Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Shamima Begum a victim or a criminal?

558 replies

ShamimaBegu · 28/03/2023 10:34

Just listened to the podcasts about Shamima Begum. How can Shamima Begum not be viewed as a victim of grooming and sex trafficking? How on earth would a 15 year old got to Syria without adults making it happen?
She was married off and became pregnant on multiple occasions. She surely is as much a victim as a criminal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 08/04/2023 10:58

Blossomtoes · 07/04/2023 14:09

If you work in a professional environment in the public sector you meet people of all ethnicities. I’ve worked with people whose parents and grandparents have moved here from all over the world and not encountered any who are conflicted about their British identity. The more educated people are, the more confident they tend to be about who they are.

I share your experience that I've not encountered many with these conflicted feelings, but I'm not sure about the educated bit. I meet a lot more working class lads with the attitude of ^'I am who I am. Fuck em if they don't like it.'>

To me it seems like there's a lot more hand wringing from the middle classes. Like how we're always told it's the ultimate sin to ask where somebody is from. I just don't see this in real life. I actually find that a lot of non-white people are a lot more likely to ask.

Like, I've been training up a Ghanaian guy the past fortnight. Lovely bloke. He moved here as a child in the early 00's and has lived in Belgium, Amsterdam, and all over the UK. Always asking questions about heritage etc. Am I Scottish because of my red hair and surname. Why don't I have a Scottish accent if I'm of Scottish descent etc. He's always pointing out other black people and explaining he can usually tell where they're from by their appearance. Somebody was rude to him onsite the other day and he said he was particularly annoyed because the guy was Portuguese and 'same as me, looking to make a life in this country'.

I still tend to err on the side of caution at first, but really so much of this middle class hand wringing and wokeism, doesn't seem to usually be a thing in the real world, well not outside of overly ethical corporate environments like the law firm I once worked for which literally had a 'no banter, banter can be harmful' policy. I've found mist people like it when people are interested in their background.

Apologies to have gone on a bit of a tangent.

Blossomtoes · 07/04/2023 14:09

If you work in a professional environment in the public sector you meet people of all ethnicities. I’ve worked with people whose parents and grandparents have moved here from all over the world and not encountered any who are conflicted about their British identity. The more educated people are, the more confident they tend to be about who they are.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 07/04/2023 12:54

Jourdain11 · 07/04/2023 11:11

And people wonder why ethnic minority teens are conflicted about their British identity....

Are they really though?

British non-white is the largest demographic nowadays in quite a few of our cities in the under 20s bracket.

I meet loads of Indian/Pakistani and Jamaican lads working in the construction sector. Certainly a hell of a lot more than when I was doing office work where it's dominated by white brits (possibly due to the need for good written English and because most white collar businesses are owned by white people).

Some of the sites I go to are almost all Indian as they tend to employ their own. I just don't see this existential angst so many white middle class people speak of. I often wonder if it's because they work in professional environments and don't actually meet many black or Asian lads in their day to day lives.

Jourdain11 · 07/04/2023 11:11

And people wonder why ethnic minority teens are conflicted about their British identity....

ginghamstarfish · 07/04/2023 11:07

I am amazed - and pleased - that the government has not allowed her back here. If you choose to go off and join a terrorist organisation, then no you should not be allowed back (to live at taxpayers' expense). Why doesn't she go off to Afghanistan or the like, surely she could find another man to marry her there and continue with her support of fanatic Islamist terrorism.

Jourdain11 · 07/04/2023 10:58

I'm not calling anyone names? Show me where I did?

And how is saying, "she can go to Bangladesh, we don't want her here" not xenophobic? If you don't want to be insulted, don't be insulting. I honestly find it kind of horrifying.

Blossomtoes · 07/04/2023 10:50

No we’re not xenophobic. Calling anyone who disagrees with you names and insulting them really doesn’t help your argument.

Jourdain11 · 07/04/2023 10:49

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:27

These just make me even less keen to have her back in the country. She'll be out in the public within a few years and I have no faith in our services (mental health, police, etc) to provide the necessary support or tracking.

And 'illegal immigrants' is a well known term. I don't know where you got 'illegal people' from.

