing Muslim Sanjid Javid. Hence the ridicule for your assertion that her race and religion are causing her to be victimised.

And as I have clarified, I am talking about the public. Many Home Secs have made bad decisions based purely on public sentiment. The state should be above that, applying logic and consistency.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 10:00

I dont think any is suggesting she shouldn't have been punished but even James Bulgers killers were given the opportunity to be rehabilitated and live their lives in the UK, obv under licence and one has been recalled several times.

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 10:00

ex-isis fighters (men) have managed to get back to the uk and haven’t been stripped of citizenship.

Jack Letts was.

Noicant · 29/03/2023 09:57

I’m inclined to think 15 years olds can be utterly fucking stupid. The podcast basically makes it sound like she followed her friends which I can believe.

I think that people steeped in political/religious extremist groups basically lose their moral compass. It’s a bit like the “be kind, it’s ok to punch a granny in the face, she deserved it” crew. They see appalling crimes committed against others as deserving for their own imagined victimisation. You see this across all sorts of groups, left and right at the extreme fringes violence is acceptable. I struggle to understand how slavery and rape were fine by her but then I’m not radicalised.

What I don’t understand is how the judges think she presents a very real threat but the podcast suggests that she basically got married had kids and didn’t go out much. Even her old mate Shamima was talking about her like she’s a bit pathetic. Yet the government considers her to be extremely dangerous. I’d really like that explained.

I do think dumping her on Kurds to look after isn’t ok. Unless the deal is, you keep these people and we will pay you and they are happy with that. What concerns me more are the number of children in these camps who are being radicalised. They are being raised in a cult. She raises a point that loads of people got back tot he UK and the government is just making an example of her, I think thats true, ex-isis fighters (men) have managed to get back to the uk and haven’t been stripped of citizenship.

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:56

Tescoland · 29/03/2023 09:52

Is being groomed an excuse now in the eyes of the law? Does it make you exempt from punishment?
I’m only asking because based on this theory, most criminals were abused, groomed or damaged in some way. Nobody becomes a criminal just out of the blue.

So we might as well abolish prisons and punishments because all criminals had some kind of shit going on in their lives before they committed their crimes. If you dig deep enough into someone’s past, you always find something that could have affected their psyche in a way that turned them to crime. Shall we set all of them free then because it’s not their fault?

Not sure how you've managed to deduce so much inference from my post.

Most criminals get a chance to serve their time and be rehabilitated. Even kids like Jamie Bulger's murderers.

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:56

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:53

Well, given the current HS's policies on immigration and sending people to Rwanda, I don't think this is a great yard stick to be honest.

But actually, I was talking about the general public.

It wasn’t the current Home Secretary who removed her citizenship, was it? It was the very brown, non practicing Muslim Sanjid Javid. Hence the ridicule for your assertion that her race and religion are causing her to be victimised.

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:53

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:48

her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case

By a brown Home Secretary with the same religion? Please.

Well, given the current HS's policies on immigration and sending people to Rwanda, I don't think this is a great yard stick to be honest.

But actually, I was talking about the general public.

Tescoland · 29/03/2023 09:52

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:45

She was groomed and is consequently a victim and, given her experiences, most likely remains a very damaged individual. Sadly, the reality is that this may mean she continues to pose a danger. Or alternatively, she may be successfully rehabilitated and hugely beneficial to the UK in terms of helping us learn more about how to effectively prevent this happening to others. Either way, to leave her stateless, having allowed this to happen to her, is unforgivable. And I agree with others that her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case with the grooming and sexual exploitation of children.

Is being groomed an excuse now in the eyes of the law? Does it make you exempt from punishment?
I’m only asking because based on this theory, most criminals were abused, groomed or damaged in some way. Nobody becomes a criminal just out of the blue.

So we might as well abolish prisons and punishments because all criminals had some kind of shit going on in their lives before they committed their crimes. If you dig deep enough into someone’s past, you always find something that could have affected their psyche in a way that turned them to crime. Shall we set all of them free then because it’s not their fault?

potniatheron · 29/03/2023 09:52

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:48

her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case

By a brown Home Secretary with the same religion? Please.

Unfortunately we can only trust a Labour Government (ideally led by Jeremy Corbyn) to ever place a person of colour (or indeed a woman) into a position of high office. We all know it would never happen under the racist Tories.

Cocochai · 29/03/2023 09:51

highintheskypurple · 28/03/2023 11:55

I mean, if she was a girl who was trafficked and turned into a prostitute, I think I'd feel sorry. But a terrorist? Who the fuck could accidentally become a terrorist? 15 is old enough to know better.
the killers of poor James Bulger were only 10 but we don't think of them as victims do we? (and if you do fuck off)

Exactly.

If two 10-year olds can be held accountable for their actions and said to know exactly what they were doing then why is a 15-year old attracting sympathy? Whether she was groomed or not, or whether James Bulger’s killers had a terrible childhood which led to what they did, we are all ultimately accountable for our actions.

Also, there was talk of sending James Bulger’s killers to New Zealand once released. It caused uproar in NZ and the Prime Minister at the time had to make a statement to say they would never be allowed in.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 09:50

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:45

She was groomed and is consequently a victim and, given her experiences, most likely remains a very damaged individual. Sadly, the reality is that this may mean she continues to pose a danger. Or alternatively, she may be successfully rehabilitated and hugely beneficial to the UK in terms of helping us learn more about how to effectively prevent this happening to others. Either way, to leave her stateless, having allowed this to happen to her, is unforgivable. And I agree with others that her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case with the grooming and sexual exploitation of children.

