Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:45

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 16:30

As I understand it though the court ruling was nothing to do with whether the decision was the right one. It didn’t look at evidence of her crimes etc. It was simply about whether the Home Secretary is legally allowed to strip her of her citizenship rights. Not whether it was a good decision to do so. It’s not confirmation or denial of what she has or hasn’t done so doesn’t actually give us any more information. Just because it is legal doesn’t make it morally right. And I think the concluding statement had a qualifier on it to this effect.

So what would be the evidence given in court that can’t be made public be about?

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 16:40

And the Kurdish people who run the camp where we want to leave her are asking for help. What happens if they simply decide they don’t want to run the camps any more? What do we do then?

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 16:30

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:18

Any decision made on national security in this country is of course based on keeping myself my kids and wider public safe . It was said if we knew , we would understand .
This case has been to court evidence has been submitted some of that evidence has not been made public ,her appeal was denied so at this moment she’s not welcome back in the UK this is a decision I believe would not of been taken lightly and has not been made by one person alone .
So I’m going to stick to my view this decision was made in the interest of safety in the UK . It’s just my opinion as you are entitled to yours none of which will have any bearing on what happens to her .

As I understand it though the court ruling was nothing to do with whether the decision was the right one. It didn’t look at evidence of her crimes etc. It was simply about whether the Home Secretary is legally allowed to strip her of her citizenship rights. Not whether it was a good decision to do so. It’s not confirmation or denial of what she has or hasn’t done so doesn’t actually give us any more information. Just because it is legal doesn’t make it morally right. And I think the concluding statement had a qualifier on it to this effect.

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:21

And I’m not going to dig into why she’s safer being over there then over here . Il leave that to national security.

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 16:18

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 15:38

I didn’t ask if you cared about her or have sympathy for her. I asked how refusing to prosecute someone you believe to be a dangerous criminal is in line with trying to ‘keep your children safe.’ It is not. Your argument was nonsense.

Any decision made on national security in this country is of course based on keeping myself my kids and wider public safe . It was said if we knew , we would understand .
This case has been to court evidence has been submitted some of that evidence has not been made public ,her appeal was denied so at this moment she’s not welcome back in the UK this is a decision I believe would not of been taken lightly and has not been made by one person alone .
So I’m going to stick to my view this decision was made in the interest of safety in the UK . It’s just my opinion as you are entitled to yours none of which will have any bearing on what happens to her .

verdantverdure · 29/03/2023 16:02

LakieLady · 29/03/2023 16:01

Victim. She's been treated very badly imo.

By everyone, ever.

LakieLady · 29/03/2023 16:01

Victim. She's been treated very badly imo.

babybythesea · 29/03/2023 15:55

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 15:36

I can’t comment any further as I don’t work for national security and all facts in this case have not been made public.
Anyone 19 years of age saying that attack was justified, I really can’t have much sympathy for them and il leave them in care of the people who do know . That is just my opinion and you don’t have to agree .

The thing with this is she said this two days after giving birth. She’d had a difficult journey after the fall of the city she was living in, while heavily pregnant. She was in a camp in difficult conditions surrounded by people who killed you if you said the wrong thing. One account is of a woman who’d been murdered and dumped in a septic tank. A male journalist tracked her down and she said those things - I’m not sure if I’d have denounced ISIS at that point. Especially if I was trying to protect my newborn.

Listen to later interviews- she does condemn those things.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 29/03/2023 15:38

Climbles · 29/03/2023 15:21

Both. Either way she’s British and we should never have let those babies die. I don’t think she’s anymore of a threat than all the murders we let out of prison every day.

Most murderers kill one person or a handful. Terrorists plan attacks that kill dozens or sometimes hundreds.

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 15:38

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 15:36

I can’t comment any further as I don’t work for national security and all facts in this case have not been made public.
Anyone 19 years of age saying that attack was justified, I really can’t have much sympathy for them and il leave them in care of the people who do know . That is just my opinion and you don’t have to agree .