Illegal immigrants may be a "well-known term" but it's widely considered to be othering and many discourage its use. There are plenty of words and phrases which are well-known, but it doesn't make it acceptable to use them.

Jourdain11 · 07/04/2023 10:47

nothingcomestonothing · 07/04/2023 08:09

Who do you think is responsible for the infrastructure of the camp? Who do you think is guarding it?

These posters don't care. Basically, they're just xenophobic.

nothingcomestonothing · 07/04/2023 08:09

Blossomtoes · 06/04/2023 21:43

But it’s ok for Syria to spend the money looking after her?

She’s costing Syria fuck all.

Who do you think is responsible for the infrastructure of the camp? Who do you think is guarding it?

Blossomtoes · 06/04/2023 21:43

But it’s ok for Syria to spend the money looking after her?

She’s costing Syria fuck all.

Tandora · 06/04/2023 19:08

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 16:51

Whether or not she should be our responsibility, there are thousands of people more deserving of the limited capacity we have to help everyone who needs help.

As I said upthread, it'd be amazing if homeless veterans got even close to the amount of sympathy this 'ex' terrorist gets.

This is totally ridiculous logic.

babybythesea · 06/04/2023 18:54

123rainbow · 06/04/2023 05:41

Agree with this. The money it would take to monitor her would be unreal. She could go to Bangladesh. Why won't she? Because they wouldn't be so soft or even be debating her fate. She maybe a British citizen, but she condemned it and everything it stood for. I think she needs to stay away for her own protection.

But it’s ok for Syria to spend the money looking after her?

nothingcomestonothing · 06/04/2023 07:43

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:08

But we also have responsibility to protect our country and inhabitants. Sending a message that 'if you leave to join ISIS you don't get to come back' is a strong deterrent.

We also have a responsibility for the people within our society who are struggling and didn't run off to plot against us. Like the aforementioned homeless veterans. Honestly, fuck ISIS and fuck Shamima. The cost of keeping her in a grotty camp is a fraction of the £7 million our government spends every day on housing illegal immigrants in hotels (not saying I disagree with this but mentioning for context).

But we're not sending the message 'if you leave to join ISIS you don't get to come back' - over 300 UK men who went to join ISIS and actually fought for them have been allowed back and are walking the streets of the UK. How is she more dangerous then they were/are?

And if you don't agree with spending.£millions on housing illegal immigrants, I assume you think we should be able to send them back where they came from? How can we, if we won't take back our citizens from other countries? We can't have it both ways.

mycoffeecup · 06/04/2023 07:12

123rainbow · 06/04/2023 05:41

Agree with this. The money it would take to monitor her would be unreal. She could go to Bangladesh. Why won't she? Because they wouldn't be so soft or even be debating her fate. She maybe a British citizen, but she condemned it and everything it stood for. I think she needs to stay away for her own protection.

How about the minor point that she doesn't have Bangladeshi citizenship and they have said they won't take her or give her a passport?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47312207

British schoolgirl Shamima Begum during her interview with the BBC on Monday

Shamima Begum will not be allowed here, Bangladesh says

Bangladesh says there is "no question" of Shamima Begum being allowed into the country.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47312207

Jourdain11 · 06/04/2023 06:19

123rainbow · 06/04/2023 05:41

Agree with this. The money it would take to monitor her would be unreal. She could go to Bangladesh. Why won't she? Because they wouldn't be so soft or even be debating her fate. She maybe a British citizen, but she condemned it and everything it stood for. I think she needs to stay away for her own protection.

Because she's never visited Bangladesh and has no known links there?

123rainbow · 06/04/2023 05:41

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:08

But we also have responsibility to protect our country and inhabitants. Sending a message that 'if you leave to join ISIS you don't get to come back' is a strong deterrent.

We also have a responsibility for the people within our society who are struggling and didn't run off to plot against us. Like the aforementioned homeless veterans. Honestly, fuck ISIS and fuck Shamima. The cost of keeping her in a grotty camp is a fraction of the £7 million our government spends every day on housing illegal immigrants in hotels (not saying I disagree with this but mentioning for context).