I think you have articulated this so well. I have had some personal involvement in a situation that could have ended up like her (not me but a friend). It was so devastating at the time but luckily the police in our area do a huge amount of work with young people who are being groomed by extremists so many are helped before anything top serious has happened.

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:48

her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case

By a brown Home Secretary with the same religion? Please.

Whatafustercluck · 29/03/2023 09:45

She was groomed and is consequently a victim and, given her experiences, most likely remains a very damaged individual. Sadly, the reality is that this may mean she continues to pose a danger. Or alternatively, she may be successfully rehabilitated and hugely beneficial to the UK in terms of helping us learn more about how to effectively prevent this happening to others. Either way, to leave her stateless, having allowed this to happen to her, is unforgivable. And I agree with others that her race and religion have seen her judged far more savagely than would otherwise be the case with the grooming and sexual exploitation of children.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 09:44

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:41

It’s not about consent. It’s about criminal responsibility. The age of criminal responsibility in this country is ten. Quite simply our legal system makes her responsible for her own actions and decrees that she was old enough to know right from wrong. She voluntarily stole a passport (a crime) and joined a barbaric, murderous regime.

All the talk about consent and grooming is irrelevant. She’s a criminal, pure and simple and, according to the security agencies, a dangerous one.

She should 100% be punished, but not sure I agree she should be banished from the UK, locked up and throwaway the key as many posters seem to be suggesting. Grooming is relevant here though, that is how people often become involved with ISIS. Not just underage females, but older males who are vulnerable etc. Doesn't mean they shouldn't be punished of course but I do believe they are the UKs problem.

onetimenamec · 29/03/2023 09:43

It will probably hinge on how much right of reply she was given at the time her rights were revoked. The answer is probably not much and there was nobody sufficiently knowledgeable or legally conversant to act on her behalf. That is the basis upon which the decision would be revised.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 09:41

onetimenamec · 29/03/2023 09:35

She was a mature and intelligent fifteen year old, there's no getting away from it. You can even see that now. She is an old head on young shoulders, a considered thinker. There are fifteen year olds who are over sensitive, immature, damaged, naive but she was not.

The law doesn't care how mature someone is though as it's hard to prove. She was definitely damaged though.

Blossomtoes · 29/03/2023 09:41

It’s not about consent. It’s about criminal responsibility. The age of criminal responsibility in this country is ten. Quite simply our legal system makes her responsible for her own actions and decrees that she was old enough to know right from wrong. She voluntarily stole a passport (a crime) and joined a barbaric, murderous regime.

All the talk about consent and grooming is irrelevant. She’s a criminal, pure and simple and, according to the security agencies, a dangerous one.

onetimenamec · 29/03/2023 09:35

She was a mature and intelligent fifteen year old, there's no getting away from it. You can even see that now. She is an old head on young shoulders, a considered thinker. There are fifteen year olds who are over sensitive, immature, damaged, naive but she was not.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 09:33

Tg2023 · 29/03/2023 06:35

👆🏼 this

At 15 we know what we're doing!

I don't necessarily disagree that we know what we're doing at 15 but on here (and in the eyes of the law) if a 15 yo decides they want to date a man over 18 then they are being groomed and aren't old enough to consent. I am not understanding why this is different. In that line of thinking she wasn't old enough to consent to do what she did so was essentially groomed. Not saying I don't think she deserves punishing, I'm just interested in how people have decided its different.

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 09:27

ChristinaXYZ · 28/03/2023 20:28

But we do hold children much younger to account for criminality and presumably all children are criminal because of some kind or abuse /grooming in the background (I'm talking serious criminality not graffitti or shoplifting). For example Robert Thompson and Jon Venables aged when they killed Jamie Bulger and in the 60s Mary Bell who killed two children, again aged only 10 when she killed.

They all rightly served time behind bars. Begum was much older - half as old again - and has not appeared particularly remorseful. I'll save most of my sympathy for the victims of the terror group, mainly the women and girls used as sex slaves.

Having said that I do still think she should have been prosecuted here in the UK and if convicted served her sentence here. I also think there are many adults who need holding to account from the family of the three girls to the system that lets three girls use passports to leave the country without their parents' permission.

There is no doubt in my mind that Begum should be held accountable for her actions though agreed her age should give some context.

I don't think its about not punishing her though, you could argue this point about any child who has committed a crime as most of them are likely to have factors involved that have steered them towards committing these crimes. She is no different but surely she should be punished, rehabilitated (if possible) etc like those other children were.

MarshaBradyo · 29/03/2023 09:16

potniatheron · 29/03/2023 09:05

She's brown and a Muslim, that automatically makes your guilty in the eyes of the tory government and a not insignificant portion of the UK population.

You're right. Tory votes would never judge a brown and/or Muslim person by the content of their character rather than the olour of their skin. I certainly can't imagine the racist Tories ever accepting a brown leader or a Muslim Home Sec. Gosh, I wonder if it might happen under Labour.

Yes these points seem to be lacking reality