I didn’t ask if you cared about her or have sympathy for her. I asked how refusing to prosecute someone you believe to be a dangerous criminal is in line with trying to ‘keep your children safe.’ It is not. Your argument was nonsense.

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 15:36

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 15:03

So how is refusing to prosecute this person (who you believe to be a dangerous criminal) keeping your kids safe? It isn’t. She’s in exactly the same position she was when the Manchester attack happened, in that she is not convicted of any crimes, basically inaccessible, and in a great position to network with other potential terrorists. That argument does not hold.

I can’t comment any further as I don’t work for national security and all facts in this case have not been made public.
Anyone 19 years of age saying that attack was justified, I really can’t have much sympathy for them and il leave them in care of the people who do know . That is just my opinion and you don’t have to agree .

maranella · 29/03/2023 15:28

I think she was definitely groomed and, as such is a victim. There is no evidence that she ever had anything to do with being a perpetrator and when the woman she claims groomed her (Sharmeena) was found by the BBC in Syria still working for ISIS she laughed at the idea that Shamima Begum was in the Hisbah (the women's group that went around beating other women for dressing/behaving inappropriately). She said she couldn't have been in it because she didn't speak Arabic and that SB was really quiet and just stayed at home. Given that she was only 15, had a nasty, controlling husband who didn't allow her out (by his own admission), that sounds believable to me. I think she should be allowed to return to the UK and face the consequences. She was 15 FFS. I think there's a lot of misogyny and Islamophobia that's keeping her stuck in that shithole camp in Syria. Her whole family is here. She was born here. Bangladesh has said she can't have a passport, so removing her British one has left her stateless, which I thought was not allowed under the UNCHR.

Climbles · 29/03/2023 15:21

Both. Either way she’s British and we should never have let those babies die. I don’t think she’s anymore of a threat than all the murders we let out of prison every day.

verdantverdure · 29/03/2023 15:18

Danielle9891 · 29/03/2023 15:12

Guilty but it is the way she was brought up. Her dad attended a rally and burned a union jack flag. Lee Rigby killer was also there.
www.politicalite.com/latest/updated-revealed-father-of-isis-three-attended-rally-with-anjem-choudary-and-lee-rigby-killer/

Still grooming though, right?

Like those little kids in infant school who say racist things they don't even understand. Brainwashed by bollocks since birth.

OneTC · 29/03/2023 15:16

From your own article:

Abase Hussen, father of Amira Abase, who fled with Shamima Begum in 2014 to join ISIS marched at the front of the demonstrators, behind a banner reading: ‘The followers of Mohammed will conquer America’

Danielle9891 · 29/03/2023 15:12

Guilty but it is the way she was brought up. Her dad attended a rally and burned a union jack flag. Lee Rigby killer was also there.
www.politicalite.com/latest/updated-revealed-father-of-isis-three-attended-rally-with-anjem-choudary-and-lee-rigby-killer/

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 15:12

OneTC · 29/03/2023 14:52

I’m sure she’s under surveillance over there.

Like Sharmeena was? She escaped ages ago

I’m sure if the bbc can track her down she not that well hidden .

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 15:03

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 14:47

I’m sure she’s under surveillance over there . I can’t fully protect my kids no but I do hope this is a big lesson for anyone thinking of travelling to join terrorist groups .

So how is refusing to prosecute this person (who you believe to be a dangerous criminal) keeping your kids safe? It isn’t. She’s in exactly the same position she was when the Manchester attack happened, in that she is not convicted of any crimes, basically inaccessible, and in a great position to network with other potential terrorists. That argument does not hold.

OneTC · 29/03/2023 14:52

I’m sure she’s under surveillance over there.

Like Sharmeena was? She escaped ages ago

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 14:47

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 13:46

Okay, so you’re soooo worried about keeping your kids safe from another Manchester attack - in that case you surely will not want to leave a person you believe to be a dangerous supporter of/colluder in this attack as open and free and inaccessible as they were the day the bloody attack happened. You would of course want them tried for their crimes and kept under surveillance in an appropriate prison or facility by the UK government, who are charged with keeping your kids safe.