Agree with this. The money it would take to monitor her would be unreal. She could go to Bangladesh. Why won't she? Because they wouldn't be so soft or even be debating her fate. She maybe a British citizen, but she condemned it and everything it stood for. I think she needs to stay away for her own protection.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:49

MoreSleepPleasee · 05/04/2023 23:34

I may be very wrong as I've not just looked in to this but what I remember from some time ago was that she was basically saying children have died on both sides, no?

She said it was justified because Syrian children were also killed in bombings. The difference is that the air strikes were not specifically intended to kill civilians and wouldn't have happened without the presence of Shamima's mates.

MoreSleepPleasee · 05/04/2023 23:34

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:29

I'd wager you'd feel differently had one of your children been killed in the Manchester bombing. Seeing her attempt to justify it and knowing that she deliberately chose to support the organisations responsible.

I may be very wrong as I've not just looked in to this but what I remember from some time ago was that she was basically saying children have died on both sides, no?

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:29

MoreSleepPleasee · 05/04/2023 23:25

I've never understood the hatred towards her. She was a child who was groomed. She is a victim.

I'd wager you'd feel differently had one of your children been killed in the Manchester bombing. Seeing her attempt to justify it and knowing that she deliberately chose to support the organisations responsible.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:27

Jourdain11 · 05/04/2023 23:21

@StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar What about the fact that Shamima Begum was a British minor when she was targeted by ISIS? Weren't authorities responsible for safeguarding her?

Those girls sat in a bus station in Istanbul for more than 24h after flying. It seems bizarre to me that they didn't manage to track them. They were minors, and at least two of them had travelled on stolen passports. They knew where they'd flown to. Not to mention that their handler was acting for Canadian security services.

More going on with that than meets the eye in my humble opinion.

And btw, people aren't illegal. They may have come here illegally, or might be working illegally, but the individuals themselves are not "illegal people".

These just make me even less keen to have her back in the country. She'll be out in the public within a few years and I have no faith in our services (mental health, police, etc) to provide the necessary support or tracking.

And 'illegal immigrants' is a well known term. I don't know where you got 'illegal people' from.

MoreSleepPleasee · 05/04/2023 23:25

I've never understood the hatred towards her. She was a child who was groomed. She is a victim.

GGBOY · 05/04/2023 23:22

I think she’s more criminal than victim. However It’s really complex . She was young , but just because she was young when she did it, that doesn’t make her innocent . Everyone’s got to start somewhere . She could come back for the UK and still hold the same views . I don’t see her as a reformed character.

I am glad she hasn’t been allowed back to the UK , she could not be easily be a security risk and our justice system is too weak to deal with it. Who knows what is going on in her head .

Jourdain11 · 05/04/2023 23:21

@StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar What about the fact that Shamima Begum was a British minor when she was targeted by ISIS? Weren't authorities responsible for safeguarding her?

Those girls sat in a bus station in Istanbul for more than 24h after flying. It seems bizarre to me that they didn't manage to track them. They were minors, and at least two of them had travelled on stolen passports. They knew where they'd flown to. Not to mention that their handler was acting for Canadian security services.

More going on with that than meets the eye in my humble opinion.

And btw, people aren't illegal. They may have come here illegally, or might be working illegally, but the individuals themselves are not "illegal people".

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 05/04/2023 23:08

nothingcomestonothing · 05/04/2023 17:00

But it's not about 'helping' her - we have dumped the responsibility for a citizen of this country, onto another country. That's both morally wrong (to her but also to a poorer country we've offloaded our problem to), and setting a dangerous precedent when we expect to be able to deport criminals from other countries back where they came from if they commit crime here.

But we also have responsibility to protect our country and inhabitants. Sending a message that 'if you leave to join ISIS you don't get to come back' is a strong deterrent.

We also have a responsibility for the people within our society who are struggling and didn't run off to plot against us. Like the aforementioned homeless veterans. Honestly, fuck ISIS and fuck Shamima. The cost of keeping her in a grotty camp is a fraction of the £7 million our government spends every day on housing illegal immigrants in hotels (not saying I disagree with this but mentioning for context).