Unless your ideas on everything are that confused. As in, rather than the faff of trying them in court, we should simply let child sex offenders go on holiday and then strip them of their citizenship to ‘keep our kids safe.’

I’m sure she’s under surveillance over there . I can’t fully protect my kids no but I do hope this is a big lesson for anyone thinking of travelling to join terrorist groups .

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 13:46

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 13:35

Its a bit more then a stupid comment esp to the victims and families of that attack, that along with security risks that have not been made public. It also not being easy I imagine to strip citizenship without very good reason .

I’m not shrinking my responsibility, it is maybe letting the people in charge of national security in this country do their job who have a lot more knowledge on this case then you or I .

Okay, so you’re soooo worried about keeping your kids safe from another Manchester attack - in that case you surely will not want to leave a person you believe to be a dangerous supporter of/colluder in this attack as open and free and inaccessible as they were the day the bloody attack happened. You would of course want them tried for their crimes and kept under surveillance in an appropriate prison or facility by the UK government, who are charged with keeping your kids safe.

Unless your ideas on everything are that confused. As in, rather than the faff of trying them in court, we should simply let child sex offenders go on holiday and then strip them of their citizenship to ‘keep our kids safe.’

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 13:35

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 13:01

What are you talking about? People say these stupid things. What does stripping British citizens of their citizenship have to do with ‘keeping your kids safe?’ She wasn’t in this country when that terrorist attack happened! Her not being in this country would not prevent that attack, because she wasn’t in the country when it happened. So dumping British citizens in Syria and making them the problem of an impoverished war torn country isn’t ‘keeping your kids safe.’ It’s just shirking your responsibilities onto a country that doesn’t have the resources to refuse or fight you on it.

Its a bit more then a stupid comment esp to the victims and families of that attack, that along with security risks that have not been made public. It also not being easy I imagine to strip citizenship without very good reason .

I’m not shrinking my responsibility, it is maybe letting the people in charge of national security in this country do their job who have a lot more knowledge on this case then you or I .

ImAGoodPerson · 29/03/2023 13:24

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/03/2023 11:27

Luckily the police in our area do a huge amount of work with young people who are being groomed by extremists so many are helped before anything top serious has happened

That's wonderful to hear, if the efforts have been helpful in your area; unfortunately even to make the attempt is deemed racism by some, which isn't always so beneficial - especially if they later try to fall back on "why weren't they stopped?"

That said, while there are some they'll never reach, it's got to be a plus if those "on the sidelines" can be worked with - initiatives which many communities are already doing so much towards

We were shocked at how common it was in our area, it's one of those things you think happens in other areas to other people. Obviously my knowledge of who has been helped is very limited to my own experiences but I was extremely impressed with the team of police who assisted and supported the children, more than can be said about the school who were dreadful in their conduct.

OneTC · 29/03/2023 13:17

If it's a question of national security and she's super dangerous then what's the benefit to leaving her in a semi secure refugee camp that loads of fighters have escaped from?

Kanaloa · 29/03/2023 13:01

Sallydimebar · 29/03/2023 11:05

I think of Saffie-Rose quite often as we were there the month before ,I couldn’t imagine taking my child to a concert all excited and happy and not bringing them home, the terrible injuries she suffered before she died.

Then for Shamima to sit there at 19 so calm and collective to say that was justified she appears beyond help to me . Yes maybe more should of been done beforehand but I have to side with the government and national security in keeping my kids safe .

What are you talking about? People say these stupid things. What does stripping British citizens of their citizenship have to do with ‘keeping your kids safe?’ She wasn’t in this country when that terrorist attack happened! Her not being in this country would not prevent that attack, because she wasn’t in the country when it happened. So dumping British citizens in Syria and making them the problem of an impoverished war torn country isn’t ‘keeping your kids safe.’ It’s just shirking your responsibilities onto a country that doesn’t have the resources to refuse or fight you on it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread